2nd Quartile Casper Canada: Cutoffs, Formulas & Next Steps
Free, no sign-up to start.
Got a 1st or 2nd quartile Casper score in Canada? See medical school weights, cutoffs, Casper-free MD programs, and your exact next steps.
Free, no sign-up to start.
A 2nd quartile Casper score places you in the lower-middle band of test-takers for your cycle, and it does not automatically disqualify you from Canadian medical schools. Because Acuity Insights rules allow only one sitting per Casper test type per admissions cycle, your best move right now is matching your GPA and MCAT strengths to the right school formulas. Sources: AFMC Admission Requirements of Canadian Faculties of Medicine (2027), AFMC Admission Requirements of Canadian Faculties of Medicine (2026), AFMC Canadian Medical Education Statistics 2025, Section A. Last checked November 12, 2026.
On this page
- What 2nd quartile and 1st quartile Casper scores mean in Canada
- Canadian medical school Casper weights and cutoffs
- Canadian medical schools that do not require Casper
- 1st and 2nd quartile Casper scores on Reddit vs. official Canadian data
- 5-step action plan after a 1st or 2nd quartile result
- How Casper is formatted and scored (and why 2nd quartile happens)
- How to move from a 2nd quartile answer to a stronger response
- Practice question
- Frequently asked questions
- Sources
What 2nd quartile and 1st quartile Casper scores mean in Canada
Opening your portal to see a 2nd quartile or 1st quartile Casper result stings, especially when Canadian medical admissions feel razor-thin. Quartiles divide everyone in your testing group into four relative bands, from the 1st quartile at the bottom to the 4th quartile at the top. Landing in the 2nd quartile means you scored in the lower-middle band, ahead of the 1st quartile and behind the 3rd and 4th quartiles. Landing in the 1st quartile places your result in the lowest of the four relative bands for your cohort.
Acuity Insights confirms that certified human raters, not AI systems, score your open-response answers. Your results go automatically to the programs on your distribution list. Each individual program then determines how and when to weigh that score alongside grades and other admissions criteria. Casper is designed to complement academic metrics rather than replace them.
In Canada, the practical difference between a 2nd quartile and a 1st quartile comes down to minimum screening thresholds versus weighted pre-interview formulas. Two Canadian faculties state explicit statistical floors in AFMC admission guides: Dalhousie Medical School considers only applicants who score above -1.5 standard deviations from the mean for an interview, and the University of Manitoba requires a score greater than 1.5 standard deviations below the mean for its Manitoba and Out-of-Province pools. A 2nd quartile score sits above a 1.5 standard deviation floor, whereas a low 1st quartile result risks screening out at schools that apply statistical thresholds.
Watch out for two pieces of bad information that circulate online. Some third-party prep sites claim you can pay a fee to retake Casper in the same cycle, or reverse the bands by calling the 1st quartile the top group. Official testing rules strictly prohibit taking the same Casper test type more than once per admissions cycle, and the 4th quartile is always the highest band.
Canadian medical school Casper weights and cutoffs
Every Canadian medical school sets its own rules for Casper. Based on individual faculty profiles reported as of February 2026 in the 2027 AFMC Admission Requirements guide, 10 of Canada's 19 faculties of medicine require Casper in the current cycle, by our count. Some plug your score into an exact pre-interview equation, others apply an eligibility screen, and several drop Casper to zero once interviews begin.
If you searched for McMaster with a 2nd quartile Casper score, the math is tight. Casper makes up nearly one third of your invitation score across McMaster's 217 regular-quota seats. Offsetting a 2nd quartile takes top-end GPA and CARS marks, especially from outside Ontario, where only 30 spots (5% of interview spots) go to Outside Ontario applicants.
Memorial University of Newfoundland sets no minimum Casper score, though it recommends scores in the 3rd and 4th quartiles alongside a recommended MCAT of at least 505 and a competitive academic record (the mean GPA is 3.5 on a 4.0 scale). Queen's University, the University of Saskatchewan, and Quebec's three French-language faculties (Université Laval, Université de Sherbrooke, and Université de Montréal) also require Casper. Check each faculty's official admissions page for stream-specific updates before locking in your final list.
| Medical School | Pre-Interview Casper Role | Non-Casper Pre-Interview Share |
|---|---|---|
| McMaster University | Not published | Not published |
| Dalhousie University | 25% of interview score | Interview selection only, must score above -1.5 SD from mean |
| University of Manitoba | 30% of base formula | Must exceed 1.5 SD below pool mean, drops to 10% post-interview |
| McGill University | 20% of interview formula | Final admission selection is 100% interview |
| Memorial University | Evaluated in file review | Reviewed alongside GPA (3.5 mean) and MCAT (505+ recommended) |
Canadian medical schools that do not require Casper
- University of Toronto (Ontario): No Casper required, MCAT required, 303 regular-quota seats (288 in-province, 15 out-of-province).
- Western University, Schulich School of Medicine (Ontario): No Casper required, MCAT required, 187 regular-quota seats (178 in-province, 9 out-of-province).
- University of Ottawa (Ontario, English and French streams): No Casper required (replaced by an asynchronous MMI), no MCAT required, 170 regular-quota seats (160 in-province, 10 out-of-province, with 95% of seats reserved for Ontario applicants under provincial directives).
- NOSM University (Ontario, Sudbury and Thunder Bay campuses): No Casper required, no MCAT required, 88 regular-quota seats (84 in-province, 4 out-of-province) focused on Northern Ontario, rural, Indigenous, Francophone, and Black admission streams.
- Toronto Metropolitan University (Ontario, Brampton): No Casper required, no MCAT required, 94 regular-quota seats (89 in-province, 5 out-of-province).
- University of Alberta, Faculty of Medicine & Dentistry (Alberta): No Casper required in its 2027 AFMC faculty profile, MCAT required, 192 regular-quota seats (163 in-province, 29 out-of-province).
- University of Calgary, Cumming School of Medicine (Alberta): No Casper required, MCAT required, 3-year MD program with 160 regular-quota seats (141 in-province, 19 out-of-province).
- University of British Columbia (British Columbia): No Casper required, MCAT required, 328 regular-quota seats (295 in-province, 33 out-of-province).
- Simon Fraser University, School of Medicine (British Columbia): Included among Canada's 19 medical faculties and not on the list of Casper-requiring schools. Confirm current seat and eligibility criteria directly with the faculty.
1st and 2nd quartile Casper scores on Reddit vs. official Canadian data
Search for 1st quartile or 2nd quartile Casper scores on Canadian premed Reddit forums and you will find hundreds of anxious posts debating whether an application cycle is over. Self-reported forum threads rarely separate in-province applicants from out-of-province applicants, and in Canada, provincial seat quotas shape your odds even more sharply than your Casper band.
Look at the official seat and admission numbers to see why two applicants with the exact same 2nd quartile score have completely different outcomes. At Memorial University, the 2024/25 success rate was 40.3% for Newfoundland and Labrador residents compared with 8.9% for Other Canadian applicants across 611 total applicants. At Dalhousie, the 169 first-year positions are dedicated to Maritime residents (87 Nova Scotia at Halifax, 30 Nova Scotia at Cape Breton, 40 New Brunswick at Saint John, and 6 PEI at Halifax) plus 6 seats for Other Canadian applicants in the Indigenous and Black Learners Admissions Pathways, with no General Pool Out-of-Province seats. At McGill, only 5 regular-quota seats are open to Canadians residing outside Quebec, and at Manitoba, 133 of 140 regular-quota seats go to in-province residents.
Pathway rules also explain why 1st and 2nd quartile applicants still matriculate at Casper schools. At the University of Manitoba, applicants in the Canadian Indigenous applicant pool must write Casper if they also want to be considered in the general pools, yet Casper is not used in selecting registrants within the Canadian Indigenous applicant pool itself.
Finally, keep test-type rules straight if you are also applying to Canadian nursing, pharmacy, or allied health programs. Hundreds of higher education programs use Casper across medicine, nursing, pharmacy, allied health, and graduate studies. While you cannot retake the same Casper test type in a single cycle, Acuity Insights uses distinct, non-interchangeable test types across different program categories, countries, and languages. If you apply to a French-language program or a separate health professions category that specifies a different Casper test type, you sit a separate exam for that test type.
5-step action plan after a 1st or 2nd quartile result
Because Casper scores are valid for only one admissions cycle and cannot be retaken within the same test type, your strategy depends on whether application deadlines are still open. Use this five-step plan to spend your time and money where the math works for you.
- Step 1, Audit your school list by non-Casper weight: Keep every eligible Casper-free faculty at the top of your list. Among Casper schools, favor programs where GPA, MCAT, or CV carry 70% to 80% of the pre-interview weight (such as McGill at 80%, Dalhousie at 75%, or Manitoba at 70% before coefficients) if you clear their GPA floors (3.3 at Dalhousie, 3.30 AGPA at Manitoba).
- Step 2, Match applications to your home-province quota: Prioritize every medical school in your home province first. Applying out of province with a 1st or 2nd quartile Casper score at McMaster (5% Outside Ontario interview cap) or Manitoba (7 out-of-province regular seats) faces steep structural odds unless your GPA and MCAT sit near the top of the pool.
- Step 3, Use fee waivers if cost limits how broadly you apply: Applying to more faculties raises your statistical chance of an offer. If fees are a barrier, check the AFMC Medical School Application Fee Waiver Program, which waives most or all application fees at 9 participating faculties (Ottawa, Queen's, Toronto, NOSM, TMU, McMaster, Western, Saskatchewan, and Alberta, with UBC also participating on AFMC's fee waiver portal).
- Step 4, Check test-type and language rules for parallel programs: If you are adding Quebec French-stream faculties (none of Quebec's four medical schools require the MCAT) or Canadian nursing, pharmacy, and allied health programs, log in to your Acuity Insights account at least 3 days before your preferred test date to verify whether those programs accept your existing distribution or require a separate Casper test type or language.
- Step 5, Shift all preparation to the MMI and panel interview: Once an interview invitation arrives, a 2nd quartile Casper stops holding you back at several faculties. Casper drops to 0% after interviews at Dalhousie and McGill, and drops from 30% to 10% at Manitoba while your MMI carries 35% of the composite score.
How Casper is formatted and scored (and why 2nd quartile happens)
Show details
If you plan to reapply in a future cycle or sit a separate Casper test type, knowing how human raters evaluate your answers helps you fix what held your score down. Casper takes about 65 to 85 minutes and contains 11 scenarios split across two sections: 4 video-response scenarios with two 1-minute spoken answers each (submitted automatically when time expires) and 7 typed-response scenarios where both open-ended questions appear on the same page with 3.5 minutes total to type both answers. You get an optional 10-minute break after the video section and an optional 5-minute break halfway through the typed section.
Across those 11 scenarios, certified raters assess how you reason through realistic interpersonal dilemmas across nine skills: collaboration, communication, empathy, ethics, fairness, motivation, problem solving, resilience, and self-awareness. A large meta-analysis published in Medical Education combining 27 independent studies and 100 effect sizes found that stronger performance on open-response situational judgment tests aligns with stronger downstream interview, curricular, and workplace evaluations. In an Acuity Insights survey, 35% of applicants admitted to using AI tools during the application process, which is one reason medical schools rely on live, timed video and typed scenarios that resist memorized scripts.
Skip generic third-party templates when you prepare. Acuity Insights explicitly notes that test-takers who use third-party preparation materials or do not prepare at all tend to do worse than applicants who use the free official practice test inside their Acuity Insights account. During your practice test, watch the clock so you do not run out of time on the second question of a 3.5-minute typed prompt, and gather context before jumping straight to a rigid rule. If you have a documented disability or temporary medical condition that affects typing or speaking under tight timers, submit an Accommodations Request Form at least 4 weeks before your scheduled test date.
How to move from a 2nd quartile answer to a stronger response
Show details
Raters score how you think and explain your reasoning, not whether you guess a single right outcome. Avoid picking one side right away, lecturing another person on rules, or leaving the second prompt half-finished. Instead, stay calm, check missing facts privately before judging, weigh how a decision affects everyone involved, and propose concrete next steps under conditional 'if-then' possibilities.
Take an official sample scenario from Acuity Insights where a store customer asks you, as the manager, for a refund. A second prompt asks how you would communicate a refusal. An answer that only cites store policy misses empathy and problem solving. A balanced answer listens to why the customer is upset without interrupting and checks the item's condition and receipt history. When refusing a refund, explain store policy plainly in a calm tone. Then offer a fair alternative such as troubleshooting, manufacturer warranty help, or store credit if permitted.
Practice question
You are working on a four-person university lab project due in three days. One teammate, Paul, messages you privately to say a flare-up of a medical condition is forcing him to pause his courses, and his section is unfinished. How should you and your group handle this situation? Explain your reasoning. (Adapted from an official Acuity Insights sample topic.)
See an example answer
Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. First, I would reply to Paul privately with warmth and reassurance so he knows his health comes first and that I will keep his medical details confidential. Before making any group plan, I would ask Paul what he feels comfortable sharing with our other two teammates and whether he has already contacted our professor or accessibility services about temporary academic accommodations. Next, I would check what raw data or notes Paul has completed so far, if he is up for sending a quick file without doing extra work. With Paul's consent on how to frame his absence, I would meet with the remaining teammates to divide the unfinished analysis fairly based on each person's strengths and schedule over the next three days. I would also suggest emailing our lab instructor together to explain that a teammate had an unexpected documented absence and ask whether a short extension or adjusted grading scope is appropriate. That protects Paul's privacy and academic standing while keeping our team organized and accountable for turning in accurate work on time.
It addresses both human care and practical execution without breaking confidentiality. Instead of blaming Paul or silently dumping work on one person, the answer checks consent first, gathers existing work, shares remaining tasks fairly across teammates, and loops in the instructor for appropriate support.
Frequently asked questions
Can I get into a Canadian medical school with a 2nd quartile Casper score?
Yes, a 2nd quartile score does not automatically disqualify you, and each program sets its own weighting alongside grades and exams.
Does a 1st quartile Casper score screen me out in Canada?
A 1st quartile result places you in the lowest of the four relative bands and can put you at risk of falling below statistical cutoffs, such as the requirement at Dalhousie and the University of Manitoba to score higher than 1.5 standard deviations below the mean. Even with a 1st quartile result, your score has zero impact at Canadian medical schools that do not require Casper, including Toronto, Western, Ottawa, Alberta, Calgary, and UBC.
Can I pay to retake Casper in the same cycle after a 1st or 2nd quartile?
No, Acuity Insights testing rules prohibit taking the same Casper test type more than once per admissions cycle. Your score applies to that single cycle and test type only, though separate Casper tests are required if you apply to programs in a different test-type category, country, or language.
Is a 2nd quartile Casper competitive at McMaster Medical School?
Offsetting that one-third weight takes very high GPA and CARS marks, particularly for Outside Ontario applicants competing for 30 interview spots (5% of total spots).
Which Canadian medical schools do not require Casper for 2027 admission?
Eight Canadian faculties of medicine explicitly report that Casper is not required in their 2027 AFMC faculty profiles: the University of Toronto, Western University, the University of Ottawa (which replaced Casper with a new asynchronous MMI), NOSM University, Toronto Metropolitan University, the University of Alberta, the University of Calgary, and the University of British Columbia, while Simon Fraser University is also not listed among Casper-requiring faculties. Among these, Ottawa, NOSM, and Toronto Metropolitan University also do not require the MCAT.
Sources
- AFMC Admission Requirements of Canadian Faculties of Medicine (2027)
- AFMC Admission Requirements of Canadian Faculties of Medicine (2026)
- AFMC Canadian Medical Education Statistics 2025, Section A
- AFMC Aspirants and Applicants Fee Waiver Programs
- Take Casper: About Casper (Acuity Insights)
- Acuity Insights Assessments: Casper Dates, Fees, and Validity Guidelines
- Acuity Insights: Casper Situational Judgment Test Overview
- Acuity Insights: Open-Response SJTs and Future Professional Performance