Bottom Quartile Casper Score: Rules, Odds, and Next Steps

Try a free Casper practice scenario

Free, no sign-up to start.

Got a bottom quartile (1st quartile) Casper score? See official Acuity Insights retake rules, how medical schools use scores, and your cycle action plan.

Try a free Casper practice scenario

Free, no sign-up to start.

A bottom quartile (or 1st quartile) Casper score places your result in the lowest of the quartile tiers compared with peers who took the same test type, though it does not automatically end your medical school or health professions candidacy. According to Take Casper, each program sets its own weight for Casper alongside academic grades, and you are limited to 1 attempt per Casper test type per admissions cycle across the exam's 11 open-response scenarios. Because a same-cycle retake of that test type is off the table, your strongest move is to audit your school list and demonstrate clear interpersonal judgment in your essays and interviews. Sources: About Casper - Take Casper, Casper Dates, Fees, and Validity Guidelines - Take Casper, Casper Overview - Acuity Insights. Last checked November 12, 2026.

What a bottom quartile Casper score means

Casper is not a pass-or-fail exam with a universal cutoff. Instead, it is an open-response situational judgment test designed to measure social intelligence and professionalism through realistic dilemmas where you explain what you would do and why.

According to Take Casper, your responses are evaluated by certified human raters rather than artificial intelligence, using multiple independent raters and a structured scoring process. Across more than 20 years of research, over 150 internal and external studies, 600+ institutional partners, and 1M+ test-takers reported by Acuity Insights, the assessment focuses on how you reason through competing priorities rather than whether you memorized a single right answer.

By our count from Take Casper's About Casper page, raters look for evidence across 9 listed skills that contribute to social intelligence and professionalism: collaboration, communication, empathy, ethics, fairness, motivation, problem solving, resilience, and self-awareness. A bottom quartile placement signals that, compared with your testing cohort, your answers showed less consistent reasoning or narrower perspective-taking across those areas, or ran short of detail under the clock.

You do not need to upload or mail your result to schools on your list. Scores are automatically delivered to the programs you designated for distribution, and each school updates your application status inside its own admissions portal.

Official Casper retake and score validity rules

Several third-party prep blogs claim you can pay an extra fee to retake Casper during the same application season if you dislike your quartile. Official registration policy on Take Casper states the exact opposite: applicants are not permitted to take a Casper test type more than once per admissions cycle. Your score stands for that test type until the cycle closes.

Casper scores are valid only for a singular test type, such as American Health Sciences or Canadian Health Sciences, and separate tests are required for programs in different countries, categories, or required languages. For example, some Canadian programs accept Casper only in English or only in French, while bilingual programs accept either. Taking a separate required test type sends that new test only to programs matching that category, so it will not overwrite a bottom quartile score already sent to American Health Sciences schools.

If you reapply in a future admissions cycle, your old bottom quartile score does not follow you. Casper scores are valid only for a single admissions cycle, and a separate test is required in any future cycle.

Casper retake and validity rules by application scenario
Application scenarioPermitted in the same cycleOfficial rule
Retaking the same Casper test type to replace a 1st quartile scoreNoLimited to 1 attempt per test type per admissions cycle
Applying to schools requiring a different test type, country, or languageYes, as a separate testScores apply only to a singular test type and required language
Reapplying in a future admissions cycleRequires a new test next cycleScores are valid only for a single admissions cycle

How medical schools and health programs weigh a 1st quartile score

A bottom quartile Casper score hurts your odds at some programs far more than others because there is no centralized rulebook. Each individual program decides how and when to incorporate Casper into its admissions workflow. Acuity Insights states that Casper is built to complement academic metrics like GPA and entrance exams rather than replace them, and reports 25% to 50% smaller demographic differences on Casper compared with academic assessments.

Check each target school's admissions requirements page to see whether Casper is mandatory, optional, or absent from their process. Programs with heavy applicant volume often lean on early screening tools to manage interview seats, while schools emphasizing whole-application review weigh strong grades, clinical service, essays, and letters alongside a low SJT tier.

Across medical schools, nursing, pharmacy, dental hygiene, allied health, and graduate programs, admissions offices generally apply situational judgment scores in 3 distinct ways:

  • Early pre-interview prioritization: Programs use Casper early in the review process to focus limited interview slots and reviewer hours on candidates who warrant deeper consideration. For example, Curtin University Admissions Coordinator Louise Thomas noted in published partner feedback that Casper reduced staff workload and volunteer burnout when interviewing large candidate pools year after year.
  • Spotting interpersonal outliers alongside grades: Some committees use scores to catch warning signs or standout maturity that transcripts miss. Augusta University Admissions Director Lisa Daitch reported that Casper helped her team spot outliers other tools missed and validated final selections, while University of Manchester Admissions Tutor Juliette Kendall noted it added objectivity and consistency to candidate selection.
  • Balanced multi-source context: As the AAMC explains in its admissions guidance for situational judgment testing, professional readiness scores represent 1 indicator among personal statements, letters of recommendation, undergraduate GPA, MCAT scores, and traditional or multiple mini interviews. Committees frequently treat SJT performance as a plus factor between comparable candidates rather than a binary disqualifier.

Current Casper format and why applicants land in the bottom quartile

Under current specifications on Take Casper, the standard exam has 2 sections and 11 scenarios taking about 65 to 85 minutes total, including 2 optional breaks (select programs such as Australian teacher education use a shorter version). You complete 4 video-response scenarios with 2 open-ended questions each at 1 minute per response, and 7 typed-response scenarios with 2 open-ended questions presented on the same screen and 3.5 minutes total per scenario.

By our calculation from Take Casper's About Casper page, you answer 22 open-ended questions across the exam (8 video questions and 14 typed questions) within 32.5 minutes of total active response time (8 minutes of video recording and 24.5 minutes of typing). On the typed section, 3.5 minutes shared across 2 questions gives you an average of 1.75 minutes per question.

Focus your review on pacing discipline and broad reasoning across those 32.5 active minutes rather than worrying about typing speed alone. Raters evaluate how you think through a dilemma in your own words. If your recording cuts off before you explain your rationale, or if you spend 3 minutes on the first typed prompt and leave a 4-word fragment for the second, the rater for that scenario has almost no reasoning to credit.

Preparation habits also play a direct role. Take Casper explicitly warns that test-takers who rely on third-party preparation courses or who do not prepare at all tend to perform worse than applicants who practice with the free official resources inside their online account. Canned formulas make answers sound scripted and generic instead of addressing the specific people in the prompt. Common mistakes that drag scores into the bottom quartile include:

  • Jumping straight to punishment or reporting before gathering missing facts privately.
  • Validating only 1 person in the conflict while ignoring the pressures or safety concerns facing the other stakeholders.
  • Spending nearly all 3.5 minutes on the first typed question and leaving the second question unfinished.
  • Giving unconditional answers instead of using conditional if-then reasoning when key facts are uncertain.
  • Reciting memorized buzzwords from commercial prep templates instead of explaining practical next steps in plain language.
Current Casper test structure and calculated active response time
SectionScenariosQuestionsResponse limit
Video responses4 scenarios8 open-ended questions (2 per scenario)1 minute per question (8 minutes active total)
Typed responses7 scenarios14 open-ended questions (2 per scenario)3.5 minutes per scenario (24.5 minutes active total)
Full Casper exam11 scenarios22 open-ended questions total32.5 minutes active total (65 to 85 minutes exam time with 2 optional breaks)

Your step-by-step plan for the current application cycle

If your bottom quartile result is already sitting in your portal for the current cycle, do not withdraw your applications in panic. Use this action plan written by our team to protect your candidacy across the rest of your materials.

Why does consistent follow-through in essays and interviews matter so much? A research summary from Acuity Insights highlights a meta-analysis published in Medical Education combining 27 independent studies and 100 effect sizes on open-response situational judgment tests. The synthesis found that when schools evaluate aligned interpersonal skills consistently across selection stages, including interviews, predictive validity nearly doubled. At the same time, an Acuity survey found that 35% of applicants admitted to using AI tools during the application process, pushing committees to look closely at authentic, real-time interview performance.

  • Keep quiet about the score unless asked: Never email admissions offices with unsolicited excuses about a bad testing day, slow typing, or disagreement with your quartile. Defensiveness draws extra scrutiny to a single metric.
  • Rebalance your school list right away: Check every remaining school you plan to add. Prioritize programs that do not require Casper, treat it as optional, or accept the AAMC PREview exam for MD and DO admissions instead.
  • Demonstrate the 9 Casper skills in secondary essays: When writing conflict, teamwork, or failure essays, explicitly show how you listened to another viewpoint, gathered facts before acting, took accountability, and repaired trust.
  • Prepare thoroughly for live MMIs and asynchronous Video Interviews: Many programs use asynchronous Video Interviews or live station interviews to evaluate program-specific values directly. Calm, balanced spoken answers give reviewers firsthand proof of your maturity.
  • Confirm strong interpersonal letters of recommendation: Ask supervisors and faculty who have watched you handle teamwork, patient interaction, or conflict firsthand so their letters provide concrete behavioral evidence alongside your GPA and test scores.

Worked example: turning a 1st quartile draft into a strong response

Show details

To see the difference between bottom-quartile reasoning and balanced judgment, look at a sample scenario published on Take Casper. You are part of a student group assignment, and 1 group member, Paul, has stopped contributing because of a medical condition. Question 1 asks how you and your group should handle the situation, and Question 2 asks how your response would change if Paul had contributed a significant amount before putting his courses on hold.

A common bottom-quartile draft written by our team to illustrate typical mistakes looks like this: 'Question 1: Fair is fair, and everyone gets the same grade. I would tell the professor immediately that Paul stopped doing his part so our grades do not drop, and reassign his slides today. Question 2: Maybe we would leave his name on the slides he already made, though the professor still needs to grade him separately.' Notice why that response scores poorly: it jumps straight to escalation without speaking to Paul, shows zero empathy for a documented medical issue, and barely develops Question 2.

Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. Question 1: First, I would reach out to Paul privately with warmth to check on his well-being without pressuring him to disclose private medical details. Protecting both Paul's health and our team's deadline matters here. If Paul needs to step back completely, I would meet with our remaining group members to redistribute his remaining tasks fairly based on everyone's current workload, and together we would consult our instructor or course syllabus on how medical accommodations apply so Paul is not unfairly penalized while our team stays supported. Question 2: Knowing Paul already completed a substantial share before pausing his courses reinforces that he acted in good faith rather than neglecting the team. I would make sure his completed work is fully credited in our submission and let the instructor know how much foundational work he contributed early on. Rather than asking to separate him from the group project, I would advocate for an equitable grading arrangement with the professor that honors his strong early contribution while recognizing the extra closing tasks the rest of us absorbed.

The stronger response works within the 3.5-minute window because it checks on Paul privately first, respects medical privacy, protects group fairness, consults course policy constructively rather than punitively, and directly adapts its reasoning when Question 2 introduces new context.

Casper vs. AAMC PREview for medical school applicants

If you are adding medical schools after receiving a bottom quartile Casper score, you will encounter MD and DO programs that use the AAMC PREview Professional Readiness Exam instead. According to the AAMC, PREview is open to MD-granting and DO-granting medical schools as well as other postgraduate health professions programs, assessing relational skills and personal accountability.

Because PREview uses a completely different format, struggling with Casper's 1-minute video clock or 3.5-minute typing rush does not mean you will struggle on PREview. Instead of typing essays or recording videos, PREview presents scenario sets with 4 to 8 proposed actions across 186 total items (75% set in non-healthcare environments and 25% in healthcare settings). You rate each action as Very Ineffective, Ineffective, Effective, or Very Effective. Full credit goes to matching the medical educator consensus key, and half credit goes to landing 1 step away on the same side of the scale, yielding a total score from 1 to 9 with a confidence band of plus or minus 1 point and a percentile rank updated each May.

Comparison of Casper and AAMC PREview for health professions applicants
FeatureCasperAAMC PREview
Test structure11 open-response scenarios (4 video, 7 typed)186 items across scenario sets of 4 to 8 proposed responses
Response formatRecord 1-minute videos and type open answers in 3.5-minute blocksRate each action on a 4-point effectiveness scale
Scoring methodCertified human raters across multiple independent ratersMedical educator consensus key scored from 1 to 9
Official practice examsFree full-format practice test in your online accountFree, unscored PDF practice exams and an online Scored Practice Exam

How to prepare if you retake Casper in a future cycle

Show details

If you end up reapplying in a new admissions cycle, you will sit for a fresh Casper exam, and your prior bottom quartile result will not carry over. Documented in the annual Casper Technical Manual, the test is built to reward clear, authentic reasoning rather than rehearsed scripts.

Handle your booking deadlines early so logistics never add test-day stress. Register at least 3 days before your preferred test date using a government-issued photo ID in English or French with the exact name and email from your program applications. All registration fees are final and non-refundable, though there is no extra charge for Duet if your programs require it. Applicants approved for a participating U.S. or UK Fee Assistance Program, such as AAMC, AACOMAS, CASPA, ADEA, or a UCAS bursary, may qualify for waived or reduced Casper fees. If you have a documented disability or temporary medical condition, submit your Accommodations Request Form and supporting paperwork at least 4 weeks before your scheduled test.

Center your preparation on the free official Casper practice test inside your account after reserving your test date. Run the full 4-video and 7-typed structure under real timing, enforce an even split of your 3.5-minute limit between Question 1 and Question 2 on typed prompts, and practice naming every stakeholder's concern aloud before proposing a fair, practical solution.

Practice Casper scenario and example answer

Practice prompt: You are working as a peer tutor in a university science center. 10 minutes before closing, an anxious student asks you to check the answers on a take-home graded quiz due at midnight, saying they risk losing their academic scholarship if they fail. Another tutor quietly tells you they sometimes give hints on graded quizzes when students are desperate. Question 1: How do you handle the situation with the student right now? Explain your reasoning. Question 2: What, if anything, do you say to your fellow tutor afterward? Explain your reasoning.

Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. First, I would speak calmly and privately with the student so they feel heard rather than judged in a stressful moment. Because checking answers on a graded take-home quiz violates academic integrity rules and could put both the student's enrollment and their scholarship at even greater risk, I would clearly explain that I cannot review the live quiz items. Right away, though, I would use our remaining 10 minutes to review the underlying textbook concept using a different practice problem so they can apply the method on their own before midnight. I would also share campus academic advising and financial aid contacts in case they need formal support around their scholarship threshold. Second, once the student leaves, I would have a private, non-accusatory conversation with my fellow tutor. I understand wanting to help stressed peers, so I would ask what kinds of requests they have been getting lately. From there, I would remind them that hinting on graded work creates unfairness for other students and exposes the tutoring center to honor-code violations. If center guidelines feel unclear during high-stress exam weeks, I would suggest asking our supervisor to review clear boundaries at our next team meeting.

Why this response works: This answer avoids every trap that pulls responses into the bottom quartile. It addresses both prompts thoroughly within a 3.5-minute typing budget, upholds ethical rules without sounding cold, gives the stressed student immediate legitimate help on a parallel example, approaches the co-worker privately with curiosity before escalating, and connects individual choices to fairness across the wider student body.

Frequently asked questions

Can you get into medical school with a bottom quartile (1st quartile) Casper score?

Yes, a bottom quartile score does not automatically disqualify you across all medical schools. Casper is designed to complement academic metrics like GPA and entrance exams rather than replace them, and each individual program chooses how heavily to weigh scores alongside your essays, letters, and interviews.

Can I retake Casper in the same admissions cycle to improve a bottom quartile score?

No. Official registration guidelines state that applicants are not permitted to take a Casper test type more than once per admissions cycle, and you can only sit for an additional exam if you apply to programs requiring a separate test type, country, or language.

Does a 1st quartile Casper score carry over if I reapply next year?

No, Casper scores are valid only for a single admissions cycle. If you reapply in a future cycle, you must take a new Casper test, giving you a clean slate.

Should I email medical schools to explain my bottom quartile Casper score?

Do not send unsolicited emails making excuses for your score. Instead, demonstrate collaboration, empathy, ethics, and clear communication directly through your secondary essays, recommendation letters, and interviews.

Is Casper graded by AI or human raters?

Casper is scored by certified human raters, not AI, using multiple independent raters and a structured process to evaluate how you reason through scenarios.

How should I practice so I avoid the bottom quartile on a future Casper test?

Use the free official Casper practice test inside your online account after registering rather than commercial response templates. Test-takers who use third-party prep materials or skip preparation altogether tend to perform worse than applicants who use the official free practice resources.

Sources