Updated
CST Portfolio 2027: Domains, Indicators and Evidence
Free, no sign-up to start.
Free, no sign-up to start.
On this page
For 2027 Core Surgical Training there is no self-assessment on Oriel and no published point values. If you are invited to interview, you upload an index page with a letter from A to E for each of three domains, plus one piece of evidence per domain, between February 19 and 24, 2027. Assessors review it before the portfolio station, then ask you two questions on Domains 2 and 3. That station is 45% of your total score.
What the CST portfolio is in 2027
The portfolio is the evidence of what you have done so far: operating, communicating your work and improving care. The Medical Hub applying page sets out the change for 2027. “You will no longer be asked to complete self-assessment on Oriel.” Instead, “you will be asked to upload an index page with the appropriate entries for each domain (using a letter from A-E instead of a score).”
The portfolio guidance for candidates lines the domains up with three of the four domains of the GMC's Good Medical Practice. “The fourth domain, Trust and Professionalism, will continue to be assessed through the interview process.” It also says what assessors look for: “The emphasis is not simply on accumulating evidence or completing activities, but on demonstrating the quality, contribution and impact of the work undertaken.” And “The strongest evidence will demonstrate meaningful impact and, where possible, a lasting legacy”.
The three domains and their indicators
The 2027 guidance gives letters, not points. It does not publish how each letter converts into a score, so treat A as the strongest evidence and E as none. Choose one achievement per item, the one that reaches the highest letter.
| Domain | What you choose | Indicators | Asked at interview |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Knowledge, Skills and Development | Operative experience | A: 40 or more cases. B: 30 to 39. C: 20 to 29. D: 11 to 19. E: 10 or fewer, or no evidence. | No |
| 1. Knowledge, Skills and Development | Surgical experience | A: a surgical taster week (at least 5 days) or a surgical elective as a medical student (at least 4 weeks). B: neither. | No |
| 2. Patients, Partnership and Communication | One communication achievement | A to E, from a top-prize national presentation or first-author paper (A) down to none (E). Full list below. | Yes |
| 3. Colleagues, Culture and Safety | One audit or QI project | A: you led all of a surgically themed project that showed change. B: you led all of any project that showed change. C: you contributed across cycles. D: you were involved, for example in data collection. E: none. | Yes |
| 3. Colleagues, Culture and Safety | Presenting that project | A: you presented both cycles, or the intervention and change. B: you presented one cycle. C: you did not present it. | Yes |
Domain 2 has the widest range. You pick one communication achievement, and the options are not added together.
- A. Top prize for an oral presentation at a national or international medical meeting. Or: First author of a PubMed or Web of Science cited publication, not a case report or editorial letter. Or: Designed and organized a face-to-face teaching program with local educators (4 or more sessions) and delivered at least 4 of them. Or: A surgically themed podcast, webinar or patient information leaflet with demonstrable impact.
- B. An oral presentation at a national or international medical meeting. Or: First author of a prize-winning poster at a national or international meeting. Or: First author of a cited case report or editorial letter, or a published book chapter. Or: The same teaching program as A, delivered online. Or: A podcast, webinar or patient information leaflet with demonstrable impact on any topic.
- C. Regular teaching for healthcare professionals or medical students over the last year (4 or more sessions).
- D. First author of a poster at a national or international meeting. Or: An oral presentation at a regional medical meeting. Or: A cited collaborative author on a research collaborative publication.
- E. None of these.
What evidence counts
Combine everything for a domain into one PDF. The guidance lists the minimum for each:
Knowledge, Skills and Development
- One eLogbook consolidation report covering all specialties, signed on every page by a consultant with their full name, GMC number and the date. Count assisted and supervised cases, not ones you only observed. Do not upload the whole logbook.
- For a taster week or elective, a signed letter on letterhead from the supervisor with the placement, hospital, dates, their GMC number and what you did there. An acceptance letter from before you started does not count.
Patients, Partnership and Communication
- Presentations: the slides or poster, the acceptance letter or event program naming you, and a certificate of attendance. Add the prize certificate if you claim a prize.
- Publications: the article with its PubMed ID or Web of Science reference, or an acceptance letter confirming publication without changes.
- Teaching, podcasts, webinars and leaflets: a signed letter from a consultant with their GMC number and the dates, plus formal feedback the consultant has reviewed.
Colleagues, Culture and Safety
- A signed letter from the supervising consultant with their GMC number, stating your level of involvement.
- The project presentation or a summary of its scope and impact. For full points, include the slides.
- Proof you presented it, such as an acceptance letter or the meeting program showing you as presenter.
How it is checked at interview
Per the Medical Hub interviews page, the portfolio station lasts 15 minutes: a 3-minute presentation you prepare in advance, 2 minutes of questions on it, then 2 portfolio questions of 5 minutes each. Before you join, the assessors review your upload (the guidance gives them 10 to 15 minutes). “Assessors will only assess and ask questions on the first achievement uploaded per domain”
“Candidates will only be asked questions about 'Patient, Partnership and Communication' and the 'Safety and Culture' domains”, and “Assessors will ask questions even if no evidence has been uploaded”. Each portfolio question is marked from 0 (no evidence) to 6 (outstanding). “The Applicant's final portfolio scores will be based on the assessor's portfolio score, and the answers given to the questions.” On over-claiming, the guidance warns it is taken extremely seriously and that “This may be tested in the questions that a candidate is asked.”
“Tell us about the quality improvement project in your portfolio. What was your role, and what changed?”
A strong answer names your part in each stage, gives the result in numbers, and says what is still in place now that you have moved on.
Mistakes that score 0
The guidance is specific about what costs points. Most of these make an item score 0:
- No index page. It is mandatory. Without it every domain scores 0 and your evidence is not reviewed.
- A missing GMC number. Where the evidence asks for a supervisor's GMC number, a letter without one scores 0.
- Editable electronic signatures. If the signature on a PDF can be changed, assessors cannot accept it and it scores 0.
- Patient identifiable data. Hospital numbers, thank-you cards from families or unredacted meeting minutes score 0, and you may be asked to meet the clinical lead.
- Uploading more than one item. Assessors look at the first item they see in each domain. Put your best achievement in one PDF per domain.
- Reusing an achievement. Each achievement counts in one domain only. A QI project you claim in Domain 3 cannot also be your Domain 2 presentation.
- Claiming what is not finished. Everything must be complete by February 19, 2027. A 5-day taster booked for 2027 gets nothing.
- Paying to present. If you presented only because you paid a fee, you can only choose none/other.
Also, “A specific achievement can only be used in 1 domain.” “Any evidence submissions without an index sheet will be scored 0 on the domains and evidence will not be reviewed”.
How it fits with the MSRA and interview
The MSRA comes first. Per the overview, “approximately the top 1200 candidates will be invited to interview and upload evidence for the portfolio station.” “Any candidates who fail to upload evidence for their portfolio will have their interview slot cancelled”.
“Your total score will be a combination of MSRA (10%), portfolio station score (45%) and management and clinical station score (45%).” The MSRA is scaled to 0 to 10 points and the total is out of 100. So the portfolio station carries as much weight as the management and clinical station. For how that station runs, see our CST interview guide.
2027 dates
From the recruitment timelines page, read October 27, 2026.
- October 22 to November 19, 2026. Applications open on Oriel. There is no self-assessment to fill in.
- January 5 to 18, 2027. The MSRA window.
- February 16, 2027. Interview invitations (subject to change).
- February 19 to 24, 2027. Upload your index page and evidence. Every achievement must be complete by February 19.
- March 1 to 10, 2027. Interviews online, including the portfolio station.
Applying to Internal Medicine Training too? Its self-assessment works differently, with points: see our IMT portfolio guide, or the UK specialty training interviews hub for other specialties.
Sources: NHS England Medical Hub, Core Surgery portfolio guidance for candidates, applying, interviews, recruitment timelines and overview pages. All checked October 27, 2026.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a CST self-assessment in 2027?
Not on Oriel. For 2027 you no longer self-assess when you apply. If you are invited to interview, you upload an index page with a letter from A to E for each domain, plus one piece of evidence per domain, between February 19 and 24, 2027.
How many points is each CST portfolio domain worth in 2027?
The 2027 guidance does not publish point values. It gives letters from A to E for each domain. Assessors review your evidence, ask two portfolio questions and give a final portfolio score, and the portfolio station as a whole is 45% of your total.
Which CST portfolio domains are you asked about at interview?
Only Patients, Partnership and Communication, and Colleagues, Culture and Safety. You get two portfolio questions of 5 minutes each, and assessors ask them even if you uploaded no evidence.
What makes a CST portfolio item score 0?
No index page, a supervisor letter without the GMC number it asks for, an electronic signature that can be edited, or any patient identifiable data. A publication without a PubMed ID or Web of Science reference also scores 0.
How does the CST portfolio fit with the MSRA?
The MSRA decides who is invited, roughly the top 1,200 candidates. Your total is then the MSRA at 10%, the portfolio station at 45% and the management and clinical station at 45%. How the MSRA works