Does Casper Coaching Work? What Official Evidence Shows

Try a free Casper practice scenario

Free, no sign-up to start.

Official Acuity Insights evidence shows test takers who use third-party Casper prep courses tend to do worse than those who use the free practice test.

Try a free Casper practice scenario

Free, no sign-up to start.

No, paid third-party coaching is not needed for Casper. According to Acuity Insights, test takers who use third-party preparation materials or do not prepare at all tend to do worse than those who use the free official Casper practice test. Because Casper evaluates your authentic judgment across 11 open-response scenarios, structured self-practice under real time limits is the best way to prepare. Sources: About Casper - Acuity Insights, How to Prepare for Casper - Acuity Insights, A Step-by-Step Guide for Test Takers (PDF) - Acuity Insights. Last checked November 11, 2026.

What Acuity Insights Says About Third-Party Coaching

More importantly, Acuity Insights reports on its official test preparation page that test takers who use third-party preparation materials or do not prepare at all tend to perform worse than applicants who use the free Casper resources provided directly inside their Acuity Insights account.

Casper is an open-response situational judgment test (SJT) built to evaluate your social intelligence and professionalism in real-world situations. Because the assessment measures how you think, make decisions, and explain your reasoning in your own words, there is no factual syllabus to memorize and no reason to purchase commercial preparation courses.

  • Performance comparison: Test takers using the free official practice test tend to outperform both unprepared test takers and those using third-party prep materials.
  • Core requirement: Strong answers explain both what you would do in a scenario and why you would do it.

Why Scripted Coaching Templates Fall Short on Casper

On Casper, relying on a memorized script works against how the exam is actually graded.

Every Casper test is scored by certified human raters, not artificial intelligence. Raters complete training on scoring criteria, calibration, and implicit bias to evaluate the quality of your ideas, judgment, and reasoning. They are explicitly trained not to grade you on response length, spelling mistakes, punctuation, grammar issues, or the use of jargon.

Furthermore, you cannot tailor your personality to please one specific evaluator. Each of your 11 scenarios is scored by a different human rater, and your responses are anonymized so raters never see your name or personal information. How you answer one scenario has no effect on how your next scenario is scored. If you spend your time typing out a rehearsed template instead of directly answering the 2 questions on the screen, you lose valuable seconds without earning points for formatting or vocabulary.

How Human Raters Evaluate Casper Responses (Acuity Insights Step-by-Step Guide)
What Raters EvaluateWhat Raters Ignore
What you would do in the scenarioResponse length
Why you would do it (your motivations and reasoning)Minor spelling, grammar, or punctuation errors
How you consider different perspectives and complex challengesJargon or rigid formatting (bullet points are allowed)
The 9 core social intelligence and professionalism skillsYour personal identity or appearance on camera

What Casper Measures and How the Timing Works

Instead of paying a coach to teach you theory, you need to understand the 9 specific competencies Casper tests and the strict clock you will face on test day. As you respond to scenarios, Acuity Insights states that you are demonstrating skills that contribute to social intelligence and professionalism: collaboration, communication, empathy, ethics, fairness, motivation, problem solving, resilience, and self-awareness. For medical school applicants, this focus aligns with the broader admissions framework described by the Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC), whose Premed Competencies for Entering Medical Students model includes 17 professional, thinking and reasoning, and science competencies, and whose AAMC PREview exam similarly evaluates personal accountability and relational skills in hypothetical scenarios across a 75-minute, 186-response rating format.

The standard Casper assessment takes 65 to 85 minutes to complete, including 2 optional breaks. Select programs, such as Australian teacher education programs, use a shorter format with fewer scenarios and reduced testing time.

You will answer 22 open-ended questions across 11 scenarios during the standard exam, which gives you an average of 1.75 minutes per question in the typed section. Because each question within a scenario is scored individually by the rater, spending all 3.5 minutes writing a long essay for the first typed question leaves the second question blank and hurts your overall score.

  • Video response section: 4 scenarios, with 2 open-ended questions per scenario and 1 minute to record each response (8 video responses total).
  • Typed response section: 7 scenarios, with 2 open-ended questions presented on the same page and 3.5 minutes total to respond to both questions (14 typed responses total).
  • Scoring output: Scores for each question across all scenarios are combined and standardized into a single overall score, and you receive a quartile score showing how you compare to peers.

1-on-1 Coaching vs. AI Simulation vs. Free Official Practice

When deciding how to invest your preparation time and money, it helps to compare commercial 1-on-1 coaching, timed simulation practice, and the free official Acuity Insights practice test against what the exam actually requires.

Because Casper is designed to assess your authentic responses in time-limited, real-world scenarios where professional judgment is required quickly, your preparation needs to focus on format familiarity, pacing, and explaining both what you would do and why. Acuity Insights allows you to take the official practice test in your account as many times as you like for free after reserving your test, though your practice responses are not saved, scored, or reviewed.

Structured self-practice and timed simulation help you build comfort with the 1-minute video and 3.5-minute typed limits, whereas third-party prep courses are not endorsed by Acuity Insights and test takers who use third-party materials tend to do worse than those who use the free official resources.

Comparing Casper Preparation Approaches Using Official Acuity Insights Criteria
Preparation FactorThird-Party 1-on-1 Coaching & CoursesTimed Self-Practice & SimulationFree Official Acuity Insights Practice Test
Official Acuity Insights evidenceTest takers using third-party prep tend to do worse than those using free official resourcesAcuity recommends practicing organizing thoughts under time constraints and recording yourself on PC Camera or Mac Photo BoothTest takers using the free official practice test tend to do better than those using third-party materials or not preparing
Alignment with human rater scoringRaters ignore jargon, formatting, and response length, and evaluate authentic reasoning instead of memorized contentHelps you practice answering both individually scored questions and explaining both what you would do and whyMatches the exact format and timing of the Casper test type you registered for
Repetition and feedbackNot affiliated with or endorsed by Acuity InsightsCan be repeated with free online typing tools and reviewed with a trusted friend, family member, or advisorCan be taken unlimited times in your Acuity Insights account, though responses are not saved, scored, or reviewed

How to Prepare for Casper for Free: A Step-by-Step Self-Study Plan

You can build all the pacing, typing, and camera skills you need without spending money on a tutor. Acuity Insights provides a clear set of preparation strategies that anyone can follow at home. In addition, budget-conscious applicants who have been approved for a participating US or UK Fee Assistance Program, such as the AAMC Fee Assistance Program (which requires a US-based home address and a 2025 total family income equal to or less than 400% of the 2025 national poverty level for your family size), AACOMAS, CASPA, ADEA, or UCAS bursary, may be eligible to have their Casper test fees waived or reduced when booking.

Start by reserving your test early so you get access to the free official practice test inside your Acuity Insights account. You can take this practice test as many times as you want. Your practice responses are not saved, scored, or reviewed, which gives you a pressure-free environment to test your pacing. If you have approved time accommodations, your approval letter will include a separate link to a practice test that matches your accommodated timing.

Use this checklist written by our team, built directly from official Acuity Insights preparation guidelines, to structure your self-practice before test day:

  • Step 1: Run a baseline practice test. Log in at my.acuityinsights.app/casper, go to the Casper section, and select Start practice test. Treat it like a real test session to feel the 1-minute video and 3.5-minute typed time limits.
  • Step 2: Build typing speed if needed. You must type your answers in real time during the exam. If typing is not a strength for you, use free online typing tools to get comfortable and build confidence before test day.
  • Step 3: Practice on your computer camera. To overcome camera shyness for the 4 video scenarios, record yourself answering sample prompts using the Camera app on a PC or Photo Booth on a Mac. Pay attention to your body language and tone, speak clearly, and behave naturally.
  • Step 4: Ask someone you trust for feedback. You do not need a paid consultant to review your practice. Acuity Insights recommends reviewing your self-recorded videos and asking a trusted friend, family member, or advisor for honest feedback.
  • Step 5: Practice the 'What and Why' rule and bullet points. For every practice question, take a few seconds to plan, then state both what you would do and why you would do it. In the typed section, practice listing your main points as bullet points first if you feel pressed for time, and make sure you allocate time to answer both questions on the page.

Official Sample Scenario and Labeled Example Answer

To see how explaining 'what' and 'why' works under a 3.5-minute time limit without relying on coaching jargon, look at this official word-based scenario published on the Acuity Insights Casper overview page.

Official Prompt: Think of a time when you had to make a sacrifice in order to accomplish a goal. Question 1: Briefly describe the situation and the sacrifice you made to accomplish the goal. Question 2: Imagine that despite the sacrifice made, you failed to accomplish the goal. How would you have felt in this situation? Explain your reasoning.

In a real typed scenario, both questions appear on the same screen and you have 3.5 minutes total to answer both. Below is a comparison of a weak scripted response versus a strong, authentic response, including the option to use bullet points as permitted by Acuity Insights.

Example answers written by our team. The applicant is invented.

  • Weak Scripted Response (Question 1): As a future health professional committed to empathy, ethics, resilience, and self-awareness, I always consider all stakeholders when making a sacrifice for a goal. During college, I had to balance many competing responsibilities and sacrificed my personal free time to study harder for my classes so I could achieve academic excellence. (Question 2): If I failed, I would gather all the facts and communicate non-judgmentally with my professor.
  • Strong Authentic Response (Question 1): During my junior year, my goal was to complete my honors biology thesis while supporting my family after my father had surgery. To make time for both lab work and driving my younger sister to school every day, I gave up my spot as captain of the club soccer team. I chose this sacrifice because my family's immediate well-being and my academic commitment had to come before an extracurricular activity I loved, even though stepping away from my teammates was painful.
  • Strong Authentic Response (Question 2): If my thesis experiment had still failed despite giving up my final season of soccer, I would have felt deeply disappointed and frustrated at first. Why I would feel this way and how I would respond: 1. It is natural to grieve the loss of a team role when the tradeoff does not pay off as planned. 2. However, I would remind myself why I made the choice: protecting my time for my family was still the right priority. 3. I would meet with my thesis advisor to review what went wrong in the protocol, document what I learned from the failed trials, and ask how I could salvage the data for a smaller departmental presentation.

Why This Example Works Without Coaching

The weak response wastes time listing competency buzzwords, gives a vague answer to Question 1 without explaining a specific motivation, and runs out of time on Question 2 without answering how the applicant would have felt or why. Because raters are trained to ignore jargon and score each question individually, this scripted approach loses points on both questions.

The strong response splits time evenly between Question 1 and Question 2 so the rater can score both. In Question 1, it clearly states what the sacrifice was (stepping down from club soccer) and why the applicant made it (prioritizing family care and academic commitments). In Question 2, it uses numbered points to organize thoughts quickly, acknowledges honest human emotion (disappointment and frustration), and shows resilience and problem solving by explaining the next constructive steps with the thesis advisor.

Strict Test-Day Rules: AI Tools, Notes, and Retakes

Show details

Violating Acuity Insights test security rules can result in score cancellation and a report of your actions being shared directly with the admissions programs on your distribution list.

During your Casper test, your webcam and microphone must remain on, uncovered, and facing you the entire time, including during the typed section. Copy and paste functionality is disabled inside the test platform, and you must type your responses in real time.

Review the official rules on prohibited aids and retakes in the table below.

Casper Test-Day Rules and Retake Policy (Acuity Insights)
CategoryOfficial Rule
Prohibited items and toolsPre-written notes (handwritten or digital), AI tools of any kind, and speech-to-text or dictation tools (unless pre-approved for accommodations) are strictly prohibited
Real-time response rulesCopy and paste functionality is disabled, and your webcam and microphone must remain on and facing you throughout the entire test
Retake policyYou cannot retake the same Casper test type in the same admissions cycle to try to improve your score

Frequently asked questions

Does Casper coaching or third-party test prep actually work?

According to Acuity Insights, test takers who use third-party preparation materials or do not prepare at all tend to do worse than those who use the free official Casper practice resources.

What is the best way to prepare for Casper without paying for a tutor?

Reserve your test to get access to the free official practice test in your Acuity Insights account, which you can take unlimited times to practice the 1-minute video and 3.5-minute typed limits. Acuity Insights also recommends practicing explaining both what you would do and why, using free online typing tools if needed, and recording yourself on your computer camera to review with someone you trust.

Do Casper raters grade on grammar, spelling, or response length?

No. Certified human raters are trained to evaluate the quality of your ideas, judgment, and reasoning rather than response length, spelling mistakes, punctuation, grammar issues, or jargon. You are even allowed to use bullet points in your typed responses to capture your main ideas.

Can I use AI tools or pre-written coaching notes during the Casper test?

No. Pre-written notes (handwritten or digital), AI tools of any kind, and speech-to-text or dictation tools are strictly prohibited during Casper, and copy-paste functionality is disabled.

Can I retake Casper if I get a low quartile score?

No. Applicants are not permitted to take the same Casper test type more than once per admissions cycle to try to improve their score.

Sources