How to Write an Ethical Dilemma Essay in Nursing
Free, no sign-up to start.
Write a strong ethical dilemma in nursing essay or Casper answer using the 2025 ANA Code of Ethics, bioethical theories, and worked examples.
Free, no sign-up to start.
An ethical dilemma essay in nursing analyzes a clinical situation where competing moral duties collide and honoring one principle requires sacrificing another. Strong papers evaluate the conflict using core bioethical principles alongside the 10 provisions of the 2025 American Nurses Association Code of Ethics for Nurses, which serves as the definitive standard for ethical nursing practice. You build a defensible argument by describing the clinical case in first person, weighing opposing courses of action in objective third person, and proposing concrete advocacy and safety steps. Sources: 2025 Code of Ethics for Nurses, American Nurses Association, 2025 Code of Ethics Provisions, American Nurses Association, Ethics and Human Rights in Nursing, American Nurses Association. Last checked November 13, 2026.
On this page
- What Counts as a True Ethical Dilemma in Nursing
- Bioethical Principles and the 2025 Code of Ethics
- Comparing Ethical Theories on the Same Clinical Case
- Step-by-Step Structure and Voice Rules for Your Paper
- Worked Essay Excerpt and Why Solo Hero Stories Backfire
- High-Yield Clinical Topics and Institutional Action Steps
- Nursing Ethics Scenarios on Casper and Program Applications
- Pre-Submission Checklist for Your Nursing Ethics Paper
- Practice question
- Frequently asked questions
- Sources
What Counts as a True Ethical Dilemma in Nursing
When you sit down to write an ethical dilemma in nursing essay, your paper succeeds or fails on the scenario you choose. Many students pick an obvious rule violation, such as a colleague stealing medication or falsifying vitals out of laziness, where the right action is clear and undisputed. A genuine ethical dilemma requires a collision between competing moral obligations where every available choice carries a real moral cost. As Mildred Solomon of The Hastings Center notes in a 2016 Association of American Medical Colleges report on clinical ethics training, everyone in these situations may be acting morally while remaining unsure which choice or policy does the most good.
Before you draft your thesis for an essay on an ethical dilemma in nursing, separate three distinct concepts that clinical papers frequently mix up. Naming the exact type of moral problem in your opening section shows your grader or admissions reader that you understand clinical ethics terminology.
You also need to distinguish legal competence from clinical decision-making capacity if your paper involves a patient refusing care or asking to leave against medical advice. Courts determine legal competence, whereas clinicians assess bedside decision-making capacity for a specific treatment choice at a specific moment. As medical trainees interviewed by the Association of American Medical Colleges point out, children and acutely delirious patients cannot make valid treatment decisions, yet subtle bedside capacity assessments become murky when clinicians question capacity simply because they disagree with an adult patient's choice. If a post-operative patient pulls out an intravenous line during acute delirium, stopping harm is not a violation of autonomy because delirium temporarily removes decision-making capacity.
- Ethical dilemma, a clinical conflict where valid ethical principles pull in opposite directions, such as respecting a capable adult's refusal of life-prolonging care when beneficence urges intervention.
- Moral uncertainty, a bedside moment when you sense a moral problem in a patient interaction but feel unsure which ethical principles or professional rules apply.
- Moral distress, a situation where you know the ethically right action to protect a patient, yet hierarchical team pressure, fear of reprimand, or institutional barriers discourage you from speaking up.
Bioethical Principles and the 2025 Code of Ethics
Every ethical dilemma essay nursing rubric expects you to pair foundational bioethical principles with professional nursing standards. In the May 2017 issue of the Online Journal of Issues in Nursing, clinical ethics analysis groups bedside dilemmas around 4 core ethical principle categories, namely autonomy and the right to self-determination, beneficence and nonmaleficence, disclosure and the right to knowledge, and veracity. Autonomy protects a capable patient's right to make choices aligned with personal beliefs. Beneficence directs you to act for the patient's good, while nonmaleficence requires avoiding and minimizing harm. Disclosure obligates providers to share clinical facts needed for informed consent, including medical errors, and veracity requires accurate, objective truth-telling in plain language so patients can understand their care and trust their team.
To anchor those principles in US professional standards, cite the newly revised 2025 Code of Ethics for Nurses with Interpretive Statements. Developed through a revision panel and public comment period that drew over 6,300 responses from 3,000 individuals, the Code serves as the definitive standard for ethical nursing practice and highlights nursing's commitment to social justice and health equity. Outdated sample papers online stop at nine provisions, so citing the 10 provisions of the current edition immediately sets your analysis apart.
By our calculation from the American Nurses Association Code of Ethics overview, 3 of the 10 provisions (30 percent) govern the direct nurse-to-patient relationship, 3 of the 10 provisions (30 percent) address nurse-to-colleague responsibilities and the work environment, and 4 of the 10 provisions (40 percent) focus on advancing the profession, interprofessional collaboration, social justice, and global health. That breakdown matters for your essay because 70 percent of the Code reaches beyond one-on-one bedside care into workplace safety, peer accountability, and systemic equity.
| Provision Group | Specific Provisions | Core Ethical Focus | Essay Topics Supported |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nurse-to-Patient | Provisions 1, 2, and 3 | Compassion, inherent human dignity, primary commitment to care recipients, trust, and safety advocacy | Treatment refusal, family versus patient wishes, informed consent, confidentiality, and error disclosure |
| Nurse-to-Colleague and Workplace | Provisions 4, 5, and 6 | Practice authority and accountability, moral duties to self and workplace safety, and ethical work environments | Moral distress, unsafe staffing, speaking up in steep hierarchies, conscientious objection, and blame culture |
| Profession and Interprofessional | Provisions 7 and 8 | Knowledge development, policy generation, and collaboration across healthcare and public disciplines | Ethics committee consultations, interdisciplinary care conflicts, and updating hospital safety protocols |
| Nurse-to-Society and Global Community | Provisions 9 and 10 | Enacting policies for social justice, eliminating health inequities, and advancing global and environmental health | Triage and scarce resource allocation, care access for uninsured patients, and algorithmic bias |
Comparing Ethical Theories on the Same Clinical Case
Listing bioethical definitions without testing them against broader moral theories leaves your analysis shallow. High-scoring nursing papers show how classical and nursing-centered ethical frameworks weigh the exact same bedside facts differently. Deontology judges an action by moral duties and rules regardless of whether hiding the truth might seem calmer in the short run. Utilitarianism evaluates choices by weighing projected benefits and harms across everyone affected. Relational care ethics, which aligns with the relational ethical tradition described in the Code of Ethics for Nurses, centers trust, human vulnerability, communication context, and ongoing caregiving relationships.
Use the comparison matrix below when drafting your theoretical analysis and counterargument paragraphs. Showing why two valid frameworks point toward different priorities proves you are analyzing a genuine dilemma rather than lecturing the reader.
| Analytical Lens | Central Moral Question | Application to Disclosing a Medication Error | Application to Capable Adult Refusing Treatment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Deontology (Duty-Based) | Which action fulfills unconditional moral duties such as veracity and respect for persons? | Mandates prompt, honest disclosure because truth-telling and the patient's right to knowledge apply regardless of personal fear | Requires honoring the capable patient's refusal because self-determination cannot be overridden for paternalistic reasons |
| Utilitarianism (Outcome-Based) | Which course of action produces the greatest net benefit and minimizes total harm? | Weighs patient anxiety against medical necessity, concluding disclosure prevents untreated complications and fixes system flaws | Examines survival odds, symptom burden, and family impact, creating tension when treatment offers clear medical benefit |
| Relational Care Ethics | How can the nurse preserve trust, dignity, and mutual support within the care relationship? | Focuses on compassionate, face-to-face honesty, timely clinical follow-up, and non-punitive support for the reporting nurse | Prioritizes open dialogue to explore the patient's fears, cultural values, and family dynamics without coercion |
Step-by-Step Structure and Voice Rules for Your Paper
One question trips up nursing writers more than any other, whether to use first person or third person. Academic nursing ethics assignments frequently blend personal clinical reflection with formal literature analysis, and using the wrong voice in the wrong section weakens your paper. Use first person when recounting a paradigm case you witnessed in clinicals and when reflecting on your personal values and moral growth at the end of the paper. Shift strictly to objective third person in the middle sections where you analyze bioethical principles, cite the Code of Ethics, apply a decision-making framework, and evaluate opposing options.
Organize your essay in clear sequential blocks so your grader can trace your reasoning from clinical problem to policy recommendation. Build your thesis statement around the exact moral tension rather than a vague promise to discuss ethics. A strong thesis pattern states that while one principle supports a protective clinical intervention, another principle and specific Code provisions require an alternative path to safeguard patient self-determination and trust. When introducing the opposing view, use neutral academic transitions such as, From a beneficence-focused perspective, clinicians might argue, followed by, However, overriding a capable patient's informed refusal erodes veracity and violates Provision 1.
- Introduction and thesis, open with the clinical stakes, name the competing ethical principles, identify the relevant Code of Ethics provisions, and state your reasoned resolution in one clear thesis sentence.
- Clinical scenario narrative (first person if reflective, third person if analyzing an assigned case), state relevant clinical facts, timeline, patient capacity status, and key stakeholders using pseudonyms to protect privacy.
- Dilemma identification, isolate the two competing moral obligations and explain why institutional policy or clinical urgency makes it impossible to satisfy both fully.
- Theoretical and professional code analysis (strictly third person), evaluate the conflict through bioethical principles, at least one normative theory, and specific provisions from the 2025 Code of Ethics.
- Alternative actions and counterargument (strictly third person), present the strongest moral case for the opposing course of action, analyze its clinical and ethical consequences, and explain why you set it aside.
- Resolution, system recommendations, and personal reflection (return to first person for personal reflection), detail concrete bedside and unit-level steps and reflect on how the case shaped your professional identity.
Worked Essay Excerpt and Why Solo Hero Stories Backfire
Whether you are writing a graded Bachelor of Science in Nursing ethics paper or a healthcare admissions essay, avoid framing yourself as the lone moral hero saving a patient from careless teammates. In the Association of American Medical Colleges competency-based application review framework, an example applicant evaluation illustrates this exact trap. While leading an ethics committee and respecting confidentiality earned a 5 out of 5 rating for Ethical Responsibility and reflecting on 2 years with a refugee program earned a 4 out of 5 for Empathy, writing a personal hero story that overshadowed team contributions scored 1 out of 5 on Teamwork. Strong nursing ethics writing credits interprofessional collaboration, preceptors, pharmacists, physicians, and unit managers.
During my senior medical-surgical rotation, I cared for Mr. Alvarez, an alert, oriented adult admitted with worsening heart failure who declined a recommended implantable defibrillator after discussing his goals with his daughter. His bedside cardiology resident urged our team to keep pressing Mr. Alvarez each shift until he signed the consent form, arguing the device could prevent sudden cardiac arrest. Standing at the bedside, I felt caught between supporting life-saving medical care and honoring my patient's clear, repeated refusal. Worked essay excerpt written by our team. The student and patient are invented.
This clinical conflict pits beneficence against patient autonomy and the right to self-determination. Under a narrow consequentialist view, persistent persuasion appears justified if device placement extends survival. However, because the clinical team confirmed that Mr. Alvarez possessed intact decision-making capacity and understood the risk of sudden death, repeated pressure crosses from patient education into coercion. Provision 1 of the 2025 Code of Ethics directs nurses to practice with compassion and respect for the inherent dignity and worth of every person, while Provision 3 requires advocating for the rights, health, and safety of care recipients. Requesting an interprofessional goals-of-care meeting aligns the medical team with the patient's documented values rather than leaving bedside staff in isolated conflict. Worked essay excerpt written by our team. The student and patient are invented.
Participating in that family and team conference reshaped how I view patient advocacy. Rather than confronting the resident alone, I shared Mr. Alvarez's stated priorities with my clinical preceptor and the attending nurse, which prompted a calm palliative and cardiology huddle. I learned that ethical practice relies on clear team communication and early collaboration rather than silent moral distress. Worked essay excerpt written by our team. The student and patient are invented.
High-Yield Clinical Topics and Institutional Action Steps
Show details
If your professor lets you choose your own topic for an ethical dilemma essay in nursing, everyday clinical conflicts often produce stronger, more realistic papers than rare courtroom dramas. Clinicians interviewed in the 2016 Association of American Medical Colleges ethics report noted a frequent mismatch between abstract textbook debates and daily practice, pointing out that bedside questions regularly arise around childbirth, abortion, contraception, infectious diseases, sexuality, disclosing a trainee's experience level with a procedure, and speaking up when surgical risks are understated.
Medical error disclosure is another rich, evidence-backed essay topic. In the May 2017 Online Journal of Issues in Nursing, Jeanne Sorrell cites a 2016 Johns Hopkins calculation estimating that medical errors cause more than 250,000 deaths per year in the United States, replacing respiratory disease from the 2013 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention rankings as the third leading cause of death behind heart disease and cancer. Sorrell shares the paradigm case of an oncology nurse with over 25 years of nursing experience who reconstituted 4 vials of a newly formatted chemotherapy medication and administered 250 mg instead of the ordered 100 mg. Although terrified of losing her license, the nurse immediately informed her manager and the oncologist, who disclosed the error to the patient and started aggressive cell-count support that saved the patient's life. In contrast, a cited study of 289 Canadian long-term care nurses found that differing definitions of harm led busy staff to skip reporting errors they perceived as causing no harm.
When you write the recommendations section of your paper, go beyond vague advice like talk to your supervisor. Registered nurses represent the largest group of healthcare professionals at over 3 million strong according to a 2016 American Nurses Association figure cited in the Online Journal of Issues in Nursing, placing nurses in a direct position to build a Culture of Safety where safety outweighs competing organizational goals. Propose concrete institutional steps drawn from clinical ethics and safety practice.
- Request early interprofessional ethics input, involve nurses, physicians, chaplains, and medical interpreters when value conflicts first surface rather than calling a formal ethics committee at the 11th hour when little time remains to reflect.
- Use structured communication tools, apply SBAR handoffs and post-event task debriefings so junior nurses and students can raise safety or consent concerns clearly in steep hierarchies.
- Build forcing functions and standardized orders, recommend computerized order-entry locks, mandatory safety checklists, and uniform dose-versus-dilution formatting that make dosing mix-ups nearly impossible.
- Replace blame culture with story-sharing and clear disclosure policies, establish non-punitive error reporting and transparent patient disclosure protocols so fear of punishment never delays corrective treatment.
Nursing Ethics Scenarios on Casper and Program Applications
Show details
You will also test these exact ethical reasoning skills before you ever set foot in a nursing classroom if your target programs require situational judgment testing or admissions essays. Casper, an open-response situational judgment test completed by more than 1 million applicants across 600+ partner programs worldwide and backed by over 20 years of research and over 150 internal and external studies, asks you to respond to realistic scenarios using typed and video answers in your own words.
Selective nursing schools use these scenarios to measure ethics, empathy, communication, and judgment alongside grades. For example, McMaster University's collaborative Bachelor of Nursing program across McMaster University, Mohawk College, and Conestoga College evaluates about 1,500 applicants per year across its 3 sites. By pairing Casper scores with academic averages above a minimum grade threshold, McMaster accepted applicants whose grades fell below the prior year's 92 percent cut-off while aligning selection with entry-to-practice nursing competencies.
If you are writing about an ethical dilemma for a formal healthcare application essay, follow strict factual integrity rules. In the 2027 AMCAS Applicant Guide, applicants must complete the Personal Comments Essay (plus 2 additional essays for combined MD-PhD applicants), proofread carefully because no changes are permitted after submission, and provide complete, current, and accurate information. Any alleged falsification, omission, or discrepancy in application materials can trigger a formal investigation report. Change patient and colleague names to protect confidentiality and explicitly note the pseudonym if appropriate, while keeping your own role, actions, and clinical observations completely truthful.
Pre-Submission Checklist for Your Nursing Ethics Paper
Show details
Before you turn in your essay, run your draft through this review checklist created by our team to catch the structural and clinical slips that cost points on nursing rubrics.
- True moral tension, verify that your scenario pits two legitimate ethical duties against each other rather than describing simple negligence or misconduct.
- Capacity check, confirm that your paper separates clinical decision-making capacity (such as ruling out acute delirium or hypoxia) from a capable adult's autonomous right to refuse care.
- Current professional code, check that every provision reference matches the 10 provisions of the 2025 Code of Ethics for Nurses rather than older editions.
- Voice discipline, ensure clinical stories and closing self-reflections use first person while bioethical, theoretical, and policy analysis stays in objective third person.
- Fair counterargument, read your opposing-action paragraph to confirm you Steel-manned the competing principle with clinical empathy before explaining why your chosen path prevails.
- Team-centered resolution, replace solo hero framing with concrete interprofessional actions, early ethics consultation, SBAR communication, or unit-level safety improvements.
- Confidentiality and accuracy, verify that all patient, preceptor, and facility identifiers are anonymized in academic papers and that personal admissions essays contain zero exaggerated claims.
Practice question
During a hospital clinical shift, your nursing preceptor realizes a routine post-operative dose of intravenous antibiotics was given late to an elderly patient who has just become acutely confused and is trying to climb out of bed to go home. Your preceptor asks you not to mention the late dose when calling the physician about the patient's sudden confusion, saying the antibiotic timing is unrelated and reporting it will get both of you blamed. How do you handle this situation?
See an example answer
My immediate priority is keeping the patient physically safe at the bedside and making sure the physician has accurate clinical facts to treat the acute confusion. Because sudden post-operative confusion can signal infection, hypoxia, or delirium, the patient currently lacks clear decision-making capacity to leave safely, so I would stay at the bedside or ask a teammate to stay with the patient using calm reassurance while we assess vital signs. Next, I would speak privately and respectfully with my preceptor. I understand the fear of unfair blame during a busy shift, and I do not want to jump to conclusions about why the confusion started. At the same time, withholding the exact timing of the antibiotic could mislead the physician's diagnostic workup for sepsis or medication reaction and violates our duty of honesty to the patient. I would invite my preceptor to call the physician together so we can share the complete timeline objectively. If my preceptor still refuses to disclose the late dose, I would involve my clinical instructor or charge nurse to ensure accurate reporting and timely patient care. Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented.
This response secures immediate bedside safety first and correctly recognizes that acute post-operative confusion impairs decision-making capacity rather than representing an autonomous discharge request. It addresses the preceptor privately with empathy for blame-culture pressure while upholding veracity, complete clinical disclosure, and a clear escalation path.
Frequently asked questions
What ethical principles belong in an ethical dilemma in nursing essay?
Clinical nursing analyses center on autonomy and the right to self-determination, beneficence, nonmaleficence, disclosure and the right to knowledge, veracity, and social justice. Pair the two principles in direct tension in your case with matching provisions from the 2025 Code of Ethics for Nurses.
Can I use first person in a nursing ethics essay?
Yes, when your assignment includes a personal clinical paradigm case or a closing reflection on your own values and moral distress, write those sections in first person. Switch to objective third person for your theoretical analysis, literature citations, and evaluation of policy options, and always check your course syllabus instructions.
How many provisions are in the current ANA Code of Ethics for Nurses?
The revised 2025 Code of Ethics for Nurses contains 10 provisions. Provisions 1 through 3 govern the nurse-to-patient relationship, Provisions 4 through 6 address nurse-to-colleague responsibilities and ethical workplaces, and Provisions 7 through 10 cover advancing the profession, interprofessional collaboration, social justice, and global health.
What is the difference between an ethical dilemma and moral distress in nursing?
An ethical dilemma occurs when competing moral principles support mutually exclusive actions and every option sacrifices an ethical value. Moral distress happens when you know the ethically appropriate action for your patient, yet hierarchical pressure or institutional barriers discourage you from acting or speaking up.
How do nursing schools test ethical dilemmas on Casper?
Programs such as McMaster University's collaborative Bachelor of Nursing use Casper open-response typed and video scenarios to evaluate how applicants exercise judgment, ethics, communication, and empathy in realistic situations. Multiple independent raters score how clearly you weigh competing perspectives rather than looking for a single multiple-choice answer.
Sources
- 2025 Code of Ethics for Nurses, American Nurses Association
- 2025 Code of Ethics Provisions, American Nurses Association
- Ethics and Human Rights in Nursing, American Nurses Association
- Ethical Issues with Medical Errors, Online Journal of Issues in Nursing (May 2017)
- Rethinking Nursing Admissions at McMaster, Acuity Insights
- Casper Open-Response Situational Judgment Test, Acuity Insights
- Teaching Tomorrow's Doctors Tough Ethical Questions, AAMC
- Competency-Based Application Review, AAMC
- 2027 AMCAS Applicant Guide Essays, AAMC
- 2027 AMCAS Applicant Guide Investigations, AAMC