Can You Fail the Casper Test? 1st Quartile Next Steps

Try a free Casper practice scenario

Free, no sign-up to start.

You cannot officially fail Casper. Learn what a 1st or 2nd quartile score means, Acuity Insights retake rules, and strategic next steps for your applications.

Try a free Casper practice scenario

Free, no sign-up to start.

You cannot officially pass or fail the Casper test. Applicants receive a quartile ranking that compares their performance to other test takers who completed the same test type, while individual programs receive standardized scores and decide independently how to weigh them. Because Acuity Insights permits only one attempt per test type per admissions cycle, you cannot retake the assessment to improve a 1st quartile score until the next cycle. Sources: Acuity Insights: About Casper, Acuity Insights: Casper Dates and Fees, AAMC: Preparing for Your Medical School Interview. Last checked November 11, 2026.

How Casper Scoring Works and What 1st Quartile Means

Seeing a 1st quartile result in your account can feel discouraging, but there is no passing or failing grade on Casper. The assessment is designed to provide admissions committees with insight into your social intelligence and professionalism, complementing your academic record rather than replacing it.

When you complete the 65 to 85 minute assessment, your responses across all 11 scenarios are evaluated by certified human raters, not artificial intelligence. Casper consists of 2 sections: 4 video-response scenarios and 7 typed-response scenarios. Each scenario presents 2 open-ended questions. A single rater scores both questions within one scenario, and a completely different rater scores each of your 11 scenarios. This multi-rater design ensures that no single evaluator determines your outcome and that a weak answer on one prompt does not carry over to influence the rest of your test.

Raters are trained to evaluate the quality of your ideas, your judgment, and your reasoning across complex interpersonal dilemmas. They do not penalize you for response length, spelling mistakes, grammar, or formatting styles. Scores across all questions are combined and standardized using statistical methods to produce your overall performance.

There is a distinct difference between what you receive and what admissions offices evaluate. While applicants see a high-level quartile band, programs receive a detailed standardized overall score. Each individual program determines how and when to use Casper scores as part of its admissions process, meaning the weight and role of your score vary widely by school.

These quartiles reflect how your score compares relative to all other applicants who completed the same test type in that testing cohort:

  • 1st Quartile (Q1)
  • 2nd Quartile (Q2)
  • 3rd Quartile (Q3)
  • 4th Quartile (Q4)
Casper Test Structure and Pacing
SectionScenario CountQuestions per ScenarioResponse Time LimitOptional Break
Video Responses4 scenarios2 open-ended questions1 minute per question10 minutes
Typed Responses (Part 1)4 scenarios2 open-ended questions on the same page3.5 minutes total per scenario5 minutes (varies on select international formats)
Typed Responses (Part 2)3 scenarios2 open-ended questions on the same page3.5 minutes total per scenarioNone (End of test)
Total (By our calculation from Acuity Insights)11 scenarios22 questions total8 minutes video recording + 24.5 minutes typing (32.5 minutes active response time)15 minutes total optional break time

Can You Retake Casper After a 1st Quartile Score?

Acuity Insights enforces a strict testing policy: applicants are not permitted to take a Casper test type more than once per admissions cycle. You cannot register for a second sitting within the same application year simply to improve a 1st or 2nd quartile score.

Casper scores are valid for only a single admissions cycle and for a singular test type. If you apply again in a future admissions cycle, you must take a new Casper test. When you reapply in a subsequent year, programs evaluate your new score, giving you a fresh start.

  • Different test types or languages: Casper test types are not interchangeable across countries or professions. If you apply to programs in different categories (such as American Health Sciences versus Canadian Health Sciences) or different languages (such as English versus French for Canadian programs), you must complete a separate Casper test for each required test type.
  • Verified technical platform issues: Acuity Insights considers same-cycle retakes only under rare, documented technical circumstances. The issue must not be caused by your personal computer or local internet connection, must be verified by Acuity Insights, and a retake is offered only if another test date remains available before your program distribution deadlines.

Why Low Scores Happen: Pacing and Core Competencies

Show details

Acuity Insights states that Casper does not test for a single right answer. Instead, raters assess how you think through complex challenges, consider multiple perspectives, and explain your reasoning across core skills that contribute to social intelligence and professionalism. These include collaboration, communication, empathy, ethics, fairness, motivation, problem solving, resilience, and self-awareness.

In our team's experience analyzing test pacing, lower quartile results often stem from time management bottlenecks and unbalanced answers rather than poor personal character. By our calculation from official Acuity Insights test formats, test takers have 32.5 minutes of total active response time to address 22 questions across 11 scenarios. In the typed section, both questions appear on a single screen with a shared 3.5 minute countdown. This averages out to 205 seconds (1 minute and 45 seconds) per question.

A frequent pacing pitfall occurs when an applicant spends 3 minutes crafting an extensive answer to the first prompt, leaving only 30 seconds for the second. Because the human rater evaluates and scores each of the 2 questions independently, an incomplete or blank second response significantly lowers your cumulative score for that scenario.

Acuity Insights notes on its preparation page that applicants who use third-party test prep materials or fail to prepare at all tend to perform worse than those who use the free official practice test in their account. Our team recommends avoiding rigid, memorized templates, which can prevent you from addressing the unique nuances of each prompt.

Next Steps for 1st and 2nd Quartile Applicants: School List Strategy

Receiving a 1st quartile result does not mean your application cycle is over. Because each program determines how and when to use Casper scores, the weight given to your result varies across institutions. Many medical schools evaluate Casper holistically alongside your GPA, MCAT scores, essays, and clinical experiences.

First, do not send unsolicited emails to admissions offices explaining or apologizing for a low Casper score. Admissions committees receive standardized score distributions directly and evaluate them according to their own internal policies. Reaching out to make excuses draws unnecessary negative attention to a metric that may only represent a minor consideration in their overall review.

Use this structured diagnostic self-audit written by our team to evaluate your performance and guide your current cycle decisions:

  • Rushing to judgment: Did you jump directly to disciplinary action or take a rigid stance before gathering facts, or did you explore multiple perspectives in a non-judgmental manner?
  • Missing stakeholders: Did you consider only the two primary individuals in the scenario, or did you recognize how the dilemma affected secondary parties, bystanders, and institutional policies?
  • Time allocation: Did you run out of time on the second typed prompt or leave questions incomplete?
  • Video delivery: Did you freeze or run out of time before stating your solution during the 1-minute video recordings?
  • Check delivery status in your portal: Confirm that your Acuity Insights account shows your test as completed and delivered. Some medical schools take time to manually update their local applicant portals.
  • Audit additional programs on your list: You can add more programs to your Casper distribution list after testing if they use the same test type and their distribution deadlines have not passed. Use the AAMC Medical School Admission Requirements (MSAR) database to review admissions policies and requirements across US and Canadian medical schools before spending additional distribution fees.
  • Identify schools that do not require Casper: If you choose to expand your school list, prioritize programs that do not require a situational judgment test, or programs that use the AAMC PREview exam instead.
  • Understand AAMC PREview participation: As of June 2026, medical schools participating in the AAMC PREview exam do so across 4 distinct categories: Requiring PREview, Recommending PREview, Requiring an SJT (where PREview satisfies the requirement), or Exploring PREview for Future Use (where scores are not used to evaluate current-year applicants).
  • Recognize holistic review practices: In guidance for admissions officers, the AAMC notes that schools most frequently use situational judgment scores as one indicator among many, often as a plus factor when evaluating comparable applicants alongside academic and experiential metrics.

How to Offset a Low Quartile in Your Medical School Interviews

If you receive an interview invitation, your application has successfully advanced past initial screening. According to the AAMC guide on preparing for medical school interviews, being invited to an interview means you have already impressed reviewers with your personal statement, letters of evaluation, and academic history.

The AAMC notes that medical schools usually interview significantly more applicants than they accept, making the interview a major determining factor in admissions. Crucially, the interview gives you a direct opportunity to demonstrate qualities such as empathy, self-awareness, emotional intelligence, communication ability, and interpersonal skills. These represent the exact qualities evaluated by Casper, allowing strong interview performance to supersede a low quartile ranking.

According to AAMC interview guides, interview invitations typically begin in late summer or early fall and continue through winter or spring, with interviews most commonly held from August to February. Schools conduct interviews using 4 technology formats (live in-person, live virtual, hybrid, and asynchronous virtual) and 4 structural styles:

  • Multiple Mini Interview (MMI): Consists of 6 to 10 stations, each focused on a distinct question or scenario, with about 5 minutes to respond at each station. Because MMIs evaluate situational judgment in real time, practicing spoken ethical problem solving is an effective way to showcase strong interpersonal judgment.
  • Group Interview: Multiple candidates work together to solve a problem or complete a task within a set time limit, allowing evaluators to assess teamwork and collaboration.
  • Panel Interview: Multiple interviewers question a single applicant at the same time, asking detailed follow-up questions.
  • One-on-One Interview: A single interviewer meets individually with the candidate for 20 to 30 minutes (or 30 to 60 minutes) to explore application details and personal background.

How to Prepare If You Retake Casper Next Cycle

Show details

If you reapply in a future admissions cycle, you will start with a completely clean slate. Medical schools evaluate your new Casper score for that cycle and do not retain past attempts. Use this focused preparation checklist developed by our team to build stronger habits:

  • Take the free official practice test: Log in to your Acuity Insights account and take the full-length official practice test. It includes both typed and video prompts under realistic timed conditions. Because practice responses are not saved or scored, review your answers with a trusted mentor to obtain actionable feedback.
  • Practice balanced pacing: In the typed section, practice allocating your 3.5 minutes evenly between both questions (about 105 seconds each) so you never leave a prompt unanswered.
  • Drill spoken video responses: Practice recording 1-minute video responses using your computer's built-in camera tool. Learn to deliver a clear, compassionate response within 60 seconds without rushing.
  • Apply non-judgmental fact finding: When reviewing scenarios, always gather relevant information privately before making major decisions, acknowledge the feelings of all parties involved, and offer constructive, ethical solutions.
  • Avoid commercial test prep courses: Rely on authentic problem solving and official practice materials rather than third-party prep packages or rigid templates.

Practice Casper Scenario and Example Answer

Comparing a weak response to a strong response illustrates why certain answers receive lower ratings from human evaluators. Below is an official Acuity Insights practice scenario with an analysis of a weak response written by our team, contrasting it with the strong model answer in our practice exercise below.

  • Weak Response (Typical of 1st Quartile): 'Question 1: Paul is letting the entire group down, which is completely unfair to those of us who care about our grades. I would tell Paul that if he doesn't submit his part of the assignment by tomorrow morning, our group will take his name off the project and report him to the professor for academic neglect. Medical conditions happen, but you cannot leave your teammates hanging. Question 2: Even if he contributed earlier, he abandoned the project at the end. I would give him partial credit only for what he did, but I would make sure the instructor knows he failed to finish his commitment so our own grades don't suffer.'
  • Why the Weak Answer Fails: This response jumps to immediate conclusions, lacks empathy for a peer experiencing a medical condition, uses punitive threats, and fails to seek guidance from the course instructor. It scores poorly on collaboration, communication, and empathy.

Practice question

Official Acuity Insights Sample Scenario: You are a group member. One of your group members, Paul, has stopped contributing to your group assignment due to a medical condition. (1) How should you and your group members handle this situation? Explain your response. (2) Imagine that Paul contributed a significant amount to the assignment before he put his courses on hold. How, if at all, would this change your response to the previous question? Explain your reasoning.

See an example answer

Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. Question 1: First, I would reach out to Paul privately to express support and check on his health, ensuring he does not feel pressured about coursework while managing an illness. Next, I would meet with the remaining group members to review remaining tasks and timeline obligations. Before making any changes to group roles or redistributing assignments, we should consult the course instructor. We can explain that a team member is facing medical difficulties while maintaining Paul's personal privacy, and ask for guidance regarding a possible extension or adjusted expectations. Question 2: If Paul completed significant work before putting his courses on hold, our team's priority should be ensuring he receives full academic credit for his contributions. I would document the specific research and sections Paul completed so the professor can evaluate his work fairly. The remaining group members and I can divide the remaining sections to complete the assignment successfully while respecting Paul's substantial initial effort.

This response divides active response time evenly across both questions so neither prompt is rushed. It demonstrates empathy by prioritizing Paul's well-being, upholds fairness and ethics by protecting his medical privacy and ensuring academic credit, collaborates with remaining peers, and approaches the instructor for institutional guidance.

Frequently asked questions

Can you officially fail the Casper test?

No, Casper does not have a passing or failing cutoff. Test takers receive a quartile ranking comparing their performance to peers who completed the same test type, and each participating admissions program independently determines how to evaluate and weight the results.

Can I retake Casper in the same cycle if I get a 1st quartile score?

No. Acuity Insights does not permit applicants to retake the same Casper test type more than once per admissions cycle. Retakes within the same cycle are considered only for rare, verified technical platform issues that are confirmed by Acuity Insights.

Do medical schools see my 1st quartile score if I reapply next cycle?

No. Casper scores are valid for only a single admissions cycle. When you reapply in a future admissions cycle, you must take a new Casper test, and programs evaluate only your new score for that cycle.

Do spelling errors or typing mistakes lead to a 1st quartile score?

No. Acuity Insights trains human raters to focus exclusively on the quality of your ideas, judgment, and reasoning. Raters do not score down for spelling, grammar, punctuation, or response length.

Sources