How to Write a Letter of Recommendation for Residency
Free, no sign-up to start.
How to write a recommendation letter for medical residency: AAMC structure, ACGME competencies, AI rules, 2027 portal upload steps, and a sample letter.
Free, no sign-up to start.
To write a strong letter of recommendation for medical residency, state your supervisory role and clinical setting, back up your praise with observed patient or research examples, and benchmark the applicant against PGY-1 expectations and ACGME competencies. Focus on the target specialty rather than repeating the CV, and place the letter on signed institutional letterhead. In the 2026 NRMP Program Director Survey, 86% of responding program directors cited specialty-specific letters of recommendation when selecting interviewees. Sources: AAMC and OPDA: Guidelines for Writing a Narrative Letter of Recommendation for a Residency Applicant, AAMC: ERAS for Letter Writers (2027 Season Updates and Key Dates), AAMC: AAMC Letter Writer Portal Overview and FAQs. Last checked November 12, 2026.
On this page
- What a medical residency recommendation letter needs to do
- Before you write: what to gather and when to decline
- Step-by-step structure and the 6 ACGME Core Competencies
- Sample narrative recommendation letter template (written by our team, not AAMC)
- Wording, faint praise, bias, and generative AI rules
- How to upload letters: AAMC Letter Writer Portal, PDF rules, and CaRMS
- For residency and health program applicants: how letters shape your interviews
- Practice question
- Frequently asked questions
- Sources
What a medical residency recommendation letter needs to do
When faculty look up how to write a letter of recommendation for medical residency, or how to write a recommendation letter for medical residency, the goal is a focused clinical evaluation rather than a general character reference. Joint guidelines from the Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) and the Organization of Program Directors Association (OPDA) advise connecting directly observed behaviors to the performance demands of the applicant's chosen specialty.
Before drafting, check whether the specialty uses a free-text narrative letter or a required form. The AAMC and OPDA framework is recommended for narrative letters and does not apply to Standardized Letters of Evaluation (SLOEs), Structured Evaluative Letters (SELs), or Standardized Letters of Recommendation (SLORs). Starting in the 2027 Electronic Residency Application Service (ERAS) cycle, the AAMC Letter Writer Portal hosts standardized templates for Urology, Dermatology, Plastic Surgery-Integrated, and Pain Medicine, while the Canadian Resident Matching Service (CaRMS) assigns online structured forms for six R-1 disciplines.
If you are an applicant reading this guide to prepare for residency or health professions interviews, Confetto runs realistic AI mock interviews with rubric-based feedback. Start your free week.
| Format | Where used | How the writer completes it |
|---|---|---|
| Narrative letter of recommendation | Most US ERAS specialties and general CaRMS R-1 disciplines | Written on institutional letterhead as a clinical evaluation and uploaded as a PDF |
| Specialty standardized evaluation (SLOE, SEL, SLOR, or portal templates) | Select US specialties including Urology, Dermatology, Plastic Surgery-Integrated, and Pain Medicine | Completed using the specialty organization's rubric or the AAMC Letter Writer Portal template |
| CaRMS online structured reference letter | Canadian R-1 applications in Family Medicine, Emergency Medicine, Orthopedic Surgery, Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Psychiatry, and Pediatrics | Assigned automatically upon request and completed directly inside the CaRMS Online referee account |
| Applicant support form | Select CaRMS programs, including introductory structured forms in Anesthesiology and Dermatology | Provided directly to the referee by the applicant rather than generated by CaRMS |
Before you write: what to gather and when to decline
Ask the applicant for a brief prep packet before you begin. Per the AAMC narrative guidelines, confirm which specialty or specialties the student is pursuing and ask for an updated curriculum vitae (CV) and a draft personal statement if you do not already have them. Request the portal email or ERAS Letter Request Form as well, which shows the applicant's identifier, the Letter ID, and whether they waived their right to inspect the letter.
If an applicant is applying to two specialties, such as a primary surgical discipline and a backup or preliminary field, never write one generic letter recommending them for "any residency program." Adjust the letter to match each specialty's performance requirements and have the student generate a separate request for each specialty.
Only agree to write if you can offer a genuinely strong, firsthand evaluation. If your contact with the student was too brief or clinical concerns remain unresolved, decline early and kindly so they can ask another supervisor. Never ask an applicant to write their own recommendation letter. Selection committees rely on your authentic, firsthand clinical perspective, which self-drafted letters erase.
- Target specialty check: confirm every discipline the student plans to enter so your closing endorsement names the right specialty.
- Dates and clinical setting: pull your rotation schedule to state the exact timeframe, context, and frequency of your supervision.
- Waiver and confidentiality: verify the FERPA access waiver on the ERAS request, or prepare CaRMS's required confidentiality line.
- Permission for private details: ask the applicant for explicit permission before sharing any private or sensitive personal circumstance.
Step-by-step structure and the 6 ACGME Core Competencies
A clear narrative recommendation letter moves from your credibility as an evaluator to concrete clinical examples and closes with a calibrated readiness benchmark. Avoid repeating grades or extracurricular lists already visible in the CV.
Start on official institutional letterhead with the current date. In your opening paragraph, state your role (such as clerkship supervisor, clinical faculty, career advisor, or research mentor), when you worked together, the duration and frequency of your contact, the clinical or research setting, and your background assessing residency candidates.
Build two or three body paragraphs around direct observations in three parts: background on the situation, the specific behavior you observed, and the consequence of the applicant's actions. Connect those stories to why the applicant is pursuing the specialty and to the six Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) Core Competencies below. If you address a clinical challenge, a slow rotation start, or an academic record discrepancy, focus on how the learner responded to feedback and grew.
Anchor your closing paragraph to an explicit readiness benchmark, such as functioning at the level of a leading fourth-year medical student or an incoming intern (PGY-1), or tie performance to specialty ACGME Milestones. Whenever you rank or compare a learner, define the exact comparison group, such as graduating medical students on your sub-internship or applicants to the specialty. Explicit benchmarking helps International Medical Graduates (IMGs) most, since comparing an IMG directly to US or Canadian fourth-year students gives committees a familiar clinical baseline. For Canadian matches, CaRMS notes that North American clinical supervisors are ideal for IMGs, though references from any physician or professor are accepted with an official translation if not written in English or French.
- Professionalism: commitment to professional responsibilities and adherence to ethical principles.
- Patient Care and Procedural Skills: compassionate, patient- and family-centered care and safe execution of medical, diagnostic, and surgical procedures for the area of practice.
- Medical Knowledge: applying biomedical, clinical, epidemiological, and social-behavioral sciences directly to patient care.
- Practice-Based Learning and Improvement: evaluating one's own patient care, appraising scientific evidence, and improving through self-evaluation.
- Interpersonal and Communication Skills: effective information exchange and collaboration with patients, families, and health professionals.
- Systems-Based Practice: responsiveness to the larger health care system, social determinants of health, and coordination of care resources.
Sample narrative recommendation letter template (written by our team, not AAMC)
Our team wrote this single-page template to show how institutional formatting, situation-behavior-outcome examples, ACGME competencies, and a PGY-1 benchmark fit together. Replace every bracketed detail with your own observations, and verify that the applicant's name and pronouns match from top to bottom.
[Official University or Hospital Letterhead] | [Date] | To: Residency Selection Committee, [Target Specialty] | Re: [Applicant Full Name], AAMC ID: [00000000]. [Applicant First Name] has waived the right to inspect this letter of recommendation under FERPA.
I am writing in strong support of [Applicant Full Name] for residency training in [Target Specialty]. As an [Academic Rank] and [Clinical Role] at [Institution Name], I have supervised and evaluated medical students and residents for [Number] years. I worked directly with [Applicant First Name] for four weeks in [Month Year] on our inpatient [Service Name] service, rounding together five days a week and observing [their/her/his] bedside exams, family updates, and clinical decision-making firsthand.
[Applicant First Name] already functions at the level of an incoming PGY-1 intern in patient care and medical knowledge. During week two, [they/she/he] admitted an older adult presenting with acute confusion. Rather than anchoring on urinary colonization from an outside lab report, [Applicant First Name] reconciled home pill bottles with the patient's daughter, identified an accidental doubling of an anticholinergic prescription, and proposed a targeted deprescribing plan. Within 36 hours the patient's delirium cleared without unnecessary broad-spectrum antibiotics.
[Applicant First Name] also stood out for practice-based learning, communication, and systems-based practice. After first-week coaching to open morning presentations with a clear diagnostic priority, [they/she/he] restructured every presentation the next day. Nursing staff and our unit case manager praised [Applicant First Name] for arranging a charity-pharmacy bridge supply and a visiting-nurse blood pressure check for an uninsured patient, preventing an emergency department return.
Compared with graduating medical students applying to [Target Specialty] whom I have supervised over the past [Number] years, [Applicant First Name] ranks among the strongest clinical learners on our service, and we plan to recruit [them/her/him] to our own program. Sincerely, [Handwritten or Electronic Signature] | [Writer Full Name, Credentials, Position] | [Email Address] | [Phone Number].
Sample letter written by our team for illustration. All names and clinical details are invented.
Wording, faint praise, bias, and generative AI rules
Show details
Vague adjectives without clinical proof can hurt a strong candidate. Calling a student "punctual," "polite," or "solid" without concrete clinical stories reads as faint praise next to letters showing complex patient management, and praising "improvement" without explaining the starting baseline can imply weak initial skills.
Check your draft for unconscious bias as well. Use equally active, skill-focused language for candidates with matching clinical strengths regardless of background, rather than communal labels like "helpful and caring" in place of procedural or diagnostic credit. Leave out personal details such as a divorce or small-town upbringing unless they tie directly to specialty interest and you have the applicant's permission. Before exporting, check the applicant's name spelling and pronouns on every line so cut-and-paste leftovers from prior letters never slip in.
If you use generative artificial intelligence (genAI) to assist with initial drafting or tone, follow your institution's AI governance rules and the AAMC's four guardrails. First is human oversight: never rely on AI to form your judgment, and edit until the letter sounds like your own voice. Second is privacy: never paste identifiable student names, CVs, or personal statements into personal web-based AI tools, and enter data only into institutionally approved tools that comply with privacy laws such as FERPA. Third is fairness: standardize inputs across candidates and audit AI drafts for agentic versus communal wording bias. Fourth is accuracy: edit through multiple rounds to cut generic praise or invented clinical details.
| Evaluation goal | Avoid (vague or biased framing) | Write instead (observed behavior and benchmark) |
|---|---|---|
| Supervisory context | I have known him for several years and he was responsible for tasks. | I was his research mentor from May to August 2025, meeting weekly while he showed critical thinking on our study. |
| Professionalism | She works well with others and he is a good listener. | She displayed professionalism when she owned a delayed lab follow-up, resulting in timely outpatient treatment. |
| Procedural skill and composure | She is very helpful and caring, and he dealt with a divorce. | She showed proficiency in ultrasound-guided IV placement, and he kept composure prioritizing acute tasks under stress. |
| Readiness benchmark | He is at the top of his cohort and she performed well. | In patient care, he functions at the level of an intern among graduating students due to his independent workups. |
| Specialty endorsement | I recommend her for any residency program. | I believe she will succeed as a resident in neurology based on her localization skills and family communication. |
How to upload letters: AAMC Letter Writer Portal, PDF rules, and CaRMS
Show details
Beginning with the 2027 ERAS season, writers submit residency and fellowship letters through the AAMC Letter Writer Portal, which opened on June 4, 2026 and replaced the retired ERAS Letter of Recommendation Portal (LoRP). The portal also manages letters for the American Medical College Application Service (AMCAS) and the Summer Health Professions Education Program (SHPEP). Unfulfilled ERAS requests sent prior to that opening date must be requested again by the applicant.
Writers can upload directly from the request email link with or without an AAMC account. If you write many letters each year, ask learners to send requests to your AAMC account email address so requests match automatically to your Pending dashboard. Administrative designees uploading for an author should create their own separate AAMC account rather than sharing login credentials. For ERAS portal help, the AAMC Support Center is open Monday to Friday from 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. ET.
Under ERAS portal rules, your file must already be saved as a standard 8.5 by 11 inch PDF under 1 MB, with no encryption, password protection, or digital signatures. Flatten scanned or image signatures into a regular PDF rather than applying a locked digital certificate, and switch to black and white or compress logos if your file exceeds 1 MB. Uploaded letters cannot be deleted, so upload a revised PDF to fix a mistake (programs see only the newest version) or upload a blank PDF to retract a letter.
For Canadian residency matches, referees upload through a CaRMS Online referee account. CaRMS asks that narrative letters include the date, contact duration, an explicit confidentiality statement confirming the applicant has not seen and will not receive a copy, and an assessment across eight areas: cognitive skills and knowledge, problem-solving and patient management, behavior and attitudinal skills, communication and working relationships, motivation and punctuality, sense of responsibility, discipline-specific procedural skills, and special qualities (stating directly if any area was not observed). CaRMS does not accept mailed documents, and under 2026 R-1 Match rules for the Quebec Specialist Strike, programs could request at most 2 letters from Quebec applicants (who could submit up to 3) from physicians of any specialty.
| Date | Milestone |
|---|---|
| March to May 2026 | Existing letters transferred into the new AAMC system |
| June 4, 2026 | AAMC Letter Writer Portal opens and standardized specialty templates go live |
| July 1 and July 15, 2026 | MyERAS opens for fellowship submission (July 1) and program review begins (July 15) |
| September 2, 2026 | MyERAS opens for residency application submission |
| September 23, 2026 | Residency programs may begin reviewing applications |
For residency and health program applicants: how letters shape your interviews
Whether you are applying to medical residency or to medical, dental, PA, pharmacy, or nursing programs, recommendation letters do their heaviest work before interview day.
Once you reach the interview, live conversation drives the final outcome. For rank order lists in the 2026 NRMP Program Director Survey, program directors placed the highest weight on interpersonal skills (89%, mean 4.7), interactions during interviews (84%, mean 4.7), and feedback from current residents (74%, mean 4.5).
Because waived letters are confidential, interviewers will not quiz you on lines you have never read. Instead, committees check whether the person on screen matches the clinician your mentors described. Expect questions about constructive clinical feedback you received from a supervisor, a patient workup where you took ownership, or what a close mentor taught you about your field. If your interview day includes timed scenario stations alongside faculty interviews, review our MMI practice questions with answers to sharpen your structure.
Before your interviews start, revisit the rotation or project behind each letter and practice telling one two-minute story of clinical growth or teamwork out loud. Confetto lets residency, medical, dental, PA, pharmacy, and nursing applicants rehearse traditional, panel, and MMI interviews with AI follow-up questions and rubric-based feedback. Start your free week.
Practice question
Tell me about a piece of constructive clinical feedback you received from a supervisor or letter writer on a rotation, and how it changed the way you cared for patients afterward.
See an example answer
On my third-year internal medicine clerkship, my ward attending pulled me aside during week two right after morning rounds. I had just presented a newly admitted patient with decompensated heart failure and read off every lab value from the overnight panel, which buried the real problem, her rising creatinine on high-dose diuretics. He told me that a student reports data, while an intern commits to the clinical headline in the first sentence. That evening I changed how I prepared for rounds. At the top of each patient card, I wrote one summary sentence naming the active problem and the decision needed that morning, and I only reported normal labs when they ruled out an acute danger. By the final week of the month, my presentations took half the time, and our team used those saved minutes at the bedside reviewing discharge medication changes with families. Carrying that habit into my fourth-year sub-internship taught me to ask attendings for specific expectations in week one rather than waiting for a midpoint grade. Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented.
It names a real clinical blind spot without making excuses, shows the exact change made the next day, and connects the supervisor's coaching to better patient care rather than just a better grade.
Frequently asked questions
What documents should a residency letter writer ask for before drafting?
Under the AAMC and OPDA guidelines, confirm which specialty or specialties the applicant is pursuing and request an updated CV and a draft personal statement. You also need the email link from the AAMC Letter Writer Portal or the ERAS Letter Request Form to upload the PDF.
Where do faculty upload residency letters for the 2027 cycle?
Residency and fellowship letters are submitted through the AAMC Letter Writer Portal, which opened on June 4, 2026 and replaced the retired ERAS Letter of Recommendation Portal (LoRP). Writers can upload directly from the request email link as a guest or sign in with an AAMC account.
What are the PDF size and formatting rules for ERAS recommendation letters?
Save the letter as a standard 8.5 by 11 inch PDF under 1 MB on institutional letterhead, signed (an electronic signature is acceptable) and dated, with your position, email address, and phone number. ERAS portals reject files with encryption, password protection, or locked digital-certificate signatures.
Can faculty use ChatGPT or generative AI to write a residency letter of recommendation?
The AAMC states that generative AI may support initial drafting or tone editing, provided it never replaces your firsthand assessment and you edit out generic or biased phrasing. Never enter identifiable applicant data into personal web-based AI tools, and use only institutionally approved tools that comply with privacy laws such as FERPA.
How much do residency letters of recommendation matter compared with interviews?
In the 2026 NRMP Program Director Survey, 86% of responding program directors cited specialty-specific letters of recommendation (mean importance 4.0) when selecting applicants to interview. After interviews, final rankings depend most heavily on interpersonal skills (89%, mean 4.7) and interview interactions (84%, mean 4.7).
Sources
- AAMC and OPDA: Guidelines for Writing a Narrative Letter of Recommendation for a Residency Applicant
- AAMC: ERAS for Letter Writers (2027 Season Updates and Key Dates)
- AAMC: AAMC Letter Writer Portal Overview and FAQs
- AAMC: Letter of Recommendation Portal (LoRP) Technical FAQ
- NRMP: 2026 Program Director Survey Results Narrative Report (PDF)
- NRMP: Charting Outcomes Program Director Survey Results, 2026 Main Residency Match
- CaRMS: R-1 Main Residency Match Reference Guidelines for Referees
- CaRMS: R-1 Main Residency Match Applicant Document Types