Is 2nd Quartile Casper Bad? Meaning & Next Steps

Try a free Casper practice scenario

Free, no sign-up to start.

Scored 2nd quartile on Casper? Learn what your result means, why retakes are blocked this cycle, how medical schools weigh it, and what to do next.

Try a free Casper practice scenario

Free, no sign-up to start.

No, a 2nd quartile Casper score is not a failing grade or an automatic medical school rejection. A quartile ranking places your performance in the lower-middle relative band of test takers, sitting above the 1st quartile and below the midpoint. According to Acuity Insights, Casper is designed to complement academic metrics rather than replace them, and each individual program sets its own weight and timing for your score. Sources: Casper Overview for Higher Education Admissions - Acuity Insights, Casper Technical Manual (Updated Oct 23, 2026) - Acuity Insights, About Casper Format and Rating - TakeAltus. Last checked November 12, 2026.

What a 2nd quartile Casper score actually means

Casper is an open-response situational judgment test used by more than 600 institutional partners worldwide, with over 1 million applicants having completed the assessment according to Acuity Insights. Landing in the 2nd quartile means your overall performance fell in the lower-middle quarter of your testing group, ahead of the 1st quartile and behind the 3rd and 4th quartiles.

A 2nd quartile result does not measure your personal morality or your clinical knowledge. TakeAltus states that Casper evaluates how you think through complex situations and explain your reasoning across 9 core skills: collaboration, communication, empathy, ethics, fairness, motivation, problem solving, resilience, and self-awareness. Certified human raters, not artificial intelligence, score your open-ended responses using a structured rating process documented in the Casper Technical Manual, which was updated on October 23, 2026 in accordance with the 2014 Standards for Educational and Psychological Testing.

Several persistent rumors on applicant forums distort how scoring works. First, both video and typed sections count toward your evaluation, so weak pacing in either format pulls down your standing. Second, your score is not a penalty for slow spelling or rough phrasing, because human raters are trained to ignore spelling mistakes, grammar issues, and jargon. Third, programs do not wait on you to self-report quartiles, because scores are sent directly to the schools on your distribution list and status updates appear inside each school's application portal.

How medical and health professions schools weigh a 2nd quartile result

Whether a 2nd quartile score hurts your chances depends on how each school on your list builds its admissions formula. The weight and role of your result vary by institution across medical, nursing, pharmacy, allied health, teacher education, and graduate business programs.

According to Acuity Insights, many programs use Casper early in the admissions process to prioritize applicants before investing staff time and interview slots in deeper file review. At a program that uses situational judgment scores as a heavy pre-interview filter, a 2nd quartile score creates real headwinds unless the rest of your academic profile stands out. At programs that treat the assessment as 1 data point alongside grades, entrance exams, and lived experience, applicants with 2nd quartile results remain viable contenders for interviews and offers.

In U.S. and Canadian medical admissions, the AAMC Mission-Aligned Selection framework (formerly called Holistic Review) guides schools to evaluate competencies across 4 linked areas: experiences, attributes, academic metrics, and competencies, known as the EAMC model. A June 14, 2023 AMCAS webinar showcased this approach at the University of Kansas School of Medicine and the University of Maryland School of Medicine. Both schools align their selection criteria with institutional mission and regional health needs instead of relying on 1 test score. Strong clinical hours, sustained service, clear essays, and supportive reference letters can offset a lower-middle situational judgment band.

Your current-cycle triage plan: 5 steps to take right now

Do not withdraw active applications out of panic after seeing a 2nd quartile report. Because you have already paid primary and test distribution fees, withdrawing guarantees a rejection that a balanced review might never have issued. Work through this 5-step audit written by our team to focus your energy where you can still move the needle this cycle.

  • Verify program-specific screening rules: Check the admissions requirements page for every school on your list, and cross-reference U.S. and Canadian medical schools in the Medical School Admission Requirements (MSAR) online database to see whether a school enforces a minimum threshold or reviews files across all metrics.
  • Confirm score delivery and matching account details: Open your Casper portal and verify that your registered name, email address, and government-issued ID details match your primary application portals so distributed scores link cleanly.
  • Complete required companion assessments: Check whether any of your designated programs require Duet alongside Casper. Official registration rules confirm there are no additional charges to take Duet when a program requires it, and leaving it incomplete stalls your file.
  • Build the 17 premed competencies into remaining secondaries: Medical school competency guidelines from the AAMC track 17 entering-student competencies across professional, thinking and reasoning, and science domains. Use remaining secondary essays and update letters to show concrete stories of ethical responsibility, teamwork, resilience, and service.
  • Shift preparation toward live interviews: Research cited by the test developer links situational judgment constructs with interview performance and professionalism. Earning an interview gives you live minutes to prove your interpersonal judgment directly to faculty raters.

Why good applicants land in the 2nd quartile: pacing math and rating habits

Most 2nd quartile results come from mechanical execution gaps under strict timers, not from bad ethics. Standard Casper takes about 65 to 85 minutes to complete, including 2 optional breaks, and splits into 2 sections across 11 scenarios (select programs, such as Australian teacher education, use a shorter version). You complete 4 video-response scenarios with 2 open-ended questions each at 1 minute per response, plus 7 typed-response scenarios with 2 open-ended questions presented on the same page under a 3.5-minute timer.

By our calculation from TakeAltus, those 11 scenarios require 22 separate open-ended answers across 32.5 minutes of active response time (8 video answers across 8 minutes and 14 typed answers across 24.5 minutes). That leaves an average of 1.75 minutes (1 minute and 45 seconds) per typed question if you divide your page timer evenly. Because official test-prep rules state that each question is scored individually, spending 3 minutes writing a polished paragraph for the first prompt on a page leaves only 30 seconds for the second prompt. Doing that across several scenarios drags a thoughtful applicant straight into the 2nd quartile.

Preparation choice also plays a documented role. Official Casper prep guidance reports that test takers who use third-party preparation courses or materials, or who do not prepare at all, tend to perform worse than applicants who practice with the free official practice test inside their test account. Memorized templates often produce stiff answers that state an action without explaining the personal reasoning behind it.

Casper Format Breakdown and Common 2nd Quartile Traps
Test ComponentOfficial StructureActive Time & Per-Question PaceCommon 2nd Quartile Habit
Video Section4 scenarios, 2 questions each8 minutes total, 1 minute per question (official rate)Freezing on camera or repeating the prompt instead of stating a clear decision and rationale
Typed Section7 scenarios, 2 questions per page24.5 minutes total, 1.75 minutes per question (by our calculation from TakeAltus)Spending almost the whole 3.5-minute page timer on Question 1 and leaving Question 2 unfinished

How to offset a 2nd quartile Casper score in MMI and traditional interviews

Once a program invites you to a Multiple Mini Interview (MMI) or traditional panel interview, your live communication carries real weight. Interviewers are evaluating the same interpersonal qualities that Casper samples early in the cycle, including empathy, fairness, collaboration, and problem solving, but now you have interactive follow-up questions and natural body language working in your favor.

During scenario stations or behavioral questions, avoid the exact shortcuts that hold situational judgment scores down. Start by naming the competing pressures on every person involved before taking a stance, so the interviewer hears that you do not rush to judgment with incomplete facts. Gather information privately and respectfully first, rather than accusing a colleague or patient in public.

Next, commit to a concrete course of action and state the principle behind it. Explaining both what you would do and why you chose that option shows mature reasoning. If an interviewer pushes back with a new constraint, treat it just like a follow-up Casper prompt: acknowledge how the new fact shifts the stakes, state whether your decision changes, and walk through your updated priority.

Casper retake policy, test types, and score expiration rules

Show details

One of the most damaging pieces of bad advice online claims that you can pay an extra fee to retake Casper and overwrite a 2nd quartile score during the same application season. Official Casper validity guidelines strictly prohibit this: applicants are not permitted to take a Casper test type more than once per admissions cycle, and all test fees are final and non-refundable.

The only situation where you take an additional Casper exam in the same application year is when you apply to programs that require different test types. Casper scores apply only to a singular test type, such as American Health Sciences versus Canadian Health Sciences, or programs with different language mandates. For Canadian programs, some schools accept only English or only French while bilingual schools accept either, so you must match each school's language rule before booking.

If you end up reapplying in a future admissions cycle, your 2nd quartile result will not follow you. Casper scores remain valid for 1 admissions cycle only, and a separate test is required for future cycles. That clean slate gives reapplicants a full opportunity to fix their pacing, use bullet points where helpful on typed prompts, and log repeated runs on the free official practice exam.

Accommodations and fee assistance if you test in a future cycle

Show details

If a documented disability, medical condition, or temporary accessibility need slowed your reading, typing, or speaking speed on test day, plan early before any future cycle. Official rules require you to submit an Accommodations Request Form and supporting documentation at least 4 weeks before your scheduled test date, while standard test registration should happen at least 3 days before your preferred slot. Applicants approved for extended time receive a dedicated link in their approval letter to a practice test matching their approved timing.

Applicants reapplying on a tight budget can also lower testing costs. Candidates approved for participating U.S. or UK fee assistance programs, including AAMC, AACOMAS, CASPA, ADEA, or a UCAS bursary, may qualify to have Casper fees waived or reduced.

Worked example: upgrading a 2nd quartile habit into a complete response

Show details

Official test-prep guidance stresses 2 habits above all others: answer every question with detail about your motivations, and explain both what you would do and why. Notice that bullet points are explicitly permitted on typed responses if you want to get your core ideas onto the page before expanding them.

In the practice box below, our team wrote a realistic 2-question group scenario modeled on the workplace and academic prompts shown on official preview pages. Compare how a rushed, surface-level approach (such as writing "I would tell Jordan no because lying about hours breaks clinic rules") skips motivations, whereas the full example response protects time for both questions, checks facts privately, accounts for team fairness, and justifies every step.

Practice question

You are co-leading a student clinic volunteer shift. Your co-leader, Jordan, has arrived 30 minutes late to the last 2 shifts and asks you to sign off on full attendance hours anyway so a scholarship renewal is not jeopardized. 1) How do you respond to Jordan right now? Explain your reasoning. 2) Imagine Jordan privately shares that a parent recently started afternoon dialysis treatments across town. How, if at all, does this change your approach? Explain your reasoning.

See an example answer

Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. For Question 1, I would speak with Jordan in a private room after clinic tasks are settled and decline to sign off on unworked hours. Falsifying attendance records breaches professional ethics and is unfair to volunteers who completed full shifts, and it could also compromise patient flow at the clinic. At the same time, I want to avoid assuming laziness, so I would calmly ask if something outside the clinic is causing the scheduling conflict and check whether Jordan can make up the missed 60 minutes on an upcoming shift to protect the scholarship honestly. For Question 2, learning about Jordan's parent does not change my refusal to falsify past records, because integrity rules still hold under personal stress. However, it shifts how I support Jordan moving forward. With Jordan's permission, I would approach our faculty coordinator together to request switching Jordan to a later shift block or redistributing opening duties so Jordan can care for family while earning every required scholarship hour legitimately.

This response splits attention evenly across both individually scored prompts instead of exhausting the timer on Question 1. It names multiple stakeholders (Jordan, fellow volunteers, clinic patients, and the scholarship program), checks context privately before judging, holds a firm ethical boundary on falsifying records, and explains the reasoning behind both the refusal and the practical scheduling solution.

Frequently asked questions

Is 2nd quartile Casper bad or considered failing?

No, Casper does not have a pass or fail score. A 2nd quartile result places you in the lower-middle relative band of test takers, and each individual program decides independently how to weigh that result alongside the rest of your application.

Can I retake Casper to replace a 2nd quartile score this cycle?

No. Official test guidelines state that applicants are not permitted to take the same Casper test type more than once per admissions cycle, and all fees are non-refundable.

Can you get accepted to medical school with a 2nd quartile Casper score?

Yes, unless a specific school sets a higher screening cutoff on its admissions page. Medical schools using mission-aligned selection evaluate your grades, test scores, attributes, and experiences together rather than relying on 1 exam.

Did poor typing grammar or spelling cause my 2nd quartile score?

Spelling and grammar errors do not lower your score directly because certified human raters are trained to disregard spelling mistakes, grammar issues, and jargon. However, slow typing can still hurt you if you run out of time before answering both individually scored questions on a page.

Does my 2nd quartile Casper score carry over if I reapply next year?

No, Casper scores are valid for only 1 admissions cycle. If you reapply in a future cycle, your old score expires and you must register for a new test.

Are video scenarios scored on the Casper test?

Yes, applicants respond to realistic scenarios using both typed and video answers, and both formats are evaluated by certified human raters to assess how you think, reason, and communicate.

Sources