Confetto

JGME Residency Interview in the 21st Century: AAMC Guide

Practice the residency interview now

Free, no sign-up to start.

What Journal of Graduate Medical Education research and 2024 AAMC guidelines say about residency interviews in the 21st century: virtual formats and prep.

Practice the residency interview now

Free, no sign-up to start.

Research in the Journal of Graduate Medical Education (JGME) and June 2024 AAMC guidance define the 21st-century residency interview through two major shifts: moving from in-person visits to virtual video interviews, and replacing unstructured conversations with structured, rubric-scored behavioral and situational questions. The AAMC recommends virtual interviews for residency and fellowship programs because travel costs range from hundreds to thousands of dollars, over 70% of surveyed plastic surgery applicants missed 7 or more days of medical school for in-person interviews, and the U.S. health care sector accounts for 8% to 10% of national greenhouse gas emissions. Sources: AAMC: Virtual Interviews Applicant Preparation Guide, AAMC: Interviews in GME: Where Do We Go From Here?, AAMC: Best Practices for Creating and Conducting Residency Interviews. Last checked November 11, 2026.

What JGME research says about the 21st-century residency interview

When applicants and program directors search for the Journal of Graduate Medical Education (JGME) literature on residency interviews in the 21st century, they are tracking how graduate medical education moved from day-long campus visits to structured online selection. Across the AAMC interview preparation and policy guides, four peer-reviewed JGME studies anchor the evidence base for how modern residency interviews work.

Before 2020, most residency and fellowship programs did not consider conducting their selection process virtually. Early JGME papers tested video technology and reviewed selection validity years before the COVID-19 pandemic forced every specialty online. Later JGME research measured what that transition saved in applicant money and carbon emissions.

Alongside those four JGME papers, the AAMC's literature tables trace how specific specialties tested virtual and structured formats over the past two decades. In urology, Shah et al. (2012) published a randomized evaluation of a web-based interview process for resident selection in the Journal of Urology. In gastroenterology, Daram et al. (2014) studied the feasibility and utility of web-based videoconference fellowship interviews in the American Journal of Gastroenterology, and Pasadhika et al. (2014) examined residency interview video conferencing in Ophthalmology. Vadi et al. (2016) compared web-based and face-to-face interviews for an anesthesiology training program in the International Journal of Medical Education, while Pourmand et al. (2018) evaluated the feasibility and usability of tele-interviews in the Western Journal of Emergency Medicine.

To rehearse the behavioral and situational questions used in structured virtual interviews, Confetto runs AI mock interviews for residency and healthcare applicants with real-time follow-up questions and rubric feedback. Start your free week.

Core JGME residency interview studies cited in AAMC guidance
Study and JGME citationFocus area in residency selectionWhere AAMC applies the findings
Edje et al. (2013), Vol. 5, Issue 3, pp. 503-505Using Skype as an alternative for residency selection interviewsAAMC Virtual Interviews: Applicant Preparation Guide
Williams et al. (2015), Vol. 7, Issue 3, pp. 331-333Videoconference interviewing tips for successAAMC Virtual Interviews: Applicant Preparation Guide
Stephenson-Famy et al. (2015), Vol. 7, Issue 4, pp. 539-548Literature review on the use of the interview in resident candidate selectionAAMC Best Practices for Creating and Conducting Interviews
Domingo et al. (2023), Vol. 15, Issue 1, pp. 112-116The carbon footprint and financial cost of virtual residency interviewsAAMC Interviews in GME: Where Do We Go From Here?

Why the AAMC recommends virtual residency interviews

In its June 2024 guidance, the AAMC recommends that residency and fellowship programs use a virtual interview format. While each institution evaluates formats based on its own mission and context, the AAMC outlines five key considerations that drive modern residency interview policy.

First, in-person interviewing is expensive. According to applicant surveys cited by the AAMC, interview costs range from hundreds to thousands of dollars. For medical school applicants surveyed by the AAMC, 96% agreed or strongly agreed that they saved money interviewing virtually, and 85% named reduced financial impact as the top advantage.

Second, applicants prefer virtual formats. In early 2023 AAMC focus groups, residency applicants favored virtual interviews because they cut travel time and expense, and allowed them to interview from a familiar space with less interview-day stress. In the AAMC survey of medical school applicants, 90% preferred a virtual format or the option of a virtual format, naming reduced financial impact, reduced travel time, and scheduling flexibility as the top three advantages.

Third, travel pulls fourth-year students out of clinical training. In a survey of plastic surgery residency applicants by Susarla et al. (2017) cited by the AAMC, over 70% missed 7 or more days of medical school to attend in-person interviews. Virtual interviews let students complete morning and afternoon interviews on the same day without losing days of clinical rotations to airport travel.

Fourth, separating assessment from recruitment reduces evaluation bias. When programs keep the formal interview separate from optional campus visits or social events, interactions outside the interview do not introduce bias or irrelevant details into the scoring rubric. For programs that offer optional in-person events, the AAMC suggests considering travel and lodging stipends so those visits are accessible.

Fifth, virtual interviewing lowers the environmental toll of academic medicine. (2021) in the New England Journal of Medicine. Research by Domingo et al. (2023) in JGME and Hampshire et al. (2023) in Academic Medicine supports virtual interviews as a practical way for training programs to cut that carbon footprint.

When residency programs weigh Virtual Only, Hybrid, or In-Person Only formats, the AAMC outlines specific reasons and safeguards for each choice. Programs choose a Virtual Only format when many applicants live out of state, when the institution commits to lowering its carbon footprint, or when scheduling flexibility is a priority. To run a Virtual Only process well, programs offer virtual recruiting activities to every applicant and establish clear technology standards and interviewer training for faculty.

Programs that choose a Hybrid format, where an applicant can select either an in-person or virtual interview, often have a mix of local and out-of-state applicants or want to showcase a rural or less well-known area while preserving choice. For Hybrid programs, the AAMC advises standardizing procedures and interviewer training across both modalities, blinding the selection committee to which interview format an applicant chose, offering virtual recruiting to all candidates, and telling applicants upfront how the program keeps the hybrid process equitable. Programs that use an In-Person Only format typically draw from a local applicant pool that does not require extended travel or need to showcase a rural location, and the AAMC recommends that they provide financial support to applicants who need help covering travel expenses.

Structured vs. unstructured residency interviews

The second defining change in 21st-century residency selection is how interviewers ask questions and score your answers. According to the AAMC Best Practices for Creating and Conducting Interviews guide, the goal of the interview is to measure two types of fit from organizational psychology: person-organization fit (applicant-program fit, matching your values and learning style to the program's culture) and person-job fit (applicant-specialty fit, matching your competencies and skills to the demands of residency).

Unstructured interviews have flexible content, no predetermined questions, and no standardized scoring rules. Research cited by the AAMC found no association between unstructured faculty interview scores and Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) milestone ratings. Unstructured conversations also have poor inter-rater reliability, increase interviewer bias around age, race, and gender, and create openings for inappropriate or illegal questions, which are disproportionately directed toward certain groups.

Structured interviews use predefined, job-relevant questions and established scoring rubrics for every candidate. A 2022 systematic review on medical school interviewing methods by Lin et al. in Perspectives on Medical Education underscored that structured interviews with standardized questions have stronger validity and are preferred by applicants, while unstructured interviews have lower validity and higher susceptibility to bias. In residency selection, multi-institutional research by Marcus-Blank et al. (2019) in Academic Medicine and surgical simulation MMI research by Lund et al. (2022) in the Journal of Surgical Education show that structured interview scores correlate with first-year residency performance.

Specifically, the AAMC notes that structured interview scores predict first-year residents' end-of-year performance in professional competency, patient care, and communication skills. Literature cited by the AAMC, including Costa and Gardner (2021) and Otugo et al. (2021), also shows that structured formats can reduce race, age, and gender bias and increase workforce diversity, with benefits that may be even stronger in an online format. In one residency program cited by the AAMC where faculty initially worried that structured questions would feel stiff and ruin conversational flow, all 12 participating faculty members found the structured system easy to use and score, and reported uncovering past behaviors that unstructured chats missed. Applicants in that program also reported that structured interviews were no harder than unstructured ones and did not interfere with faculty interaction.

  • Content structure: Asking professionally relevant or specialty-specific questions improves validity, fairness, and applicant reactions. Covering the same topics for all applicants and using behavioral or situational prompts improve reliability, validity, and fairness.
  • Evaluation structure: Rating each answer, using defined rating scales, taking detailed notes, and using formulas to calculate total interview scores all improve reliability, validity, and fairness. Training interviewers improves all four outcomes, including positive applicant reactions.
  • Blinded interviewing and panel choices: When interviewers have no access to your application file beforehand, or when multiple interviewers rate you, reliability and fairness go up, though applicant reactions can be less favorable because you must introduce your own background from scratch.
  • Limiting follow-up probes and questions: Strict limits on probing questions and not having applicants ask questions increase reliability and fairness, though applicants react less favorably when they cannot ask questions during the scored session.

Live vs. asynchronous formats and what programs ask

A traditional in-person residency visit is a day-long event featuring a facility tour, lunch or rounds, an evening reception, and conversations with the program director, two or three faculty members, and one or two residents. Virtual interviews split into two formats instead.

Live Virtual Interviews connect you with one or more interviewers in real time over video conferencing software, where you answer questions face-to-face and often ask your own questions at the end. Asynchronous Virtual Interviews, also called on-demand interviews, have no interviewer on the call. You read a text prompt or watch a prerecorded video question, and your webcam records your spoken answer for reviewers to score later.

Whether your session is live or recorded, the AAMC notes that most residency interview questions fall into three categories: behavioral, general, and situational. In every category, the AAMC gives two strict confidentiality rules: never share patient details that could identify someone separately or in combination (names, locations, diagnoses, or distinguishing characteristics), and always call the person simply "the patient." Similarly, if a story portrays a colleague negatively, leave out their name, title, location, and any identifying trait.

  • Behavioral questions: Ask for a specific past example to prove your skills. You should state the situation or task, the actions you took, and the outcome. AAMC example: "Please describe a time when you observed a member of the medical team you were working with behave in a manner that was inconsistent with an established protocol. Explain what the situation was, what actions you took, and the outcome."
  • Situational questions: Present a hypothetical scenario and ask what you would do, why you would take those actions, and what result you expect. AAMC example: "Imagine you are on your morning rounds. The chief resident describes a difficult case you and a colleague worked on earlier in the week and compliments your handling of the situation. She gives you sole credit and fails to mention that your colleague played a major role. What would you do?"
  • General questions: Ask you to describe yourself, your goals, and your interest in the program or specialty broadly. Common prompts from the AAMC frequently asked questions list include "Tell me about yourself," "Why are you interested in our program?", "Can you tell me about this deficiency on your record?", "What problems will our specialty face in the next 5-10 years?", and "Describe a particularly satisfying or meaningful experience during your medical training."

Applicant preparation checklist for a virtual residency interview

We built this step-by-step preparation plan from the AAMC Virtual Interviews: Applicant Preparation Guide and the AAMC Introduction to Residency Interviews. Use it one week before your first interview date.

  • Confirm the format details with the program: Check your invitation for whether the interview is live or asynchronous, the video platform, the number of interviewers, the length of each session, and the competencies assessed.
  • Map your CV to core competencies: Pick one strong clinical or nonclinical story for each skill on your CV. Strip out all patient names, locations, and specific diagnoses so you automatically say "the patient" out loud.
  • Use a computer or tablet, not a phone: The AAMC recommends a computer or tablet for stability and advises using a device that cannot receive incoming phone calls mid-answer.
  • Test your connection and switch to Ethernet if needed: Run a check on SpeedTest.net. If home Wi-Fi lags, use a wired Ethernet cable or book a private room at your medical school.
  • Set lighting in front of you and camera at eye level: Do not sit with a window or bright lamp behind you, which casts a shadow. Place a lamp in front of your face, center your head and shoulders in the frame, and raise the camera to eye level.
  • Run a recorded rehearsal: Record yourself answering one behavioral and one situational prompt. Watch the playback to check that you are looking into the camera lens rather than at the screen, and check for chair swiveling or hand gestures that cover your face.
  • Lock down interview-day logistics: Close every background program and notification on your computer, plug in your charger, and give the interviewer or coordinator your phone number in advance as a backup plan in case video fails.
  • Skip salary and call-schedule questions during the interview: The AAMC notes that salary, benefits, and on-call hours are provided in program packets or websites, and asking about them in the interview reflects poorly on you. Ask questions about educational and career fit instead, and send thank-you notes afterward unless the program tells you not to.

Scheduling etiquette, cancellations, and ERAS 2027 dates

Show details

Virtual interviews make it easier to accept every invitation initially and decide later which programs you actually want to attend. The AAMC notes that when taken to the extreme, this practice is called "interview hoarding." Holding onto an interview slot you do not want blocks another applicant from getting invited, strains program staff, and reflects back on your medical school's reputation with that department in future cycles.

If you need to cancel or reschedule an interview, the AAMC states that under no circumstances should you ever be a no-show. Contact the residency program by email or phone as soon as your plans change, preferably at least two weeks in advance. When you give at least two weeks' notice, you do not need to give an explanation.

Canceling or rescheduling with less than one week's notice should only happen in true emergencies, such as a sudden illness or a death in the family. In an emergency, state the nature of the emergency briefly without graphic clinical detail. If you call by phone to cancel or reschedule, consider sending a brief follow-up email to confirm the change.

Since the 2024 ERAS season, applicants have also been able to use program signals and geographic preferences in MyERAS to show genuine interest before interview invitations go out. Repeat applicants who certified and submitted an ERAS application within the prior seven years can import their application data and letters of recommendation into the current season. Remember that registering with ERAS does not register you for any established match, so you must register separately with the matching organization.

For the 2027 ERAS residency cycle, the AAMC timeline sets five key milestones (all times Eastern Time): the 2027 ERAS season begins on June 4, 2026 at 9 a.m. ET, ECFMG distributes tokens to International Medical Graduate (IMG) residency applicants on June 24, 2026, residency applicants may begin submitting MyERAS applications to programs on September 2, 2026 at 9 a.m. ET, residency programs may begin reviewing MyERAS applications in the Program Director's WorkStation (PDWS) on September 23, 2026 at 9 a.m. ET, and the 2027 ERAS season ends on May 31, 2027 at 5 p.m. ET.

Practice a structured residency interview question

Below is the situational prompt from the AAMC Virtual Interviews: Applicant Preparation Guide, paired with an example answer written by our team to show how to cover action, reasoning, and expected outcome under a structured rubric.

How to practice structured residency questions out loud

Once you have reviewed the example answer, test your own stories against the AAMC's 38 frequently asked residency interview questions.

When you are ready to practice out loud with timed behavioral, situational, and general residency questions, Confetto gives you live follow-ups and a scored rubric report after every session. Start your free week.

Practice question

Imagine you are on your morning rounds. The chief resident describes a difficult case you and a colleague worked on earlier in the week and compliments your handling of the situation. She gives you sole credit and fails to mention that your colleague played a major role. What would you do?

See an example answer

Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. "In that moment on rounds, I would thank the chief resident for the kind words and immediately share the credit out loud so the whole team hears it. I would say something specific, such as, 'Thank you, I appreciate that, and I want to make sure everyone knows that my co-student stayed late with me to reassess the patient, call the family, and coordinate the follow-up plan.' Speaking up right away matters because waiting until after rounds leaves the attending and the rest of the team with an inaccurate picture of who did the work. My goal is to make sure my colleague's effort is recognized publicly while keeping the conversation warm and respectful toward the chief resident, who likely just did not see both of us working on the case. Afterward, I would check in briefly with my colleague to make sure they felt supported. Doing this builds trust on the team and shows that patient care is shared work, not a competition for grades."

Follows the AAMC framework for situational questions: states the immediate action you would take on rounds, explains why speaking up in front of the team is better than waiting, names the expected outcome for team trust, and refers to 'the patient' without any identifying details.

Frequently asked questions

What articles has the Journal of Graduate Medical Education published on residency interviews?

AAMC interview guides highlight four foundational JGME studies: Edje et al. (2013) on using Skype for residency interviews, Williams et al. (2015) on videoconference interview tips, Stephenson-Famy et al. (2015) reviewing the literature on resident candidate selection interviews, and Domingo et al. (2023) on the carbon footprint and financial cost of virtual residency interviews.

Does the AAMC recommend virtual or in-person residency interviews?

In its June 2024 update, the AAMC recommends that residency and fellowship programs use a virtual interview format. Virtual interviews save applicants hundreds to thousands of dollars in travel costs, reduce missed days of fourth-year clinical rotations, match applicant preferences, and lower greenhouse gas emissions.

Why do residency programs use structured interviews instead of unstructured interviews?

Research cited by the AAMC shows no association between unstructured faculty interview scores and ACGME milestone ratings, whereas structured interview scores predict first-year residents' end-of-year performance in patient care, communication, and professional competency. Structured interviews also improve inter-rater reliability and reduce demographic bias.

What is the difference between live and asynchronous virtual residency interviews?

Live virtual interviews use video conferencing to connect you with one or more interviewers in real time for a two-way conversation. Asynchronous (on-demand) virtual interviews have no interviewer present, and you record webcam responses to text or prerecorded video questions that reviewers score later.

What is interview hoarding and how far in advance should I cancel a residency interview?

Interview hoarding is accepting every interview invitation initially and deciding later which ones to attend, which blocks slots for other applicants. If you need to cancel or reschedule, never be a no-show and contact the program by email or phone preferably at least two weeks in advance.

Sources