Medical Student Reference Letter: CaRMS and ERAS Guide
Free, no sign-up to start.
Who to ask, when to ask, what to give your writer, and how letters reach CaRMS and ERAS this cycle, with scripts, a sample letter and official dates.
Free, no sign-up to start.
Ask a physician who supervised your clinical work and can describe specific things you did. The AAMC advises contacting writers at least 4 to 6 weeks before the letter deadline and giving them your CV, personal statement, evaluations and transcripts. For the 2027 CaRMS R-1 match, references are due 25 November 2026 at 21:00 ET. Sources: AAMC: Letters of Recommendation for Residency Applicants, AAMC: 2027 MyERAS Applicant User Guide, Letters of Recommendation, AAMC: ERAS for Letter Writers. Last checked November 15, 2026.
On this page
- Who should write your reference letter
- How many letters you need, and which type
- Dates for the 2026-27 cycle
- How to ask, with scripts you can copy
- What to give your writer
- What a strong letter says
- How the letter gets submitted, and the waiver
- Hard situations and what to do
- If you are applying to medical school instead
- Practice question
- Frequently asked questions
- Sources
Who should write your reference letter
For a US residency application, the AAMC advises that letters come from physicians who know you well, rather than residents, pre-clinical faculty or non-physicians. Pick people who watched you work with patients. The AAMC suggests getting to know the clerkship directors and faculty on your rotations, electives and sub-internships, because that is where your writers come from.
CaRMS defines a referee more broadly: a physician, professor or non-clinical individual recommending you for further medical training. Each program still sets its own document rules in its program description, so read those before you choose.
Choose the attending who can name what you did over a well-known name who can't. If you are unsure who in your specialty to ask, the AAMC suggests asking your advisor or student affairs dean.
Some programs want a department chair letter. When you create each letter entry in MyERAS, you answer whether it is needed to fulfill a Department Chair requirement. To check each program's letter rules, the AAMC points you to the Residency Explorer tool and the Program Directors Association Guide for Residency Applicants.
How many letters you need, and which type
In ERAS, you can assign up to four letters to each program. In CaRMS, the documents each program wants, including references, are listed in its program description. Plan for at least one letter from the specialty you are applying to, plus letters that cover your other strong rotations.
Several specialties now want a form instead of a free-form letter. CaRMS calls these structured reference letters, and the writer completes them online. ERAS calls them standardized letters, such as the SLOE, SLOR, eSLOE and SEL, and you pick standardized or narrative when you create the letter entry.
| Item | CaRMS R-1 (Canada) | ERAS (US) |
|---|---|---|
| Who writes | A physician, professor or non-clinical individual | Physicians who know you well, rather than residents, pre-clinical faculty or non-physicians (AAMC advice) |
| Where the writer submits | CaRMS Online referee account | AAMC Letter Writer Portal, which replaced the Letter of Recommendation Portal (LoRP) from the 2027 season |
| Letters per program | Set in each program description | Up to four |
| Structured or standardized forms | Structured reference letters in Family Medicine, Emergency Medicine, Orthopedic Surgery, Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Psychiatry and Pediatrics | Standardized letters (SLOE, SLOR, eSLOE, SEL) where the specialty uses them. 2027 templates are posted for Urology, Dermatology, Plastic Surgery-Integrated and Pain Medicine |
| How you label a request | Generic, discipline-specific or program-specific | A specialty or General, narrative or standardized, and whether it meets a Department Chair requirement |
| Confidentiality | The letter states you have not seen it and will not receive a copy | You choose whether to waive. The AAMC recommends waiving |
| Asking before the system opens | Early reference form, sent by the referee with the letter to documents@carms.ca | Requests run through the AAMC Letter Writer Portal, which opened June 4, 2026 |
Dates for the 2026-27 cycle
These are the official dates for this cycle. If you are applying in Canada, the CaRMS reference deadline is the one to plan around now. For ERAS, work back from the day you plan to submit, since programs may begin reviewing on September 23.
The plan below the table is ours, not CaRMS's or the AAMC's. It turns those dates into steps you can put in your calendar.
- During the rotation. Tell the attending early that you hope to ask for a letter, and ask for feedback at the midpoint so you have time to act on it.
- Last week of the rotation. Make the ask in person while your work is fresh.
- As soon as they say yes. Send the request email, the Letter Request Form or CaRMS request, and your summary sheet.
- As the deadline gets close. Send a short reminder if the letter is not in.
- A few days before the deadline. Send a final, brief check.
- When the letter is uploaded. Send a thank-you note.
- After the match. Tell each writer where you matched.
| Date | What happens | System |
|---|---|---|
| June 4, 2026 | AAMC Letter Writer Portal opens for the 2027 ERAS season. Unfulfilled requests sent before this date must be requested again | ERAS |
| September 2, 2026 | MyERAS opens for residency application submission | ERAS |
| 9 September 2026 at 12:00 (noon) ET | CaRMS Online opens, and you can send reference requests | CaRMS |
| September 23, 2026 | Residency programs may begin reviewing applications | ERAS |
| 5 November 2026 at 17:00 ET | Deadline to request CaRMS translation of references | CaRMS |
| 25 November 2026 at 21:00 ET | Reference submission deadline | CaRMS |
| November 26 at 12:00 ET | File review opens | CaRMS |
How to ask, with scripts you can copy
Ask in person if you can. Ask whether they are comfortable writing you a letter, and watch the answer. The AAMC suggests choosing writers who do not hesitate or seem unsure, since they are likely to write a stronger recommendation. It also advises asking as you finish each rotation, while your work and performance are fresh in their minds.
The in-person ask: "I really valued working with you on [service]. I'm applying to [specialty] this cycle. Do you feel you know my work well enough to write me a strong letter?"
The request email, sent the same day: "Thank you for agreeing to write a letter for my [specialty] applications. The request form is attached, and I have [waived / not waived] my right to see the letter. I'm working to a deadline of [date]. I've attached my CV, personal statement, my evaluation from our rotation and a one-page summary of the patients and tasks we worked on together. I'm happy to meet if that would help."
Four weeks before the deadline: "I wanted to check in on my letter for [specialty]. My deadline is [date]. Please let me know if you need anything else from me."
One week before: "A quick reminder that my letters are due on [date]. Thank you again for your help."
Thank-you note, once it is uploaded: "Your letter is in. Thank you for the time you took to write it and for everything you taught me on [service]."
Match update: "I matched to [specialty] at [program]. Your letter was part of that, and I wanted you to hear it from me." The AAMC recommends a thank-you note and updates on significant news, since your writers have invested in your career.
Following up is your job. The AAMC says it is your responsibility to track requests and make sure letters are submitted on time.
If you want to rehearse the ask out loud, or the residency interviews that follow, Confetto runs mock interviews with follow-up questions on your answers.
What to give your writer
The AAMC lists the core set: your CV, personal statement, copies of your evaluations and transcripts if available, plus an offer to meet and talk about your goals and strengths. Our checklist below adds what a busy attending needs to write specifics fast.
Put it all in one email with one attachment per item. A writer who has to search for your evaluation will write a vaguer letter.
- CV with a recent photo, so they can place you.
- Personal statement, even as a draft.
- Your evaluation from their rotation, with the written comments.
- Transcript, if your school releases it.
- A one-page summary: the dates you worked together, a few moments with what you did, and feedback you acted on. Remove anything that could identify a patient.
- The letter type: generic, discipline-specific or program-specific for CaRMS, or the specialty, narrative or standardized, and chair status for ERAS.
- The deadline with the time zone, and the request link or form.
- Your waiver choice, stated plainly.
What a strong letter says
Share this part with your writer. The AAMC's guidelines for letters of evaluation are written for medical school applicants, but their principles fit clinical letters well. The AAMC's ERAS for Letter Writers page also links its Guidelines for Writing a Narrative Letter of Recommendation for a Residency Applicant.
CaRMS asks that reference letters include a confidentiality statement, the date the letter was written, and the time and duration of the writer's contact with you. It also asks for an assessment of cognitive skills and knowledge, problem solving and patient management, behavior and attitudinal skills, communication skills and working relationships, motivation and punctuality, sense of responsibility, procedural skills for the discipline, and special qualities and unique contributions. If the writer has not observed one of these, the letter should say so.
Sample letter written by our team. The student, writer and hospital are invented.
[Letterhead] [Date the letter was written]. Dear Program Director, I am writing to recommend Priya Nair for residency training in internal medicine. I was her attending on the general medicine ward at Lakeview General Hospital for four weeks in September. I saw her on rounds every weekday and reviewed all of her notes. Ms. Nair has not seen this letter and will not receive a copy.
Her clinical reasoning stood out early. In her second week, she noticed a rising creatinine in a patient admitted for pneumonia that the team had put down to dehydration. She reviewed his medication list, found a recently started NSAID, and presented a plan to stop it and recheck. His kidney function recovered.
She communicates clearly with patients and the team. I watched her explain a new diagnosis of heart failure to a patient with limited English through a hospital interpreter, then ask him to repeat the plan in his own words. She arrived before pre-rounds every day and closed every task she took on. When I told her that her presentations ran long, her next ones were half the length.
I did not observe her procedural skills on this rotation. Among the clerks I have supervised on this ward over three years, she is in the top group I would want as a resident. I recommend her without reservation. Sincerely, [Name, title, signature]
Why this sample works: the first paragraph states the relationship, the setting and how long they worked together. Each claim comes with something the writer saw, what the student did and what happened. The unobserved skill is named rather than skipped. The comparison names its group, and the last line is a clear endorsement.
- Give an accurate assessment of the applicant rather than advocate for them.
- State how long you have known the applicant, in what role, and whether your observations are direct or indirect.
- Quality of information matters more than length. Focus on the applicant, not the service or institution.
- Describe behaviors you saw directly: the situation, what the applicant did and what followed.
- Ask the applicant's permission before including anything private or sensitive.
- If you compare, name the comparison group and your reason for it.
- If you use generative AI to draft or edit, the final letter must reflect your own assessment, judgment and firsthand observations.
| Vague line | Specific line | What it adds |
|---|---|---|
| She is a hard worker. | She arrived before pre-rounds every day and closed every task she took on. | Behavior the writer saw, not a label |
| One of the best students I have worked with. | Among the clerks I have supervised on this ward over three years, she is in the top group. | A comparison group and a reason for the comparison |
| She has good clinical skills. | She found a medication cause of a rising creatinine and proposed a plan to stop it. | Situation, behavior and consequence |
| I am happy to recommend her. | I recommend her without reservation for your program. | A clear endorsement |
How the letter gets submitted, and the waiver
In ERAS, you create a separate entry in MyERAS for each letter. Once you confirm it, MyERAS generates a Letter Request Form with a unique Letter ID. You can email the form from MyERAS with a personal message. Send each form to one writer only, because each Letter ID can be used once. The writer or their designee uploads the letter through the AAMC Letter Writer Portal, using the link on the form or the Letter ID.
Every uploaded letter is watermarked with the uploader's name and the date and time. You get an email when a letter is uploaded, and then you can assign it. Check before you assign. Letters cannot be replaced once assigned to a program you applied to, and programs are not guaranteed to review letters assigned after your initial application.
In CaRMS, you create a reference request in CaRMS Online and your referee is notified. The referee submits in their CaRMS Online referee account. Structured reference letters are completed online in that account.
For format, CaRMS early references go in as a PDF on letterhead, not a JPEG or Word file. The AAMC notes that file size and resubmission rules differ by service, so writers should follow the guidance for the service they are uploading to.
The waiver is a one-time choice in ERAS. The AAMC recommends waiving your right to see your letters. If you waive, you cannot view or obtain that letter under any circumstances. A CaRMS letter includes a statement that you have not seen it and will not receive a copy.
Your MSPR, the dean's letter, is a different document. CaRMS describes it as a letter of standing from your dean that reports on your activities and clinical performance. Current-year Canadian graduates' MSPRs are usually transferred to CaRMS by the school, so it does not count as one of your reference letters.
Hard situations and what to do
Show details
Most letter problems come from the wrong writer or a late request. These are the cases students ask about most, with our advice.
- The writer hesitates. Thank them warmly and ask someone else. The AAMC's own advice is to choose writers who do not hesitate.
- You had a weak evaluation or a failed exam. Ask a writer who saw you after it and can describe the change. AAMC guidance says writers can describe obstacles and how they led to growth, and must ask your permission before including private or sensitive information.
- You have no letter from your specialty yet, or you are switching. Book a rotation or elective in the new specialty and ask there. In ERAS, a letter labeled General can go to several specialties, but General removes the narrative or standardized choice. In CaRMS, ask your earlier writers for a generic reference.
- Your best writer supervised an away elective. Ask in the last week, before you leave, and give them your summary sheet. CaRMS asks writers to state the time and duration of contact, so a short elective is fine if the letter says so.
- The writer asks you to draft it. Offer your summary sheet with facts and dates instead of finished wording. The judgment in the letter has to be theirs.
- CaRMS specialty rules changed. CaRMS's reference guidelines list Anesthesiology and Dermatology forms as applicant support forms in an introductory period, which you send to the referee yourself. Its June 2026 early-reference instructions say Anesthesiology, Dermatology, Family Medicine, Emergency Medicine, Orthopedic Surgery, Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Psychiatry, Pediatrics and Pediatric Emergency Medicine programs will no longer accept narrative letters. Check each program description before you request.
- The CaRMS deadline is close and a letter is missing. Referees can still submit after 25 November 2026 at 21:00 ET, but CaRMS warns it may cut the time you have to assign letters before file review opens.
If you are applying to medical school instead
Show details
Premed applicants use different systems. For AMCAS, you can have up to 10 letters associated with your application, though that does not mean any school wants 10. Letters are not required to submit your application or to have it verified. Reapplicants must send new letters each cycle.
AMCAS accepts a committee letter, a letter packet or individual letters, and each counts as one entry. Writers upload PDF or Word files through the AAMC Letter Writer Portal, where letters are marked received immediately, or through Interfolio, which can take up to 3 business days. Some medical schools require letterhead and a signature. To fix a letter, the writer uploads a new version using the same Request ID.
AAMC guidance asks writers of these letters to describe how you have, or have not, shown the premed competencies needed for success in medical school.
For DO schools, AACOM says all colleges of osteopathic medicine require letters. They arrive through the AACOMAS application or through services each school names, such as Interfolio, VirtualEvals or U.S. mail. Requirements vary by school, so check each college before your writers submit.
Practice question
Your attending agrees to write your letter and asks, "What would you like me to focus on?" What do you say?
See an example answer
Example answer written by our team. The student is invented. "Thank you, I really appreciate it. I'd be grateful if you could speak to how I handled my own patients, since that's what I most want programs to see. The case I think of first is Mr. L in week two. I noticed his creatinine climbing and traced it to the NSAID he'd started before admission, and you let me present the plan on rounds. I'd also value anything you saw about how I took feedback. When you told me my presentations ran long, I cut them down, and I hope that showed. I've put both on a one-page summary with dates, plus my evaluation from the rotation and my CV, so you don't have to rely on memory. I'm applying to internal medicine, the deadline is in five weeks, and I've waived my right to see the letter. If there's an area you didn't get to observe, like procedures, I completely understand if you say so."
It answers the question with two specific moments the attending actually saw, so the letter can describe behavior instead of adjectives. It hands over the materials the AAMC suggests, states the deadline and the waiver, and gives the writer permission to say what they did not observe, which matches CaRMS guidance.
Frequently asked questions
Can a resident write my residency reference letter?
For ERAS, the AAMC advises letters from physicians who know you well rather than residents, pre-clinical faculty or non-physicians. CaRMS accepts a physician, professor or non-clinical individual as a referee, but check each program description.
How many reference letters does a medical student need?
In ERAS you can assign up to four letters to each program. In CaRMS, each program description lists the references it wants, and some specialties accept only structured reference letters.
Should I waive my right to see my letters?
The AAMC recommends waiving. In ERAS, a waived letter can never be viewed or obtained by you, and CaRMS letters include a statement that you have not seen the letter and will not receive a copy.
Is the MSPR or dean's letter a reference letter?
No. CaRMS describes the MSPR as a letter of standing from your dean that reports on your activities and clinical performance, and current-year Canadian graduates' schools usually transfer it for them.
What if my writer misses the CaRMS reference deadline?
Referees can submit after 25 November 2026 at 21:00 ET. CaRMS warns this may reduce the time you have to assign the letter to programs before file review opens on November 26 at 12:00 ET.
Can I swap a letter after assigning it in ERAS?
No. Letters cannot be replaced once assigned to a program you applied to, so confirm each letter before you assign it.
Sources
- AAMC: Letters of Recommendation for Residency Applicants
- AAMC: 2027 MyERAS Applicant User Guide, Letters of Recommendation
- AAMC: ERAS for Letter Writers
- AAMC: AAMC Letter Writer Portal
- AAMC: Guidelines for Writing a Letter of Evaluation
- AAMC: 2027 AMCAS Applicant Guide, Letters of Evaluation
- AAMC: Section 6 of the AMCAS Application, Letters of Evaluation
- AAMC: Types of Letters of Evaluation
- CaRMS: Reference guidelines (R-1 referee)
- CaRMS: R-1 reference deadlines
- CaRMS: Document types (applicant)
- CaRMS: Instructions for early reference submission
- AACOM: The Application Process