Confetto

Situational Judgment Test Score: Casper & PREview Guide

Practice the med school interview now

Free, no sign-up to start.

Learn how situational judgment test scores work on Casper and AAMC PREview, how Z-scores, percentiles, and 1 to 9 scales work, and what makes a good score.

Practice the med school interview now

Free, no sign-up to start.

A situational judgment test score measures how your reasoning and professional judgment compare to peers or an expert scoring key, rather than against a universal pass mark. On Casper, Acuity Insights reports your results to admissions programs as a standardized Z-score and a percentile relative to applicants in your exact test instance. On the AAMC PREview exam, the AAMC converts your raw item credits into a total scaled score from 1 to 9, reported alongside a confidence band and a three-year percentile rank. Sources: Acuity Insights Casper Implementation Guide, Acuity Insights Casper Admissions Overview, Acuity Insights 2026 Casper Technical Manual. Last checked November 13, 2026.

How Situational Judgment Test Scores Work

Situational judgment test scores give admissions committees a standardized measure of social intelligence, ethics, and professional judgment alongside GPA and cognitive exam scores. Depending on which assessment your program requires, your test will follow one of two distinct scoring designs: an open-response evaluation or a keyed rating-scale exam.

Open-response assessments like Casper ask what you would actually do in a realistic dilemma and why, rather than asking you to pick what you think the single right answer should be. Certified human raters evaluate your typed and video explanations across multiple scenarios, and your combined performance is standardized against the other applicants who took that exact test session.

Rating-scale assessments like the AAMC PREview Professional Readiness Exam ask what a student should view as effective or ineffective behavior. The AAMC builds its master scoring key in collaboration with medical school admissions officers, faculty, and student affairs representatives. Your raw points depend on how closely your effectiveness ratings match those educators' consensus ratings before the AAMC equates your result onto a 1 to 9 scale.

Casper vs. AAMC PREview Scoring Overview
Scoring FeatureCasper (Acuity Insights / TakeAltus)
Question formatOpen-ended typed and video responses across 11 scenarios
Prompt focusWhat you would do and how you explain your reasoning
Who establishes the scoreCertified, independent human raters (not AI) using a structured process
Scores sent to schoolsStandardized Z-score and percentile rank
Comparison groupOther applicants in the exact same test instance
Score validity windowValid for a single admissions cycle and a single test type

How Casper Calculates Z-Scores and Percentiles

Standard Casper assessments contain 11 scenarios split across two sections and take about 65 to 85 minutes to complete, including two optional breaks (select tracks, such as Australian teacher education programs, use a shorter version). In the video section, you complete 4 scenarios with 2 open-ended questions per scenario and 1 minute to record each response. In the typed section, you complete 7 scenarios with 2 open-ended questions on the same page and 3.5 minutes per scenario to type both answers.

By our calculation from TakeAltus's published Casper format, you answer 8 video questions across 8 minutes of recording time and 14 typed questions across 24.5 minutes of writing time, giving you 32.5 minutes of active response time across 22 open-ended questions. Multiple independent human raters grade your responses so that no single rater determines your overall mark. Over 1 million applicants have completed Casper across more than 600 partner institutions worldwide.

As detailed in Acuity Insights' October 2026 implementation guide and October 2026 technical manual (developed under the 2014 Standards for Educational and Psychological Testing), admissions committees receive two numbers for your file: a Z-score and a percentile. Your Z-score shows how far above or below the mean you scored compared to everyone else in your exact test instance. A Z-score tells how close your score is to the average, where a positive Z-score means you performed above average and a negative Z-score means you performed below average. Your Casper percentile translates that relative standing into the percentage of peers you outperformed, meaning a 75th percentile result beat 75% of test-takers in that cohort.

How AAMC PREview Calculates Your 1 to 9 Score

On the AAMC PREview exam, every suggested response to a scenario is rated on a four-point effectiveness scale split into two sides: Very Ineffective and Ineffective on one side, and Effective and Very Effective on the other. You earn full credit on an item when your rating matches the medical educators' consensus key exactly.

Partial credit protects you when your judgment points in the right direction but differs slightly in degree. You earn half credit when your choice sits one step away from the consensus key on the same side of the scale. For instance, if medical educators key an action as Effective and you rate it Very Effective, you receive half credit. If you cross the center line and rate that same Effective action as Ineffective, you receive zero credit.

Because test forms vary slightly in item difficulty, the AAMC uses a statistical process called equating to convert your raw item credits into a total scaled score from 1 to 9. Equating guarantees that a scaled score of 6 carries the exact same meaning regardless of which test form you received or when you tested. Every score report also includes a confidence band showing the range where your true score likely sits, discouraging admissions officers from over-interpreting tiny differences between applicants. Alongside that band, you receive a percentile rank showing the percentage of examinees over the most recent three testing years who earned the same or lower score. Because the AAMC refreshes this norm table every May, your 1 to 9 scaled score never changes, though your percentile rank can shift if you reapply in a later year.

Worked Example: How AAMC PREview Credit Rules Score Four Responses
Item in ScenarioEducator Consensus KeyYour Selected RatingScoring Alignment RuleCredit Awarded
Response AVery IneffectiveVery IneffectiveExact match with consensus keyFull credit
Response BEffectiveVery EffectiveOne step away on the same side of the scaleHalf credit
Response CIneffectiveVery IneffectiveOne step away on the same side of the scaleHalf credit
Response DEffectiveIneffectiveCrosses to the opposite side of the scaleNo credit

What Counts as a Good Situational Judgment Test Score

Neither Acuity Insights nor the AAMC sets a universal passing mark, so what counts as a good situational judgment test score depends on how each school weights the exam. TakeAltus states directly that individual programs decide when and how to weigh Casper scores. Furthermore, Acuity Insights advises admissions teams against rigid screen-in or screen-out cut scores, noting that hard cutoffs reduce cohort diversity and can eliminate capable applicants over minor numerical differences.

Still, Acuity Insights' Silver Valley University admissions model illustrates how admissions rubrics group Z-scores and percentiles into clear performance tiers, with a maximum score of 12 (3 points for each of the 4 measures). On Casper, any positive Z-score shows above-average performance relative to peers in your test instance, and higher percentiles mean you outperformed a larger share of the cohort.

On the AAMC PREview 1 to 9 scale, scores closer to 9 reflect tighter alignment with medical educators' consensus standards, while very low scores draw scrutiny during file review. AAMC research spanning more than a decade, including a six-year longitudinal study (2020 to 2026) across six partner medical schools and a 2025 study on medical school dismissals, found that while MCAT scores and undergraduate GPAs strongly predict academic dismissal risk, PREview scores provide a strong signal of non-academic termination risk.

How Admissions Committees Weight Your SJT Score

Show details

Acuity Insights outlines three standard models that universities use to combine SJT results with academic records during pre-interview screening. Knowing these models shows why a moderate SJT score rarely sinks an otherwise strong file, while a high SJT score can push a borderline academic file into the interview pool.

In a formulaic model, schools assign fixed mathematical weights to each metric. In Acuity Insights' River Fork University case study, an admissions office reviewing 3,000 applicants for 700 interview spots and 300 seats weights pre-interview files as 1/3 GPA, 1/3 GRE, and 1/3 Casper Z-score. The top 600 applicants earn automatic interview invites, ranks 601 to 800 receive manual file reviews for the remaining 100 spots, and final seat offers combine ½ MMI/interview score with ½ pre-interview formula score.

In a rubric model like Silver Valley University's, committees score four components (GPA, GRE, Casper, and reference letters) at up to 3 points for each of the 4 measures, for a maximum score of 12. Applicants with 10 to 12 total points are fast-tracked to interviews, while those scoring 6 to 10 receive a full file read. Finally, in a qualitative model, trained reviewers read your entire file, including transcripts, essays, CVs, and SJT scores, to make an interview decision without plugging your score into a numerical formula.

Competencies Evaluated and How to Raise Your Score

Casper scenarios test ten core personal and professional skills, listed across TakeAltus and Acuity Insights materials as collaboration, communication, empathy, ethics, fairness, motivation, problem solving, resilience, self-awareness, and teamwork. Backed by more than 20 years of research and over 150 internal and external studies, open-response scoring rewards answers that weigh multiple perspectives rather than jumping to a one-sided verdict.

Preparation also measurably improves rating-scale SJT scores, especially when you focus on spotting bad options. A 2021 AAMC research study comparing rule-based and feedback-based SJT coaching found that both methods raise average SJT scores without hurting test validity, and revealed that recognizing ineffective behaviors is more coachable than distinguishing among effective ones. For Casper, TakeAltus notes that test-takers who complete the free official practice test inside their Acuity Insights account perform better than applicants who do not prepare or who rely on unverified third-party courses.

Use this five-step checklist built by our team to protect your score across both exam formats:

  • Eliminate counterproductive actions first on rating scales: Check whether an option breaches confidentiality, ignores safety, shifts blame, or bypasses direct communication before deciding how ineffective it is.
  • Guard the midline on AAMC PREview: Ask first whether an action makes the problem better (Effective side) or worse/unaddressed (Ineffective side) so you never lose full item credit by crossing the center divide.
  • Gather facts privately before escalating on Casper: State how you would speak privately and non-judgmentally with the person involved to learn missing context before reporting minor issues, unless safety or policy requires immediate escalation.
  • Use conditional if-then logic when stakes conflict: Show raters how your plan adapts depending on new facts (for example, how you respond if a struggling teammate has a medical emergency versus if they simply forgot a deadline).
  • Practice under exact test timing: Run full practice blocks at 1 minute per Casper video prompt and 3.5 minutes per two-question typed screen so your reasoning never cuts off mid-sentence.

Practice Scenario and Example Answer

Show details

Open-response raters score the structure and fairness of your thinking, not polished vocabulary or memorized buzzwords. Notice how the practice scenario and model response on this page pause judgment, gather private context, protect group standards, and explain why each step respects everyone involved.

When you review your own practice answers, check three things: did you name every stakeholder affected by the dilemma, did you state both what you would do and why, and did you offer a practical path forward that avoids punishing someone before hearing their side? Hitting those three marks consistently across 11 scenarios is what drives positive Casper Z-scores.

Score Reporting, Validity Windows, and Retake Rules

Show details

Casper and AAMC PREview follow strict and very different rules on retakes, score expiration, and school distribution. Planning your test date early keeps administrative errors from delaying your file review.

  • Casper single-cycle validity and retake ban: Casper scores apply to only one admissions cycle and one specific test type (such as American Health Sciences). You cannot retake the same Casper test type within the same admissions cycle, and applying to programs in different countries, languages, or tracks requires separate tests.
  • Casper registration deadlines and fees: Reserve your Casper date at least 3 days in advance with a government-issued photo ID, or submit accommodation forms at least 4 weeks ahead. All registration fees are non-refundable, scores go automatically to your selected schools, and programs requiring Duet include it at no extra cost.
  • AAMC PREview AMCAS uploads and score history: Once scored, PREview results upload automatically to your AMCAS application on the scheduled release date. Your report shows every scored exam you have taken since 2020 (including 2020 and 2021 exams taken when it was called the AAMC SJT), though non-participating AMCAS schools cannot view your scores until admissions decisions conclude.
  • AAMC PREview voiding and non-AMCAS sharing: Choosing to void your PREview exam on test day counts toward your testing attempts, produces no score, and leaves nothing on AMCAS. For non-AMCAS schools, you send reports through the Share Scores tool in the AAMC Testing Services Score Reporting System. Requests cannot be canceled once submitted, and any new PREview scores earned within one calendar year transmit automatically to those authorized programs.

Practice question

You are working on a four-person lab project worth a major portion of your final grade. Two days before the submission deadline, one group member, Jordan, stops replying to messages and leaves their assigned data section incomplete. Your other two teammates want to remove Jordan's name from the report immediately and tell the professor that Jordan abandoned the team. How would you handle this situation? Explain your reasoning.

See an example answer

Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. I would ask my two teammates to hold off on removing Jordan's name until we check on Jordan directly and make a plan to protect our report deadline. Right now, we do not know whether Jordan is dealing with a sudden illness, a family emergency, or poor time management, so penalizing Jordan without facts would be unfair. First, I would reach out to Jordan privately by phone or text to express concern, check that they are safe, and ask honestly whether they can finish their section today. At the same time, I would offer to split the unfinished data analysis with my remaining teammates so our group does not miss the deadline if Jordan cannot respond. If Jordan replies with a sudden emergency, we can share what they already completed and ask the professor together for a short extension if needed. If Jordan simply chose not to contribute and still does not respond before submission, I would tell Jordan transparently that we will ask the professor for guidance on fair credit while submitting our completed work on time.

Human raters look for empathy, fairness, communication, and practical problem solving under pressure. This response pauses a premature punishment, gathers missing context privately, protects the team's academic deadline, and uses clear if-then reasoning for both outcomes.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good score on the situational judgment test?

Each admissions program sets its own benchmark rather than using a single national pass mark. On Casper, positive Z-scores and higher percentiles indicate above-average standing relative to peers in your test cohort. On the AAMC PREview exam, scaled scores closer to the top of the 1 to 9 scale show stronger alignment with medical educators' consensus ratings.

How are Casper situational judgment test scores reported to schools?

Acuity Insights sends your selected programs a standardized Z-score and a percentile rank comparing your performance to everyone else in your exact test instance. Certified human raters evaluate your typed and video responses across 11 scenarios to produce those scores.

Can you get partial credit on the AAMC PREview exam?

Yes, the AAMC awards full credit when your rating matches medical educators' consensus rating and half credit when your rating sits one step away on the same side of the effectiveness scale, such as choosing Very Effective when the key is Effective. If your answer crosses to the opposite side of the scale, such as rating an Effective action as Ineffective, you receive zero credit.

Can I retake Casper if I want a higher situational judgment test score?

No, TakeAltus rules prohibit taking the same Casper test type more than once during a single admissions cycle. Because Casper scores expire after one admissions cycle, you can only take that test type again if you reapply in a future cycle.

Why can my AAMC PREview percentile rank change if my score stays the same?

Your 1 to 9 total scaled score is fixed permanently through test equating, so it never changes. However, the AAMC recalculates its percentile rank table every May using examinee data from the three most recent testing years, which can shift the percentile attached to your score in a later cycle.

Do admissions committees use strict cutoff scores for situational judgment tests?

Each school sets its own policy, though Acuity Insights explicitly advises admissions committees against strict screen-in or screen-out cut scores because hard cutoffs reduce flexibility and cohort diversity. Instead, programs commonly combine SJT scores with GPA and test metrics through weighted formulas, multi-point rubrics, or whole-file reviews.

Sources