Situational Judgment Test Medicine: Casper vs. PREview
Free, no sign-up to start.
Compare medical school situational judgment tests (SJTs). See 2026 Casper and AAMC PREview formats, timing, scoring rules, and a worked practice answer.
Free, no sign-up to start.
In medical school admissions, a situational judgment test (SJT) evaluates your professionalism, empathy, and ethical reasoning through hypothetical dilemmas rather than clinical science. North American medical schools primarily use 2 exams: Acuity Insights Casper, a 65 to 85-minute open-response test with 11 video and typed scenarios, and the AAMC PREview exam, an about 75-minute multiple-choice test where you rate 186 behavioral responses. Neither exam replaces the MCAT or GPA, and individual medical schools decide whether to require, recommend, or explore scores during admissions review. Sources: Acuity Insights: About Casper, Acuity Insights: Casper Dates, Times, and Guidelines, AAMC: About the AAMC PREview Exam. Last checked November 11, 2026.
On this page
- What a situational judgment test measures in medicine
- Casper vs. AAMC PREview: side-by-side comparison
- Acuity Insights Casper format and timing
- AAMC PREview format and timing
- How medical school SJTs are scored and used
- 2026 registration rules, fees, and test dates
- 4-step preparation plan and ethical checklist
- Worked practice scenario and example answer
- Practice question
- Frequently asked questions
- Sources
What a situational judgment test measures in medicine
Medical schools use situational judgment tests to measure how you handle complex interpersonal and ethical situations before you enter clinical training. While your undergraduate GPA and MCAT score show your academic readiness, an SJT gives admissions committees a standardized look at your non-academic competencies.
According to Acuity Insights and the Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC), these assessments do not require any prior experience in a healthcare setting. Instead, they present everyday workplace, academic, and personal dilemmas to see how you judge professional behaviors, collaborate with peers, and take accountability under pressure.
Individual medical programs set their own policies on how SJT results factor into admissions. Depending on the school, submitting a score may be a strict requirement to complete your application, an optional recommendation, or an exploratory data point gathered for future admissions cycles.
- Acuity Insights Casper competencies: collaboration, communication, empathy, ethics, fairness, motivation, problem solving, resilience, and self-awareness.
- AAMC PREview Relational Skills: working effectively on teams, building relationships, collaboration, empathy, interpersonal skills, and compassion.
- AAMC PREview Personal Accountability: ethical responsibility, reliability, resilience, adaptability, and continuous self-improvement.
Casper vs. AAMC PREview: side-by-side comparison
Although Casper and AAMC PREview both evaluate pre-professional readiness, they test you in completely different ways. Casper asks you to generate your own solutions from scratch on camera and in writing, while AAMC PREview asks you to judge pre-written responses on a fixed 4-point rating scale.
You can prepare for open-ended video and typed prompts by reviewing our guide to the Casper test format and practicing under real time limits.
| Feature | Acuity Insights Casper | AAMC PREview |
|---|---|---|
| Test administrator | Acuity Insights | Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) |
| Question format | Open-ended video and typed responses | Multiple-choice effectiveness ratings (4-point scale) |
| Total length | 65 to 85 minutes (includes 2 optional breaks) | About 75 minutes |
| Volume of items | 11 scenarios (22 total open-ended questions) | 186 items grouped into scenario sets (4 to 8 items per set) |
| Who scores the exam | Certified human raters (no AI scoring) | Automated key based on medical educator consensus |
| Retake policy | 1 attempt per test type per admissions cycle | Up to 2 attempts per testing year (4 lifetime attempts) |
| Score validity | Valid for a single admissions cycle and singular test type | Valid for multiple years |
| Registration fee (2026) | Varies by country and program (waived or reduced with eligible fee assistance) | $105 flat fee (includes unlimited score distribution. $0 first attempt with AAMC FAP) |
Acuity Insights Casper format and timing
According to Acuity Insights, the current Casper exam takes 65 to 85 minutes to complete, includes 2 optional breaks, and consists of 11 total scenarios split across 2 sections.
Every scenario on Casper gives you 2 open-ended prompts. By our calculation from Acuity Insights format data, you will answer 22 open-ended questions across the 11 scenarios during only 32.5 minutes of active response time (8 minutes of speaking and 24.5 minutes of typing), giving you 1 minute and 45 seconds per question on average in the typed section.
To build speed for the 3.5-minute written prompts, check out our Casper test prep guide and run through realistic sample Casper questions before test day.
- Video response section: 4 scenarios, 2 open-ended questions per scenario, with 1 minute to record each video response.
- Typed response section: 7 scenarios, 2 open-ended questions presented on the same page per scenario, with 3.5 minutes total to type both answers.
- Scenario types: includes both video-based scenarios (where you watch a short video interaction) and word-based prompts (where you read a short statement or reflection prompt).
AAMC PREview format and timing
Originally launched in 2020 as the AAMC Situational Judgment Test and renamed in 2022, the AAMC PREview Professional Readiness Exam is a standardized, remote-proctored online test. It takes about 75 minutes to complete and must be taken on a desktop or laptop computer using Guardian browser software, never on a mobile phone or tablet.
The exam contains a single test section of 186 behavioral responses for you to evaluate. By our calculation from AAMC format specifications, rating 186 items in 75 minutes gives you an average of 24.2 seconds per item, including the time needed to read each scenario passage.
Unlike Casper, PREview does not ask what you would personally do in a situation. Instead, the test presents brief text-based scenarios, each followed by 4 to 8 possible actions someone might take. You must rate the effectiveness of each individual action based on whether it will make the situation better or worse.
- 4-point rating scale: Very Ineffective, Ineffective, Effective, or Very Effective.
- Scenario setting split: every PREview exam form maintains an exact ratio of 75% non-healthcare scenarios and 25% healthcare scenarios.
- Content balance: about half of the items measure personal accountability skills and the other half assess relational skills, distributed evenly across competencies.
- Live remote proctoring: a human proctor verifies your ID, conducts a visual scan of all 4 corners of your room and under your desk, and monitors you via webcam and microphone.
How medical school SJTs are scored and used
Casper and PREview rely on distinct grading systems. Casper responses are evaluated entirely by certified human raters using a structured rubric, without AI grading. Your scores are automatically distributed to the programs you selected on your distribution list, and each school decides how to weigh the score in its admissions process.
On the AAMC PREview exam, your answers are scored against an answer key created by a consensus of medical school faculty, admissions officers, and student affairs experts. Every item undergoes review by more than 10 trained reviewers for potential bias and sensitivity before being used.
Your PREview score report displays a total scaled score from 1 to 9, a confidence band of plus or minus 1 point, and a percentile rank (which the AAMC updates every May). According to AAMC guidance for admissions officers, medical schools most frequently use PREview scores as a plus factor when comparing similar applicants, an early screening indicator, a metric in a weighted selection matrix, or a tool to identify matriculants who may benefit from professional development support.
- PREview Full Credit: awarded when your rating exactly matches the medical educators' consensus rating (for example, rating an item Effective when the key is Effective).
- PREview Half Credit: awarded when your rating is 1 step away from the consensus rating on the same side of the scale (for example, rating an item Very Effective when the key is Effective, or rating an item Very Ineffective when the key is Ineffective).
- PREview Zero Credit: awarded when your rating crosses to the opposite side of the scale (for example, rating an item Ineffective when the key is Effective).
2026 registration rules, fees, and test dates
Show details
Registration timelines and retake limits differ sharply between the 2 exams. For Casper, you must create an Acuity Insights account using a government-issued photo ID and register at least 3 days before your preferred test date to allow for identity verification and payment processing. If you need disability or medical accommodations for Casper, you must submit your request form and documentation at least 4 weeks before your scheduled test.
You can only take a specific Casper test type (such as American Health Sciences or Canadian Health Sciences) once per admissions cycle, and your score is valid for that single cycle only. If your programs also require Duet, it is included at no additional charge. Applicants approved for a participating US or UK Fee Assistance Program (including AAMC, AACOMAS, CASPA, ADEA, or UCAS bursary) can have their Casper fees waived or reduced.
For the AAMC PREview exam, testing is offered across 8 testing windows from April 15, 2026 through October 15, 2026, with registration opening on February 24, 2026. Appointments are scheduled on a first-come, first-served basis between 8 a.m. and 1 a.m. Eastern Time. Score reports are released about 30 days following each testing window. Examinees may take PREview no more than 2 times in a single testing year and no more than 4 times in their lifetime. You may reschedule an appointment up to 2 weeks before your test date for a $25 fee, or cancel at least 48 hours in advance for a 50% refund.
The standard 2026 registration fee for PREview is $105, which includes unlimited score distribution. Approved AAMC Fee Assistance Program recipients pay $0 for their first registration and receive a 50% discount on subsequent registrations or rescheduling fees. Qualified Canadian examinees who apply via AFMC can also receive a voucher for 1 free PREview exam and a 50% discount on subsequent registrations if requested at least 5 days prior to the registration deadline.
4-step preparation plan and ethical checklist
Neither Casper nor PREview tests memorized science facts, so your preparation should focus on timing, format familiarity, and structured reasoning. Both Acuity Insights and the AAMC provide free official practice exams that mirror the real testing interface and scoring logic.
When you evaluate a scenario on either test, grounding your reasoning in the 4 core pillars of medical ethics helps you justify why an action is responsible:
Autonomy: Respecting an individual's right to make their own informed decisions and protecting private confidences.
Beneficence: Acting in a manner that actively promotes the wellbeing, safety, and growth of patients, peers, and team members.
Non-Maleficence: Taking deliberate care to avoid causing harm, escalating tension unnecessarily, or creating avoidable risks.
Justice: Ensuring fair distribution of responsibilities, equal treatment under institutional policies, and impartial resolution of disputes.
Use the 4-step plan and checklist our team wrote below to structure your practice sessions over 2 weeks.
- Step 1: Confirm your school requirements first. Check the MSAR database, AMCAS, and your Acuity Insights portal to list which of your target schools require or recommend Casper, PREview, or either SJT.
- Step 2: Take the free official baseline tests. Log into your Acuity Insights account after reserving your test to take the full-length Casper practice exam, and download the 2 free unscored AAMC PREview PDF practice tests (plus the optional $20 Scored Practice Exam in the MCAT Official Prep Hub).
- Step 3: Audit your reasoning against core competencies. For PREview, read the official scoring rationales to see why an action is keyed Effective versus Very Effective. For Casper, practice addressing both prompts on the page within 3.5 minutes without leaving the second question blank.
- Step 4: Run a technical check 48 hours before test day. Verify your webcam, microphone, ID name match, and workspace requirements so you do not lose time or forfeit fees during check-in.
- Our response checklist for open-ended dilemmas: (1) Gather missing facts privately before accusing anyone, (2) Acknowledge the perspectives and needs of every person involved, (3) Fulfill your professional and ethical responsibilities without breaking institutional rules, and (4) Propose a constructive next step that prevents the problem from happening again.
Worked practice scenario and example answer
To show how these competencies work under real timing constraints, below is an official sample scenario from Acuity Insights paired with a timed model response written by our team.
On the typed section of Casper, both questions appear on the same screen and you have 3.5 minutes total to type both answers. Learn more about how human raters evaluate your reasoning in our breakdown of how Casper is scored. You can also practice live with our timed Casper simulation tool to test your pacing.
Practice question
Official Acuity Insights Sample Scenario: You are a group member. One of your group members, Paul, has stopped contributing to your group assignment due to a medical condition. (1) How should you and your group members handle this situation? Explain your response. (2) Imagine that Paul contributed a significant amount to the assignment before he put his courses on hold. How, if at all, would this change your response to the previous question? Explain your reasoning.
See an example answer
Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. 1. First, I would reach out to Paul privately to express support for his health and ask if he is comfortable sharing his timeline or needs, without pressuring him to disclose private medical details. Protecting his privacy and wellbeing comes first. Next, I would meet with the remaining group members to see if we can temporarily redistribute his remaining tasks so our project stays on track. If the workload is too heavy for the rest of us to absorb fairly, I would consult the course instructor or teaching assistant to ask about an extension or an adjusted grading structure that protects both Paul's academic standing and our team's grade. 2. If Paul had already completed a substantial portion of the assignment before putting his courses on hold, my priority would shift toward making sure he receives full academic credit for the work he already contributed. I would document the specific sections Paul completed and share that record with the instructor so he can receive an incomplete grade, partial credit, or a medical accommodation rather than a zero. Within the group, knowing he already did his fair share would make it much easier for the rest of us to divide the final polishing tasks without resentment.
It demonstrates empathy and respect for privacy first, collaborates with teammates before escalating, and uses practical fairness in the second prompt by documenting Paul's prior work for the instructor.
Frequently asked questions
What is a situational judgment test (SJT) in medical school admissions?
A situational judgment test presents hypothetical workplace, academic, or interpersonal dilemmas to measure non-academic skills such as professionalism, empathy, ethics, communication, and collaboration. Medical schools use SJTs alongside the MCAT and GPA to evaluate how applicants make decisions and judge professional behavior.
What is the difference between Casper and AAMC PREview?
Casper is an open-response exam with 11 scenarios where you record 1-minute videos and type answers within 3.5 minutes for certified human raters to score. AAMC PREview is an about 75-minute multiple-choice test where you rate the effectiveness of 186 pre-written responses on a 4-point scale from Very Ineffective to Very Effective.
Does the AAMC PREview or Casper replace the MCAT exam?
No. The AAMC explicitly states that the PREview exam does not replace the MCAT exam, but instead complements academic metrics like your GPA and MCAT score by assessing professional readiness.
Can I retake Casper or AAMC PREview in the same admissions cycle?
You cannot retake the same Casper test type more than once in a single admissions cycle. For AAMC PREview, you are allowed to take the exam up to 2 times within a single testing year and up to 4 times total in your lifetime.
How long are Casper and AAMC PREview scores valid?
Casper scores are valid for only a single admissions cycle and a single test type, meaning reapplicants must take a new test in future cycles. AAMC PREview scores remain valid for multiple years, so you can submit an existing PREview score report if you delay your application or reapply.
How much do medical school SJTs cost and does fee assistance apply?
For the 2026 testing year, the AAMC PREview exam costs a flat fee of $105, which includes unlimited score distribution. Both AAMC PREview and Acuity Insights Casper honor approved fee assistance benefits (such as the AAMC Fee Assistance Program), waiving or reducing registration fees for eligible applicants.
Sources
- Acuity Insights: About Casper
- Acuity Insights: Casper Dates, Times, and Guidelines
- AAMC: About the AAMC PREview Exam
- AAMC: PREview Exam FAQs
- AAMC: Prepare for the AAMC PREview Exam
- AAMC: Register for the AAMC PREview Exam (2026 Calendar and Fees)
- AAMC: PREview Participating Schools (2026 Essentials)
- AAMC: About the PREview Exam for Admissions Officers