What Happens If You Fail the Casper Test?

Try a free Casper practice scenario

Free, no sign-up to start.

You cannot pass or fail Casper. See how quartile scores work, why same-cycle retakes and rescores are blocked, and what to do after a 1st quartile.

Try a free Casper practice scenario

Free, no sign-up to start.

You cannot officially pass or fail the Casper test because there is no universal passing score. Instead, human raters evaluate your responses and send official results directly to your selected schools, while your account displays a quartile ranking showing how your typed section compared with peers in the same admissions cycle. Under the Acuity Insights Terms of Use, you can take a Casper test type only 1 time per admissions cycle, you cannot request a rescore, and retakes are granted only for verified technical problems reported within 1 week of your test date. Sources: About Casper: Format, Scoring, and Sample Scenarios (TakeAltus), Acuity Insights Terms of Use: Quartiles, Retakes, Rescores, and Red Flags, Casper Dates, Registration Guidelines, and Cycle Validity (TakeAltus). Last checked November 12, 2026.

Why you cannot officially fail Casper

Casper is an open-response situational judgment test used to evaluate social intelligence and professionalism across realistic scenarios, with more than 1 million applicants tested across over 600 partner institutions worldwide. Unlike licensing exams, Casper has no failing grade or standardized cutoff mark. Every academic program decides independently how and when to use your score as part of its admissions review.

What you see in your account is also different from what admissions committees receive. Under the Acuity Insights Terms of Use, neither the test maker nor your selected academic programs share your raw assessment results with you directly. Even though human raters score both video and typed scenarios for the official score report sent automatically to your selected programs, the Terms of Use specify that your account displays a quartile ranking indicating how you performed on the typed section relative to other applicants taking Casper in the same admissions cycle.

Certified human raters, not artificial intelligence, grade the Casper admissions assessment, and multiple independent raters score your test across over 150 internal and external validation studies backing the exam.

A low quartile vs. an official Red Flag

Many applicants worry that a 1st quartile result means evaluators labeled them unethical or unsuited for health care. Under the exam rules, a low quartile ranking and a misconduct or professionalism alert are completely separate outcomes. A low quartile reflects lower relative ratings on your open-ended answers, which often happens when you run out of time on the second question of a prompt or state what you would do without explaining why.

By contrast, Section 11 of the Terms of Use defines a formal administrative alert called a Red Flag from Acuity Insights. Remote proctoring monitors your keystrokes, microphone audio, and webcam video throughout the sitting. Using artificial intelligence in any form while completing the assessment is strictly prohibited and automatically triggers a Red Flag that is sent with violation details to every academic program on your distribution list.

Proctors and staff can also assign and report a Red Flag for inappropriate or unusual exam responses, inappropriate video images, an unannounced change in appearance compared with your government photo ID, or harassment of support personnel. When an applicant breaches the rules, test access can be blocked for the remainder of the current admissions cycle, for up to 5 years, or permanently, and breach decisions are final and cannot be appealed.

How a low Casper quartile differs from a formal Red Flag
FactorLow Quartile ResultOfficial Red Flag or Rule Breach
What causes itLower relative human rater scores on open-ended responsesProhibited AI use, inappropriate responses or video, ID mismatch, or harassment
What appears in your account1st or 2nd quartile relative standing indicatorAssessment cancellation or account block notice if rules were breached
What programs receiveStandardized assessment results with no misconduct alertDirect Red Flag notification and violation details sent to selected programs
Impact on future cyclesExpires after 1 admissions cycle so you start fresh next cycleAccount block can last the current cycle, up to 5 years, or permanently

Retake, rescore, and fit-to-sit rules in the same cycle

If you receive a 1st quartile ranking mid-cycle, you cannot book another sitting to improve it. Applicants are allowed to complete a specific Casper test type only 1 time per admissions cycle. Score appeals are closed off too, because Section 13.3 of the Terms of Use states that applicants may not request a rescore of any assessment.

Testing while sick or distracted will not qualify you for a second attempt either. Launching the exam serves as a binding fit-to-sit declaration confirming that you are physically, mentally, and emotionally able to test and know of no reason your performance would suffer. Once you start a session, you cannot pause it to finish later, reschedule it, or ask to cancel your results afterward. Rescheduling is permitted only before you begin the online exam and only to an open test date within the same admissions cycle.

Only these narrow paths involve sitting for Casper again during the same application year:

  • Verified technical failures: Retake requests are considered strictly when the proctoring and security team verifies a technical problem during your exam. You must report the technical problem and request the retake within 1 week of your actual test date, because any request submitted after 1 week is denied. You are responsible for your hardware, webcam, microphone, and internet connection, so problems caused by an improper home setup can also be denied, and a new test date is not guaranteed even when approved.
  • Separate Casper tests are required if you apply to programs in different test categories, countries, or required languages such as English and French in Canada. Completing a second test category satisfies a separate school requirement rather than replacing your first test score.

How admissions programs weigh a low Casper score

Because every institution sets its own evaluation policy, a 1st quartile result does not affect every school on your list the same way. Casper is built to complement grades and academic test scores rather than replace them, and platform research shows 25% to 50% smaller demographic differences than academic assessments. At the same time, many programs use Casper early in admissions to prioritize which applicants receive interview invitations before staff invest time in full file reviews.

For students applying to US MD and DO schools, admissions guidance for the AAMC PREview exam from the Association of American Medical Colleges outlines 5 ways medical schools integrate situational judgment test scores into selection. While individual school formulas vary, these 5 approaches illustrate why a low score stops progression at an early-screening program while remaining survivable elsewhere.

Admissions committees also gather professionalism evidence from multiple parts of your file. Personal statements, letters of recommendation, traditional interviews, and multiple mini interviews all give reviewers direct evidence of your judgment and communication alongside a single test sitting.

Five ways medical schools incorporate situational judgment test scores
Review StageHow Admissions Committees Use the ScoreRisk of a Low Score
Initial screeningUsed early to prioritize candidates before interviews and full file reviewHigh risk at programs that prioritize interview slots early
Academic contextReviewed alongside undergraduate GPA, MCAT score, and courseworkModerate risk when academic metrics carry primary weight
Plus factorUsed to distinguish comparable applicants rather than as a binary disqualifierLow risk because a low score does not trigger automatic rejection
Final selectionPlaced into a weighted evaluation matrix or compared with interview ratingsModerate risk that strong interview scores can help offset
Matriculant supportUsed after admission to identify incoming students for professional skill developmentNo admissions penalty when reserved for post-entry support

Five-step mid-cycle plan after a 1st or 2nd quartile

Seeing a 1st quartile result while secondary applications are still pending can rattle your confidence, especially since you cannot inspect your raw score or retest right away. Work through this 5-step triage plan written by our team to keep your current application cycle on track.

  • Step 1, Audit your school list in each application portal: Check the admissions requirements page for every program on your list and review the Medical School Admission Requirements directory for US medical schools to confirm which programs require Casper, which treat it as optional, and which do not collect it. Focus your remaining secondary essay effort first on schools where Casper is not required or where files are reviewed alongside grades.
  • Step 2, Separate Casper programs from AAMC PREview programs: A growing group of US MD and DO schools use PREview instead of Casper. PREview is an independent 186-item situational judgment exam. Your Casper quartile never goes to PREview-only schools, and you can practice using 2 free PDF practice exams and a $20 scored practice exam.
  • Step 3, Leave paid applications active unless a school states a hard cutoff: Your quartile reflects only your relative performance on the typed section compared with peers, not the internal weighting each program applies alongside GPA and entrance exams. Let programs update your status directly inside their application portals instead of withdrawing completed files early.
  • Step 5, Treat every interview invitation as a clean opportunity: Medical school interview guidance notes that an interview invite means your personal statement, letters, and academic history already impressed reviewers, and schools interview far more applicants than they accept. Visit your prehealth advisor for mock interviews covering 20 or 30 minute one-on-one interviews, group tasks, and the multiple mini interview, which typically uses 6 to 10 stations at 5 minutes per station.

Current 11-scenario format and why scores drop

Show details

Under the current TakeAltus format, standard Casper tests feature 2 sections and 11 scenarios in total, taking about 65 to 85 minutes including 2 optional breaks (select programs, including Australian teacher education programs, use a shorter format with fewer scenarios and reduced testing time). Both video and typed sections are rated by humans.

By our calculation from TakeAltus, you complete 22 open-ended questions across 32.5 minutes of active response time: 8 spoken answers across 8 minutes in the video section, plus 1054 written answers across 24.5 minutes in the typed section (an average of 1.75 minutes, or 1 minute and 45 seconds, per typed question). Seeing that exact clock explains why well-prepared students accidentally drop into the 1st quartile.

In the typed section, both open-ended questions sit on the same page under a shared 3.5-minute timer, yet raters score each question individually. Spending 3 minutes polishing Question 1 leaves Question 2 nearly blank and drags down half the scenario. Raters are trained to disregard minor spelling errors, grammar mistakes, and jargon, and bullet points and unfinished closing thoughts are accepted. Editing typos instead of answering both prompts with clear reasoning is a common trap.

Current Casper format and active response timing
SectionScenariosQuestions per ScenarioOfficial Time LimitTotal Questions and Time (By our calculation from TakeAltus)
Video responses4 scenarios2 open-ended questions1 minute per response8 spoken questions across 8 minutes of recording
Typed responses7 scenarios2 open-ended questions3.5 minutes per scenario14 written questions across 24.5 minutes
Full standard test11 scenarios2 open-ended questions65 to 85 minutes with 2 optional breaks22 scored questions across 32.5 minutes of active response time

Reapplying and retaking Casper in a future cycle

Show details

If you reapply in an upcoming admissions cycle, a past 1st quartile does not follow you as an active score. Casper scores are valid for 1 admissions cycle only, cannot be rescheduled into a new cycle, and require a separate Casper test whenever you apply in a future year. Because the exam methodology is standardized and documented in the Casper Technical Manual, which is updated annually, retesting with the exact same pacing habits risks repeating a low quartile unless you change how you practice.

To move up quartiles on your new attempt, start with the official practice tool inside your Acuity Insights account rather than buying third-party courses. TakeAltus notes that test takers who use its free official practice test tend to perform better than applicants who use third-party preparation materials or do not prepare at all. You can take the official practice test unlimited times without your answers being saved, scored, or reviewed. Drill listing your main ideas in bullet points first when short on time, expanding every answer to state both what you would do and why, and practicing 1-minute recordings on your computer camera app so speaking on video feels natural.

Lock in your registration and setup rules early when booking your next-cycle test:

  • Register at least 3 days early: Book your seat at least 3 days before your preferred test date with a government-issued photo ID in English or French, matching the exact name and email on your applications. Fees are final and non-refundable except for documented health or compassionate emergencies. Applicants approved for participating US or UK Fee Assistance Programs (including AACOMAS, CASPA, ADEA, UCAS bursary, or the AAMC program) can have fees waived or reduced, and there is no extra charge for Duet when a school requires it.
  • Request accommodations at least 4 weeks ahead: Applicants with documented disabilities or medical conditions must submit the Accommodations Request Form and supporting documents at least 4 weeks before their scheduled test date. Approved extra-time letters include a separate practice test link set to your approved timing, and accommodation status remains confidential from programs and raters unless needed to report a rule breach.
  • Confirm your time zone before test day: Test sessions run in either North American Eastern time or Australian Eastern time unless marked otherwise, so check the countdown clock inside your account and test your webcam and microphone ahead of time.

Worked example: Fixing a 1st-quartile response

Consider one of the official sample scenarios published for Casper: your group member, Paul, has stopped contributing to a group assignment because of a medical condition. Question 1 asks how you and your group should handle the situation, and Question 2 asks how, if at all, your response would change if Paul had already contributed a large share before putting his courses on hold. You have 3.5 minutes total for both questions.

A common 1st-quartile approach spends almost the entire 3.5 minutes venting frustration on Question 1, immediately reporting Paul to the professor to protect the group grade without speaking to him privately first, and leaving a rushed single line on Question 2 ('I would keep his name on the paper'). That response misses empathy, skips information-gathering, and starves the individually scored second prompt.

Compare that with a balanced 3.5-minute response written to earn full credit on both prompts. Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented.

Question 1: First, I would reach out to Paul privately with warmth and without pressuring him for medical details, checking on his well-being and confirming whether he has officially paused his coursework. Next, I would meet with our remaining group members to redistribute the unfinished sections fairly so we still meet our deadline without resentment. Before changing any credit or escalating, I would consult the course instructor or syllabus guidelines on medical leaves while respecting Paul's privacy, because the instructor can clarify fair grading options without penalizing someone facing a health crisis.

Question 2: Knowing Paul already completed a substantial share reinforces that his absence comes from illness rather than a lack of effort, so his prior work must be credited fairly. With the group's agreement and the instructor's guidance, I would keep Paul's name on the submission or attach a clear contribution summary reflecting the work he already built, because erasing completed academic work would be unfair while transparent communication with the professor keeps grading equitable for everyone.

Practice question

Official Casper sample word-based prompt (3.5 minutes total for both questions): Think of a time when you had to make a sacrifice in order to accomplish a goal. Question 1: Briefly describe the situation and the sacrifice you made to accomplish the goal. Question 2: Imagine that despite the sacrifice made, you failed to accomplish the goal. How would you have felt in this situation? Explain your reasoning.

See an example answer

Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. Question 1: During my junior year, our campus free-clinic translation team lost its evening coordinator right before flu-shot season. My goal was keeping Spanish-speaking families from losing walk-in hours while also maintaining my biochemistry coursework. To make both work, I stepped back from my intramural soccer team for the semester and gave up my Friday evenings to train 2 new bilingual volunteers until the clinic schedule stabilized. Question 2: If the clinic still had to cut evening hours despite giving up my season and weekends, I would have felt genuinely disappointed and frustrated at first, especially for the patients who relied on late appointments. Still, once that initial sting settled, I would not have regretted making the sacrifice. Stepping up gave the clinic its best shot at staying open and taught me where our scheduling bottleneck actually sat, so I would focus on debriefing with the clinic director to use what we learned when rebuilding hours next term.

It divides the 3.5-minute timer cleanly across both individually scored prompts, grounds Question 1 in a specific real-world trade-off without exaggerating, and answers Question 2 with honest emotion followed by constructive reflection and reasoning rather than hollow perfectionism.

Frequently asked questions

Can you literally fail the Casper test?

No, Casper does not issue a pass or fail grade. Human raters evaluate your responses and send official scores directly to your selected programs, while you receive a quartile ranking showing how your typed section compared with peers in the same admissions cycle.

Can I retake Casper in the same cycle if I score in the 1st quartile?

No, you can take a Casper test type only 1 time per admissions cycle, and low scores do not qualify for a retake. Same-cycle retakes are considered strictly when the proctoring and security team verifies a technical problem that you reported within 1 week of your test date.

Can I appeal my Casper quartile or pay for a rescore?

No, official Terms of Use prohibit applicants from requesting a rescore of any assessment. Starting the exam also confirms you are fit to sit, meaning completed test results stand and cannot be changed afterward because of illness or personal stress.

Does a 1st quartile Casper score carry over if I reapply next year?

No, Casper scores are valid for 1 admissions cycle only and cannot be carried over or rescheduled into a future cycle. If you reapply in a new admissions year, you must register for and complete a brand-new Casper assessment.

When am I allowed to take Casper more than once in the same year?

You only take more than 1 Casper exam in the same cycle when your schools require separate test types, such as applying across different countries, program categories, or required languages like English and French in Canada. Each sitting applies only to its own test category and does not overwrite scores on another test type.

Can typos or bullet points cause a low Casper score?

No, raters are trained to ignore minor spelling mistakes, grammar issues, and jargon, and using bullet points or leaving a final thought unfinished does not hurt you. Scores drop when you run out of time for one of the individually scored questions or state what you would do without explaining why.

Sources