Confetto

CaRMS Emergency Medicine Structured Reference Letter

Practice the residency interview now

Free, no sign-up to start.

The CaRMS Emergency Medicine Structured Reference Letter format, 5 narrative domains, Top 1/3 ranking, CCFP(EM) forms, and referee checklist.

Practice the residency interview now

Free, no sign-up to start.

The CaRMS Emergency Medicine Structured Reference Letter (SRL) is a standardized online questionnaire for the R-1 Main Residency Match that replaces a traditional uploaded letter. Per CaRMS's sample form, referees write specific examples across five narrative domains and rank the applicant in the Top 1/3, Middle 1/3, or Bottom 1/3 against all medical students they have worked with. When you select the structured reference letter option in CaRMS Online, the system automatically assigns the form to your referee's account. Sources: CaRMS: Sample Emergency Medicine Structured Reference Letter (R-1 PDF), CaRMS: R-1 Main Residency Match Reference Guidelines for Referees, CaRMS: R-1 Main Residency Match Applicant Document Types. Last checked November 11, 2026.

What the R-1 Emergency Medicine Structured Reference Letter looks like

Emergency Medicine is one of six disciplines in the R-1 Main Residency Match with a permanent, nationwide structured reference letter built into CaRMS Online, alongside Family Medicine, Orthopedic Surgery, Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Psychiatry, and Pediatrics. Two other R-1 disciplines, Anesthesiology and Dermatology, have national approval for structured reference letters but remain in their introductory period as applicant support forms.

Unlike a traditional letter of reference or an applicant support form that you must send to your writer, the Emergency Medicine SRL is assigned automatically when you pick the structured reference letter option from the drop-down menu in your CaRMS Online account. Your referee completes and submits it directly inside their CaRMS Online referee account.

Online guides frequently confuse the Canadian R-1 Emergency Medicine SRL with United States Standardized Letters of Evaluation (SLOEs) or with Family Medicine and Enhanced Skills match forms. Neither appears on CaRMS's official R-1 Emergency Medicine sample form.

Once your letters are requested and you move toward interview prep, Confetto, an AI mock interviewer for residency and medical school interviews (MMI, traditional, panel), lets you rehearse emergency medicine scenarios and behavioral questions out loud with follow-up questions. Start your free week.

Official R-1 Emergency Medicine Structured Reference Letter breakdown (Source: CaRMS sample form)
Form sectionExact prompt on the CaRMS sample formFormat
Confidentiality of contentHas the candidate viewed this letter or had the opportunity to directly influence the content?Yes / No checkbox
Demographics: RelationshipHow long/well and in what capacity do you know the candidate? (E.g., clinical work, research, other? Number of shifts worked with candidate?)Open text box
Demographics: Frame of referenceFrame of reference (E.g., how many students/residents do you work with? What type of practice do you have?)Open text box
Domain 1: CommitmentCommitment to specialist emergency medicine. Have they thoughtfully considered their career choices?Open narrative box
Domain 2: Work ethicWork ethicOpen narrative box
Domain 3: TeachabilityTeachabilityOpen narrative box
Domain 4: EmpathyEmpathyOpen narrative box
Domain 5: Teamwork and communicationAbility to work as part of a team/communication skillsOpen narrative box
Global assessmentHow does this trainee compare to ALL medical students you have worked with?Top 1/3, Middle 1/3, or Bottom 1/3 checkbox, plus Comments box
Other commentsPlease enter any other comments that you might have about the candidate here (performance, advocacy, leadership, scholarship, strengths or weaknesses not covered above).Open narrative box

The 5 narrative domains and what your referee needs to write

The R-1 Emergency Medicine SRL does not use numerical Likert scales for its core domains. Instead, the form states: "Narrative comments are essential to our assessment of candidate files. Please provide specific examples regarding the candidate in the domains listed below. If you are unable to comment in a specific domain, please note this in the appropriate field."

Because each domain requires concrete observations, a preceptor who only recalls that you were pleasant on shift will struggle to fill five text boxes. When you work with your preceptors and when you supply your reference packet, make sure they have observed you in each area and have specific reminders of your clinical work.

  • Commitment to specialist emergency medicine. The prompt asks: "Have they thoughtfully considered their career choices?" Discuss why you are pursuing five-year FRCPC specialist training, how you have explored the specialty on shift, and your long-term clinical goals.
  • Work ethic. Referees need concrete behaviors to cite. Initiating patient care promptly, reassessing patients before handover, following up on pending lab results, and maintaining stamina during resuscitations give your writer clear material.
  • Teachability. This box captures how you receive and apply feedback. If a preceptor coaches you on case presentation structure or ultrasound technique, demonstrate on your subsequent shifts that you applied that guidance.
  • Empathy. In fast-paced emergency settings, applicants often focus exclusively on procedural tasks. Bedside presence, clear explanations of delays, and compassionate communication with distressed patients and family members provide relevant examples for this domain.
  • Ability to work as part of a team/communication skills. Emergency medicine relies on interprofessional collaboration. Clear handovers and professional communication with triage nurses, respiratory therapists, and consulting services give your referee observable points.
  • Additional comments. The closing text area invites notes on performance, advocacy, leadership, scholarship, and any strengths or weaknesses not covered above. Provide your CV and academic summary so your referee can address off-shift contributions.

How the Demographics and Global Assessment sections work

Selection committees review two demographic fields that establish your referee's clinical context before evaluating the five narrative domains.

The first demographic question asks how long, how well, and in what capacity the referee knows you, including clinical work, research, or other settings, and the specific number of shifts worked together. The second asks for the referee's frame of reference, such as the volume of learners they supervise annually and their practice setting.

Because emergency physicians supervise many students across an academic year, they may not track the exact number of shifts you shared. Tracking your shifts and including the dates, locations, and shift types in your referee packet ensures this section is completed accurately.

The Global Assessment asks: "How does this trainee compare to ALL medical students you have worked with?" The referee must check one of three forced-choice options: Top 1/3, Middle 1/3, or Bottom 1/3, followed by an explanatory Comments field.

The form opens with a mandatory confidentiality question: "Has the candidate viewed this letter or had the opportunity to directly influence the content?" with a Yes or No checkbox. Never ask to review an SRL draft or supply pre-written text. Providing your CV, personal letter, and an objective log of shared shifts is standard practice, not influencing content.

R-1 FRCPC Emergency Medicine vs. CCFP(EM) Enhanced Skills reference forms

Canadian emergency medicine residency training follows two routes: the five-year Royal College (FRCPC) program in the R-1 Main Residency Match, and the one-year Family Medicine / Enhanced Skills (FM/ES) program, known as CCFP(EM), for family medicine graduates.

These matches use different reference forms, evaluation items, and reference groups. CaRMS distributes separate assessment documents: the R-1 Emergency Medicine Structured Reference Letter sample, the general FM/ES Referee Assessment Form sample, and two program-specific Family Medicine / Emergency Medicine forms (an applicant referee assessment and a Program Director's Assessment).

By our count from those four official CaRMS forms, the structure differs substantially across streams: the R-1 Emergency Medicine SRL uses 5 narrative domains and a 3-tier global ranking, the general FM/ES Referee Assessment Form includes 7 objective 5-point ratings, 5 narrative prompts, and a 5-tier global ranking, and the Family Medicine Program Director's Assessment rates 11 clinical and professionalism factors on a 3-point scale.

Comparison of CaRMS Emergency Medicine reference forms across R-1 and FM/ES matches
FeatureR-1 Emergency Medicine SRL (FRCPC)FM/ES Referee Assessment Form (General)Family Medicine - EM Referee AssessmentFM Program Director's Assessment
Match streamR-1 Main Residency MatchFamily Medicine / Enhanced Skills (FM/ES) MatchFamily Medicine / Emergency Medicine (EM) Residency ProgramNational CFPC / Emergency Medicine Program Application
Comparison groupALL medical students you have worked withALL Family Medicine residents that you have worked withOther Family Medicine residents you have knownOngoing Family Medicine training expectations (based on number of ITERs)
Global ranking tiers3 tiers: Top 1/3, Middle 1/3, Bottom 1/35 tiers: Top 5%, Top 10%, Top 25%, Top 50%, Bottom 50%5 statements: Performing far below level expected of an FM resident. Performing below level (but should be considered for an R3 position). Performing at level expected. Upper 25%. Upper 5%Overall prompt: As program director, would you accept this candidate into your program? (Yes, without reservations / Yes / No)
Objective rating itemsNone (narrative domains only)7 factors rated Unacceptable to Excellent: Medical judgment, Organizational skills, Interpersonal skills, Motivation, Insight, Reliability, Maturity7 factors rated Unacceptable to Excellent (plus Unable to Judge): Medical judgment (evaluates data gathering, problem solving, investigation planning, and recognizing limitations), Organizational skills, Interpersonal skills, Insight, Motivation, Reliability, Maturity11 items rated Exceeds, Meets, or Below Expectations: Medical knowledge, Organizational skills, Communication skills, Receptiveness to feedback, Procedural skills, Punctuality, Speed and stamina, Attitude and professionalism, Participation, Team skills/leadership, Self-directed learning
Narrative prompts5 core domains (Commitment to specialist EM, Work ethic, Teachability, Empathy, Teamwork/communication) + Global comments + Other comments5 required boxes (Teachability/work ethic/reliability, Clinical performance, Procedural competence, Teamwork/communication, One area to improve upon) + Global comments + Personal commentsRequires completing the questionnaire in addition to a formal personalized letter of referenceComments on failed/below-expectation rotations, ongoing concerns, disciplinary/legal actions, and any Below Expectations ratings (attach letter if necessary)
Recommendation scaleNone (uses Global Assessment tertile)4 tiers: Recommend without reservation, Recommend, Recommend with some reservation, Would not recommend4 tiers: Recommend without reservation, Recommend, Recommend with some reservation, Would not recommend for EM residency3 tiers: Accept without reservations, Yes, No

Who to ask for your Emergency Medicine reference letters

CaRMS R-1 guidelines define an eligible referee as a physician, professor, or non-clinical individual recommending an applicant for medical training. Individual residency programs set their own requirements regarding the total number of letters and required referee specialties, which are listed in the program descriptions on CaRMS.

For International Medical Graduates (IMGs), CaRMS indicates that references should ideally come from North American clinical settings, though any letter written by a physician or professor is accepted.

For the 2026 R-1 Match, CaRMS implemented specific rules in response to the Quebec Specialist Strike: programs may request at most two reference letters from Quebec applicants (who may submit up to three), programs must accept letters from any physician regardless of specialty, and programs cannot mandate references from the host institution. Furthermore, programs must accept incomplete MSPRs resulting from strike disruptions.

When selecting preceptors, prioritize attending emergency physicians who worked multiple shifts with you, observed your direct patient assessments, and understand your clinical goals well enough to write detailed narrative examples.

How to request and submit the SRL in CaRMS Online

All structured reference letters and FM/ES forms are integrated into CaRMS Online and must be submitted electronically through the referee portal. CaRMS does not accept hardcopy or mailed submissions.

The standard workflow and key procedural exceptions include:

  • Standard R-1 request. In CaRMS Online, create a reference request and select Emergency Medicine structured reference letter from the drop-down menu. Specify whether the request is generic, discipline-specific, or program-specific. CaRMS Online notifies your referee and automatically assigns the electronic SRL to their account.
  • Early reference requests. If an elective finishes while CaRMS Online is closed between cycles, provide your referee with the CaRMS early reference form. The referee emails both the completed early reference form and the reference document to documents@carms.ca. Once CaRMS Online opens, you must create a reference request in your account and email the request ID to documents@carms.ca so the documents team can upload it.
  • IMGs with existing letters. International medical graduates who possess letters from their home country must create a reference request in CaRMS Online and email the document alongside the CaRMS coversheet to documents@carms.ca.
  • Translations. Documents written in languages other than English or French require an official translation. CaRMS UGME rules state that original foreign-language documents should not be submitted.
  • FM/ES 2027 deadlines. For the 2027 Family Medicine / Enhanced Skills Match, CaRMS Online opens for applicants on July 28, 2026 at 12:00 noon ET.

Referee prep packet and shift log checklist (written by our team)

Emergency physicians manage rotating shifts and supervise multiple learners throughout a block. Providing your referee with a concise summary shortly after your last shift together simplifies their completion of the Demographics and narrative boxes.

Use this checklist written by our team to prepare your reference materials:

  • CaRMS submission instructions. Explain that CaRMS Online will email an electronic invitation linking directly to the Emergency Medicine SRL form in their referee account, meaning no separate PDF upload on letterhead is necessary for R-1 FRCPC programs.
  • Shift log with dates and settings. Provide an exact record of the shifts you worked together, including dates, hospital sites, and clinical environments (acute care, resuscitation bays, ambulatory zones, or overnight shifts).
  • Key patient encounters. Briefly summarize two or three complex cases you managed together (without identifying information), noting your differential diagnosis, procedural involvement, or communication with family members.
  • Feedback incorporation. Highlight a specific clinical suggestion the preceptor provided on shift and explain how you implemented it in subsequent encounters, which directly supports the Teachability domain.
  • Updated CV and personal letter. Supply your current CV and personal statement so the referee can reference leadership, scholarly work, and your rationale for choosing emergency medicine.
  • Submission deadlines. State the date you need the form completed in CaRMS Online, along with a polite follow-up timeline two weeks prior.

What happens if a referee uses a traditional reference letter instead?

Show details

Some disciplines and fellowship programs continue to require traditional letters of reference. For instance, Pediatric Emergency Medicine in the Spring Subspecialty Residency Match (SSRM) holds national approval for a structured reference letter, but operates as an applicant support form during its introductory period that applicants must forward to referees.

When an off-service preceptor writes a standard narrative letter, CaRMS guidelines recommend covering eight evaluation areas:

  • A confidentiality statement confirming the applicant has not viewed and will not receive the reference
  • The date the letter was written, alongside the duration and nature of contact
  • Cognitive skills and knowledge base
  • Problem solving and patient management skills
  • Behavior and attitudinal skills
  • Communication skills and working relationships
  • Motivation, punctuality, and sense of responsibility
  • Procedural skills specific to the discipline, as well as unique contributions

Turning your SRL experiences into interview answers

The five narrative domains on the R-1 SRL (specialist commitment, work ethic, teachability, empathy, and teamwork) and the objective criteria on FM/ES forms reflect the core competencies emergency medicine programs evaluate.

When preparing for residency interviews, whether structured as an MMI or a panel interview, build your story bank around the clinical shifts, feedback discussions, and team interactions observed by your referees. Consult our guides on MMI practice questions with answers and how to manage a multi-evaluator panel interview to practice answering under timed conditions.

To practice residency scenarios with realistic follow-up questions and rubric-based feedback, use Confetto. Start your free week.

Practice question

Teachability and teamwork are two core domains on the CaRMS Emergency Medicine Structured Reference Letter. Tell us about a time on an emergency medicine shift when a preceptor or nurse gave you critical feedback, and what you did on your next shift.

See an example answer

Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. "On the second shift of my first emergency medicine elective, I assessed a man in his 50s with epigastric pain. I gathered a thorough history, ordered initial labs with my resident's co-sign, and went to present the case to my attending. Three sentences in, my attending stopped me and told me I was burying the headline. I had started with five minutes of social history instead of stating my top dangerous differentials and what I needed from him right away. He asked me to step back for 60 seconds, reorganize around cardiac and biliary causes, and try again. I took a breath, stated my working diagnosis and ECG plan first, and then filled in the history. Before my next shift with him two days later, I wrote a three-line template at the top of my clipboard: chief complaint and vitals, most likely and most dangerous diagnoses, and my proposed plan. On our next three cases, my presentations took under 90 seconds, and at sign-over he noted how quickly I had adjusted."

It mirrors what preceptors look for in the Teachability domain on the CaRMS SRL: a real piece of clinical feedback accepted without defensiveness, a concrete change in behavior on the very next shift, and an observable result.

Frequently asked questions

How do I request the Emergency Medicine Structured Reference Letter in CaRMS Online?

Log into your CaRMS Online account, open the reference request section, and select Emergency Medicine structured reference letter from the drop-down menu. CaRMS Online automatically delivers the standardized electronic form to your referee's account to complete online.

What are the 5 domains on the CaRMS R-1 Emergency Medicine Structured Reference Letter?

Per CaRMS's sample form, the five narrative domains are Commitment to specialist emergency medicine, Work ethic, Teachability, Empathy, and Ability to work as part of a team/communication skills. Referees must provide specific narrative examples in each field.

How does the Global Assessment ranking work on the Emergency Medicine SRL?

The R-1 Emergency Medicine SRL asks referees: 'How does this trainee compare to ALL medical students you have worked with?' Referees select one of three tiers: Top 1/3, Middle 1/3, or Bottom 1/3, and provide explanatory comments in an adjoining text box.

Does the CCFP(EM) match use the same reference letter as the R-1 Emergency Medicine match?

No. The Family Medicine / Enhanced Skills match uses dedicated assessment forms that rate applicants across seven objective factors like medical judgment and insight, rank residents against other family medicine trainees in percentiles, and require attaching a personalized reference letter.

Can I view my CaRMS Emergency Medicine Structured Reference Letter before it is submitted?

No. The R-1 Emergency Medicine SRL includes a Confidentiality of Content field asking the referee 'Has the candidate viewed this letter or had the opportunity to directly influence the content?' with a Yes or No checkbox, ensuring references remain confidential.

How do I get a CaRMS reference if my elective ends while CaRMS Online is closed?

Provide your referee with a completed CaRMS early reference form. The referee emails the form and reference document to documents@carms.ca. Once CaRMS Online opens, create a reference request and email the request ID to CaRMS so the document can be attached to your account.

Sources