Confetto

Ethical Dilemma in Pediatric Nursing: Examples & Guide

Learn what creates an ethical dilemma in pediatric nursing, review common clinical examples, use a bedside decision checklist, and practice for Casper.

An ethical dilemma in pediatric nursing happens when core bioethical duties like autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence, and justice pull in opposite directions during a child's care. Because pediatric nursing spans from newborn age through young adulthood under a patient- and family-centered model defined by the American Nurses Association (ANA), conflicts often arise between parental authority, a child's developing voice, and clinical recommendations. Nursing admissions teams also test this exact ethical judgment early using the Casper situational judgment test, which over 1 million applicants have completed across more than 600 partner programs according to Acuity Insights. Sources: ANA Pediatric Nursing: Scope and Standards of Practice, 2nd Ed., 2025 Code of Ethics for Nurses | American Nurses Association, ANA Position Statement: Nurses' Professional Responsibility to Promote Ethical Practice Environments (2021). Last checked November 12, 2026.

What creates an ethical dilemma in pediatric nursing

Pediatric nursing focuses on protecting, promoting, and optimizing health and abilities for children from newborn age through young adulthood, according to the ANA Pediatric Nursing: Scope and Standards of Practice (2nd Edition, co-published with the National Association of Pediatric Nurse Practitioners and the Society of Pediatric Nurses). Using a patient- and family-centered care approach, pediatric nurses work to prevent illness and injury, restore health, maximize comfort in health conditions and at the end of life, and advocate for children and families.

Unlike adult care where 1 competent patient usually speaks for themselves, pediatric care operates as a triad: the child, the parents or legal guardians, and the healthcare team. The American Association of Colleges of Nursing (AACN) Ethics Concept notes that nursing behavior is guided by commonly accepted bioethical principles: autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence, and justice. An ethical dilemma surfaces when honoring 1 principle forces you to compromise another.

If you are preparing for nursing school applications, you can practice reasoning through family-centered conflicts like these in our Casper practice scenarios before test day.

  • Autonomy and self-determination: Respecting a patient's right to make choices, which in pediatrics means balancing legal guardian authority with a child's or adolescent's emerging voice and capacity.
  • Beneficence: Acting to promote the child's health, comfort, and well-being.
  • Non-maleficence: Preventing harm, pain, and unnecessary suffering, including avoiding unwarranted or unwanted treatments.
  • Justice: Delivering fair, unbiased care and advocating for access and human rights across all populations, including children with intellectual and developmental disabilities.

Pediatric nursing ethical dilemma examples at the bedside

Across acute care, outpatient clinics, school health, and palliative care, 4 scenarios come up repeatedly in nursing education and practice.

Each pediatric nursing ethical dilemma example below requires the nurse to uphold the fiduciary nurse-patient relationship described in Provision 2 of the ANA Code of Ethics for Nurses. Provision 2 states that the nurse's primary commitment is to the patient, whether an individual, family, group, community, or population.

  • Parental refusal of clinically recommended care: Guardians decline an intervention or medication due to personal, cultural, or spiritual beliefs while the clinical team aims to restore health and prevent harm. AACN Domain 9 (Sub-competency 9.1g) directs nurses to respect patient preferences while seeking guidance from mentors or instructors when self-determination conflicts with clinical recommendations.
  • Adolescent privacy, confidentiality, and reproductive health: An adolescent or minor with developmental needs asks for confidential counseling on sexual behavior, contraception, or pregnancy while a parent objects to sex education or asks the nurse to share private details. Under AACN Sub-competency 9.1f, nurses must safeguard privacy and confidentiality and obtain patient consent before sharing information with family members, in compliance with state laws and institutional protocols.
  • End-of-life care and prolonging suffering: Families and clinicians disagree on transitioning to palliative or hospice care, do-not-resuscitate (DNR) decisions, or continuing aggressive treatments. ANA position statements emphasize the nurse's ethical obligation to relieve pain and suffering, minimize unwarranted or unnecessary medical treatment, and enable the patient to live with as much physical, emotional, social, and spiritual well-being as possible.
  • Self-determination and disability in pediatric care: Caregivers assume a child or young adult with intellectual and developmental disabilities (IDD), which originate before age 18, cannot participate in care choices. The ANA Position Statement on care for people with IDD explains that disability does not automatically mean incapacity, and nurses must assess capacity frequently, prevent diagnostic overshadowing of pain or mental health needs, and encourage supported decision-making.
Common pediatric nursing ethical dilemmas and the principles in tension
Clinical scenarioCompeting ethical dutiesCore nursing obligation (ANA / AACN)
Guardian declines recommended treatmentGuardian surrogate authority vs. beneficence and preventing harmClarify shared understanding, respect cultural values, and escalate to team and ethics resources if patient safety is at risk
Adolescent requests confidential reproductive counselingPatient privacy and self-determination vs. family expectationsSafeguard confidentiality, follow state law and institutional policy, and provide factual, developmentally appropriate education
Disagreement over continuing aggressive end-of-life interventionsFamily hopes for prolongation vs. non-maleficence and comfortAdvocate to relieve pain and minimize unnecessary suffering, collaborate with palliative care, and call a family or ethics consult
Excluding a youth with IDD from care planningProtective surrogate control vs. patient dignity and autonomyAvoid assuming incapacity, use validated nonverbal pain tools when needed, and involve the youth at their developmental level
Show details

Working through pediatric dilemmas requires separating legal authority from ethical inclusion. The ANA IDD Position Statement defines decision-making capacity as the ability to understand and appreciate the nature and consequences of health decisions and to formulate and communicate them. When a patient lacks legal or clinical decision-making capacity, substitute or surrogate decision-makers step in to balance autonomy with protection.

Surrogate decision-making carries real friction. Caregivers experience multidimensional fatigue affecting emotional, social, financial, physical, and spiritual functioning. Surrogate choices also do not always match the patient's own preferences or clinical best interest. Even when parents hold legal consent authority, ethical practice includes pediatric assent. AACN Sub-competency 9.1f calls on nurses to actively involve patients in care decisions so they understand interventions at a developmentally appropriate level.

Nurses also carry strict legal and ethical duties when surrogate actions cross into harm, victimization, abuse, or neglect. The ANA states that nurses must be alert to and take action in all instances of illegal or unethical actions that place a patient's rights or best interests in jeopardy. Nurses must follow mandatory state reporting laws and institutional safety channels without hesitation.

ANA Code of Ethics and AACN standards for resolving conflicts

Show details

Professional standards give pediatric nurses a concrete rulebook so bedside decisions do not rely on personal guesswork. The revised 2025 ANA Code of Ethics for Nurses, shaped by over 6,300 public comment responses from 3,000 individuals, serves as the definitive standard for ethical nursing practice across 10 provisions.

In academic preparation, the AACN Essentials (approved April 6, 2021, and updated April 2026) set explicit observable behaviors under Domain 2 (Person-Centered Care) and Domain 9 (Professionalism). Entry-level and advanced-level nurses are held accountable to demonstrate ethical comportment, comply with relevant laws and regulations, and collaborate across professions to resolve ethical dilemmas.

  • ANA Provisions 1 to 3 (Nurse-to-Patient): Practice with compassion and respect for inherent dignity (Provision 1), keep your primary commitment to the patient (Provision 2), and advocate for patient rights, privacy, health, and safety (Provision 3).
  • ANA Provisions 4 to 6 (Nurse-to-Colleague and Self): Take accountability for optimal care (Provision 4), honor your own dignity, moral point of view, and conscientious objection without ever abandoning a patient (Provision 5), and help build an ethical work environment (Provision 6). Notably, human flourishing is addressed in 6 of the 10 provisions of the 2025 Code.
  • Institutional ethics resources: The ANA Position Statement on Ethical Practice Environments highlights hospital ethics committees, ethics consult services, individual ethicists, chaplains, palliative care consultants, Schwartz rounds, interprofessional family meetings, and shift huddles as reflective moral spaces. Effective ethics resources must meet 4 criteria: they must be knowledgeable, known, available, and sanctioned by leadership.

Bedside action plan and scripts for pediatric ethical conflicts

When you are caught between an upset parent, a frightened child, and a medical order, having a repeatable sequence prevents emotional reactivity. Below is a 5-step bedside checklist written by our team, built on AACN Domain 9 progression indicators and ANA conflict-resolution guidance.

Use calm, neutral words that keep the relationship intact while protecting the child. The short verbal examples inside the steps below are written by our team to show how participatory, solutions-focused communication sounds in real time.

  • Step 1, Check immediate safety and regulatory boundaries: Determine right away if the child faces imminent physical danger, an unreported error, or suspected abuse or neglect. If a statutory reporting rule or immediate life-safety protocol applies, follow institutional policy and notify your supervisor immediately.
  • Step 2, Practice intentional presence and clarify shared meaning: Sit at eye level and listen to both the guardian and the child without interrupting. Example script by our team: 'I can see how much you care about Maya and how overwhelming this plan feels. Can you walk me through your biggest concern about starting this treatment today?'
  • Step 3, Check personal bias and honor the child's voice: Reflect on your own stress or assumptions (AACN 9.1d). Ask developmentally appropriate questions so the child or adolescent can express discomfort, fear, or preferences, and use validated nonverbal pain assessment tools if the child cannot self-report.
  • Step 4, Avoid secret-keeping traps and maintain transparency: If a family asks you to hide information or bypass a protocol, explain your professional role kindly without taking sides against them. Example script by our team: 'I want to respect your family's beliefs, and I also have a duty to answer Leo honestly if he asks me direct questions. Let us talk together with the attending doctor and child life specialist before we go in so we have a plan everyone understands.'
  • Step 5, Escalate to interprofessional and ethics resources: Never carry an ethical dilemma alone. Bring the issue to a shift huddle, mentor, palliative care team, or formal hospital ethics consult service so all stakeholders, including clinicians, chaplains, and family members, can deliberate openly.

Moral distress, moral courage, and nurse resilience

Show details

Caring for seriously ill children when care plans feel misaligned with the child's comfort takes a heavy toll on pediatric nurses. The ANA Position Statement on Ethical Practice Environments notes that moral distress is associated with suboptimal ethical climates and is a major contributor to burnout and leaving the profession.

Clinical units track this burden using validated instruments cited by the ANA. The Measure of Moral Distress for Healthcare Professionals (MMD-HP, updated in 2019 from Corley's 2001 Moral Distress Scale) uses 27 items across acute, outpatient, and long-term care settings to pinpoint unit-level root causes. For real-time tracking, the Moral Distress Thermometer (created in 2013) measures immediate distress and has been used alongside Pediatric Ethics and Communication Excellence (PEACE) rounds in pediatric intensive care units.

Countering moral distress requires both organizational support and moral courage. The AACN Essentials define moral courage as the willingness to act upon ethical values and do the right thing despite adversity and personal risk. To help nurses speak up under pressure, the ANA highlights the CODE mnemonic: Courage to be moral, Obligations to honor, Dangers to manage, and Expression and action. Organizations can pair this framework with peer ethics champion programs and required critical-incident debriefings.

How Casper tests this exact ethical judgment in admissions

Grades and test scores show what you know, which OJIN scholars distinguish as structured education. Moral character and professional identity reflect character formation. In a 2025 Harvard Flourishing Data Collaborative survey of 2,010 university students cited in OJIN (June 2026), students rated 'becoming more honest' lowest among 24 outcomes at the end of a 4-year education. Because nursing's social contract rests on public honesty and ethical comportment, nursing and health professions admissions teams look well beyond GPA.

Hundreds of selective nursing, medical, pharmacy, and allied health programs use Casper, an open-response situational judgment test from Acuity Insights backed by more than 20 years of research and over 150 internal and external studies. Instead of asking you to pick a pre-written multiple-choice option, Casper presents realistic interpersonal and ethical scenarios and records your authentic typed and video answers in your own words.

Multiple independent raters score how you think, reason, and weigh competing perspectives rather than checking whether you guessed a single predetermined outcome. When a Casper prompt involves a vulnerable minor, an overwhelmed parent, or a colleague cutting corners, raters look for the exact habits outlined in AACN Domain 9: gathering missing context, showing empathy without bias, respecting autonomy and confidentiality rules, and collaborating with supervisors or team resources.

Worked Casper scenarios and practice plan

Even when a Casper prompt is set outside a hospital, or places you as a student volunteer or clinic assistant on a pediatric unit, your reasoning structure stays the same. Pause before taking a rigid side, name the competing responsibilities, protect safety first, talk privately and respectfully with the people involved, and use legitimate institutional support.

Consider a second quick scenario written by our team before reading the full worked example below. You are volunteering at a summer camp infirmary when a 15-year-old camper confides that they forgot their asthma rescue inhaler at home. The teen begs you not to call their parents because their family is stressed about money. A strong Casper response prioritizes physical safety first by notifying the camp nurse immediately so emergency medication access is arranged. You then validate the teen's worry about family stress with empathy and explain kindly why health safety cannot be kept secret. Finally, you help the nurse connect the family with low-cost clinic or assistance resources without judgment.

Ready to test your timing on video and typed prompts? Head over to our Casper practice hub to work through full-length open-response scenarios and sharpen your ethical reasoning.

Practice question

You are a nursing student completing a clinical rotation in an outpatient pediatric clinic. Before the nurse practitioner enters the exam room, the mother of a 16-year-old patient pulls you into the hallway and asks you to check her daughter's electronic chart and tell her privately if her daughter tested positive for pregnancy or requested contraception at last month's visit. How do you handle this situation?

See an example answer

Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. I am caught between a mother's understandable concern for her teenager's well-being and my strict ethical and legal duty to protect the 16-year-old patient's privacy, confidentiality, and developing autonomy. First, I would stay calm and decline to access or share any chart details in the hallway. I would acknowledge the mother's worry warmly so she feels heard rather than judged, while clearly explaining my role boundaries as a nursing student and clinic privacy rules regarding adolescent health records. Next, I would immediately inform my clinical preceptor and the nurse practitioner before anyone enters the room so the licensed care team knows about the hallway request. If clinic policy and state confidentiality laws protect the adolescent's reproductive health records, sharing them without the teen's consent would violate both the law and patient trust. When the nurse practitioner meets with the patient privately, the team can check in with the teenager, ask about her comfort and safety at home, and see whether she wants help talking with her mother or prefers to keep her care confidential. That protects the patient's rights while keeping communication respectful.

This response names the 2 competing values immediately, refuses an unauthorized chart disclosure right away, treats the worried parent with empathy instead of hostility, escalates to the clinical preceptor within student scope of practice, and centers the adolescent's consent and safety.

Frequently asked questions

What is an ethical dilemma in pediatric nursing?

An ethical dilemma in pediatric nursing occurs when core bioethical principles like autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence, and justice conflict during the care of a patient from newborn age through young adulthood. Most often, a nurse must balance a legal guardian's decisions, the child's developing self-determination, and clinical duties to prevent harm and relieve suffering.

What are the most common ethical dilemma examples in pediatric nursing?

Common pediatric nursing ethical dilemma examples include parental refusal of clinically recommended treatments, disagreements over end-of-life care and DNR decisions, adolescent requests for confidential reproductive healthcare, and supporting self-determination for youth with intellectual and developmental disabilities.

What should a pediatric nurse do first when a parent refuses recommended care?

First, assess whether the child faces an immediate life-or-safety risk that triggers emergency institutional protocols. Next, listen empathetically to understand the family's cultural or personal concerns, avoid judgment, and seek guidance from mentors, the interdisciplinary care team, or the hospital ethics consult service as directed by AACN professionalism standards.

How do pediatric nurses measure and manage moral distress?

Healthcare teams assess moral distress using tools cited by the ANA, such as the 27-item Measure of Moral Distress for Healthcare Professionals (MMD-HP) and the real-time Moral Distress Thermometer. Nurses mitigate moral distress through ethics education, unit debriefings, palliative and ethics consultations, peer ethics champions, and structured moral courage strategies like the CODE mnemonic.

Does the Casper test ask pediatric nursing ethics questions?

Casper tests social intelligence and professionalism through realistic open-response scenarios using typed and video answers rather than testing clinical medical trivia. You may see scenarios involving minors, family disagreements, privacy boundaries, or authority conflicts where raters evaluate how empathetically and fairly you reason through competing obligations.

Sources