Confetto

Ethical Dilemma Nursing Case Scenario: Bedside & Casper

Study realistic nursing ethical dilemma case scenarios using the 2025 Code of Ethics, bedside scripts, EHR charting examples, and Casper test prep.

An ethical dilemma nursing case scenario happens when competing moral duties clash at the bedside and every clinical option carries a real trade-off. Nurses resolve these conflicts using the 10 provisions of the 2025 Code of Ethics for Nurses published by the American Nurses Association. Nursing admissions committees also test this judgment on the Casper situational judgment test, which presents 11 open-response scenarios in 65 to 85 minutes according to TakeAltus. Sources: 2025 Code of Ethics for Nurses - American Nurses Association, 2025 Code of Ethics Provisions - American Nurses Association, Ethics and Human Rights in Nursing - American Nurses Association. Last checked November 12, 2026.

What Makes a Nursing Case an Ethical Dilemma

A nursing ethical dilemma case scenario involves ethical and value conflicts where valid professional duties point in opposite directions at the same time, so honoring one obligation strains another.

Life and death decisions are part of everyday nursing, making ethics fundamental to professional integrity. Naming which obligations collide is your first step toward a defensible decision on a hospital shift or on nursing situational judgment test scenarios. If you are preparing for nursing school admissions, test your judgment now with timed Casper practice scenarios.

The 2025 Code of Ethics for Nurses: All 10 Provisions

The Code of Ethics for Nurses serves as the definitive standard for ethical nursing practice. When the American Nurses Association revised this edition with a panel of nurses across practice settings, over 6,300 public comment responses were received from 3,000 individuals. Nurses can also study all 10 provisions through the Decoding the Code online series for 10 ANCC CNE Contact Hours.

Provisions 1 to 3 guide nurse-to-patient duties, Provisions 4 to 6 cover accountability and ethical workplaces, and Provisions 7 to 10 address policy, interdisciplinary collaboration, social justice, and global health. Official ANA position statements also guide recurring bedside conflicts. Key statements cover Nursing Care and Do-not-resuscitate Decisions, The Ethical Use of Restraints, Nurses' Roles and Responsibilities in Providing Care and Support at the End of Life, Privacy and Confidentiality, and The Ethical Responsibility to Attend to Pain.

All 10 provisions of the Code of Ethics and bedside application
ProvisionCore Ethical StandardBedside Case Application
Provision 1Practice with compassion and respect for the inherent dignity, worth, and unique attributes of every personHonoring religious refusals and caring for patients without stigma
Provision 2Hold primary commitment to the recipient of care, whether an individual, family, group, or populationCentering the patient's wishes when relatives push a different plan
Provision 3Establish trust and advocate for the rights, health, and safety of care recipientsProtecting privacy, verifying consent, and escalating unsafe conditions
Provision 4Maintain authority, responsibility, and accountability for nursing practice and optimal careRefusing unsafe orders and questioning risky dosing
Provision 5Uphold moral duties to self, including integrity, competence, and a safe workplace that fosters flourishingSpeaking up against workplace violence, fatigue, or unsafe assignments
Provision 6Establish, maintain, and improve the ethical environment of the work settingSupporting Just Culture reporting and stopping unit bullying
Provision 7Advance the profession through knowledge development, standards, and health policyJoining unit evidence-based audits and restraint-reduction updates
Provision 8Build collaborative networks with nurses, other disciplines, and the publicCoordinating care plans with physicians, social work, and chaplains
Provision 9Enact practices, policies, and legislation to promote social justice and eliminate health inequitiesSecuring medical interpreters and fair discharge plans for uninsured patients
Provision 10Participate through nursing organizations in the global community to promote human and environmental flourishingSupporting disaster readiness, infection control, and sustainable supply use

End-to-End Nursing Ethical Dilemma Case Scenarios

Below are four hypothetical clinical scenarios written by our team. All patients, relatives, and clinicians are invented.

Case A: Blood Refusal During Active Bleeding (Human Dignity vs. Optimal Care). Elena is an alert adult admitted with an acute upper gastrointestinal bleed, dropping blood pressure, and rising heart rate. As a Jehovah's Witness, she refuses whole blood, packed red cells, plasma, and platelets even if fatal, while accepting non-blood volume expanders. In the hallway, her husband whispers, 'Wait until she loses consciousness, then hang the blood.' Provision 1 calls on nurses to respect the inherent dignity, worth, and unique attributes of every person, and Provision 2 centers primary commitment on the recipient of care. Confirm the attending physician explains exact mortality risks, verify Elena's signed blood-refusal directive, infuse ordered crystalloids and hemostatic medications promptly, and explain to her husband why Elena's documented decision stands.

Case B: Signed DNR Order vs. Family Demands (Primary Commitment vs. Family Distress). Marcus has end-stage pulmonary fibrosis, arrives unresponsive in acute respiratory failure, and has a documented Do-Not-Resuscitate order and advance directive declining intubation and compressions. His adult daughter shouts at the bedside, 'Put him on the breathing machine right now or I will sue!' Provision 2 establishes primary commitment to the patient, backed by the Do-not-resuscitate Decisions position statement. Maintain comfort oxygen and dyspnea relief, bring the attending physician and palliative care specialist to the room, ask chaplaincy or social work to support her grief, and review Marcus's written goals together in a quiet room.

Case C: Patient Privacy Requests vs. Safety Advocacy (Confidentiality vs. Patient Safety). Clara, a frail older adult admitted for dehydration, has patterned forearm bruises in multiple healing stages and an untreated shoulder burn. She asks you to promise secrecy, fearing her adult caregiver will place her in a nursing home. Provision 3 directs nurses to establish trust and advocate for the rights, health, and safety of care recipients. Never promise secrecy when a patient's safety is in danger. Gently explain your duty to keep her safe, examine her privately, and coordinate immediately with the emergency physician and social worker on a protective care plan.

Case D: Impaired Peer on a Short-Staffed Shift (Patient Safety vs. Peer Loyalty). Halfway through night shift, your former preceptor Sam smells of alcohol, slurs words, and leaves an automated cabinet narcotic waste unverified. Provision 3 and Provision 4 place patient protection and professional accountability above peer loyalty or shift workload. Ask Sam to pause patient care immediately, privately alert the charge nurse and house supervisor so another nurse reconciles medications and assumes Sam's patients, and follow employee health protocols.

Bedside Communication Scripts and EHR Charting Examples

Structured communication steadies tense conversations while protecting ethical boundaries. The dialogue scripts and Electronic Health Record charting excerpts below are hypothetical templates written by our team.

Ask-Tell-Ask Script for Distressed Relatives: First Ask what they understand: 'What has Elena shared with you about her faith and medical care?' Next Tell the clinical and ethical boundary plainly: 'Elena is alert and understands the bleeding risk, and nursing ethics center our primary commitment on honoring her clear choice. We are giving every non-blood fluid and medication she accepts.' Finally Ask how to support them: 'What feels hardest right now, and would you like our physician or chaplain to sit with you both?'

SBAR Escalation Script: Situation: 'Elena in Bed B has an upper GI bleed with falling blood pressure and refuses blood products.' Background: 'She is oriented with a signed blood refusal on file, and her spouse asked staff to transfuse if she loses consciousness.' Assessment: 'Hemodynamics are worsening alongside family conflict.' Recommendation: 'I need you at the bedside now to document capacity and informed refusal, order aggressive non-blood hemostatic care, and update her spouse.'

Defensible EHR Charting Excerpts: Informed Refusal: 'Patient alert and oriented x4. Verbalized refusal of blood products citing religious convictions, consented to IV crystalloids and pharmacologic bleeding control. Attending Dr. Patel explained shock and mortality risks at bedside. Patient restated risks in own words and signed refusal form. Chaplaincy offered to spouse.' Chain-of-Command Escalation: 'Privately notified Charge RN Kim and House Supervisor Taylor of medication reconciliation concern per hospital safety policy. Charge RN assumed patient care and scheduled medications. Internal risk report submitted.' Never write unverified accusations about a coworker in a patient chart.

5-Step Checklist for Bedside Ethical Decisions

Show details

When competing duties collide on a shift, use this five-step checklist written by our team to organize the clinical facts and apply the Code of Ethics for Nurses.

  • Clarify the clinical facts: Gather verified symptoms, lab trends, and current orders first so missing medical details do not look like an ethical deadlock.
  • Center the recipient of care: Under Provision 1 and Provision 2, confirm what the patient values and keep your primary commitment on the care recipient rather than outside pressure.
  • Weigh safety and accountability: Apply Provision 3 and Provision 4 to advocate for patient rights, health, and safety while maintaining accountability for optimal nursing care.
  • Collaborate across disciplines: Under Provision 8, coordinate with nurses and other disciplines such as physicians, social work, palliative care, and chaplaincy, then enter objective, time-stamped documentation.
  • Review the unit workflow: Debrief with unit peers after resolution to evaluate outcomes and update local practice standards under Provision 6 and Provision 7.

Protecting Nurse Well-Being and Ethical Workplaces

Show details

Repeated value conflicts and high-stakes care decisions affect nurse well-being alongside patient safety. Provision 5 affirms moral duties to self, including an expectation of a safe workplace that fosters flourishing, integrity, and competence, while Provision 6 and ANA position statements on Nurses' Professional Responsibility to Promote Ethical Practice Environments, Just Culture, Addressing Nurse Fatigue, and Promoting Nurses' Mental Health guide collective workplace support. Use this debriefing checklist written by our team after difficult cases.

  • Check in after high-stakes shifts: Hold a brief post-event huddle with unit colleagues after traumatic codes or treatment refusals to support team well-being.
  • Evaluate assignment safety: Raise fatigue or unsafe workload concerns early in alignment with Registered Nurses' rights when considering a patient assignment.
  • Flag recurring system barriers: Report unclear Do-Not-Resuscitate documentation or delayed interdisciplinary consults through non-punitive Just Culture channels.
  • Protect personal flourishing: Use peer support and mental health resources so you preserve professional integrity and competence.

How Casper Tests Nursing Ethical Dilemmas in Admissions

Selective nursing programs assess ethical reasoning before clinical rotations using Casper from Acuity Insights, completed by 1M+ applicants across 600+ partner institutions and supported by 20+ years of research and over 150 studies. Certified human raters evaluate collaboration, communication, empathy, ethics, fairness, motivation, problem solving, resilience, and self-awareness based on what you would do and why.

The standard Casper test takes 65 to 85 minutes with 2 optional breaks across 2 sections and 11 scenarios. By our calculation from the official TakeAltus format table, you answer 22 open-ended questions across 32.5 minutes of active response time, averaging 1.75 minutes per typed question.

Worked Casper Scenario (invented by our team): While volunteering at a free blood-pressure clinic, your supervisor asks you to log normal readings for three walk-in clients who left unscreened so the clinic hits its monthly grant target. Question A: How do you respond? Question B: If uninsured neighbors have no other local clinic, does your decision change?

Example Breakdown (written by our team): For Question A, speak with your supervisor privately and respectfully decline to falsify the records. Explain that fabricated blood-pressure readings could endanger returning clients with undiagnosed hypertension and put the clinic's grant at risk. Then offer practical alternatives, such as calling the three clients back for screening or explaining foot-traffic barriers to the grant coordinator. For Question B, express empathy for uninsured neighbors while keeping your ethical boundary firm, offering to work an extra outreach session or help draft a transparent grant extension request.

Casper test format and pacing breakdown
Section FormatScenarios and QuestionsOfficial Time LimitActive Pacing (By Our Calculation)
Video Response Section4 scenarios, 2 open-ended questions per scenario1 minute per response8 video questions across 8 minutes of recording time
Typed Response Section7 scenarios, 2 open-ended questions on the same page3.5 minutes total per scenario14 typed questions across 24.5 minutes (1.75 minutes per question)
Full Standard Assessment11 scenarios across 2 sections with 2 optional breaks65 to 85 minutes total22 open-ended questions across 32.5 minutes of active response time

Checklist to Prepare for Casper Ethical Scenarios

Follow this checklist before test day, and build extra speed with Casper practice scenarios.

  • Register early: Create your Acuity Insights account with government-issued photo ID and book at least 3 days before your preferred test date, or submit accommodations paperwork at least 4 weeks ahead. You may take a Casper test type only once per admissions cycle, and scores apply to a single cycle.
  • Complete timed official practice: Rehearse both 1-minute video responses and 3.5-minute typed pages under real clock limits using the free practice test in your account.
  • Split typed pages evenly: Each prompt on a 3.5-minute page is scored individually, so never spend all your time on the first question.
  • Use bullet points when time runs short: Certified human raters ignore minor spelling or grammar slips and accept bullet points that explain what you would do and why.
  • Gather context before judging: Explore private reasons behind interpersonal conflicts, protect immediate safety, and propose practical next steps.

Practice question

During a hospital clinical rotation, your fellow nursing student Maya confides that she accidentally contaminated a sterile dressing tray in a patient's room when no one was watching, but finished the dressing change anyway because the unit is low on trays and she fears failing the rotation. She asks you not to tell your clinical instructor. What do you do, and why?

See an example answer

Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. My first priority is protecting the patient from a preventable wound infection, so I cannot keep the contaminated dressing secret. I would speak with Maya privately in a quiet hallway right away and acknowledge how stressful it feels to worry about failing a rotation. Calmly and without judgment, I would explain that leaving a non-sterile dressing on an open wound puts the patient's health and safety at direct risk, and hiding a mistake causes far greater harm to trust and her standing than reporting it honestly right away. I would encourage Maya to tell our clinical instructor herself within the next few minutes and offer to walk with her for support so the patient's wound can be assessed and redressed safely. I would also let Maya know plainly that if she chooses not to tell the instructor immediately, I will report what happened myself so the patient receives prompt care. Handling it this way protects the patient first, treats Maya with empathy and transparency, and gives her the chance to take accountability and learn in a supervised clinical setting.

This response puts patient safety first by ensuring the contaminated dressing is replaced promptly, while treating the peer with empathy, giving her a clear chance to self-report with support, and stating a transparent boundary if she refuses.

Frequently asked questions

What is an example of an ethical dilemma nursing case scenario?

A common nursing ethical dilemma case scenario happens when an alert adult refuses a life-saving blood transfusion for religious reasons while distressed relatives beg staff to intervene. Here, the obligation to promote health and provide optimal care under Provision 4 conflicts with respecting the patient's inherent dignity, worth, and unique attributes under Provision 1 of the Code of Ethics for Nurses.

How many provisions are in the 2025 Code of Ethics for Nurses?

The revised Code of Ethics for Nurses contains 10 provisions. Provisions 1 to 3 guide nurse-to-patient care, Provisions 4 to 6 address accountability and ethical workplaces, and Provisions 7 to 10 cover policy, collaboration, social justice, and global health.

How does the Casper test evaluate ethical decision making for nursing school?

Casper is an open-response situational judgment test from Acuity Insights where applicants answer realistic interpersonal and ethical dilemmas in video and typed formats. Certified human raters score how well you weigh multiple perspectives, protect safety and fairness, and explain what you would do and why.

How much time do you get for each ethical scenario on Casper?

On the standard 11-scenario Casper test, you get 1 minute per question across 4 video scenarios (2 questions each) and 3.5 minutes per page across 7 typed scenarios (2 questions per page). Including 2 optional breaks, the assessment takes about 65 to 85 minutes.

Do spelling or grammar mistakes hurt your Casper score on typed scenarios?

No, certified human raters are trained to ignore minor spelling mistakes, grammar slips, and bullet-point formatting. Raters focus on your ethical reasoning, empathy, and motivation within the time limit.

Sources