Confetto

GMC Ethical Scenarios: Cases, Rules & SJT Guide

Practice the med school interview now

Free, no sign-up to start.

Review all 13 GMC ethical scenarios in Professional standards in action, UK consent and privacy rules, the BMA 6-step method, and Casper prep.

Practice the med school interview now

Free, no sign-up to start.

GMC ethical scenarios are 13 fictional front-line clinical case studies published by the UK General Medical Council under Professional standards in action, which replaced Good medical practice in action. They test how doctors, physician associates, and anesthesia associates apply professional standards across confidentiality, consent, prescribing, child safeguarding, and patient safety. You use the same multi-perspective judgment on medical school interviews and situational judgment tests like Casper and the AAMC PREview exam. Sources: GMC: Professional standards in action case studies, BMA: Approaching a medical dilemma as a medical student, BMA: Medical students and the GMC. Last checked November 12, 2026.

What GMC Ethical Scenarios Cover in Professional Standards in Action

Searches for GMC ethical scenarios or Good medical practice in action point to the General Medical Council interactive case hub now called Professional standards in action. As the British Medical Association notes, the GMC's mandate is to protect, promote, and maintain the health and safety of the public by ensuring proper standards in the practice of medicine. Medical royal colleges set clinical treatment guidelines, while the GMC sets ethical and professional rules across 3 distinct regulated professions: doctors, physician associates, and anesthesia associates.

Professional standards in action features 13 fictional front-line case studies under Good medical practice sorted into 5 filters: Confidentiality (6), Decision making and consent (3), Prescribing (2), Children and young people (2), and Concerns about patient safety (1). Prescribing the contraceptive pill to a 15-year-old without parental knowledge appears under both Prescribing and Children and young people. By our count from the GMC Professional standards in action directory, 9 of the 13 front-line case studies test confidentiality (6) or decision making and consent (3), making privacy and autonomy your 2 highest-yield topics.

Every case centers on a clinical moment where medical facts alone do not settle what to do next, such as a stab-wound patient refusing police contact or an unfit driver staying on the road. If you are preparing for situational judgment tests alongside ethics review, read our guide to the Casper test.

The 4 Ethical Pillars and Regulatory Codes Behind Every Case

Every GMC scenario turns on competing duties from biomedical ethics. Clinical reference guidance on Patient.info notes that modern medical ethics rests on the 4 principles introduced in 1979 by Beauchamp and Childress in Principles of Biomedical Ethics. Naming which principles pull in opposite directions turns an unclear clinical story into a structured choice.

Professional codes translate these 4 principles into daily standards in both the UK and the US. The 2024 edition of GMC Good medical practice instructs clinicians to treat each patient as an individual and leave personal prejudice about lifestyle, age, sexuality, ethnicity, religion, or politics at the clinic door, alongside strict duties never to harm or seduce patients. As a multiprofessional regulator, the GMC applies professional standards across doctors, physician associates (PAs), and anesthesia associates (AAs) with dedicated guidance on working with PAs and AAs, provides Ethical hub resources on speaking up and tackling racism in the workplace, and publishes support materials for patients subjected to sexual misconduct. Those workplace and patient-respect standards align with BMA bullying, harassment, and discrimination guidance and AMA Code Opinions 1.1.2 and 1.2.2 prohibiting clinical discrimination and prejudiced or derogatory conduct.

  • Respect for autonomy: Asking what information a patient wants, respecting informed voluntary choices even when medically unwise, and never assuming beliefs based on culture or community.
  • Beneficence: Taking positive steps to advance a patient's welfare through treatment, prevention, and shared decision making.
  • Nonmaleficence: Abstaining from inflicting harm or unjustified risk, judged on what is known at the time, without withholding beneficial care simply because every treatment carries slight risk.
  • Justice: Providing fair, non-judgmental care while balancing public safety and shared health resources.

Side-by-Side Comparison of Core GMC Scenarios

The GMC directory lists short scenario teasers without placing the governing rules and first clinical steps together. The structured list below maps 6 core dilemmas from Professional standards in action to their competing principles, official standards, and immediate actions, while the next 2 sections walk through the remaining 7 front-line cases so all 13 scenarios are covered in full.

  • Patient with a knife wound refuses police contact: Weighs autonomy and privacy against public nonmaleficence under GMC gunshot and knife wounds guidance and the Common Law Duty of Confidentiality. Treat the injury first, check immediate danger to anyone else, and disclose without consent only to prevent, detect, or prosecute serious crime.
  • Patient keeps driving against medical advice: Weighs confidentiality against road-user safety under GMC reporting concerns to the DVLA or DVA guidance. Explain the clinical and legal risk clearly, urge patient self-reporting, and notify the DVLA or DVA directly if they keep driving.
  • Police request a clinic patient list without a court order: Weighs confidentiality against crime investigation under the Data Protection Act 2018, UK GDPR, and the 8 Caldicott Principles. Refuse blanket list access, clarify the specific risk, and share minimum proportionate details only if serious crime or harm justifies it.
  • Patient with HIV has not informed sexual partner: Weighs patient privacy against preventing serious harm under GMC serious communicable diseases guidance. Support the patient to tell their partner voluntarily, assess transmission risk, and weigh direct disclosure if an identifiable person faces serious harm.
  • 15-year-old asks for the contraceptive pill without parents knowing: Weighs minor autonomy against parental involvement under Gillick competency and GMC children and young people guidance. Encourage involving a parent, check for coercion or abuse, assess full understanding and maturity, and prescribe confidentially if competent.
  • Concerns arise over a colleague's underperformance: Weighs collegial support against patient safety under GMC Raising and acting on concerns guidance and AMA Principle II. Put patient safety first, gather objective facts, seek senior or defense advice, and report honestly through local governance channels.

Confidentiality and Public Interest Disclosures in Practice

Confidentiality covers 6 of the 13 GMC scenarios because clinicians regularly face requests to share private data. UK patient records are governed by the Common Law Duty of Confidentiality, the Data Protection Act 2018, UK GDPR, and the 8 Caldicott Principles published by the National Data Guardian in 2020. Privacy is strict but not absolute. You may disclose information with express patient consent, under statute or court order, or when protecting others from serious harm outweighs confidentiality.

Three of the GMC privacy cases test public-safety thresholds directly. When police ask for clinic patient details to assist with an assault inquiry without a court order, handing over a full clinic list breaches data law unless a specific, serious public threat justifies proportionate sharing. When a patient presents with a stab wound and refuses police contact, you treat the injury first and assess ongoing danger before deciding whether serious crime prevention warrants disclosure. The same sequence governs a patient who drives against medical advice or a patient who has not shared an HIV diagnosis with a sexual partner: support the patient to act voluntarily first, and disclose relevant facts without consent only when refusal leaves road users or an identifiable partner at serious risk.

The remaining privacy and safeguarding cases test family boundaries and vulnerable patients. In Listening to concerns from a patient's family member, a relative contacts the doctor worried about a patient's health and safety. You should listen carefully to assess clinical or public risk, but make clear at the start that you cannot guarantee their conversation will be kept from the patient. Before sharing any medical information back with family, obtain the patient's express consent and record even verbal consent in the medical notes.

In Disclosing information about a patient experiencing domestic abuse, you weigh confidentiality against the risk of serious harm to the patient. Speak with the patient privately, check capacity and immediate danger, offer support resources, and seek consent before contacting outside agencies unless grave risk to the patient or others justifies a public interest disclosure. By contrast, in Child safeguarding concerns arising from parental substance misuse, you work to preserve your patient's trust so they stay engaged in care, yet BMA guidance notes that when child protection concerns arise, parents' preferences take second place to the child's safety and interests.

Informed consent applies to prescribing as well as surgery. The 2015 ruling in Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board centered patient autonomy by requiring doctors to consider an individual patient's priorities and adapt risk discussions to their needs rather than reciting every rare complication, while AMA Opinion 2.2.1 directs physicians to assess understanding, explain options including foregoing treatment, and document the choice. In the GMC prescribing scenario Patient asking for alternative medication, shared decision making when a patient requests an unlicensed medicine means exploring the patient's values respectfully, explaining safety and licensing limits alongside evidence-based options, and supporting ongoing care even if an unsafe prescription must be declined.

Capacity cases test whether you separate a medically unwise choice from a lack of capacity. Competent adults may refuse effective or life-saving treatment, a duty also reflected in AMA Opinion 1.1.7. Professional standards in action pairs 2 Alzheimer's cases to show how decision-making changes over time. In Assessing a patient's capacity, a patient with Alzheimer's disease appears to refuse further diagnostic investigation. Never assume incapacity from a diagnosis alone. Check decision-specific understanding in plain language, involve family appropriately without overriding a competent patient, and respect an informed refusal if capacity remains intact. In the companion case, Making decisions when a patient lacks capacity, you support a patient with Alzheimer's disease to think ahead about future care while they still have capacity, using advance care planning to record wishes and involve chosen relatives early.

The final adult consent scenario, Assessing and diagnosing someone who has profound and multiple learning disabilities, follows a non-verbal patient in pain who may lack capacity to consent to examination. Never treat a communication barrier as automatic incapacity or dismiss acute pain because of a disability. When an adult lacks capacity for a decision, GMC guidance sets 3 rules: make the patient's interests your first concern, protect their privacy and dignity, and involve them as far as their abilities allow. You can share necessary facts with family or carers to establish best interests without opening the entire medical record.

Under age 16, UK courts apply Gillick competency, asking whether the young person has sufficient understanding and maturity to understand fully what is proposed. In Prescribing the contraceptive pill to under-16s, a 15-year-old visits the surgery asking for contraception without parental knowledge. Speak with the young person privately, encourage involving a parent without making it mandatory, check for coercion or child safeguarding risks, confirm full understanding of the medicine and sexual health options, and prescribe confidentially if competent. If a young person lacks maturity to decide, someone with parental responsibility must be involved.

Raising Concerns and Student Fitness to Practice

Show details

In A colleague's underperformance, concerns are raised about another clinician's fitness to practice. Whenever a colleague's performance, conduct, or health puts patients at risk, GMC guidance places patient safety first while also expecting appropriate support for the colleague. Gather objective facts, check immediate clinical danger, and submit an honest appraisal to an appropriate person in your employing or contracting organization, seeking advice from an uninvolved colleague, professional body, or medical defense organization if needed. If local channels fail or do not exist, escalate to the GMC or, in the US, the state medical licensing board.

Honesty and openness also govern how clinicians handle clinical mistakes, adverse incidents, and colleague errors. AMA Principle II requires physicians to be honest in all professional interactions and strive to report colleagues deficient in character or competence, or engaging in fraud or deception, to appropriate entities. Patient.info notes that while clinical risks and benefits are judged on what was known at the time rather than hindsight alone, clinicians must keep patient welfare first, communicate openly with patients, and record ethical discussions and advice sought in the clinical notes. When care goes wrong, explaining openly what happened, apologizing, addressing any harm promptly, and reporting through safety channels protects patient trust.

Undergraduate medical students follow a separate system. BMA ethics guidance states that medical students are not registered with the GMC and do not face GMC fitness to practice hearings directly. Medical schools manage student fitness to practice using Promoting excellence, Outcomes for graduates, and joint GMC and Medical Schools Council standards when behavior or unmanaged health issues risk patient harm, disregard clinical responsibilities, exceed student competence, abuse trust, or involve dishonesty.

The BMA 6-Step Checklist and Clinical Script for Dilemmas

In OSCEs, MMIs, and ward shifts, jumping straight to legal threats breaks rapport. The BMA ethics department outlines a 6-step methodology that keeps patient communication ahead of escalation.

Use the checklist below alongside clear, empathetic phrasing. If a patient having blackouts tells you he still drives to work and asks for secrecy, our team wrote this model clinical script: 'I hear how worried you are about getting to work and paying bills, and I want to help with that practically. Because another blackout at the wheel could seriously hurt you or someone else, medical rules mean you must stop driving now and the DVLA has to be told. It is best if you notify them yourself, so let us review how to contact them today and look into fit notes or transport support while we run tests. If you keep driving without telling them, my duty to public safety means I would have to inform the DVLA directly after letting you know first.'

  • Step 1, Recognize the ethical dilemma: Secure urgent medical care first, then spot where moral duties conflict beyond pure clinical facts.
  • Step 2, Break the problem into core parts: Strip out minor details, define the exact question, and identify competing principles.
  • Step 3, Seek missing facts and the patient's view: Talk privately to check fears, maturity, or capacity, seeking the patient's views even if capacity seems impaired.
  • Step 4, Check law and professional guidance: Apply GMC rules, BMA toolkits, the AMA Code, and statutes.
  • Step 5, Analyze harms and consult support: Weigh competing duties and consult senior clinicians, a clinical ethics committee, or a defense body when unsure.
  • Step 6, Justify and document the decision: Act reasonably under time pressure and record patient talks, colleague advice, and guidance consulted in the medical notes.

How GMC Scenarios Prepare You for Casper and SJTs

Show details

Admissions situational judgment tests evaluate the same non-academic judgment practiced in GMC scenarios across open-response exams like Casper and rating exams like the AAMC PREview Professional Readiness Exam. Administered from April through October in 2026 across 75% non-healthcare and 25% healthcare scenarios, the AAMC PREview exam groups these core readiness competencies into personal accountability, including ethical responsibility and reliability, and relational skills, including empathy, compassion, and collaboration.

Casper prompts test those exact judgment skills directly because you construct your own reasoning instead of rating pre-written choices. Just like a GMC front-line case, strong Casper responses resist taking a quick, single-sided stance and show how you weigh competing obligations for every person affected. Begin by ruling out acute harm, then explain what missing context you would gather in a private, non-judgmental conversation before assuming fault. Use conditional if-then reasoning to show how your next step adapts, such as helping someone resolve an issue voluntarily when safe versus escalating if another person faces serious harm.

Whether a prompt takes place in a clinic, a research lab, or a workplace team, applying the GMC and BMA sequence keeps your response grounded under clock pressure: protect immediate safety, listen empathetically to each viewpoint, check governing rules, offer practical support to reduce harm, and escalate proportionately only when needed. Put this structure to work under timed conditions in our Casper practice hub.

Practice question

You are a resident doctor in an emergency department. A 22-year-old man arrives alone with a deep forearm stab wound. While you suture the injury, he is alert and oriented, tells you the fight is over, and begs you not to call the police because he fears retaliation. How do you handle this situation?

See an example answer

Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. My first priority is stabilizing and treating his wound thoroughly while making sure he feels safe and cared for, because clinical care never depends on whether a patient agrees to speak with police. Once acute medical danger is ruled out, I would speak with him privately and calmly to understand what happened, asking open, non-judgmental questions to check whether the attacker is nearby, whether a weapon is still in play, and whether he or anyone else remains in immediate danger. I would explain clearly that patient confidentiality is a strict duty, so I will not automatically share his identity if nobody else is at risk, while also explaining GMC knife-wound rules that require alerting police without consent if serious crime prevention or public safety demands it. If there is an ongoing threat to others or hospital staff, I would consult a senior clinician, inform the patient before disclosing minimum necessary details to police, and document my clinical care, risk assessment, and ethical reasoning in his medical notes.

This answer applies GMC gunshot and knife wounds guidance alongside the BMA 6-step method. It secures emergency medical care first, gathers risk context privately without judgment, respects confidentiality unless public danger or serious crime prevention outweighs privacy, consults a senior colleague before proportionate disclosure, and documents the reasoning.

Frequently asked questions

What are GMC ethical scenarios?

GMC ethical scenarios are 13 fictional front-line case studies on the General Medical Council's Professional standards in action hub, which replaced Good medical practice in action. They help doctors, physician associates, and anesthesia associates apply professional standards to confidentiality, consent, capacity, prescribing, safeguarding, and patient safety.

When can a doctor breach confidentiality under GMC guidance?

Clinicians may disclose confidential data with express patient consent, under statute or court order, or when protecting others and the wider public good outweighs privacy. Specific public interest cases include gunshot and knife wounds, unfit drivers who keep driving, serious communicable diseases, and child protection.

What is the BMA 6-step approach to a medical dilemma?

The BMA methodology follows 6 steps: recognize the ethical conflict, break it into core questions and principles, gather facts including the patient's viewpoint, check relevant law and guidance, weigh harms and consult colleagues or a clinical ethics committee if needed, and justify and document the decision in the notes.

How did Montgomery v Lanarkshire change informed consent?

The 2015 Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board ruling centered patient autonomy across all interventions, including prescribing. Clinicians must consider each patient's individual priorities and adapt explanations of significant risks and alternatives to their needs.

Do medical students face GMC fitness to practice hearings?

No, BMA guidance notes that undergraduate medical students are not registered with the GMC and do not undergo GMC fitness to practice proceedings directly. Individual medical schools manage student fitness to practice using joint GMC and Medical Schools Council standards.

Sources