Dos and Don'ts for Conducting GME Interviews
Free, no sign-up to start.
AAMC and NRMP guidelines for conducting GME interviews: structured questions, rubrics, prohibited topics, virtual rules, and post-interview conduct.
Free, no sign-up to start.
When conducting graduate medical education (GME) interviews, the Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) recommends evaluating 3 to 5 core competencies using structured behavioral or situational questions and behaviorally anchored rating scales of 3 to 7 points. Interviewers must ask every applicant the same job-relevant questions, document factual statements rather than subjective opinions, and strictly avoid prohibited topics such as marital status, family planning, age, religion, or disabilities. Under National Resident Matching Program (NRMP) rules, neither programs nor candidates may solicit or disclose ranking intentions during or after the interview. Sources: AAMC: Interview Resources for Residency Programs, AAMC: Best Practices for Creating and Conducting Interviews (Residency), AAMC: Conducting Effective Structured Residency and Fellowship Selection Interviews. Last checked November 11, 2026.
On this page
- Quick-reference dos and don'ts for GME interviewers
- Why GME programs rely on structured interviews
- Pre-interview setup: competencies, rubrics, and scheduling
- In the room: questioning techniques, STAR probes, and body language
- Prohibited questions and legal boundaries
- Handling prohibited inquiries and applicant reporting
- Virtual, hybrid, and in-person interview operational rules
- Scoring, rating errors, and NRMP post-interview compliance
- Structured GME interview prompt and model response
- Practice question
- Frequently asked questions
- Sources
Quick-reference dos and don'ts for GME interviewers
Residency and fellowship selection interviews work best when every candidate faces the same questions and the same scoring rules. According to the AAMC, unstructured interviews show poor inter-rater reliability, fail to correlate with Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) milestone ratings, and increase the risk of illegal inquiries.
If you are an applicant reviewing this guide to understand how faculty evaluate candidates, Confetto lets you practice structured residency behavioral and situational questions out loud with rubric-based feedback. Start your free week.
Here are the core rules from the AAMC structured interview guidance, organized by interview stage.
| Stage | Do | Don't |
|---|---|---|
| Before the interview | Select 3 to 5 competencies to evaluate. Train a pilot group of 3 to 5 interviewers on the rubric, then train all interviewers. Keep tech support and the applicant's phone number on hand. | Do not evaluate pure medical knowledge that is better measured by exams or transcripts. Do not leave applicants guessing about interviewer names, formats, or links. |
| Questioning | Ask predefined behavioral or situational questions tied to the specialty and program mission. Use STAR probes (Situation, Task, Action, Result) to gather complete examples. | Do not ask judgmental, why, leading, or simple yes/no questions. Do not over-probe in a manner that reveals the desired answer. |
| Prohibited topics | Keep inquiries strictly focused on professional competencies, past experiences, and alignment with program goals and values. | Do not ask about age, race, religion, sexual orientation, marital status, children, pregnancy, disabilities, accommodations, arrests, drug use, or military discharge. |
| In-room conduct | Spend more time listening than talking. Smile and nod occasionally. If an applicant wanders off track, say 'OK' briefly and guide them back to the original question. | Do not frown, raise an eyebrow, or use a harsh tone. Do not give live performance feedback such as saying 'Good' or 'Great' during the interview. |
| Note-taking | Document objective, factual keywords and phrases from the applicant's statements to justify your rubric rating. Take notes at a consistent pace for every candidate. | Do not record personal opinions, subjective inferences, or protected demographic details. Do not attempt verbatim transcription. |
| Scoring | Score one dimension at a time against a 3- to 7-point behaviorally anchored scale. In hybrid setups, blind final selection committees to who interviewed online versus in person. | Do not judge webcam backgrounds, tech drops, physical appearance, or personal 'chemistry.' Do not compare candidates against each other while scoring. |
| After the interview | Limit post-interview communication to answering objective applicant questions about the program. Offer an anonymous survey after the Match cycle closes. | Do not solicit ranking intentions or make ranking promises that violate the NRMP Match Code of Conduct. |
Why GME programs rely on structured interviews
The AAMC defines residency selection through two dimensions from organizational psychology: applicant-program fit (person-organization fit) and applicant-specialty fit (person-job fit). Applicant-program fit addresses how an applicant's attitudes, work styles, and goals line up with your program's mission, culture, and learning resources. Applicant-specialty fit addresses the knowledge, skills, and attributes required to succeed in that specialty.
How you conduct your interviews determines whether you actually evaluate either dimension. In a 2022 systematic review cited by the AAMC (Lin et al.), unstructured interviews showed lower validity and were vulnerable to bias based on age, gender, and academic metrics. In contrast, structured interviews had higher validity and were preferred by applicants. A multi-institutional study (Marcus-Blank et al., 2019) also showed that structured interview scores predicted first-year residents' end-of-year performance in professional competency, patient care, and communication skills.
Faculty sometimes worry that using a structured guide will harm conversational flow. In one residency program where 12 faculty members initially doubted structured interviewing for that reason, all 12 faculty members found the structured system easy to use and score after implementation. They noted that asking about past behaviors yielded critical details an unstructured chat would have missed, and applicants did not view the format as harder or less interactive.
Research evaluating 15 structural choices across interview design and evaluation (adapted from Campion et al., 1997 and Levashina et al., 2014) shows that only two choices improve reliability, validity, fairness, and applicant reactions at the same time: asking questions that are professionally relevant or specialty-specific, and training your interviewers. By our count from the AAMC structural components data, other measures like using defined rating scales and asking all candidates questions on the same topics improve fairness and validity without hurting applicant experience, while rigid steps like banning applicant questions harm rapport.
Pre-interview setup: competencies, rubrics, and scheduling
Preparation begins well before interview day. The AAMC recommends selecting 3 to 5 competencies to evaluate across your interviews. These should reflect attributes an incoming PGY-1 resident needs on day one, not specialized skills taught during residency. Technical medical knowledge should be excluded from the interview room, as transcripts, clinical evaluations, and licensure exams measure it more reliably.
In the AAMC Sample Structured Interview Guide, a program conducting 3 interviews (Interviews A, B, and C) targets 5 ACGME competencies while omitting Medical Knowledge: Patient Care and Procedural Skills, Practice-based Learning and Improvement, and Systems-based Practice are evaluated in all 3 interviews. Professionalism is evaluated in Interviews A and B, and Interpersonal and Communication Skills is evaluated in Interview C.
To build the evaluation framework, follow the AAMC structured development and scheduling steps:
- Do establish a 3- to 7-point behaviorally anchored rating scale for each competency, with concrete behavioral examples defining low, middle, and high performance for an incoming first-year resident.
- Do invite individuals who interact with medical students to review draft questions, anticipate applicant responses, and verify cultural appropriateness.
- Do pilot the interview guide with 3 to 5 trained interviewers before training the entire faculty interviewer pool on the questions, scoring rubric, and unconscious bias mitigation.
- Do send every candidate an identical advance packet covering the Who, What, Where, When, and How: interviewer names and titles, pre-interview software setup, interview format, videoconference links, time zones, and preparation guidelines.
- Do give applicants adequate time to respond to interview invitations. For example, the Association of Program Directors in Vascular Surgery (APDVS) recommended for the 2025/26 cycle a universal release date of October 30, 2025, and at least 96 hours for applicants to accept or decline before releasing the slot to another candidate.
- Don't offer more interview invitations than available interview spots. As the APDVS notes, overbooking damages the integrity of the process and leads to cancellations.
- Don't enter an interview session without backup tech support contacts and the applicant's direct phone number ready in case of connection failure.
In the room: questioning techniques, STAR probes, and body language
Begin each session with a clear opening script. In the AAMC sample script, the interviewer introduces their name and role, states the interview duration, and explains that the candidate should answer with one specific story detailing the situation or task, their personal actions, and the outcome. If an applicant discusses a team effort, instruct them to specify their individual contribution. Let them know both parties may take notes, invite them to request question repetition if needed, and reserve time for their questions at the end.
Structured interviews use two primary question formats: behavioral questions (asking what a candidate did in a past situation, based on the principle that past behavior predicts future performance) and situational questions (asking how a candidate would handle a hypothetical scenario, based on the principle that intentions predict future behavior). In situational prompts, the scenario is already given, so candidate answers center on Action and Result.
When using situational or behavioral interview questions, apply these recommended practices during questioning and response evaluation:
- Do probe neutrally to complete the STAR framework. For behavioral questions, probe what factors led up to the event, what the candidate identified as the core issue, what they did first, the measurable result, and what they would do differently. For situational questions, probe what they would say first, what variables would alter their course, how the action would be received, and how they would handle negative feedback.
- Do request neutral clarification and context without leading the applicant. Useful prompts include 'Could you elaborate on the actions you took in that situation?' or 'What were the specific difficulties you faced during that time?'
- Do refocus wandering candidates politely. Acknowledge their statement briefly with a neutral word like 'OK' and firmly return to the original prompt.
- Do maintain supportive, neutral nonverbal behavior. Smile and nod occasionally, and spend more time listening than speaking.
- Do take factual, concise notes documenting the applicant's specific actions and statements to support rubric scoring.
- Don't give real-time verbal performance feedback such as saying 'Good' or 'Great' after an answer.
- Don't ask leading, judgmental, why, or simple yes/no questions. Asking 'Why did you do that?' creates defensiveness, while leading questions prompt artificial answers.
- Don't use negative body language such as frowning, raising eyebrows, or adopting a harsh tone of voice.
Prohibited questions and legal boundaries
Federal employment regulations, institutional policies, and NRMP rules strictly prohibit discriminatory inquiries during GME interviews. The AAMC emphasizes that assessing an applicant's ability to handle stress never justifies asking inappropriate or illegal questions.
Interviewers must never introduce these categories and questions:
- Demographics and identity: Do not ask 'How old are you?' or inquire about race, ethnicity, religion, sexual orientation, native language, or ancestry.
- Family and pregnancy: Do not inquire about marital status, and never ask 'Do you have or are you planning on having children during residency?' or 'What are your plans for expanding your family during residency?'
- Disabilities and health: Do not ask 'Do you have any disabilities?', 'Will you require special accommodations?', or 'Have you ever done drugs?'
- Legal, military, and financial history: Do not ask 'Have you ever been arrested?', nor ask about criminal convictions, military discharge terms, income, home value, or credit scores.
- Political and personal beliefs: Do not ask about political affiliation or personal opinions regarding abortion or euthanasia.
- Patient and colleague privacy: When probing clinical experiences, instruct applicants to avoid identifying details for patients or colleagues portrayed unfavorably. The AAMC advises using phrases like 'Without naming names' and referring to individuals as 'the patient' or 'a colleague.'
Handling prohibited inquiries and applicant reporting
Show details
Ensure that all your faculty and resident interviewers understand applicant rights, because the AAMC provides clear instructions to candidates on how to address and report inappropriate inquiries.
Under the AAMC Your Interview Rights and Responsibilities guide, applicants have the right not to answer inappropriate questions. Candidates may respectfully decline by stating they were advised not to answer questions they perceive as inappropriate, or redirect with a neutral clarification such as, 'Can you please clarify your question? I want to make sure that I am providing information that is most relevant to my candidacy,' or, 'I am uncomfortable discussing my medical history and possible use of prescription medication.'
Applicants are also instructed to report inappropriate questions to prevent future occurrences. If a program does not provide a formal reporting mechanism in advance, the AAMC advises candidates to report the interviewer's name and exact question confidentially to the program director or Designated Institutional Official (DIO) on interview day, or email program staff within 24 hours noting the date and time. Candidates also hold the right to request an alternative interview to ensure fair evaluation.
Virtual, hybrid, and in-person interview operational rules
In guidance updated in June 2024 (Interviews in GME: Where Do We Go From Here?), the AAMC continues to recommend that residency and fellowship programs use virtual interview formats. Five primary reasons support this policy: first, in-person travel costs applicants hundreds to thousands of dollars, creating barriers for learners from lower socioeconomic backgrounds. second, early 2023 AAMC focus groups and surveys showed that most residency applicants prefer virtual interviews due to financial savings and the reduced stress of interviewing from a familiar space. third, travel disrupts clinical rotations. A survey of plastic surgery applicants (Susarla et al., 2017) cited by the AAMC showed that over 70% missed 7 or more days of medical school for in-person interviews. fourth, separating assessment from recruitment reduces rating bias. fifth, reducing travel supports sustainability, as the US health care sector generates 8% to 10% of national greenhouse gas emissions.
When conducting virtual, hybrid, or in-person interviews, follow these operational guidelines:
- Do blind final decision-makers in hybrid formats. If your program offers a choice between virtual and in-person interviews, the selection committee members finalizing the rank order list must be unaware of which format each applicant selected. Note that the APDVS does not endorse hybrid interviews and requires programs using them to disclose whether the in-person option influences ranking.
- Do disregard webcam backgrounds and technical disruptions. Do not evaluate an applicant based on their visible home environment, as resources vary. If internet connections fail, switch to a phone interview without penalizing the candidate's score.
- Do optimize faculty technical environments. Check connection speeds on SpeedTest.net, use wired ethernet connections when possible, ensure proper lighting, and conduct practice trial calls before the season begins.
- Do separate recruitment from evaluative assessment. Host informal resident-only virtual social hours without faculty, use breakout rooms, and provide anonymous question channels so applicants can discuss program culture openly.
- Do use digital media to showcase the program. URiM applicants place particular importance on an institution's social media presence when assessing programs (Strumpf et al., 2023). Share videos of attendings teaching, resident conference presentations, social gatherings, and city tours.
- Do evaluate voluntary ranking safeguards for post-interview visits. As noted in APDVS guidance, programs in Internal Medicine, Pediatrics, and Vascular Surgery conducting virtual interviews can participate in the NRMP Voluntary Program Rank Order List Lock (ROL-LOCK) pilot before hosting optional in-person visits.
Scoring, rating errors, and NRMP post-interview compliance
Turning interview notes into candidate scores requires strict objectivity. The AAMC recommends evaluating applicants holistically across experiences, attributes, competencies, and academic metrics (EACMs). In vascular surgery, the APDVS recommends de-emphasizing pass/fail USMLE Step 1 and COMLEX Level 1 scores, while being transparent about how Step 2 and COMLEX Level 2 results are evaluated.
Train your interviewers to avoid common cognitive rating errors and comply with NRMP post-interview rules:
- Don't allow the Halo or Horns effect. A strong answer in communication must not artificially inflate a candidate's score in practice-based learning, nor should one weak answer depress unrelated dimensions. Score each competency independently.
- Don't succumb to Central tendency or Leniency/Severity errors. Use the complete 3- to 7-point scale, anchoring scores to the behavioral definitions on the rubric rather than bunching scores in the middle or giving uniformly high or low marks.
- Don't compare applicants against each other during the session (Contrast effect). Evaluate each candidate solely against the established rubric anchors.
- Don't infer missing facts or evaluate subjective personal attributes like physical appearance or perceived 'chemistry.'
- Don't solicit ranking intentions or make binding commitments. Under the NRMP Match Code of Conduct, programs and applicants may express interest, but neither may solicit how the other intends to rank them. The AAMC advises limiting post-interview contact strictly to answering objective applicant questions.
- Do invite candidate feedback safely. Distribute an anonymous online survey after the Match closes so applicants can share feedback on the interview experience without concern regarding their rank standing.
Structured GME interview prompt and model response
Show details
To illustrate how an AAMC-aligned structured interview unfolds, review the target competency, sample STAR follow-up probes, and our team's model response in the practice block below.
Residency candidates preparing for upcoming interviews can practice similar behavioral and situational stations out loud on Confetto and receive rubric-based scoring. Start your free week.
- Target competency: Professionalism (evaluating commitment to professional responsibilities, ethical principles, and sensitivity to diverse populations).
- Scenario focus: A co-resident inadvertently administers a higher medication dose than intended to a young patient, with no substantial health harm anticipated.
- Interviewer STAR probes: What do you consider the most critical issue in this situation? (Situation/Task), What would you say and what is the first thing you would do? (Action), and How do you think your action would be received and what would you do if your action was not received well? (Results).
Practice question
Imagine that you are part of a medical team caring for a young patient. You learn that one of your fellow residents inadvertently provided a higher dose of a medication than intended to the patient. It will not have any substantial health consequences. What would you do in this situation? (Official situational question from the AAMC Sample Structured Interview Guide)
See an example answer
Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. "My first step is making sure the patient is safe. Even if no harm is expected, I would go check on the patient, review their vital signs, and verify the exact dose given in the chart. Once I know the patient is stable, I would pull my co-resident aside for a private conversation. I would say, 'I noticed the dose in the chart was higher than ordered. The patient is doing fine right now, but we need to let our attending know together so we can monitor them properly.' If they hesitate or worry about getting into trouble, I would reassure them that mistakes happen, but keeping quiet puts the patient at risk and damages trust. I would offer to walk with them to talk to the attending right then. If they still refused to report it, I would tell them plainly that patient safety comes first and I have to let the attending know myself. Once our attending is aware, we would follow hospital safety reporting steps and be completely honest with the patient and their family."
This answer addresses the AAMC STAR criteria for situational questions without requiring additional interviewer prompts. It clearly defines the core ethical and clinical considerations (Situation/Task), outlines specific immediate actions including patient assessment and private peer communication (Action), and anticipates peer reactions while detailing escalation steps and transparent disclosure (Result).
Frequently asked questions
What questions are prohibited in a GME residency interview?
According to the AAMC, interviewers must not ask about demographics (age, race, religion, sexual orientation), family status (marital status, pregnancy, plans for children during residency), personal health (disabilities, accommodations, drug use), or legal history (arrests, criminal convictions, military discharge). Inquiries regarding political affiliation or personal opinions on abortion and euthanasia are also prohibited.
How many competencies should a residency program evaluate during an interview?
The AAMC recommends selecting 3 to 5 competencies to evaluate across residency selection interviews. These competencies should reflect skills required at the start of PGY-1 training, while medical knowledge is better evaluated through examinations and medical school transcripts.
Why does the AAMC recommend virtual interviews for GME programs?
In its June 2024 guidance, the AAMC recommends virtual interviews because travel costs applicants hundreds to thousands of dollars, removes fourth-year medical students from core clinical rotations, and produces substantial carbon emissions. Surveys and focus groups also demonstrate that most applicants favor virtual interviews for convenience and lower stress.
How can programs prevent bias if they conduct hybrid residency interviews?
The AAMC states that if an applicant chooses between virtual and in-person interviews, the committee members making final ranking decisions must remain blinded to which interview format was used. Programs must also use identical structured questions and scoring rubrics across all formats.
What are the NRMP rules on post-interview communication?
Under the NRMP Match Codes of Conduct cited by the AAMC, applicants and programs may express mutual interest, but neither party may solicit ranking intentions or make binding ranking promises. Research cited by the AAMC supports limiting post-interview contact strictly to answering objective questions about the program.
Sources
- AAMC: Interview Resources for Residency Programs
- AAMC: Best Practices for Creating and Conducting Interviews (Residency)
- AAMC: Conducting Effective Structured Residency and Fellowship Selection Interviews
- AAMC: Developing Structured Residency and Fellowship Interviews
- AAMC: Conveying Your Program and Culture in a Virtual Context
- AAMC: Interviews in GME: Where Do We Go From Here? (June 2024)
- AAMC: Your Interview Rights & Responsibilities
- APDVS: Guidance Statement Regarding the 2025/26 Application Cycle
- NRMP: Voluntary Program Rank Order List Lock (ROL-LOCK) Pilot