Medical Ethics to Know for Casper: Principles & Examples

Try a free Casper practice scenario

Free, no sign-up to start.

Learn the medical ethics to know for Casper, how core pillars and AMA principles apply to non-clinical scenarios, and how human raters score your answers.

Try a free Casper practice scenario

Free, no sign-up to start.

You do not need to memorize medical law or bioethics jargon for Casper. Acuity Insights designs the open-response exam to measure 10 soft skills tied to social intelligence and professionalism rather than textbook recall. Studying core ethical pillars and the nine American Medical Association Principles of Medical Ethics helps you explain thoughtful judgments to human raters. Sources: Acuity Insights: Casper Admissions Overview, Acuity Insights: Casper Implementation Guide, Acuity Insights: Understanding How Casper Tests Are Rated. Last checked November 12, 2026.

How Casper tests ethics through soft skills

Casper is an online, open-response situational judgment test used by more than 600 partner institutions worldwide. The exam complements grades and academic tests rather than repeating them. Instead of asking multiple-choice questions about hospital statutes or philosophical theories, Casper presents video and word-based scenarios followed by open-ended questions requiring timed typed and video responses.

In its implementation overview, Acuity Insights notes that Casper prompts applicants to respond to real-world and professional dilemmas across 10 soft skills tied to social intelligence and professionalism, highlighting communication, collaboration, empathy, resilience, and teamwork alongside thoughtfulness and judgment in its rating criteria. Those qualities mirror the 17 premed competencies published by the Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) for entering medical students, which group professional readiness into relational skills (collaboration, empathy, interpersonal skills, and compassion) and personal accountability (ethical responsibility, reliability, resilience, adaptability, and continuous self-improvement). Raters look at what you would actually do in a realistic conflict and why, not what you think a textbook answer sounds like.

Because Casper measures authentic reasoning, two common prep habits actively hurt applicants. The first mistake is ethical buzzword dropping, where test-takers force academic words like deontology, utilitarianism, or non-maleficence into a response without addressing the feelings or practical needs of the people in the prompt. The second mistake is cold legalism, where an applicant quotes rigid rules and punishes a mistake immediately without asking a single private question first. You score well by putting ethical principles into plain, empathetic action.

The four pillars of biomedical ethics and the nine AMA principles

Start your preparation with four classic biomedical pillars: autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence, and justice. Those four pillars align closely with the American Medical Association (AMA) Code of Medical Ethics, which began in May 1847 as the first national ethics code for physicians and includes nine Principles of Medical Ethics (adopted in June 1957, revised in June 1980, and revised in June 2001). Understanding both frameworks side by side helps you spot what is at stake in any dilemma without sounding rehearsed.

Each principle is what ethicists call a prima facie duty, meaning it holds true on its face until it collides with an equal or stronger duty in a specific situation. Easy questions do not appear on situational judgment tests. Casper prompts deliberately pit two good values against each other, such as respecting a friend's autonomy versus preventing harm to a group, so raters can watch how you weigh trade-offs.

  • Autonomy: Respecting an informed person's right to make choices about their own body and life, aligned with AMA Principle I (respect for human dignity and rights) and Principle IV (respecting patient rights and privacy). In everyday Casper scenarios, this means giving a teammate, roommate, or customer honest information so they can make their own informed choice instead of deciding behind their back.
  • Beneficence: Acting for the benefit of the other person and placing patient welfare first, aligned with Principle VIII (regarding responsibility to the patient as paramount) and Principle VII (bettering public health). In everyday scenarios, this looks like checking in privately on a struggling peer, connecting them with practical support, and looking for a solution that helps everyone succeed.
  • Non-maleficence: Avoiding preventable physical, emotional, or reputational harm, aligned with Principle I (competent, compassionate care) and Principle II (reporting incompetence, fraud, or deception). In everyday scenarios, this means stepping in calmly when someone's behavior puts safety at risk and refusing to publicly shame or accuse someone before knowing the facts.
  • Justice: Distributing limited time, funds, or care fairly through clear rules (procedural justice) and equitable need (distributive justice), aligned with Principle IX (supporting access to care for all people). In everyday scenarios, this means splitting a scarce club budget, shift schedule, or extension policy using transparent, consistent criteria rather than favoring a close friend.

Applying medical ethics to everyday, non-clinical prompts

Do not prepare only for dramatic hospital dilemmas like organ allocation or end-of-life care, because test day will also give you retail scheduling disputes and group project conflicts. Situational judgment tests intentionally favor everyday settings so you are evaluated on equal footing regardless of your clinical shadowing hours. On the AAMC PREview exam, for example, every test form sets 75% of scenarios in non-health care environments and 25% in health care settings. By our calculation from the AAMC PREview exam blueprint, that is a 3-to-1 ratio of everyday scenarios to clinical scenarios. Casper similarly blends general interpersonal prompts with workplace and professional dilemmas.

Every medical ethics principle translates directly into daily life once you strip away clinical vocabulary. Informed consent in a hospital becomes transparency in a workplace: if a project timeline changes or a hidden fee applies, people deserve the full truth before they agree. Beneficence and non-maleficence become psychological and physical safety: you protect a coworker from public embarrassment by speaking with them one-on-one, while still stopping an unsafe shortcut that could hurt a customer. Distributive and procedural justice become fairness under pressure: when two team members want the same day off, you listen to both needs and use an objective, repeatable rule rather than picking the person who complains loudest.

  • Workplace or retail conflicts: Balance loyalty to a stressed coworker (empathy) against honest service to customers and store safety policies (integrity and non-maleficence).
  • Academic group projects: Balance compassion for a classmate facing personal hardship (beneficence) against fair grading and honest credit for the rest of the team (justice).
  • Authority and policy disagreements: Respect existing rules while raising constructive concerns through proper channels when a policy harms people unfairly, mirroring AMA Principle III (respecting the law while seeking changes when rules conflict with a patient's best interests).
  • Conflicts of interest: Disclose personal ties or gifts openly and step back from decisions where personal gain or friendship could cloud fair judgment.

High-yield clinical duties: capacity, privacy, and colleague conduct

When a healthcare or pre-health prompt does appear on Casper, the conflict usually turns on three practical boundaries: whether a person can refuse help, when you must protect or break confidentiality, and what to do when a colleague makes a mistake or acts dishonestly.

First, separate clinical decision-making capacity from legal competence. Competence is decided by a court, whereas capacity is assessed in the moment for a specific decision. A person shows capacity when they can understand the relevant facts, appreciate how the consequences apply to their own situation, reason through their options, and express a clear choice. When an adult has capacity, autonomy generally outweighs your desire to step in for their own good (paternalism). On Casper, never force treatment or dismiss someone's refusal. Instead, ask open-ended questions to understand their fears, cultural values, or financial worries, make sure they have clear and accurate information, and keep the door open for support.

Second, understand confidentiality and its legal boundaries. AMA Principle IV states that a physician must safeguard patient confidences and privacy within the constraints of the law. In both clinical and campus scenarios, keeping private disclosures confidential builds trust, so you should never gossip in hallways, elevators, or break rooms. However, confidentiality is not absolute. You must involve appropriate authorities or supervisors when keeping a secret creates imminent risk of serious physical harm to the person or someone else, involves suspected child or elder abuse, or involves legally reportable public health threats. Even when you must report, ethical communication means telling the person honestly what you have to share and why, rather than going behind their back unnecessarily.

Third, handle impaired, dishonest, or struggling peers with graduated accountability. AMA Principle II calls on physicians to be honest in all professional interactions and to report colleagues deficient in character or competence, or engaging in fraud or deception, to appropriate entities. On Casper, separate immediate danger from ambiguous behavior. If a peer smells like alcohol before touching a patient or operating equipment, safety comes first (Principle VIII regards responsibility to the patient as paramount), so you must politely prevent them from proceeding and alert a supervisor immediately. If no one is in immediate danger, such as noticing a coworker arriving late or suspecting academic dishonesty without proof, speak with them privately first without accusing them, hear their side, and encourage them to self-report or fix the problem before escalating.

How human raters score your ethical reasoning

Knowing how your answers are graded removes the pressure to hunt for a secret trick answer. According to Acuity Insights' rating guide, every Casper response is scored by a trained, certified, and monitored human rater located in the same country as the programs receiving your score. The assessment does not use AI to score, rate, or evaluate applicant responses, and raters never see your name, grades, or personal background.

Each scenario on your test is evaluated by a different rater, and no single rater scores the same applicant twice. This distributed model prevents the halo effect, ensuring that one rushed response does not pull down your score on the next prompt. Raters focus on substance, thoughtfulness, judgment, and communication rather than penalizing minor typos or imperfect grammar under timed conditions.

Once all scenarios are rated, individual scores are averaged and converted into a standardized Z-score and percentile comparing you to peers in the exact same test instance. Programs on your distribution list receive a single combined score across typed and video sections, and each school decides how heavily to weigh that score. Check your applicant portal before test day to confirm the exact section count and timer settings for your specific program cycle.

The 5-step conditional (if/then) framework for timed answers

Because Casper prompts deliberately leave out background details, committing to a harsh, one-sided action right away makes you look impulsive. At the same time, refusing to make a decision at all makes you look indecisive. Our team recommends a five-step conditional structure that fits tight video and typing limits while showing empathy and firm judgment.

  • Step 1, Name the core tension without taking a side yet: Briefly state the two competing duties in plain English, such as supporting a stressed teammate while keeping client work accurate and safe.
  • Step 2, Gather missing facts privately and non-judgmentally: Move the conversation to a private space and ask open-ended questions. Assume there could be an unseen hardship, misunderstanding, or health issue before assuming bad intent.
  • Step 3, Acknowledge the impact on every stakeholder: Name who else is affected beyond the person in front of you, including patients, customers, other students, or supervisors.
  • Step 4, Use two clear if/then branches to make a decision: Write or speak two short conditional sentences showing how your action changes based on what you learn. For example, if the mistake was an honest misunderstanding and no one was harmed, help them correct it right away. If safety is threatened or the person refuses to correct clear dishonesty, explain calmly that you must involve a supervisor.
  • Step 5, Close with constructive prevention: Add one sentence on how to prevent the conflict next time, such as clarifying team expectations early or sharing campus support resources.

Side-by-side comparison: buzzword answer vs high-reasoning answer

Show details

To see how raters separate superficial ethics vocabulary from genuine judgment, compare these two invented responses written by our team for the same scenario. Scenario prompt: You volunteer at a free community clinic check-in desk. A long-time patient tells you privately that he stopped taking his prescribed blood pressure medication because it makes him dizzy at his construction job, and he begs you not to tell the clinic physician because he does not want to disappoint her.

Weak response. Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. As a volunteer, I must balance patient autonomy against beneficence and non-maleficence. Under medical ethics rules, the physician needs accurate clinical data to prevent a stroke, so keeping a secret violates non-maleficence. However, HIPAA and autonomy mean the patient controls his body. Because stroke risk is life-threatening, beneficence overrides autonomy here. I would tell the patient that clinic policy prohibits withholding medical facts and immediately inform the physician that he is non-compliant with his regimen so she can adjust his chart.

Why the weak response struggles: It drops formal terms (autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence, HIPAA), labels the patient non-compliant, invents a reason to override an adult's privacy without checking for imminent danger, and breaks the patient's trust immediately instead of helping him communicate with his doctor.

Strong response. Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. My responsibility is to respect this patient's trust and autonomy while helping him stay safe both on his construction site and in his long-term health. First, I would listen warmly in a private area and validate how scary it is to feel dizzy while working around heavy equipment. I would reassure him that physicians adjust medications for side effects every day and that his doctor wants a treatment plan that fits his actual work life, not to judge him. Next, I would explore collaboration: if he feels comfortable sharing this himself, or letting us bring it up together in the exam room, he stays in control and can ask about alternative medications or dosing times. If he still refuses to tell the doctor today and shows no signs of a medical emergency right now, I would respect his wishes while encouraging him to ask the doctor general questions about dizziness side effects and reminding him what warning symptoms require urgent care.

Why the strong response works: It uses zero academic buzzwords yet demonstrates autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence, empathy, and collaboration in plain speech. It recognizes why the patient stopped the pills (workplace safety), empowers him to speak with his physician, and respects an adult's decision while watching for acute emergency signs.

7-point ethics checklist before test day

Show details

Use this self-audit checklist written by our team when reviewing your timed practice recordings and typed drafts before your exam date.

  • Did I check my assumptions by asking a private, non-accusatory question before acting?
  • Did I name at least two stakeholders whose well-being or fairness is affected by my choice?
  • Did I put immediate physical safety and patient welfare ahead of social comfort or peer loyalty?
  • Did I explain ethical duties in plain, conversational words rather than dropping philosophy terms?
  • Did I include at least two if/then branches to handle different possible explanations?
  • If I had to report someone or refuse a request, did I communicate that boundary respectfully and transparently?
  • Did I suggest one practical follow-up step so the same problem is less likely to happen again?

Practice question

You are co-leading a university biochemistry study group. Before a major exam, your co-leader privately sends you photos of last semester's unreleased professor exam that she got from an older student, saying she plans to share it with the whole group tonight so everyone gets top grades. How do you handle this situation?

See an example answer

Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. I want to support my co-leader and help our study group succeed, while upholding academic honesty and protecting every student in our group from an honor code violation. First, I would speak with my co-leader privately right away, before tonight's session starts, and thank her for wanting the group to do well. Rather than attacking her character, I would ask where the photos came from to confirm whether the professor ever authorized past exams for practice. If it turns out the professor officially shares old exams on the course portal or allows them as study aids, we can verify that with the teaching assistant so everyone in the class has equal access, not just our small group. However, if the exam really is unreleased, sharing it would give our group an unfair advantage over classmates and put unsuspecting students in our group at risk of academic misconduct penalties. I would state clearly that I cannot be part of distributing unauthorized test questions and urge her to delete the file so we can run tonight's session using our own practice problems. If she insists on sending the unreleased exam to the group anyway, I would let her know transparently that I would need to warn our group members not to open it and consult the course instructor to protect everyone involved.

This response translates medical ethics directly into an everyday campus dilemma without using stiff jargon. It gathers facts privately first (checking whether the exam might actually be an authorized study resource), considers procedural and distributive justice for the whole class, protects unsuspecting group members from harm (non-maleficence), sets a firm personal boundary on honesty, and uses two clear if/then branches.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need to memorize medical laws or AMA principle numbers for Casper?

No. Casper is designed to evaluate social intelligence and professionalism rather than legal or clinical knowledge, and raters score how you think and justify decisions in your own words. Understanding general ethical duties like privacy, honesty, and patient welfare helps you organize your thoughts without needing to cite rule numbers.

Should I use terms like autonomy, beneficence, and non-maleficence in my Casper answers?

You do not get bonus points for using bioethics vocabulary, and forcing academic terms into a short answer often sounds rehearsed. You will communicate more clearly by describing the principle in plain language, such as respecting a person's right to choose for themselves while making sure they understand the risks.

When should you break confidentiality in a Casper scenario?

Under ethical standards such as Principle IV of the AMA Code of Medical Ethics, privacy must be protected within the constraints of the law. In Casper dilemmas, you should protect private disclosures unless keeping the secret creates an imminent risk of serious physical harm to the person or others, involves suspected child or elder abuse, or violates mandatory public health reporting.

Are Casper ethics questions mostly hospital scenarios?

No, Casper mixes professional dilemmas with everyday interpersonal, academic, and workplace situations so applicants are judged on character rather than clinical experience. For comparison, the AAMC PREview situational judgment test places 75% of its scenarios in non-health care environments and only 25% in health care settings.

Does Casper use AI or grammar software to grade ethics responses?

No. Every typed and video Casper scenario is evaluated by a trained, certified human rater in the same country as your target programs, and raters focus on thoughtfulness, judgment, and communication rather than spelling or grammar.

Sources