NRMP Two-Phase Match Proposal: What Was Proposed & Decided
Free, no sign-up to start.
What the NRMP Two-Phase Match proposal was, why the Board rejected it on Oct 28, 2022 after 8,258 survey responses, and how interviews work today.
Free, no sign-up to start.
The NRMP Two-Phase Match proposal was an August 2, 2022 plan from the National Resident Matching Program to replace the single Main Residency Match and Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) with 2 full matching cycles between September and March. After reviewing 8,258 public survey responses and testimony from 12 national organizations, the NRMP Board of Directors announced on October 28, 2022 that it would not move forward with the proposal as written. Today, residency applicants still go through one Main Residency Match followed by SOAP during Match Week. Sources: NRMP Call for Public Comment: Two-Phase Main Residency Match (August 2, 2022), NRMP Full Statement on the Two-Phase Match Proposal (August 2022 PDF), Decision of the NRMP Board of Directors Regarding the Two-Phase Match (October 28, 2022). Last checked November 11, 2026.
On this page
- What was decided vs. what was only proposed
- How the proposed Two-Phase Match would have worked
- Side-by-side comparison: The Scramble, SOAP, and the Two-Phase Proposal
- What the public comment survey showed (and why the NRMP said no)
- What this means for residency interviews, ranking, and SOAP today
- Cost and ranking comparison: Main Match vs. SOAP (2026-2027 rules)
- Checklist: how to manage residency interviews, ranking, and SOAP prep
- Practice residency interview question and example answer
- Practice question
- Frequently asked questions
- Sources
What was decided vs. what was only proposed
If you saw an older article about a 2-phase residency match and wondered whether you need to prepare for 2 Match Days, the short answer is no. The 2-phase model was only a proposal. On October 28, 2022, following its October 9, 2022 Board meeting, the NRMP Board of Directors decided not to implement it.
Instead, the standard single Main Residency Match and the Match Week SOAP process remain in place. While the NRMP withdrew the 2-phase framework, the Board did adopt other rules in 2022 that govern your residency interviews today, including a mandatory 48-hour minimum window to accept or reject interview invitations and a ban on programs offering more interview invitations than they have available slots.
To prepare for the residency interviews that are in place right now, Confetto runs AI mock residency interviews with follow-up questions on your own application and gives rubric-based feedback on every answer. Start your free week.
| Rule or process | Status | What it means for your application |
|---|---|---|
| Two-Phase Main Residency Match | Proposed August 2, 2022. Rejected October 28, 2022 | Not active. There is only one Main Residency Match cycle per year. |
| Eliminating SOAP | Proposed August 2, 2022. Rejected October 28, 2022 | Not active. SOAP still runs during Match Week for unmatched and partially matched applicants. |
| Two separate Match Days | Proposed August 2, 2022. Rejected October 28, 2022 | Not active. Match Week and a single Match Day remain the standard schedule. |
| 48-hour interview acceptance window | Adopted in May 2022 (effective 2023 Match onward) | Active in Section 6.2 of the Match Participation Agreement. Programs must give you at least 48 hours to accept or reject an interview offer. |
| Cap on interview invitations | Adopted in May 2022 (effective 2023 Match onward) | Active in Section 6.2 of the Match Participation Agreement. Programs cannot send out more interview invitations than their total available interview slots. |
| 1 to 2 weeks notice for cancellations | Adopted in May 2022 (effective 2023 Match onward) | Active in Section 6.2 of the Match Participation Agreement. Both applicants and programs must give reasonable notice when canceling or rescheduling. |
How the proposed Two-Phase Match would have worked
Since 1952, the NRMP has used a mathematical algorithm to pair the preferences of applicants and residency programs. In 2012, the NRMP introduced SOAP to replace the post-Match period known as the Scramble, which was an ungoverned open market during Match Week where unmatched applicants tried to find open positions.
10 years after launching SOAP, on August 2, 2022, the NRMP Board of Directors released a call for public comment on a Two-Phase Main Residency Match. The goal was to replace both the current Match and SOAP with 2 complete matching cycles inside the existing September through March recruitment window.
In SOAP, applicants do not submit a rank order list. Instead, unfilled programs build preference lists, and offers go out in rounds through the NRMP Registration, Ranking, and Results (R3) system, giving applicants a 2-hour window in each round to accept or reject a position. The Two-Phase Match proposal sought to replace those 2-hour offer rounds with a second full run of the applicant-proposing algorithm.
- Rank order lists in both phases. Both applicants and programs would submit certified rank order lists (ROLs) in Phase One and Phase Two.
- Applicant-proposing algorithm twice. Both Phase One and Phase Two would use the standard NRMP applicant-proposing mathematical algorithm instead of program-preferenced SOAP offers.
- Time between phases. The schedule would leave dedicated time between Phase One and Phase Two for applicants to research and vet programs, and for programs to conduct holistic application review and interviews.
- 2 Match Days. Each phase would end with its own Match Day, releasing full results to all participants to help with transition and program planning.
- Automatic rollover and binding commitments. Unmatched applicants and unfilled positions from Phase One would roll over into Phase Two automatically, while all matched outcomes and binding commitments from Phase One would be honored throughout Phase Two.
- Phase Two entry for newly eligible participants. Programs newly accredited by the ACGME after the Phase One ROL Certification Deadline, and applicants who were ineligible for Phase One but became eligible afterward, would be allowed to register for Phase Two.
Side-by-side comparison: The Scramble, SOAP, and the Two-Phase Proposal
To see why the NRMP considered changing Match Week, it helps to compare how unfilled positions were handled before 2012, how SOAP works in the 2026 NRMP SOAP Guide for Applicants, and what the August 2022 proposal tried to change.
| Feature | The Scramble (Pre-2012) | Current SOAP (2012 to present) | Proposed Two-Phase Match (Rejected 2022) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Governance | Ungoverned open market during Match Week | Governed by NRMP Match Participation Agreement in the R3 system | Governed by NRMP Match Participation Agreement across two complete cycles |
| How positions are assigned | Ad hoc offers outside a centralized clearinghouse | Program-preferenced offers extended across 4 2-hour Offer Rounds on Thursday of Match Week | Applicant-proposing matching algorithm used in both Phase One and Phase Two |
| Applicant rank order list (ROL) | None | None. Only programs submit preference lists | Required from both applicants and programs in both phases |
| Decision window for applicants | Unregulated, often immediate pressure | 2 hours per Offer Round to accept or reject an offer before it expires | Multi-day window to research programs, interview, and certify a Phase Two ROL |
| Application cap in the secondary round | No standardized cap | Up to 45 applications per participating application service (ERAS and ResidencyCAS) | No separate cap set in the August 2022 framework |
| Newly accredited ACGME programs | Could recruit outside the Match | Must participate in SOAP if participating in the Match and unfilled | Programs accredited after the Phase One ROL deadline could register for Phase Two |
What the public comment survey showed (and why the NRMP said no)
Between August 2 and September 2, 2022, the NRMP collected 8,258 survey responses on the proposal (5,297 complete and 2,961 partial). Nearly two-thirds of the respondents were medical students, residents, or fellows. On September 16, 2022, the NRMP Board and senior leadership also heard live testimony from 12 national medical education and student organizations, alongside meetings with AAMC constituency groups, specialty organizations, and sponsoring institutions.
At first glance, the headline survey numbers looked favorable: 60 percent of respondents viewed a Two-Phase Match as modestly (30.6 percent) or significantly (30.2 percent) advantageous, compared with 20 percent who viewed it as modestly (9.8 percent) or significantly (10.6 percent) disadvantageous, and 19 percent who were neutral. By our calculation from the NRMP October 28, 2022 Board decision report, complete responses made up 64.1 percent of the 8,258 total submissions.
However, when respondents and the 12 testifying organizations detailed the specific risks, the NRMP Board concluded that the disadvantages were of greater consequence than the benefits. In particular, testimony pointed out that a 2-phase match did not solve primary recruitment problems such as high application numbers, while introducing new burdens on fourth-year medical students and programs. Among learners who saw disadvantages, 78.9 percent cited added application or interview stress, while 67.2 percent of those seeing advantages cited more thoughtful career planning.
What this means for residency interviews, ranking, and SOAP today
Because the Two-Phase Match was not adopted, your residency interview, ranking, and Match Week strategy follows the single-phase NRMP calendar and the updated AAMC and NRMP rules.
First, know your interview rights under Section 6.2 of the NRMP Match Participation Agreement. Programs may only extend interview offers equal to, and not exceeding, their total available interview slots. They must give you at least 48 hours to accept or reject an invitation, and both you and the program must give reasonable notice, such as 1 to 2 weeks, when canceling or rescheduling an interview.
Second, understand how ranking works in the NRMP R3 system. Your $85 Main Residency Match standard registration fee covers up to 20 unique NRMP program codes on your primary rank order list and up to 20 unique codes on all supplemental rank order lists combined. Ranking more than 20 programs adds a $30 fee per extra program code up to the maximum of 300 ranks, plus an additional length fee of $50 to $200 if your list reaches 100 ranks or more. Registering after January 29 adds a $50 late fee, and couples pay an extra $45 per partner. The matching algorithm is applicant-proposing, so rank programs in order of your true preference, never rank a program where you did not interview, and certify your list before 9:00 p.m. ET on the Rank Order List Certification Deadline.
Third, know how SOAP works if you are unmatched or partially matched on Monday of Match Week. According to the 2026 NRMP SOAP Guide for Applicants, you learn your match status at 10:00 a.m. ET on Monday of Match Week (March 16, 2026 in the 2026 guide) and can begin submitting applications to unfilled programs at 11:00 a.m. ET. You can submit up to 45 applications in AAMC ERAS (which covers every Match-participating specialty except Emergency Medicine, EM Combined, and Obstetrics and Gynecology) and up to 45 applications in ResidencyCAS (which covers Emergency Medicine, EM Combined Specialties, and Obstetrics and Gynecology). You cannot contact a program during SOAP until you submit an application and the program contacts you first. 4 2-hour Offer Rounds run on Thursday starting at 9:00 a.m. ET, and nearly 60 percent of positions fill in the first round and about 80 percent fill by the end of the second round.
Cost and ranking comparison: Main Match vs. SOAP (2026-2027 rules)
Show details
Beginning with the 2027 ERAS season (which opens in June 2026), the AAMC simplified residency application fees to $11 per program for the first 1 to 30 programs per specialty, and $30 per program for 31 or more programs in that specialty. Here is a worked example of what an applicant pays across ERAS, NRMP ranking, and SOAP under current official rates.
By our calculation from the AAMC 2027 ERAS fee schedule and the NRMP Match Fees page, an applicant who applies to 35 Internal Medicine programs in ERAS, interviews at 22 of them, and certifies all 22 on their primary NRMP rank order list pays $625 in combined ERAS and NRMP fees: $330 for the first 30 ERAS programs (30 x $11), $150 for the next 5 ERAS programs (5 x $30), $85 for standard NRMP registration (covering the first 20 ranks), and $60 for 2 extra NRMP ranks (2 x $30). If that applicant enters SOAP on Monday of Match Week and applies to 45 unfilled ERAS programs, their additional SOAP application fee in ERAS is $0 because they already applied to at least one ERAS program during the regular season. If they also apply to unfilled Emergency Medicine or OB-GYN programs in ResidencyCAS after not using ResidencyCAS in the regular season, they pay a $99 new application service fee.
| Fee item | Official cost | Rule and threshold |
|---|---|---|
| ERAS applications (programs 1 to 30 per specialty) | $11 per program | Applies beginning with the 2027 ERAS season (starting June 2026). Resets for each additional specialty. |
| ERAS applications (31 or more per specialty) | $30 per program | Applies beginning with the 2027 ERAS season. Non-refundable once submitted. |
| COMLEX-USA transcript in ERAS | $80 once per season | Assessed once per ERAS season if submitting COMLEX-USA scores. |
| NRMP Main Residency Match registration | $85 | Includes up to 20 unique program codes on the primary ROL and up to 20 on supplemental ROLs. |
| NRMP Extra Rank Fee | $30 per program code | Charged for each unique program code over 20, up to the 300-rank maximum. |
| NRMP Length of Rank Order List Fee | $50 to $200 | $50 for 100-150 ranks, $100 for 151-200, $150 for 201-250, and $200 for 251-300 ranks. |
| NRMP Late Registration / Couples Fee | $50 late / $45 per partner | Late fee applies after January 29. Couples fee is per partner in the Main Residency Match. |
| SOAP application fee (existing service user) | $0 | Up to 45 applications per service if you applied to at least 1 program in that service by Monday of Match Week. |
| SOAP new application service fee | $99 per service | Charged only if you did not apply to at least 1 program in that application service (ERAS or ResidencyCAS) before SOAP. |
Checklist: how to manage residency interviews, ranking, and SOAP prep
Show details
Use this step-by-step plan to stay compliant with NRMP policies from your first interview invitation through Match Week.
- Use your 48-hour window wisely. Under Section 6.2.1 of the Match Participation Agreement, programs must give you at least 48 hours to respond to an interview invite. Check your schedule before accepting so you only accept interviews you intend to fulfill.
- Cancel at least 1 to 2 weeks ahead. If you decide to drop an interview, give the program 1 to 2 weeks notice as required by the NRMP Match Participation Agreement.
- Use program signals and geographic preferences strategically. Since the 2024 ERAS season, applicants have been able to send program signals to express interest. Review the AAMC ERAS Statistics dashboards before submitting applications to see how signals relate to interview invitations in your specialty.
- Rank in order of true preference. Put your reach programs at the top of your ROL, include at least one safety program, and never rank a program where you did not interview or would not be willing to train under a binding contract.
- Certify your ROL early. Enter and certify your list in the R3 system well before 9:00 p.m. ET on the deadline day to avoid slow servers. Check that your status changes from Ranking to Certified and that you receive the confirmation email.
- Keep a SOAP contingency folder ready before Match Week. Have an updated personal statement and letters of recommendation ready to go. For the duration of SOAP, ERAS and ResidencyCAS allow you to transfer completed Letters of Recommendation, including Standardized Letters of Evaluation (SLOEs), between the two systems.
- Follow the SOAP no-contact rule strictly. If you enter SOAP on Monday at 10:00 a.m. ET, do not call, email, or have a mentor contact an unfilled program until after you submit a SOAP application and the program reaches out to you first.
Practice residency interview question and example answer
Whether you are interviewing during the regular fall-to-winter cycle or taking a short video call with a program during SOAP on Tuesday or Wednesday of Match Week, prepare a story about how you handled a sudden change of plans or a high-pressure setback. If you are preparing for different interview styles, you can also review our MMI practice questions with answers, our panel interview guide, or our medical school interview questions for structured speaking drills.
Here is a residency interview prompt with an example answer written by our team. To practice answering out loud with AI follow-up questions, Start your free week on Confetto.
Practice question
Tell me about a time when a plan you had worked toward for months fell through on short notice. How did you make your next decision under time pressure?
See an example answer
Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. During my third-year surgery clerkship, I spent 4 months preparing a clinical quality project on postoperative discharge instructions with a faculty mentor who suddenly left the institution 2 weeks before our departmental abstract deadline. Without a faculty sponsor, my project could not be submitted, and the dataset I had been auditing was locked under his IRB protocol. That afternoon, I sat down with the clerkship director to figure out what was salvageable rather than abandoning the work. We identified an ongoing resident-led project tracking 30-day readmissions on the same service that needed someone to audit chart notes from the past quarter. Before committing, I asked the chief resident 2 questions: whether the IRB already covered medical students, and what specific work needed to be done in the next 10 days. It meant giving up first authorship, which stung after 4 months of prep, but joining their team let us finish the audit on time and taught me to separate a setback in my original plan from the larger goal of finishing useful clinical work.
It names a concrete clinical setback in the first sentence, walks through how the applicant gathered facts and sought mentorship before acting, and honestly states the trade-off they accepted under a tight deadline.
Frequently asked questions
Did the NRMP pass the Two-Phase Match proposal?
No. On October 28, 2022, the NRMP Board of Directors announced that it would not move forward with the Two-Phase Match proposal as written, keeping the single Main Residency Match and SOAP in place.
What was the NRMP Two-Phase Match proposal supposed to replace?
Published on August 2, 2022, the proposal sought to replace the single Main Residency Match and the Match Week Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) with 2 complete matching cycles between September and March, using rank order lists and the applicant-proposing algorithm in both phases.
Why did the NRMP reject the Two-Phase Match?
Although 60 percent of the 8,258 public survey respondents viewed the idea as advantageous, the NRMP Board found that the community's reported risks carried greater consequence. Those risks included added interview and application stress (cited by 78.9 percent of learners), potential bias and stigma against Phase Two applicants (52.4 percent of learners), and the fact that a 2-phase match did not address high application volumes.
How does SOAP work instead of a Phase Two match?
During Match Week, eligible unmatched and partially matched applicants learn their status on Monday at 10:00 a.m. ET and can send up to 45 applications per application service (ERAS and ResidencyCAS) starting at 11:00 a.m. ET. Programs contact applicants for brief interviews and submit preference lists, and positions are offered in 4 2-hour rounds on Thursday starting at 9:00 a.m. ET, where nearly 60 percent of positions fill in Round 1 and about 80 percent fill by the end of Round 2.
What interview rules did the NRMP actually adopt in 2022?
Beginning with the 2023 Main Residency Match, the NRMP added Section 6.2 to the Match Participation Agreement, requiring programs to limit interview invitations to the exact number of available interview slots, give applicants at least 48 hours to accept or reject an invitation, and give reasonable notice (such as 1 to 2 weeks notice) when canceling or rescheduling.
Sources
- NRMP Call for Public Comment: Two-Phase Main Residency Match (August 2, 2022)
- NRMP Full Statement on the Two-Phase Match Proposal (August 2022 PDF)
- Decision of the NRMP Board of Directors Regarding the Two-Phase Match (October 28, 2022)
- NRMP September 2022 Illuminator: New Interview Policies in the Match Agreement
- NRMP November 2022 Illuminator: October 9 Board Deliberation
- NRMP 2026 SOAP Guide for Residency Applicants (PDF)
- NRMP Match Fees
- NRMP Ranking Programs in the Main Residency Match
- AAMC Fees for the 2027 ERAS Season
- AAMC ERAS Statistics and Program Signaling Dashboards