What Would You Do Ethical Scenarios and How to Answer
Free, no sign-up to start.
Practice "what would you do" ethical scenarios for work, interviews, and Casper. Includes decision steps, verbal scripts, and a sample answer.
Free, no sign-up to start.
"What would you do" ethical scenarios are short, realistic dilemmas where two good values pull in opposite directions, such as loyalty versus honesty or rules versus empathy, and you must explain both your action and your reasoning. Universities and employers use these situational judgment questions to see how you think under pressure, including on Acuity Insights' Casper exam (11 open-response scenarios in 65 to 85 minutes) and the AAMC PREview exam (186 behavioral items). Strong answers gather missing facts before judging, weigh every person affected, and reduce harm without breaking core duties. Sources: About Casper: Acuity Insights Applicant Portal, How to Prepare for Casper: Acuity Insights, Casper Dates and Fees Guidelines: Acuity Insights. Last checked November 12, 2026.
On this page
- How to work through any "what would you do" ethical scenario
- Three moral lenses and how they change your answer
- Workplace, daily life, and modern scenarios with branching scripts
- How Casper, AAMC PREview, and MMI interviews test ethical scenarios
- Official sample prompts and why follow-up questions shift the facts
- Self-check rubric: spot your own ethical blind spots
- Casper scoring rules, logistics, and a two-week practice plan
- Practice question
- Frequently asked questions
- Sources
How to work through any "what would you do" ethical scenario
An ethical scenario rarely asks you to pick between something obviously good and something obviously bad. Instead, it puts two real responsibilities into conflict when you do not have all the facts, such as keeping a friend's secret versus protecting a team. In its 2026 Premed Competencies model, the AAMC defines ethical responsibility to self and others as behaving with honesty and integrity, considering multiple or conflicting principles and values to inform decisions, resisting pressure to engage in unethical behavior, and encouraging others to behave honestly.
Jumping straight to a rigid verdict is the fastest way to miss the mark in an interview or situational judgment test. Use this five-step sequence to organize your thoughts before you speak or type. If you have an upcoming admissions exam, read our Casper guide and run timed drills on our Casper practice scenarios page.
- Separate known facts from assumptions: Check whether a miscommunication, technical error, or personal crisis could explain someone's behavior.
- Name the competing values and stakeholders: Identify the exact tension, such as confidentiality versus safety, and list everyone affected.
- Start with a private, non-judgmental conversation: Unless someone faces immediate danger, speak one-on-one with the person involved before escalating.
- Map conditional next steps with if-then logic: Show how your action adapts depending on what you learn in that conversation.
- State both what you would do and why: Name the principle behind your final step and add one preventative habit for the future.
Three moral lenses and how they change your answer
Reasonable people often disagree on "what would you do" questions because they rely on different moral lenses. An outcome-based lens (utilitarianism) weighs foreseeable harms and benefits across everyone affected to produce the greatest overall well-being, though used alone it can tempt you to bend safety or honesty rules for short-term calm. A duty-based lens (deontology) protects rights, consent, and rules regardless of convenience, though strict enforcement without context can sound cold. A character-based lens (virtue ethics) asks what an honest, fair, compassionate person would do when nobody is watching.
Strong interview and exam answers combine all three. You uphold non-negotiable duties like safety and honesty, look for practical options that reduce harm, and speak with warmth and humility.
| Scenario | Outcome Lens (Consequences) | Duty Lens (Rules and Rights) | Character Lens (Virtue) | Balanced Action Plan |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coworker asks you to cover an unapproved absence | Covering avoids friction today, yet repeated absences overload the team and hurt service. | Falsifying attendance violates honesty policies and misleads supervisors. | A loyal yet honest peer supports a coworker without lying. | Decline to falsify records, check privately if your coworker needs help, and offer a legitimate shift swap. |
| Supervisor hints at overstating project progress to a client | Hiding delays buys short-term calm, yet later discovery damages client operations and trust. | Clients have a right to accurate reporting to make informed choices. | Integrity means resisting authority pressure constructively. | Decline to inflate numbers, bring an honest update paired with a recovery plan, and escalate internally if pressured. |
| Teammate pastes private client data into a public AI tool | Fast drafting saves hours, yet exposing private records risks severe client harm. | Privacy agreements forbid sharing protected data with unauthorized platforms. | Accountability means fixing mistakes promptly rather than hiding them. | Ask your peer to stop uploading data immediately, notify data security, and switch to approved internal tools. |
| Distressed customer asks for a refund without a receipt | Refusing hurts goodwill, while unlimited unverified cash refunds invite fraud. | Store policy requires proof of purchase to treat customers consistently. | Empathy and fairness call for respectful listening and middle ground. | Acknowledge their stress, look up the purchase by card or loyalty account, or offer store credit if policy allows. |
Workplace, daily life, and modern scenarios with branching scripts
Most dilemma lists stop after asking the question, leaving you to guess how to execute the choice aloud. Below are four scenarios across workplace pressure, personal loyalty, generative AI shortcuts, and remote work privacy, each with if-then paths and exact verbal scripts.
Scenario A (Safety versus launch bonus): Hours before a product launch, you spot an edge-case safety test failure. Your team lead calls it rare, asks you to sign the clearance sheet anyway, and warns that a delay will cost the team its bonus. If you show your lead the exact risk privately, they may pause the launch with you, protecting both public safety and trust. If they still push you to sign falsely, refuse and take the test log to the safety director, since public safety outweighs bonuses. Script: "I know how hard everyone worked, and I hate risking a delay. Still, I cannot sign off while that safety check is failing. Let's spend ten minutes with engineering to check for a quick patch or give leadership an honest heads-up together."
Scenario B (Friend loyalty versus fair hiring): A close friend applying for the same internship offers to text you leaked screenshots of last week's interview evaluation questions. If you decline and explain the disqualification risk and unfairness to other applicants, your friend may delete them and practice fairly with you. If they plan to share the leak widely, keep your own prep clean and follow your institution's honor code. Script: "I appreciate you looking out for me. I am going to pass on those screenshots, and I hope you hold off too. If leaked prompts come out, both of our applications could be pulled, so let's prep together tonight with the public guide instead."
Scenario C (Workplace AI citations): Ten minutes before a draft review, your co-author pastes in a polished section containing fabricated journal citations from an AI tool. If you ask privately where the citations came from, your peer may admit they ran out of time so you can cut the unverified text and request a short extension together. If they insist on submitting fake sources, remove your name from false claims and alert your manager before release. Script: "I tried pulling up two studies in Section B and neither issue exists. Did an AI tool draft that part? Let's strip unverified citations now and ask our manager for until tomorrow morning to plug in real data."
Scenario D (Remote monitoring versus privacy): A senior executive sees a reliable remote employee's chat icon go idle in the afternoon and asks you to pull hidden webcam snapshots and keystroke logs without telling them. Check HR policy first to confirm what tracking is disclosed and permitted, then hold an open check-in focused on work output. If deliverables are on time, reassure the executive with completed results rather than spying. If output slipped, address performance directly and check if schedule flexibility is needed. Script: "Before pulling logs, I want to verify our HR monitoring policy and check in with Jordan directly. Their milestones are on track, so a quick conversation will clarify their afternoon schedule without hurting team trust."
How Casper, AAMC PREview, and MMI interviews test ethical scenarios
Admissions committees across medicine, nursing, pharmacy, allied health, business, engineering, and teacher education test ethical scenarios because grades alone cannot show how you handle interpersonal conflict. Casper is an open-response situational judgment test completed by 1M+ applicants across 600+ partner institutions worldwide and backed by 20+ years of research and over 150 internal and external studies. Instead of multiple-choice options, Casper asks what you would authentically do in your own words across nine skills: collaboration, communication, empathy, ethics, fairness, motivation, problem solving, resilience, and self-awareness.
Standard Casper takes approximately 65 to 85 minutes, including 2 optional breaks, across 2 sections and 11 scenarios (select programs, such as Australian teacher education programs, use a shorter format). The video section has 4 scenarios with 2 open-ended questions each and 1 minute per response. The typed section has 7 scenarios with 2 open-ended questions on the same screen and 3.5 minutes total for both. By our calculation from Acuity Insights' published format, you answer 22 open-ended questions across the exam (8 video and 14 typed), giving you 1.75 minutes (105 seconds) per typed question if you split each 3.5-minute page evenly.
Medical school applicants also see closed-response and live formats. The AAMC PREview exam presents scenarios with 4 to 8 behavioral responses (186 items total, with 75% in non-health care settings and 25% in health care settings, each reviewed by more than 10 trained reviewers). You rate each item from 1 (Very Ineffective) to 4 (Very Effective) for a total score of 1 to 9 with a confidence band of plus or minus 1 point. Schools also run 1:1 interviews lasting 20 or 30 minutes and multiple mini interviews (MMI) with 6 to 10 stations at 5 minutes per station.
| Assessment | Response Format | Volume and Timing | How Responses Are Evaluated |
|---|---|---|---|
| Casper | Open-response video recordings and typed answers | 11 scenarios: 4 video (1 minute per question across 2 questions) and 7 typed (3.5 minutes for 2 questions) | Scored individually by certified human raters (not AI) on reasoning and perspective-taking |
| AAMC PREview Exam | Closed-response ratings from Very Ineffective (1) to Very Effective (4) | 186 items in sets of 4 to 8 responses, administered April through October in 2026 | Matched against medical educator consensus ratings for full or half credit on a 1 to 9 scale |
| Multiple Mini Interview (MMI) | Live spoken answers or role-play stations | Typically 6 to 10 stations with 5 minutes per station | Scored per station by school interviewers on verbal, nonverbal, and problem-solving skills |
Official sample prompts and why follow-up questions shift the facts
Official sample questions reveal how test writers check whether your judgment is adaptable rather than scripted. On Casper, the first prompt asks how you would handle an ambiguous conflict, and the second alters a variable or places you on the harder side of the call.
In one official Casper scenario, you are a store manager deciding whether to grant a customer a refund, and question two asks how you would communicate a refusal if you decided against the refund. A second official Casper scenario involves a group member named Paul who stopped contributing to an assignment due to a medical condition, followed by asking how your answer changes if Paul contributed a significant amount before putting his courses on hold. Checking on Paul comes first either way, yet prior work changes how you discuss fair credit with your instructor.
In a third official Casper prompt, volunteer coordinator Mary sends thank-you notes to volunteers Chloe and Eric, with money included only in Chloe's note, then asks if your advice changes if Eric frequently funds his volunteering out of his own pocket. Similarly, Sample 1 of AAMC PREview Practice Exam 1 presents a 2-week clinic volunteer slot that conflicts with a weekly required graded lab that cannot be made up. Effective answers honor core commitments, avoid public embarrassment, check privately for innocent oversights, and look for constructive alternatives.
Self-check rubric: spot your own ethical blind spots
Show details
Time pressure pushes many applicants into sounding like a cold rulebook or hedging without ever making a decision. Our team created this four-part rubric so you can grade three of your own recorded or typed practice responses in five minutes.
| Dimension | Needs Work | Solid | Strong |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fact Gathering | Assumes malice right away and escalates before speaking to the person. | Says you would gather more facts before deciding. | Names plausible benign explanations to check in a private talk first. |
| Stakeholder Balance | Focuses on one person's feelings or only on rigid rules. | Notes two sides of the conflict before choosing. | Weighs direct and ripple effects on peers, clients, and team trust. |
| Decision Clarity | Stays vague without committing to an action. | Commits to one clear step for the main scenario. | Commits to a clear first step plus conditional if-then branches. |
| Explaining the Why | Lists steps without naming the principle behind them. | Mentions honesty or fairness briefly at the end. | Links each action to the duty or harm it addresses and adds prevention. |
Casper scoring rules, logistics, and a two-week practice plan
Show details
Casper answers are evaluated by certified human raters rather than AI, and every question is scored individually. Leaving the second prompt on a 3.5-minute typed screen blank hurts that question's score. Raters are trained to ignore minor spelling mistakes, grammar slips, and jargon so they can focus on your reasoning, and bullet points are allowed in typed answers if you want to get your core "what" and "why" down fast.
Register at least 3 days before your preferred test date using a government-issued photo ID in English or French matching your application name. Submit accommodation requests and documentation at least 4 weeks before your test date. Scores apply to one admissions cycle and one test type, and you cannot take the same Casper test type more than once per cycle. Applicants approved for participating US or UK Fee Assistance Programs (such as AAMC, AACOMAS, CASPA, ADEA, or a UCAS bursary) can receive waived or reduced fees. Because applicants who take the free official practice test in their account tend to outperform those who skip prep or use scripted third-party courses, pair that official simulation with this two-week schedule from our team and extra timed drills on our Casper practice page.
- Days 1 to 4 (Untimed habits): Work through two dilemmas daily across work, peer, and AI privacy topics, writing missing facts, stakeholders, and an if-then branch.
- Days 5 to 8 (Typed pacing): Practice two related prompts on one 3.5-minute timer (1.75 minutes per question), testing bullet outlines if typing speed holds you back.
- Days 9 to 11 (Video reps): Record 1-minute answers in Camera (PC) or Photo Booth (Mac), checking for a calm tone, a distraction-free background, and a clear "why."
- Days 12 to 14 (Official test check): Complete the official practice test in your Acuity Insights account, confirm your North American Eastern or Australian Eastern time zone, and test your webcam and mic.
Practice question
You are an undergraduate research assistant in a university lab. While reviewing shared data files before a team submission deadline tomorrow, you notice that Jordan, a senior student on the team who has been dealing with a family emergency all week, excluded several outlier trials without documenting why. Including those trials weakens the lab's main finding. What would you do in this situation, and why?
See an example answer
Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. First, I would check the raw lab notebook and shared protocol notes to see whether a documented technical issue, such as calibration drift, justified excluding those trials. Because Jordan has been managing a family emergency, I want to avoid assuming dishonesty when exhaustion or an unuploaded note could explain the missing context. Next, I would speak with Jordan privately right away. I would express support for what they are facing at home, mention the undocumented exclusions calmly, and ask if run notes exist that have not been added yet. If a valid technical flaw occurred, I would offer to help draft the transparent exclusion note tonight so Jordan is not overloaded. However, if the trials were removed simply because they weakened our finding, I would explain that research integrity requires reporting the full dataset accurately, since selective reporting misleads future studies and breaks academic rules. If Jordan still pushed to submit the altered file, I would bring the full dataset to our principal investigator before tomorrow's deadline so we can correct the record or request a short extension.
This answer checks facts before accusing a stressed peer, opens privately with empathy, maps clear if-then steps for both innocent and unethical causes, protects research honesty, and states the principle behind each choice.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a single right answer to "what would you do" ethical scenarios?
Open-response tests like Casper ask what you would authentically do in realistic situations rather than grading against one pre-set answer. Raters score how you gather missing context, weigh competing perspectives, and explain both what you would do and why.
How much time do you get to answer ethical scenarios on Casper?
Standard Casper gives you 1 minute per question across 4 video scenarios (2 questions each) and 3.5 minutes per screen across 7 typed scenarios (2 questions together). With 2 optional breaks, the 11-scenario test takes approximately 65 to 85 minutes.
Do spelling errors or bullet points hurt your score on typed ethical scenarios?
No. Certified human raters on Casper are trained to disregard minor spelling or grammar errors under time limits, and bullet points are permitted in typed responses as long as your action and reasoning are clear.
How does Casper differ from the AAMC PREview exam?
Casper is an open-response exam where you record video answers and type responses in your own words across 11 scenarios. AAMC PREview presents 186 closed-response items across scenario sets where you rate proposed actions from Very Ineffective (1) to Very Effective (4) for a 1 to 9 score.
How do you refuse an unethical request from a boss or friend without escalating conflict?
Acknowledge their deadline stress or good intent first, state your boundary plainly in first-person terms without attacking their character, and immediately suggest a legitimate way to solve the underlying problem.
Sources
- About Casper: Acuity Insights Applicant Portal
- How to Prepare for Casper: Acuity Insights
- Casper Dates and Fees Guidelines: Acuity Insights
- Casper Overview and Research: Acuity Insights
- About the AAMC PREview Professional Readiness Exam
- The Premed Competencies for Entering Medical Students: AAMC
- Take the AAMC PREview Exam: AAMC
- AAMC Professional Readiness Exam Sample Scenarios
- Preparing for Your Medical School Interview: AAMC