Confetto

Some argue that physicians have a duty to be role models for healthy living. Do you agree or disagree?

Agree that doctors have some duty, but not a duty to be perfect. Healthy habits make advice more credible, yet doctors get sick and work exhausting hours. Take the middle view that doctors should not undermine their own advice, and hospitals should support their health.

How a 90-point answer starts

I think it depends on what we mean by duty and by role model, so let me say how I'm reading it. A professional duty is something you could be disciplined for failing, like confidentiality.

See the full answer, the 50 and 70 versions, and what moves each score up.

Practice this question free

Sample answer outline

  1. Answer first in one sentence: yes, physicians should try to practice what they advise, but being a role model is an aspiration, not a test of perfect health. Then explain why.
  2. Clarify the terms: is it a professional duty, or an expectation? A role model in what sense?
  3. Give the case for: credibility, patient trust, the public image of the profession.
  4. Give the case against: doctors are human, health isn't only about choices, and policing it could stigmatize doctors who are ill.
  5. Take a position, for example: doctors shouldn't undermine their own advice and should look after their health, but perfection isn't a professional duty.
  6. Close on the implication: supporting physician wellbeing.
  7. Say your answer out loud before the interview. Practice it with an AI interviewer that gives feedback. Start your free week

What makes it score well, and the mistakes that cost points, are in the app with this question.

How to approach policy and current issues questions

  1. Define the issue in one sentence so you and the interviewer agree on terms.
  2. Give the strongest arguments on both sides, with one fact you are sure of.
  3. Take a clear position and name its tradeoffs.
  4. Bring it back to patients and your future role.

About this question

Format
MMI station
Level
Intermediate
Asked in
MD, DO

Related questions

Say it out loud

Confetto's AI interviewer asks you this question, follows up like a real interviewer and gives feedback on your answer.

Practice this question now

Free trial

All interview questions