Confetto

AMCAS Letter Writer Guide: Rules, Portal, and Examples

Practice the med school interview now

Free, no sign-up to start.

How to write and upload an AMCAS letter of evaluation: AAMC's 8 guidelines, 17 competencies, portal steps, file limits, and examples.

Practice the med school interview now

Free, no sign-up to start.

An AMCAS letter writer evaluates a medical school applicant's observed behaviors and uploads the signed PDF or Word file under 5 MB. According to the AAMC, authors should assess suitability across 17 premed competencies and include the applicant's AAMC ID and AMCAS Request ID. Uploads through the AAMC Letter Writer Portal mark as received immediately, while Interfolio deliveries take up to 3 business days. Sources: AAMC: Guidelines for Writing a Letter of Evaluation for a Medical School Applicant, AAMC: AMCAS Letter Service for Advisors and Other Letter Authors, AAMC: The Premed Competencies for Entering Medical Students. Last checked November 14, 2026.

How the AMCAS Letter Service works for writers and applicants

Each year, 52,000 aspiring doctors apply to medical school through the AAMC's American Medical College Application Service (AMCAS). If you are asked to serve as an AMCAS letter writer, you only upload your evaluation once. AMCAS distributes your letter electronically to the participating MD schools the applicant selects.

Faculty and clinical mentors often write for students across multiple professions. While nursing schools use AACN's Liaison-operated NursingCAS and accredited PA programs overseen by ARC-PA work with PAEA's centralized system, AMCAS runs on the AAMC's own platform. That platform also handles letters for the Summer Health Professions Education Program (SHPEP) and, starting with the 2027 cycle, the Electronic Residency Application Service (ERAS).

If a medical school participates in the AMCAS Letter Service, every letter for that school must go through AMCAS. Only 3 MD programs listed by the AAMC do not participate: Northeast Ohio Medical University, the UC Berkeley - UCSF Joint Medical Program, and the University of Puerto Rico School of Medicine.

Confidentiality is strict. Under no circumstances will the AMCAS program provide applicants access to letters of evaluation. Authors who log into an AAMC account in the AAMC Letter Writer Portal can view an expanded history of all requests, including submitted documents.

  • Applicant step: Add the evaluator in Section 6 of AMCAS and generate the official AMCAS Letter Request Form.
  • Evaluator step: Receive the Letter Request Form containing the applicant's AAMC ID and unique AMCAS Request ID.
  • Drafting step: Write an objective, behavior-based evaluation on official letterhead and sign it.
  • Upload step: Submit the unencrypted PDF or Word file under 5 MB via the AAMC Letter Writer Portal or Interfolio.

The 8 AAMC guidelines: what medical schools want in a letter

The AAMC publishes 8 official Guidelines for Writing a Letter of Evaluation, endorsed for both individual and committee authors. The first rule sets the tone for the whole document: provide an accurate assessment of the applicant's suitability for medical school rather than simply advocating for them.

Admissions committees already have the applicant's transcript, coursework list, and test scores. Repeating a syllabus description, lab protocol, or resume wastes space. Quality of information matters more than letter length, so keep your focus on what the applicant actually did and how they worked with others.

Only mention grades, GPA, or MCAT scores if you add context that helps interpret them, such as a brutal curve or a sharp upward trend between exams. Similarly, if you compare the applicant to peers, name the exact comparison group and state your rationale for the comparison.

  • Assess, do not just advocate: Give an honest evaluation of readiness for medical training.
  • State your relationship early: Explain how long you have known the applicant, in what capacity, and whether your observations are direct or indirect.
  • Prioritize substance over length: Center the letter on the applicant, not on your course, lab, job description, or institution.
  • Contextualize metrics: Skip raw GPA, course grades, or MCAT numbers unless you explain what those numbers mean in your setting.
  • Describe observed behaviors: Walk through the situation, the actual behavior you saw, and the consequence of that action.
  • Ask permission for sensitive details: Get the applicant's consent before disclosing private health, family, or personal hardships.
  • Highlight unique contributions: Note obstacles the applicant overcame, how they grew, and lived experiences that shape their perspective.
  • Ground every comparison: Specify who is in your comparison group (such as students in your seminar or research assistants) and how you judge them.

The 17 AAMC premed competencies (including 2026 updates)

The AAMC Group on Student Affairs Committee on Admissions endorses 17 Premed Competencies for Entering Medical Students. Originally created in 2011 and refreshed in 2022 and 2023, the list received 2 title and definition updates from the AAMC in 2026: 'cultural humility' is now called 'self-awareness,' and 'cultural awareness' is now called 'understanding others.'

Eleven of the 17 competencies fall under Professional Competencies, while 4 cover Thinking and Reasoning and 2 cover Science. Even if you taught the applicant organic chemistry or molecular biology, committees look closely at how they communicate, take feedback, and treat teammates.

You do not need to cover all 17 competencies in one letter. Applicants will later be tested on these same traits in interviews, as shown in our UMass Chan Medical School interview guide and our MMI practice questions with answers.

AAMC 17 Premed Competencies by category
CategoryCountOfficial AAMC competenciesWhat a letter writer can observe
Professional Competencies11Commitment to Learning and Growth, Empathy and Compassion, Ethical Responsibility to Self and Others, Interpersonal Skills, Oral Communication, Reliability and Dependability, Resilience and Adaptability, Self-Awareness, Service Orientation, Teamwork and Collaboration, Understanding OthersHow the applicant seeks feedback, handles setbacks, meets deadlines, listens to patients or peers, and revises their own assumptions
Thinking and Reasoning Competencies4Critical Thinking, Quantitative Reasoning, Scientific Inquiry, Written CommunicationHow the applicant weighs competing hypotheses, analyzes data, troubleshoots failed experiments, and writes clear reports
Science Competencies2Human Behavior, Living SystemsHow the applicant applies biological, psychological, or sociocultural concepts to real problems rather than memorizing facts

A 4-part letter blueprint and before-and-after examples

The AAMC does not require a rigid template, so our team built this 4-part blueprint around the 8 official guidelines. It keeps your letter focused, readable, and grounded in observable facts.

Paragraph 1 establishes credibility. State your title, how long you have known the applicant, your role (instructor, principal investigator, clinical supervisor, or advisor), and whether you observed them directly. Paragraph 2 and Paragraph 3 deliver 2 concrete stories using the AAMC's 3-part behavioral chain: the situation, the applicant's exact behavior, and the consequence for the team, class, or patient.

Paragraph 4 gives your calibrated comparison and closing judgment. Name your denominator and group, such as undergraduate researchers you have mentored over a set number of years, explain your rationale, and state your level of support without vague hedges.

Avoid lukewarm qualifiers like 'adequate' or 'usually dependable' unless you intend to signal a concern. Cut adjectives that describe personality without proof, and check your draft so you describe male and female applicants with the same focus on initiative, analytical skill, and work ethic. Every example in the table below was written by our team, and the applicants are invented.

Invented before-and-after phrasing examples written by our team
Competency targetWeak draft (generic advocacy or recap)Strong revision (situation, behavior, consequence)
Scientific Inquiry and ResilienceMaya got an A in my biochemistry class, has a 3.92 GPA, and worked hard in my lab for 2 semesters.When our assay failed 3 weeks before a poster deadline, Maya audited 2 months of reagent logs, isolated a buffer pH drift, and rebuilt the protocol so our 4-person team presented on time.
Empathy and Oral CommunicationJordan is a compassionate, warm volunteer who always makes patients feel comfortable in our clinic.When an uninsured patient tried to leave before discharge teaching out of fear of an extra bill, Jordan paused, confirmed with the charge nurse that teaching carried no fee, and walked through the inhaler steps in plain language.
Commitment to Learning and GrowthAlex is a fast learner who improved a lot as a teaching assistant this year.After mid-semester evaluations showed students found his recitation rushed, Alex asked me to observe his Friday section, cut his slide count in half, and saw his section's quiz scores rise from the middle to the top of 8 sections.
Contextualized ComparisonSam is one of the best premed students I have ever taught and will be a great doctor.Among roughly 90 undergraduates who have completed my upper-level physiology lab over the past 5 years, Sam ranks in the top 5 for independent experimental design and reliability with shared equipment.

Uploading via the AAMC Letter Writer Portal or Interfolio

Before you open the upload screen, check 5 technical rules from the AMCAS Letter Service. Medical schools may require official institutional letterhead and the author's signature, so convert your signed document on letterhead to PDF or Microsoft Word (.doc or .docx). Confirm the file is under 5 MB and has no password protection, because AMCAS cannot process encrypted or oversized files.

Have the applicant's AMCAS Letter Request Form in front of you. Regardless of how you submit, you must include both the applicant's AAMC ID and the AMCAS Request ID printed on that form so AMCAS matches the file to the right entry.

In the AAMC Letter Writer Portal, you have 2 ways to submit. If you write many letters, register or sign in with an AAMC account. Ask students to send requests to the exact email address tied to your AAMC account so requests automatically match to your dashboard's Pending tab. If a request does not appear, use the Add Request feature or click the link in the email while logged in. You can also claim an earlier guest submission into your account.

If you spot a mistake or forgot a signature or letterhead, upload a corrected file using the exact same Request ID. AMCAS appends the new version to the existing file so medical schools can read the latest upload, because an original file cannot be deleted once AMCAS receives it. If you need live technical help with AMCAS uploads, call 202-828-0600 or email amcas@aamc.org Monday through Friday from 9 a.m. to 7 p.m. ET (closed Wednesday 3 to 5 p.m. ET). Prehealth advisors can also reach AAMC advisor support at 202-828-0950 or advisors@aamc.org from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. ET (closed Wednesday 3 to 5 p.m. ET).

AAMC Letter Writer Portal vs. Interfolio submission rules
FeatureAAMC Letter Writer PortalInterfolio
Time to mark as Received in AMCASImmediately upon upload (re-upload if status still shows Not Received)Up to 3 business days after delivery is completed
Account requirement for writersOptional: upload as a guest from the request email or sign in to an AAMC accountManaged through the applicant's Interfolio delivery workflow
Accepted file rulesPDF, .doc, or .docx, under 5 MB, not password-protectedUnder 5 MB and not password-protected
Required matching numbersApplicant AAMC ID and AMCAS Request IDApplicant AAMC ID and AMCAS Letter ID entered during Interfolio delivery
Packet or committee handlingUploaded directly by the advisor or committee officeEnter the same AMCAS Letter ID for all letters compiled into 1 packet or committee letter

Advice for clinical supervisors, physicians, and PI evaluators

Show details

Non-classroom evaluators hold an advantage when writing an AMCAS letter of evaluation. While a lecture professor mostly sees exam scores and office-hour questions, a clinic manager, volunteer coordinator, supervising physician, or lab principal investigator watches how an applicant behaves when plans change and real people are involved.

If an applicant shadowed you in clinic, be honest about the limits of your observation. Shadowing is largely passive, so do not claim clinical skill. Instead, describe how the student prepared before clinic days, respected patient privacy, adjusted to social cues in exam rooms, and asked thoughtful questions afterward.

If you supervised the applicant as a medical assistant, scribe, EMT, volunteer, or research assistant, lean on Reliability and Dependability, Teamwork and Collaboration, Ethical Responsibility, and Service Orientation. Name the shift load or team size, show how the applicant handled an unglamorous responsibility without reminders, and state the direct effect on clinic flow or lab accuracy.

  • State whether you observed the applicant directly at the bedside or bench, or indirectly through resident, nurse, or postdoc reports.
  • Replace job descriptions of your clinic or hospital with 2 specific moments where the applicant solved a problem or supported a teammate.
  • Use letterhead from your hospital, practice, agency, or university department, and include your title and contact information below your signature.

Committee letters, letter packets, and individual letters

Premedical advising offices use 1 of 3 systems for AMCAS evaluations: a Committee Letter, a Letter Packet, or Individual Letters. Talk with your prehealth advisor first to confirm which system your institution uses and whether that office transmits all letters to AMCAS.

Medical schools value committee letters because they provide an integrated institutional perspective on your readiness for medical school. According to the AAMC guidelines, committee letters combine direct observation with a synthesis of evaluations from faculty and others at your institution. Advisors who work with individual letter writers can also share the AAMC guidelines to encourage stronger focus in individual evaluations.

If you submit through Interfolio, enter your letter entries in the AMCAS application before sending them from Interfolio. Enter each Individual Letter separately in AMCAS, then match it in Interfolio using your AAMC ID and AMCAS Letter ID. Enter a Committee Letter or Letter Packet once in AMCAS. If Interfolio compiles multiple letters into 1 packet or committee letter, enter the same AMCAS Letter ID for every included letter.

The 3 AMCAS letter systems
AMCAS letter systemAMCAS entry stepInterfolio Letter ID ruleHow it functions
Committee LetterEnter once in the AMCAS applicationEnter the same AMCAS Letter ID for all letters compiled into 1 Committee LetterProvides an integrated institutional evaluation synthesizing direct observation and faculty input
Letter PacketEnter once in the AMCAS applicationEnter the same AMCAS Letter ID for all letters compiled into 1 Letter PacketTransmitted through an advising office or compiled in Interfolio under 1 AMCAS entry
Individual LettersEnter each individual letter separately in AMCASEnter the corresponding AMCAS Letter ID from each Individual Letter's Request FormSubmitted by an individual author via the AAMC Letter Writer Portal or Interfolio

AI tools, student drafts, and the applicant prep checklist

Show details

Generative AI tools now come up every cycle, and the AAMC addresses them directly in its evaluation guidelines. Letter writers who use generative AI during drafting or editing must ensure the final submitted letter reflects their own assessment, judgment, and firsthand observations of the applicant.

That same principle applies when an overburdened supervisor asks an applicant for bullet points or a rough draft. An applicant can share factual reminders of projects, dates, and outcomes, and grant permission if they want the writer to mention a personal obstacle they overcame. The evaluator should rewrite the assessment in their own voice, verify every behavioral claim against what they witnessed, and add their own peer comparison.

Clear logistics prevent 5 MB upload errors, missing letterhead, and unmatched Request IDs.

  • Link to the AAMC Guidelines for Writing a Letter of Evaluation so non-academic writers see the 17 competencies.
  • Updated CV or resume and a draft of your AMCAS personal statement for context (remind writers they do not need to repeat your GPA or MCAT).
  • Clear target date and a polite reminder that the file needs official letterhead, a signature, PDF or Word format under 5 MB, and no password.

Practice question

Which of your letter writers knows how you work under pressure best, and what specific moment would they describe?

See an example answer

My clinic nurse manager, Sarah Alvarez, saw me handle pressure up close during my 18 months as a Saturday medical assistant at our federally qualified health center. Last January, 2 staff members called out with flu on a morning with 42 scheduled patients. Instead of waiting for instructions, I arrived 20 minutes early, prepped the vaccine fridge logs and point-of-care strep kits, and proposed splitting rooming duties by hallway so the one float nurse did not waste time crossing the clinic. Midway through the morning, I noticed I had entered a blood pressure reading onto the wrong sibling's intake sheet. I flagged it immediately to Sarah before the physician opened the chart, corrected both records, and started double-checking dates of birth out loud at the cuff step. She saw both how I keep a team moving on a short-staffed shift and how I own an error right away without making excuses. Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented.

Open-file interviewers often check whether your spoken stories match the tone of your letters. Naming one supervisor, a concrete situation, an owned mistake, and the exact fix mirrors the AAMC's situation, behavior, and consequence model without sounding rehearsed.

Frequently asked questions

Can an applicant read their AMCAS letter of evaluation?

No. Under no circumstances will the AMCAS program provide applicants access to letters of evaluation. Logged-in authors using the AAMC Letter Writer Portal can view their own history of requests and submitted documents.

How long does AMCAS take to mark a letter as received?

Letters uploaded through the AAMC Letter Writer Portal are marked as received immediately. Letters delivered through Interfolio can take up to 3 business days to show as received in AMCAS.

What file format and size does the AAMC Letter Writer Portal accept?

The portal accepts PDF and Microsoft Word (.doc or .docx) files. Your document must be under 5 MB and cannot be password-protected, and medical schools may require official letterhead and your signature.

Can letter writers use ChatGPT or generative AI to help write an AMCAS letter?

Yes, for drafting or editing, provided you follow the AAMC's rule. The final submitted letter must reflect your own assessment, judgment, and firsthand observations of the applicant.

How do I fix an AMCAS letter uploaded without a signature or letterhead?

Ask the letter writer to upload the corrected version using the exact same AMCAS Request ID. The new file will be added to the existing entry because the original document cannot be removed once AMCAS receives it.

Do letter writers need an AAMC account to upload a letter?

No. Authors can click the link in the applicant's request email and upload as a guest, or sign in with an AAMC account to track pending and completed requests on a dashboard.

Sources