Confetto

GME Virtual Interview Best Practices: AAMC Findings

Practice the med school interview now

Free, no sign-up to start.

GME community findings on virtual interview best practices from the AAMC. Compare virtual, hybrid, and in-person formats, structured scoring, and prep steps.

Practice the med school interview now

Free, no sign-up to start.

The AAMC recommends that residency and fellowship programs conduct interviews virtually to reduce applicant costs, widen access, and cut carbon emissions. Across AAMC surveys and early 2023 focus groups, 90% of medical school applicants preferred virtual or optional virtual interviews, and over 70% of surveyed plastic surgery residency applicants missed seven or more days of school for in-person interviews. Best practices center on separating recruitment from assessment, using structured questions across 3 to 5 competencies, and blinding selection committees to interview format when hybrid options exist. Sources: AAMC: Interviews in GME: Where Do We Go From Here? (Updated June 2024), AAMC: Best Practices for Creating and Conducting Residency Program Interviews, AAMC: Developing Structured Residency and Fellowship Interviews. Last checked November 11, 2026.

Five AAMC findings driving virtual GME interviews

In its June 2024 guidance on Graduate Medical Education (GME) interviews, the Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) recommends virtual interviews for residency and fellowship programs, while noting that individual programs may choose different approaches based on their mission, goals, and context.

If you are preparing to answer structured residency interview questions on camera, Confetto runs AI mock interviews with real-time follow-up probes and rubric-based feedback. Start your free week.

The AAMC's UME and GME Interview Working Group summarized five findings that explain why virtual interviewing remains the recommended standard across academic medicine.

  • Financial barriers: Interview travel costs range from hundreds to thousands of dollars. In an AAMC survey of medical school applicants, 96% agreed or strongly agreed they saved money with virtual interviews, and 85% named reduced financial impact as the top advantage.
  • Applicant preference: In early 2023 AAMC focus groups, residency applicants favored virtual interviews because they reduced travel time and cost, and allowed them to interview from a familiar space with lower stress. Among surveyed medical school applicants, 90% preferred a virtual format or the option of a virtual format.
  • Time away from clinical training: Travel pulls fourth-year students away from clinical rotations. In a survey of plastic surgery residency applicants cited by the AAMC, over 70% missed seven or more days of medical school to attend in-person interviews.
  • Separating assessment from recruitment: Mixing casual recruitment visits with formal evaluation can introduce irrelevant details and bias into scoring. Conducting the interview separately from social events and campus visits keeps evaluations fairer.
  • Carbon footprint reduction: The US healthcare sector generates 8% to 10% of national greenhouse gas emissions and 25% of global greenhouse gas emissions. Virtual interviews support academic medicine's commitment to lowering travel-related emissions.

Virtual-only vs. hybrid vs. in-person formats

When you apply to residency or design your program's interview season, you will see programs weigh their applicant pool's geography and local community setting to choose an interview format. A rural program or a program in a less well-known area may weigh in-person elements differently than a large urban program drawing mostly out-of-state applicants.

The AAMC's GME guidance outlines three formats and the steps needed to run each one fairly:

  • Virtual only: Best when many applicants are out of state or require travel, when you want scheduling flexibility, or when your program is committed to reducing its carbon footprint. To run it equitably, offer virtual recruiting activities to all applicants, set clear technology standards, and train faculty on virtual interviewing.
  • Hybrid (applicant chooses virtual or in-person): Best when you have a mix of local and out-of-state applicants, want to give applicants and faculty a choice, or need to showcase a rural or less well-known area. To protect equity, standardize procedures and interviewer training across both formats, blind the selection committee to which format you or another applicant chose, tell applicants how equity is protected, and offer virtual recruiting to everyone.
  • In-person only: Used when most applicants are local and do not need extended travel, or when a program needs to showcase a rural or less well-known area. Programs choosing this route should offer financial support or stipends to applicants who need help covering travel and accommodations.

Why structured interviews outperform unstructured conversations

A core finding in the AAMC's residency selection guidance is that how questions are asked matters as much as the video platform you use. The AAMC divides residency fit into two parts from organizational psychology: person-organization fit (applicant-program fit, covering your values, culture, and learning style) and person-job fit (applicant-specialty fit, covering the competencies, skills, and attributes you need to succeed in residency).

Unstructured interviews rely on flexible questions with no standardized scoring. According to literature summarized by the AAMC, research has found no association between unstructured faculty interview scores and Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) milestone ratings. Unstructured conversations are also prone to interviewer bias, show poor inter-rater reliability, and create openings for inappropriate or illegal questions.

Structured interviews use predefined questions and established scoring rubrics for every candidate. In studies cited by the AAMC, structured interview scores predicted first-year residents' end-of-year performance in professional competency, patient care, and communication skills. They also reduce race, age, and gender bias, help increase workforce diversity, and show benefits that may be even more pronounced in an online format.

If you worry that structured protocols will feel stiff on camera, the data is reassuring. In a residency program study highlighted by the AAMC where faculty initially feared structured interviews would hurt conversational flow, all 12 participating faculty members found the structured system easy to use and score. Faculty reported uncovering important past behaviors they would have missed in an unstructured chat, and applicants reported that the structure did not interfere with faculty interaction.

How to build and score a structured virtual residency interview

The AAMC recommends evaluating 3 to 5 professionally or specialty-relevant competencies during your residency selection interview. These should represent skills you need on day one of residency, not skills you will be taught later. Technical medical knowledge should be left out of the interview because it is better measured through your educational history and exam scores.

In the AAMC's sample competency-interview mapping plan, a program runs 3 structured interviews (Interviews A, B, and C) and evaluates 4 competencies per session across 5 ACGME competencies. By our calculation from the AAMC sample mapping table, 3 of the 5 competencies (Patient Care and Procedural Skills, Practice-based Learning and Improvement, and Systems-based Practice) are scored in every room. Professionalism is scored in 2 rooms, and Interpersonal and Communication Skills is scored in 1 room.

Whether you are building an interview guide for your program or preparing to be scored against one, the AAMC recommends nine steps to standardize questions and rubrics:

  • Identify the key requirements of the residency position.
  • Select 3 to 5 target competencies to assess across your interview rooms.
  • Write behavioral questions (asking what you did in a past situation) or situational questions (asking what you would do in a hypothetical residency scenario) for each competency.
  • Invite people who interact with medical students to review the questions and discuss how applicants might answer.
  • Draft behavioral examples to anchor each point on a 3-to-7-point rating scale, reflecting real performance expectations for a first-year resident.
  • Review all questions and anchors for cultural appropriateness and alignment with program goals.
  • Document how the target competencies and questions were chosen.
  • Train a pilot group of 3 to 5 interviewers on how to use the structured guide and rating scale.
  • Train all remaining interviewers on the guide, probing rules, and rating scale before interview season starts.

How content and evaluation choices affect fairness and applicant reactions

Not every structural rule affects you the same way on interview day. Adapting research from Campion et al. and Levashina et al., the AAMC outlines how 15 specific content and evaluation choices change reliability, validity, fairness, and how applicants feel about the interview. You can read more about how multi-rater formats work in our guide to MMI practice questions with answers.

By our calculation from the AAMC's 15-component structure findings, only 2 of the 15 components produce a positive effect across validity, fairness, and applicant reactions at the same time: asking questions that are professionally relevant or specialty-specific, and training interviewers.

Here is how the AAMC summarizes the effects of those structural choices on your interview experience:

  • Positive across validity, fairness, and applicant reactions: Asking professionally relevant or specialty-specific questions, and training interviewers (which also improves reliability).
  • Positive for reliability, validity, and fairness (insufficient research on applicant reactions): Asking all applicants questions covering the same topics, using behavioral or situational questions, using defined rating scales, taking detailed notes, and using formulas to create total interview scores.
  • Improves reliability or fairness, but hurts applicant reactions: Limiting follow-up probing questions, giving interviewers no access to your application file before or during the session, using a longer interview, using multiple interviewers at once, or not allowing you to ask questions.

Using STAR probing questions during the interview

Show details

To keep interviews conversational without losing structure, the AAMC advises your interviewer to open by telling you the length of the session, noting that both of you may take notes, and explaining that your answers should focus on one specific story covering the Situation or Task, the Action you took, and the Result (the STAR method).

When you leave out part of a story or speak in generalities, trained interviewers use targeted STAR probes to draw out the missing piece. Expect these follow-ups if your initial answer is incomplete:

  • Situation or Task probes (Behavioral): What factors led up to the situation? Could you or anyone else have prevented it? What did you decide was the most critical issue to address?
  • Situation or Task probes (Situational): What do you consider the most critical issue in this scenario? What other issues concern you?
  • Action probes (Behavioral): How did you respond? What was the first thing you did? What was the most important factor you considered?
  • Action probes (Situational): What would you say? What is the first thing you would do, and what other actions could you take?
  • Result probes (Behavioral): What was the outcome? Is there anything you would have said or done differently? Were there any benefits from the situation?
  • Result probes (Situational): How do you think your action would be received? What would you do if it was not received well?

Conveying residency program culture on screen

The hardest part of virtual interviewing is judging what daily life in the hospital and city actually feels like without buying a plane ticket. The AAMC points to three channels programs build out so you can evaluate person-organization fit from home.

First, check the program website for updated deadlines, contact details, leadership and faculty profiles, rotation schedules, current resident bios, research publications, mission statements, and videos showing the hospital facilities, nurses, staff, and town. Third, attend structured virtual social events that are separate from your formal evaluation. Good formats include small virtual breakout rooms, open discussion sessions with preformatted topics, anonymous question surveys for sensitive topics, and resident-led social hours with no faculty present so you can ask candid questions.

Second, check the social media platforms the program uses to show residents' daily lives and highlight its commitment to diversity and inclusion. Citing research by Strumpf et al., the AAMC notes that underrepresented in medicine (URiM) applicants place significant importance on an institution's social media presence when making decisions. The AAMC highlights four digital substitutes you can look for on social media to answer common in-person questions:

  • Do attending physicians provide intraoperative teaching? Look for posts showing attendings and residents working together in the operating room on open and microscopy cases.
  • Does the institution support research? Look for posts by the program and attendings highlighting resident publications, clinical conferences, and podium presentations.
  • Is there a community among residents and time for life outside work? Look for photos and videos of residents together at dinners, sporting events, or with their families.
  • What is it like to live in the program's city? Look for resident posts highlighting local parks, dining, and sporting venues, plus point-of-view 'day in the life' videos.

Applicant and interviewer preparation checklist (our plan from AAMC guidelines)

You will encounter two virtual formats defined by the AAMC: Live Virtual Interviews (real-time video calls with one or more interviewers) and Asynchronous Virtual Interviews (on-demand recorded webcam responses to text or prerecorded video prompts, similar to the formats covered in our Kira Talent guide).

We organized the AAMC's technical, environmental, and privacy guidance into a step-by-step checklist for your interview week.

  • Confirm the format early: Check your invitation for whether the interview is live or asynchronous, the video platform, the number of interviewers, the length of each session, and any competencies listed.
  • Use a computer or tablet, not a phone: The AAMC recommends a computer or tablet over a mobile phone for stability and so incoming phone calls cannot interrupt your answer.
  • Test your connection and hardware: Run a speed check at SpeedTest.net. If Wi-Fi is slow, switch to a wired Ethernet cable or reserve a private room at your medical school or local library.
  • Set your lighting and camera angle: Sit in a private, quiet room with the light source or lamp in front of you, never directly behind you. Put your camera at eye level and look into the lens rather than at the screen.
  • Clear notifications and plug in: Close every other program on your device to silence alerts, keep your charger plugged into an outlet, and give your interviewer a backup phone number before starting.
  • Map one strong story per competency: Review your CV and list concrete clinical and nonclinical stories showing your highest level of proficiency. In the interview, tell one detailed story using the Situation, Action, and Result structure rather than speaking in generalities.
  • Protect patient and colleague privacy: Never share patient names, locations, diagnoses, or combinations of details that could identify someone. Refer to any patient simply as 'the patient.' If a story shows a colleague in a negative light, omit their name, title, location, and distinguishing details.
  • Run a recorded trial call: Record yourself answering practice prompts on the exact device and software you will use to check your eye contact, audio quality, and posture.

Practice structured residency question and example answer

Below is an official situational question from the AAMC's Sample Structured Interview Guide for the ACGME Professionalism competency, paired with a model response written by our team that follows the AAMC's STAR probing criteria.

Practice structured residency interviews out loud

To practice behavioral and situational residency prompts out loud and get instant scoring on your structure, use Confetto's AI mock interviewer. Start your free week.

Practice question

Imagine that you are part of a medical team caring for a young patient. You learn that one of your fellow residents inadvertently provided a higher dose of a medication than intended to the patient. It will not have any substantial health consequences. What would you do in this situation? (Source: AAMC Sample Structured Interview Guide, Professionalism)

See an example answer

Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. "The most critical issue here is patient safety and transparency, alongside supporting my coresident in reporting an honest mistake. Even when a higher dose appears unlikely to cause substantial harm, a young patient still needs appropriate clinical monitoring, and the care team and family deserve accurate information. First, I would check on the patient right away with my fellow resident to confirm their vital signs and clinical status are stable. Next, I would speak privately with my coresident. I would keep my tone calm and supportive, acknowledge how stressful medication errors are during intern year, and encourage them to report the dosing error to our senior resident and attending physician immediately. If my coresident felt hesitant or overwhelmed, I would offer to walk over and tell the senior resident together so we could update the attending, log the event in the hospital's safety reporting system, and disclose the error honestly to the patient's family. If my coresident still refused to report it, I would explain that patient safety requires me to let our senior resident know myself. Handling it openly protects the patient, preserves trust with the family, and helps the unit spot system issues that caused the mix-up."

It directly answers all three AAMC situational STAR probes: it names the most critical issue first (patient safety and transparency), walks through specific actions in order (checking the patient, speaking privately with the coresident, escalating to the senior and attending), and explains what to do if the initial conversation is not received well.

Frequently asked questions

Does the AAMC still recommend virtual interviews for residency and fellowship programs?

Yes. The AAMC recommends that residency and fellowship programs use a virtual interview format to reduce applicant costs, widen access, improve equity, and lower carbon emissions, while recognizing that individual programs may choose other formats for sound reasons.

How can residency programs prevent bias in hybrid interviews?

The AAMC advises programs offering a hybrid format to standardize questions and interviewer training across both formats, blind the selection committee to whether an applicant interviewed virtually or in person, and offer virtual recruiting activities to all applicants.

How many competencies should a structured residency interview evaluate?

The AAMC recommends selecting 3 to 5 professionally or specialty-relevant competencies that applicants should have at the start of residency, leaving out technical medical knowledge since that is better assessed through test scores and educational history.

What is the difference between live and asynchronous virtual residency interviews?

Live virtual interviews connect you with an interviewer in real time over video conferencing. Asynchronous virtual interviews have no interviewer present, and you record webcam answers to text or prerecorded video questions for reviewers to watch later.

How should residency applicants protect patient privacy during behavioral interview answers?

The AAMC instructs applicants never to share names, locations, diagnoses, or other details that could identify a patient or a colleague portrayed negatively. Always refer to the patient simply as 'the patient.'

Sources