Preference Signaling Part 3: ERAS & Match Statistics
Free, no sign-up to start.
See how preference signaling affected residency application volume, signal concentration, and interview conversion across Small, Large, and Two-Tier models.
Free, no sign-up to start.
According to the AAMC, preference signaling coincided with drops in average applications per applicant and per program, with the largest declines in Large Signal and Two-Tier specialties driven mainly by MD and DO applicants. Signals are not spread evenly: in Small Signal specialties, 24% of signals went to 10% of programs, compared to 18% in Large Signal specialties. Because signaled applicants make up an average of 47% of a program's pool in Orthopedics and 45% in Dermatology, the AAMC notes that programs receiving signals from more applicants than they interview may not need to look beyond signaled applicants to fill their interview spots. Sources: AAMC: Preliminary Program Signaling Data and Their Impact on Residency Selection, AAMC: ERAS Statistics and Specialty Dashboards, AAMC: Program Signaling for the 2027 MyERAS Application Season. Last checked November 11, 2026.
On this page
- The three program signaling approaches and their goals
- How applicants use signals across demographics and school types
- How preference signaling affected ERAS application volume
- Signal concentration: where applicants send their signals
- How signaling affects interview invitations and conversion
- Where to find Pre-Match ERAS dashboards and Post-Match NRMP statistics
- 2027 ERAS season signal allocations and application fee math
- Checklist: how to use signaling statistics to plan your list and interviews
- Practice question: explaining your preference signal in a residency interview
- Practice question
- Frequently asked questions
- Sources
The three program signaling approaches and their goals
Program signals let you express genuine interest in a residency or fellowship program at the time you submit your MyERAS application. The AAMC states that signals are meant to serve as one of many data points in holistic review when programs decide whom to invite for an interview, and that an applicant's interest can change later in the cycle after interviews or life events.
Specialties use three distinct approaches to program signaling, and the AAMC's preliminary program signaling analysis (published October 24, 2023) outlines how each model trades off signal concentration against applicant flexibility. The Small Signal approach focuses on top programs only, which helps identify true top choices and guards against overweighting signals in review, though it can concentrate signals in a small number of programs and may not represent all preferences. The Large Signal approach aims to distribute signals more evenly and encourages applicants to think carefully before applying to non-signaled programs, but it can dilute signal value and tempt programs to overweight signals. The Two-Tier Signal approach (Gold and Silver) combines both goals by using Gold signals to identify top preferences and Silver signals to offer flexibility and wider distribution, though it can also tempt programs to overweight signals and is harder to explain.
Once those signals turn into interview invitations, you need to be ready to explain why you chose each program. Confetto is an AI mock interviewer for residency and medical school interviews that runs structured, traditional, and MMI practice sessions with follow-up questions based on what you say. Start your free week.
How applicants use signals across demographics and school types
Across all three signaling approaches, the AAMC found that most applicants used the maximum number of available signals in their specialty. Usage was consistent across demographic groups, with no differences in the number of signals sent by applicant race, ethnicity, or gender.
Differences did appear across medical school types in specialties with larger signal allotments. On average, International Medical Graduate (IMG) and DO applicants sent fewer signals than their MD peers in Large Signal specialties, and fewer Silver signals in Two-Tier specialties. According to the AAMC, this difference is largely explained by application volume: IMG and DO applicants applied to fewer programs on average in those specific specialties.
The AAMC also advises programs not to misinterpret missing signal responses or use a missing signal to filter or screen out an applicant, noting that some applicants may have skipped the program signaling section when completing their application.
- Maximum usage: Most applicants use every signal their specialty gives them, regardless of whether the specialty uses a Small, Large, or Two-Tier model.
- Demographic parity: The AAMC observed no differences in signal counts sent by applicant gender, race, or ethnicity.
- Home and away rotations: For the 2027 ERAS season, the AAMC advises all applicant types (MD, DO, and IMG) to signal the programs they are most interested in, including home programs and away rotation sites.
How preference signaling affected ERAS application volume
One of the central questions around preference signaling is whether giving applicants a set number of signals reduces over-application. In its analysis of application data pulled in October 2023, the AAMC reported a notable drop in the average number of applications across many participating specialties.
Large Signal and Two-Tier specialties recorded the largest declines in both average applications submitted per applicant and average applications received per program. Some Small Signal specialties also experienced substantial drops in application volume.
Those declines were driven primarily by changes in MD and DO applicant behavior. During the same period, IMG applications continued to rise gradually. The AAMC notes that this divergence helps explain why the largest overall drops showed up in Large Signal and certain Two-Tier specialties, which historically have lower concentrations of IMG applicants. The AAMC also cautions that more data and research are needed before attributing volume drops to the signaling model alone.
Signal concentration: where applicants send their signals
Just as applications cluster at certain institutions, preference signals are not distributed uniformly across residency programs. For three consecutive years of AAMC tracking, some programs received a much larger share of signals than others, which changes how individual program directors weigh a signal within their applicant pool.
Small Signal specialties saw the heaviest clustering at the top. In the AAMC's analysis, an average of 24% of all signals went to just 10% of programs in Small Signal specialties. By contrast, Large Signal specialties spread signals more widely, with an average of 18% of signals going to 10% of programs.
Two-Tier specialties combined both patterns. Gold signals clustered near the rate of Small Signal specialties, with 22% of Gold signals going to 10% of programs, while Silver signals spread out at the exact rate of Large Signal specialties, with 18% of Silver signals going to 10% of programs.
How signaling affects interview invitations and conversion
The share of a program's applicant pool that arrives with a signal attached varies sharply by signaling model. According to the AAMC, the average percentage of a program's applicants who signaled that program reached 47% in Orthopedics and 40% in Otolaryngology (both Large Signal specialties), and 45% in Dermatology and 25% in Obstetrics and Gynecology (both Two-Tier specialties). In Small Signal specialties, that share was much smaller, averaging 10% in Pediatrics and 13% in Emergency Medicine.
By our calculation from the AAMC's specialty percentages, an average Orthopedics program sees a signal on nearly half of its applications (47%), which is 4.7 times the average rate in Pediatrics (10%) and 3.6 times the average rate in Emergency Medicine (13%).
This gap directly shapes how programs select interviewees. When a program receives signals from a high percentage of its applicants, or from more applicants than it typically interviews, the AAMC notes that program directors do not need to look beyond the signaled pool to fill their interview spots and may be tempted to treat a signal as a requirement for an interview invitation. As a result, signal-to-interview conversion rates are high across participating specialties, and highest where signals make up a large share of the applicant pool.
Where to find Pre-Match ERAS dashboards and Post-Match NRMP statistics
Show details
When you review residency statistics, keep the boundary between ERAS data and NRMP Match data clear. The AAMC states on its ERAS Statistics page that all ERAS data is Pre-Match only and excludes Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) activity. Beginning with the 2026 publication of the Historical Specialty-Specific Data Tables, the AAMC also revised those historical tables (covering the 2022 to 2026 seasons) to include only pre-SOAP applicants, whereas earlier publications included SOAP participants. Only the Cross-Specialty Applicant Data reports include SOAP application counts.
To track Pre-Match application, signal, and interview statistics, the AAMC maintains three interactive dashboards on its ERAS Statistics page, defining each ERAS season as running from the beginning of June through May 31 annually. For Post-Match statistics, such as filled positions, rank order list outcomes, and match rates, the AAMC directs applicants and programs to the National Resident Matching Program (NRMP), which operates as a separate entity from ERAS.
- ERAS Applicant and Application Volume Dashboard: Shows applicant and application counts across the current season and the four most recent prior seasons, updated the first week of every month (paused May 31 until the July cycle opens). Includes a Point-in-Time filter to compare the Latest Day in Cycle or End of Cycle.
- ERAS Program Signals Dashboard: Tracks program signal trends across specialties and application types since the 2024 ERAS season, refreshed once a month.
- ERAS Specialty Program Signaling to Interview Dashboard: Built with interview data provided by Thalamus, this dashboard tracks signal-to-interview trends across participating specialties and application types and is refreshed once a month between December and May.
- Residency Explorer Tool: Allows applicants to look up individual residency programs' interview invitation data from the prior cycle alongside program characteristics.
2027 ERAS season signal allocations and application fee math
For the 2027 ERAS season, 29 residency specialties, 17 July-cycle fellowship specialties, and 9 December-cycle fellowship specialties participate in ERAS program signaling. To register for MyERAS, you first obtain a one-time ERAS token from your Designated Dean's Office: U.S. medical schools for MD and DO seniors and graduates, the Educational Commission for Foreign Medical Graduates (ECFMG, at www.ecfmg.org/eras) for IMGs and Canadian medical graduates who graduated on or after July 1, 2025, and CaRMS (at https://www.carms.ca) for Canadian medical graduates who graduated prior to July 1, 2025. Individual programs in participating specialties are automatically opted in when they register by their cycle deadline. Those deadlines are July 1, 2026 at 9 a.m. ET for July fellowships, September 2, 2026 at 9 a.m. ET for September residencies, and November 12, 2026 at 9 a.m. ET for December fellowships. A program can still opt out in the Program Director's WorkStation (PDWS). Across the 29 participating residency specialties on the AAMC's 2027 schedule, single-tier allotments range from 2 signals (Internal Medicine/Psychiatry and Neurodevelopmental Disabilities) and 5 signals (Family Medicine, Pediatrics, and Pathology) up to 25 signals (Neurological Surgery and Otolaryngology) and 30 signals (Orthopedic Surgery and Urology). Two-Tier residency allotments include 3 Gold and 12 Silver (15 total) in Internal Medicine and Vascular Surgery (Integrated), 5 Gold and 10 Silver in Anesthesiology, 6 Gold and 9 Silver in Diagnostic Radiology, and 3 Gold and 25 Silver (28 total) in Dermatology.
Beginning with the 2027 ERAS season, the AAMC also introduced a simplified residency application fee structure: $11 per program for the first 1 to 30 programs in a specialty, and $30 per program for 31 or more programs in that specialty. Pricing resets if you apply to an additional specialty.
Combined with Large Signal and Two-Tier allocations, the 30-program fee tier creates a clear financial boundary. By our calculation from the 2027 AAMC fee schedule and signal tables, if you apply only to the programs you can signal in Orthopedic Surgery (30 signals) or Urology (30 signals), you pay $330 in ERAS residency fees (30 programs at $11 each). Applying to 30 more non-signaled programs in that same specialty costs an extra $900 (30 programs at $30 each), raising your specialty total to $1,230 for applications that carry no signal.
Checklist: how to use signaling statistics to plan your list and interviews
Use this six-step plan, written by our team around the AAMC's signaling data and 2027 ERAS rules, to allocate your signals and prepare for the interview questions they trigger.
- Check your specialty's model and total signals first: Confirm whether you have a small single-tier allotment (such as 5 in Pediatrics or Family Medicine), a large single-tier allotment (such as 25 in Otolaryngology or 30 in Orthopedic Surgery), or a two-tier split (such as 3 Gold and 12 Silver in Internal Medicine).
- Confirm individual program participation in MyERAS: Because individual programs can opt out in the PDWS and ERAS does not issue refunds for applications sent to nonparticipating programs, check the Program Signal box on the ERAS Participating Specialties and Programs page before you assign signals.
- Include your home and away rotation programs if you want to interview there: Follow the AAMC's guidance to signal your most interested programs regardless of whether they are home institutions or away rotations.
- Avoid piling every signal into the same top 10% of programs: Remember that 24% of Small signals and 22% of Gold signals cluster at just 10% of programs. Use Residency Explorer to compare your profile against prior-cycle interview invitation data so your signals go to programs where your application is competitive.
- Weigh the $30 fee jump in Large Signal and Two-Tier specialties: In specialties where 25 to 30 signals cover your realistic program list, remember that applications 1 to 30 cost $11 each while applications 31 and above jump to $30 each and carry no signal.
- Prepare a specific spoken answer for every program you signal: Signaling gets your file noticed at the interview invitation stage, and once you are in the Zoom room, interviewers will want to hear the real reason behind that signal.
Practice question: explaining your preference signal in a residency interview
Signaling a program tells the selection committee you were interested when you submitted MyERAS in September, and your interview is where you prove that interest is grounded in specifics. If you are preparing for scenario or behavioral stations alongside traditional interviews, review our MMI practice questions with answers to see how structured responses work under a timer.
To rehearse your own program-specific answers out loud and get immediate rubric-based feedback on your pacing and detail, try Confetto's AI mock interviews. Start your free week.
Practice question
You sent our Internal Medicine program one of your three Gold signals. What specifically drew you to put us in your top tier, and how does our training fit what you want to do after residency?
See an example answer
Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. "I used one of my three Gold signals here because I want to train at a safety-net county hospital with a strong inpatient heart failure service and a dedicated resident continuity clinic for Spanish-speaking patients. During my third-year medicine clerkship and my sub-internship, the weeks I felt most useful were caring for patients who came in with decompensated heart failure and had no primary care follow-up after discharge. For the past two years, I helped run hypertension and medication-reconciliation visits at our student-run clinic, and I saw how much readmission risk drops when a resident can explain a diuretic plan in the patient's own language and see that same patient two weeks later in clinic. When I looked into your program's X+Y schedule and spoke with your chief resident at the September open house, it was clear that residents here actually build their own bilingual continuity panels rather than just rotating through. My family also lives forty minutes away, so this is the community where I plan to stay and practice hospital medicine after residency."
It names three concrete reasons for the Gold signal in under 90 seconds: a clinical track that matches a real rotation experience, a specific scheduling and clinic structure learned from the program, and a clear geographic reason to stay after training.
Frequently asked questions
How did preference signaling affect the number of residency applications submitted?
According to the AAMC, average applications per applicant and average applications received per program dropped across many signaling specialties, with the largest declines in Large Signal and Two-Tier specialties. These drops were driven mainly by MD and DO applicants applying to fewer programs, while IMG application volume continued to rise gradually.
Do MD, DO, and IMG applicants use preference signals differently?
The AAMC found that most applicants use the maximum number of available signals, with no differences by gender, race, or ethnicity. On average, DO and IMG applicants sent fewer signals in Large Signal specialties and fewer Silver signals in Two-Tier specialties, largely because they applied to fewer programs in those specialties.
How concentrated are preference signals among top residency programs?
In the AAMC's analysis, an average of 24% of signals went to 10% of programs in Small Signal specialties, compared to 18% in Large Signal specialties. In Two-Tier specialties, 22% of Gold signals went to 10% of programs, while Silver signals were spread more widely at 18%.
What percentage of a program's applicants send a preference signal?
It depends on the specialty's signaling approach. The AAMC reported that the average share of applicants signaling a program was 47% in Orthopedics, 45% in Dermatology, 40% in Otolaryngology, and 25% in OBGYN, compared to 13% in Emergency Medicine and 10% in Pediatrics.
Should I send a preference signal to my home program or away rotation sites?
Yes, if they are among the programs you are most interested in attending. The AAMC advises all MD, DO, and IMG applicants to signal the programs they are most interested in regardless of whether they are home institutions or away rotations.
Does the AAMC ERAS signaling data include NRMP Match rates and SOAP outcomes?
No. ERAS statistics dashboards contain Pre-Match data only and exclude Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) activity, while Post-Match fill and match rates are published separately by the NRMP.
Sources
- AAMC: Preliminary Program Signaling Data and Their Impact on Residency Selection
- AAMC: ERAS Statistics and Specialty Dashboards
- AAMC: Program Signaling for the 2027 MyERAS Application Season
- AAMC: Program Signaling for the 2027 ERAS Season (Institutions)
- AAMC: Fees for the 2027 ERAS Season
- AAMC: Supplemental ERAS Application Data and Reports
- AAMC: Apply to Residencies with the ERAS System
- AAMC: FAQs for ERAS Residency Applicants
- ECFMG: ERAS Support Services for International Medical Graduates
- CaRMS: Canadian Resident Matching Service (Designated Dean's Office)