A 9-year-old with measles begs you for the vaccine. The parents still refuse. Do you vaccinate?
No. She already has measles, so the vaccine cannot help her now, and at nine she cannot consent over her parents. Treat her, isolate her, notify public health and trace contacts. Then talk with the parents about protecting her siblings, and reassure her.
How a 90-point answer starts
The detail I'd catch first is that the vaccine wouldn't help this child now. She already has measles, and the vaccine prevents infection, it doesn't treat it.
See the full answer, the 50 and 70 versions, and what moves each score up.
Practice this question freeSample answer outline
- Short answer: no, you do not vaccinate against the parents' wishes, and the vaccine would not help this child now anyway. Spot the clinical detail: a child who already has measles won't be helped by the measles vaccine now. The priority is treating them, isolating them and protecting contacts.
- Explain the frame: a 9-year-old can't consent alone; parents decide unless their choice puts the child at serious risk.
- Handle the vaccine refusal with curiosity, not judgment: ask open questions about what worries the parents, listen fully, then correct misinformation with plain language. The illness is a natural moment to revisit vaccines for the child's siblings and the child's other vaccines.
- Keep the child's voice in the room: acknowledge their fear and explain what will happen.
- Notify public health as required.
What makes it score well, and the mistakes that cost points, are in the app with this question.
How to approach ethical dilemma questions
- Clarify the facts and what you would want to know before acting.
- Name who is affected and the principles in tension: autonomy, doing good, avoiding harm, fairness, confidentiality.
- Walk through realistic options, starting with the least drastic.
- Choose a course of action, explain why, and say who you would involve.
About this question
- Type
- Ethical dilemma
- Format
- MMI station
- Level
- Advanced
- What it tests
- Autonomy and consent, Communication
Related questions
- A patient with Down syndrome is pregnant and wants to keep the baby. Her mother and husband want her to have an abortion. What do you do?
- A Jehovah's Witness patient refuses a blood transfusion they need to survive. What do you do?
- A family begs you not to tell their grandmother she has cancer because "it'll kill her faster." What do you do?
- How would you explain informed consent to a minor who disagrees with their guardian?
- A patient insists on a cosmetic procedure you believe is unnecessary and could damage healthy teeth. They've already paid in full. What do you do?
- Genetic testing shows the husband isn't the father. The wife begs you not to tell him. Then he asks you if anything came back abnormal. What do you say?
Say it out loud
Confetto's AI interviewer asks you this question, follows up like a real interviewer and gives feedback on your answer.
Practice this question nowFree trial