APDS Task Force: GME Virtual Interviews & Holistic Review
Free, no sign-up to start.
What the APDS Task Force and AAMC recommend for General Surgery residency: holistic review, virtual or GMEC-guided interviews, 15 ERAS signals and offer rules.
Free, no sign-up to start.
The Association of Program Directors in Surgery (APDS) Task Force strongly recommends holistic application review for General Surgery residency selection, advising programs to deemphasize numerical USMLE Step 1 and COMLEX Level 1 scores and disclose how Step 2 and Level 2 scores are considered. While recognizing AAMC advocacy for virtual interviews, the 2024-2025 APDS Task Force recommends that each program choose its interview format in consultation with its Graduate Medical Education Committee (GMEC) and consider all applicants equally regardless of format. General Surgery applicants receive 15 ERAS program signals through the 2027 ERAS cycle, and programs must give candidates at least 48 hours to respond to interview offers. Sources: APDS Task Force General Surgery Application and Interview Recommendations (2024-2025 PDF), AAMC ERAS 2027 Participating Specialties & Programs (Surgery), AAMC: Interviews in GME: Where Do We Go From Here?. Last checked November 11, 2026.
On this page
- What the APDS Task Force recommends at a glance
- Holistic review and standardized test scores in General Surgery
- GME virtual interviews vs. in-person formats: APDS and AAMC guidance
- Why the AAMC recommends virtual GME interviews (5 key considerations)
- How to use your 15 General Surgery program signals
- Interview offer dates, the 48-hour rule, and NRMP Section 6.2
- What structured residency interviews test (and how to prepare)
- Applicant checklist for virtual General Surgery interviews (our plan)
- Practice question
- Frequently asked questions
- Sources
What the APDS Task Force recommends at a glance
The task force (chaired by Jennifer Serfin, MD, with 24 additional surgical educators on the 2024-2025 roster) updated its interview format position and expanded preference signaling alongside the AAMC and the Organization of Program Director Associations (OPDA).
Here are the official APDS Task Force recommendations for the 2024-2025 recruitment cycle and the 2027 ERAS participating specialty updates, side by side with what they mean for your application and interview day. To practice structured behavioral and situational residency questions out loud before your first invitation arrives, Confetto runs AI mock interviews with real-time follow-up questions. Start your free week.
| Area | Official APDS & AAMC / NRMP Rule | What It Means for You |
|---|---|---|
| Application review | Holistic review is strongly recommended. Numerical USMLE Step 1 and COMLEX Level 1 scores (when available) should be deemphasized. | Programs evaluate your experiences and attributes alongside test scores and must disclose how Step 2 and Level 2 are used. |
| Program signaling | 15 signals in General Surgery (confirmed through the 2027 ERAS cycle). Use all 15 to indicate your top 15 programs. | Talk to program directors at your home institution and away rotations before finalizing your 15 signals. |
| Interview format | The AAMC recommends virtual interviews. APDS recommends each program consult its GMEC to choose its format and evaluate all applicants equally. | Expect mostly virtual interviews, though individual programs may select virtual, hybrid, or in-person formats with GMEC guidance. |
| First-round offer window | For 2024-2025, first-round offers were set between Wednesday, October 23, 2024, and November 1, 2024 (not prior to October 23). | Programs making offers outside the designated window are asked to be transparent with applicants. |
| Offer response window | Minimum of 48 hours to respond before a program extends the slot to another candidate (APDS and NRMP Section 6.2). | You do not need to accept an invitation within minutes, because your slot is protected for at least 48 hours. |
| Slot-to-invitation ratio | 1:1 ratio. Programs may only send invitations equal to available interview slots (e.g., 20 slots = 20 invitations). | Waitlist movement happens in waves after applicants decline or cancel, starting 48 hours after the initial release. |
| Rescheduling and cancellation | Programs must disclose cancellation policies and give reasonable notice (such as 1 to 2 weeks per NRMP Section 6.2) if canceling or rescheduling. | Read each program's invitation email for its exact cancellation lead time and response instructions. |
Holistic review and standardized test scores in General Surgery
The APDS Task Force strongly recommends holistic application review as part of the General Surgery residency selection process. Because some applicants still hold numerical USMLE Step 1 or COMLEX Level 1 scores, the task force specifies that numerical Step 1 and Level 1 scores should remain deemphasized.
Standardized test scores are not ignored. Instead, the task force advises programs to evaluate applicants and their standardized scores within the context of a holistic review and openly disclose how USMLE Step 2 and COMLEX Level 2 scores are considered. Programs are also strongly encouraged to be transparent about their core values, program characteristics, and how they use program signals during holistic screening.
This aligns with the AAMC's Mission-Aligned Selection and Retention framework (formerly called Holistic Review). The AAMC defines Mission-Aligned Selection as an evidence-informed approach to recruiting and assessing an individual's competencies by considering 4 connected parts: Experiences, Attributes, Academic Metrics, and Competencies (the EAMC model).
In the AAMC framework, programs consider each applicant's context, including their educational opportunities, financial resources, communities, experiences, and motivations, to select a cohort of learners whose complementary qualities advance the program's clinical and educational mission. Selection criteria are aligned with the program's curriculum, mission, community health needs, and physician workforce needs, and at the conclusion of each selection cycle, programs evaluate and refine their screening, interview, and selection practices to make sure they are fair, effective, and valid. The AAMC also states clearly that programs are prohibited by law from considering race, ethnicity, national origin, sex, gender, disability, or any other legally protected characteristic when making selection decisions.
- Experiences: Clinical clerkships, sub-internships, research, work history, community service, and leadership roles.
- Attributes: Personal qualities, skills, abilities, and interests that show how you operate on a surgical team.
- Academic metrics: Clerkship grades, MSPE, and USMLE Step 2 or COMLEX Level 2 scores evaluated alongside your context rather than in isolation.
- Competencies: Observable professional, interpersonal, and clinical behaviors assessed in your application and structured interview.
GME virtual interviews vs. in-person formats: APDS and AAMC guidance
During the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, surgical and medical education organizations called for virtual-only interviewing. In its 2024-2025 recommendations, the APDS Task Force updated its wording to reflect institutional discretion while keeping strict fairness standards.
The APDS Task Force explicitly recognizes that the AAMC advocates for virtual interviews to provide equity, cost savings, and reduced environmental impact. At the same time, the task force recommends that each General Surgery program consult with its Graduate Medical Education Committee (GMEC) to identify its own values and best practices when choosing an interview format. Above all, the APDS Task Force emphasizes that all applicants must be considered equally by the program regardless of which interview format is used.
Whether a surgery program interviews online, in person, or in a hybrid format, the APDS Task Force recommends 4 core interview best practices:
- Equitable opportunities for all invited applicants.
- Uniformity of the evaluation process within the program.
- Transparency about the interview and selection process.
- Mitigation strategies to prevent bias during evaluation.
Why the AAMC recommends virtual GME interviews (5 key considerations)
In its guidance document, Interviews in GME: Where Do We Go From Here?, the AAMC continues to recommend that residency and fellowship programs use a virtual interview format, while noting that individual institutions may take different approaches for sound reasons related to their mission and context.
The AAMC lays out 5 evidence-based considerations behind its virtual interview recommendation, plus specific safeguards programs should use if they choose virtual-only, hybrid, or in-person interviews:
When a program chooses its interview format, the AAMC recommends specific steps to protect fairness. Programs using virtual-only interviews are encouraged to offer virtual recruiting activities to all candidates and train faculty interviewers on virtual technology standards. Programs using a hybrid model, where applicants choose between virtual and in-person interviews, are advised to standardize procedures and interviewer training across both formats, blind selection committees to which interview format an applicant chose, and explain these equity steps to candidates. Programs using in-person-only interviews, such as those with mostly local applicants or those needing to showcase a rural or less well-known area, are advised to offer financial support to applicants who need help covering travel costs.
- High financial costs: According to applicant surveys cited by the AAMC, travel and lodging for in-person interviews cost applicants hundreds to thousands of dollars, creating a barrier for learners from lower socioeconomic backgrounds.
- Applicant preference: In AAMC focus groups held in early 2023 and published applicant surveys, most residency applicants preferred virtual interviews because they reduced travel cost, saved time, and allowed candidates to interview from a familiar, lower-stress space.
- Time away from clinical rotations: Travel pulls fourth-year students away from clinical training. In a survey of plastic surgery residency applicants cited by the AAMC, over 70% of applicants missed 7 or more days of medical school to attend in-person interviews.
- Separating assessment from recruitment: Conducting the evaluative interview separately from recruitment events (such as optional campus visits) prevents outside interactions from introducing bias or irrelevant information into interview scores. If a program offers optional in-person events, the AAMC suggests considering travel stipends to offset costs.
- Reducing the health care carbon footprint: The health care sector accounts for 8% to 10% of U.S. greenhouse gas emissions and 25% of global greenhouse gas emissions. Virtual interviews reduce the climate impact of academic medicine.
How to use your 15 General Surgery program signals
According to the AAMC's ERAS 2027 Participating Specialties and Programs report, General Surgery residency programs continue to participate in program signaling with 15 signals. The AAMC, APDS, and OPDA collaborate to share specialty-specific application guidance and increase transparency.
The APDS Task Force gives 3 direct pieces of advice to applicants planning their ERAS submission and interview season:
- Use all 15 signals for your top 15 programs: The task force recommends using your 15 signals to indicate your top 15 programs.
- Consult home and away rotation program directors: Speak directly with program directors at your home institution and at your away or audition rotations for their signaling advice and institutional guidance (including whether you should signal your home program or away rotation sites).
- Use data to right-size applications and interviews: Combine available ERAS and NRMP data with your own individual characteristics to decide how many applications to submit and how many interviews to accept.
Interview offer dates, the 48-hour rule, and NRMP Section 6.2
Standardized release windows and response rules protect both applicants and surgical programs from the scramble of exploding interview offers. For the 2024-2025 recruitment cycle, the APDS Task Force recommended that programs not offer their first round of interviews prior to Wednesday, October 23, 2024, and send all first-round offers between Wednesday, October 23, 2024, and November 1, 2024. If a program extends offers outside the recommended window, the task force asks the program to be transparent with applicants.
Every General Surgery interview offer is also governed by the APDS Task Force recommendations and Section 6.2 (Interview Period) of the NRMP Match Participation Agreement. Under Section 6.2, programs and applicants are bound to ethical behavior during recruitment, and programs must follow 3 rules:
- 1:1 invitation-to-slot cap: Programs must extend interview offers that equal, and do not exceed, the total number of available interview slots. As the APDS Task Force illustrates, if a program has 20 interview slots, it may release only 20 invitations, and can send additional invitations only after invited applicants decline or cancel.
- Minimum 48-hour response window: Programs must provide applicants no less than 48 hours to accept or reject an interview invitation before extending that slot to another candidate.
- Reasonable notice for changes: Programs must apply reasonable notification measures, such as 1 to 2 weeks' notice, when needing to cancel or reschedule an interview, and must disclose their expectations regarding offer responses and cancellations.
What structured residency interviews test (and how to prepare)
To meet the APDS requirement for uniform evaluation and bias mitigation, residency programs increasingly rely on structured interviews. According to the AAMC's Best Practices for Creating and Conducting Interviews, residency interviews assess two types of fit: applicant-program fit (how your goals, attitudes, and learning style preferences align with the program's mission, values, and culture) and applicant-specialty fit (how your competencies, skills, and abilities match the demands of the specialty).
Unstructured interviews have no predetermined questions or scoring rules, making them prone to interviewer bias, poor inter-rater reliability, and inappropriate or illegal questions, and research has not found an association between unstructured faculty interview scores and ACGME milestone ratings. Structured interviews use job-relevant predefined questions (content structure) and defined rating scales with interviewer training (evaluation structure). In one residency program study cited by the AAMC, where faculty initially worried structured interviews would hurt conversational flow, all 12 faculty members found the structured system easy to use and score, reported learning important details about past behaviors that unstructured interviews missed, and saw that structured interview scores predicted first-year residents' end-of-year clinical performance, patient care, and communication skills.
In its Virtual Interviews: Applicant Preparation Guide, the AAMC notes that virtual residency interviews take one of 2 forms: Live Virtual Interviews (real-time video conference with one or more interviewers) or Asynchronous Virtual Interviews (on-demand recorded video responses to text or video prompts). Across both formats, the AAMC groups typical residency interview questions into 3 categories:
- Behavioral questions: Ask about past experiences to evaluate your skills and behaviors. AAMC example: 'Please describe a time when you observed a member of the medical team you were working with behave in a manner that was inconsistent with an established protocol. Explain what the situation was, what actions you took, and the outcome.' Answer with the situation or task, the specific actions you took, and the outcome.
- Situational questions: Present a hypothetical clinical or team scenario. AAMC example: 'Imagine you are on your morning rounds. The chief resident describes a difficult case you and a colleague worked on earlier in the week and compliments your handling of the situation. She gives you sole credit and fails to mention that your colleague played a major role. What would you do?' Answer with what actions you would take, why you would take them, and the expected result.
- General questions: Ask you to describe yourself and your goals broadly, such as 'Tell me why you are interested in this program.'
Applicant checklist for virtual General Surgery interviews (our plan)
Show details
We built this preparation checklist from the AAMC Virtual Interviews: Applicant Preparation Guide and the APDS Task Force recommendations so you can set up your space, protect patient privacy, and manage your invitations without missing a step.
If your surgery program uses a Multiple Mini Interview circuit or structured stations, review our MMI practice questions with answers to practice timed station structures.
- Gather interview details and map your experiences: Ask the program in advance whether the interview is live or asynchronous, which platform it uses, how many interviewers you will meet, the interview length, and which competencies are assessed. Review your CV with an advisor and list your strongest clinical and nonclinical examples.
- Protect patient and colleague privacy in every story: Per AAMC rules, never share names, locations, specific diagnoses, or details that could separately or in combination identify a patient. Always refer to a patient simply as 'the patient.' If a behavioral story portrays a colleague negatively, omit their name, title, location, and distinguishing characteristics.
- Use a computer or tablet, not a phone: The AAMC recommends a computer or tablet over a mobile phone for camera stability and advises using a device that cannot receive incoming phone calls during the interview.
- Check internet speed and wired backup: Test your connection on SpeedTest.net before interview day, switch from Wi-Fi to a wired Ethernet cable if needed, and share a backup phone number with the interviewer or coordinator in advance.
- Set camera and lighting: Place the camera at eye level so your head and shoulders are centered, look directly into the lens rather than the screen, and put a light source in front of your face instead of a window or lamp behind you.
- Lock down notifications: Plug in your charger, close every other program and messaging app on your computer, and record one practice answer to check for chair swiveling, fidgeting, or audio echo.
- Manage the 48-hour clock ethically: When an offer arrives during the late-October release window, reply within the 48-hour window and release any interviews you know you will not attend with at least 1 to 2 weeks' notice so waitlisted peers can take the slot.
- Practice out loud with follow-ups: Rehearse your behavioral, situational, and 'Why this program' answers on camera with Confetto's AI mock interviewer. Start your free week.
Practice question
Imagine you are on your morning rounds. The chief resident describes a difficult case you and a colleague worked on earlier in the week and compliments your handling of the situation. She gives you sole credit and fails to mention that your colleague played a major role. What would you do? (Official sample situational question from the AAMC Virtual Interviews: Applicant Preparation Guide)
See an example answer
Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. "In that moment on morning rounds, I would thank the chief resident for the feedback and immediately share the credit out loud so the whole team hears what my colleague did. If we were rounding on the patient who had a postoperative ileus earlier in the week, I would say that I appreciated the compliment, and add that my co-sub-intern actually caught the drop in urine output first and helped me place the nasogastric tube and update the family. Naming their specific contribution right away corrects the record while the team is still together, without making the chief resident feel corrected or embarrassed. After rounds wrap up, I would also check in briefly with my colleague to make sure they felt recognized, and when I log the case or ask for shift feedback later in the week, I would frame our work as a joint effort. On a surgical service, trust between co-residents and sub-interns keeps patients safe, and sharing credit in real time makes sure everyone on the team knows their work is seen."
Follows the AAMC's exact 3-part formula for situational questions (what action you would take, why you would take it, and the expected result), credits the colleague immediately without undermining the chief resident, and refers to 'the patient' without any identifying details per AAMC privacy rules.
Frequently asked questions
Does the APDS Task Force require General Surgery programs to hold virtual interviews?
No. While the APDS Task Force recognizes that the AAMC advocates for virtual interviews to promote equity, cost savings, and lower environmental impact, it recommends that each program consult with its GMEC to choose an interview format aligned with its values and evaluate all applicants equally regardless of format.
What does the APDS Task Force recommend for USMLE Step 1, Step 2, and holistic review?
The APDS Task Force strongly recommends holistic application review for General Surgery residency selection. Programs should deemphasize numerical USMLE Step 1 and COMLEX Level 1 scores when available, evaluate standardized scores within a holistic context, and transparently disclose how USMLE Step 2 and COMLEX Level 2 scores are considered.
How many program signals do General Surgery residency applicants get in ERAS?
General Surgery applicants receive 15 ERAS program signals, confirmed through the 2027 ERAS cycle. The APDS Task Force recommends using all 15 signals to indicate your top 15 programs after consulting program directors at your home institution and away rotations.
How long do General Surgery applicants have to respond to an interview invitation?
Both the APDS Task Force recommendations and Section 6.2 of the NRMP Match Participation Agreement require programs to give candidates a minimum of 48 hours to accept or decline an interview offer before extending that slot to another applicant.
Can a General Surgery residency program send more interview invitations than it has interview slots?
No. Under NRMP Match Participation Agreement Section 6.2 and APDS Task Force guidance, programs must only extend interview invitations equal to the exact number of available interview slots, and may release additional invitations only after candidates decline or cancel.
Sources
- APDS Task Force General Surgery Application and Interview Recommendations (2024-2025 PDF)
- AAMC ERAS 2027 Participating Specialties & Programs (Surgery)
- AAMC: Interviews in GME: Where Do We Go From Here?
- AAMC: Mission-Aligned Selection and Retention (formerly Holistic Review)
- AAMC: Best Practices for Creating and Conducting Residency Program Interviews
- AAMC: Virtual Interviews: Applicant Preparation Guide