Confetto

Nursing Ethical Dilemma Case Study: Examples & Guide

Read a worked nursing ethical dilemma case study, 5 clinical examples, bioethical frameworks, charting steps, and Casper practice scenarios.

An ethical dilemma case study in nursing examines a clinical situation where 2 or more moral duties conflict and honoring one obligation requires compromising another, such as respecting treatment refusal over prolonging life. Nurses resolve these conflicts collaboratively using the 4 bioethical principles of autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence, and justice alongside the 10 provisions of the 2025 American Nurses Association Code of Ethics for Nurses. Below are a full worked bedside case, 5 nursing ethical dilemma case study examples, charting checklists, and timed Casper scenarios. Sources: 2025 Code of Ethics Provisions | American Nurses Association, 2025 Code of Ethics for Nurses | American Nurses Enterprise, Ethics and Human Rights in Nursing | ANA. Last checked November 12, 2026.

What Makes a Nursing Case Study an Ethical Dilemma

When a clinical protocol or state law clearly dictates the right action and the only barrier is time or hierarchy, you are facing moral distress or a compliance issue rather than a true dilemma. An ethical dilemma in nursing occurs when 2 valid moral principles pull in opposite directions at once, meaning every option carries a moral cost.

Because life and death decisions are part of nursing, the American Nurses Association states in its 2025 Code of Ethics for Nurses that ethics are fundamental to the integrity of the profession. Shaped by over 6,300 public comment responses from 3,000 individuals, the Code sets 10 provisions for case analysis. Provisions 1 through 3 govern the nurse-to-patient relationship through respect for dignity, primary commitment to the recipient of care, and patient advocacy. Provisions 4 through 6 address nurse-to-colleague accountability, moral duties to self, and ethical workplaces, while Provisions 7 through 10 cover scholarship, collaboration, social justice, and global health.

Alongside those 10 provisions, the American Association of Colleges of Nursing outlines 4 commonly accepted bioethical principles in its Ethics Concept tool kit: autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence, and justice. Classroom ethical dilemma in nursing case study examples also test Domain 9 Professionalism competencies, including confidentiality, honesty, and moral courage. Nursing applicants can practice these same judgment skills under time pressure with our Casper practice scenarios.

Core Bioethical and Professional Principles in Nursing Case Studies
PrincipleClinical MeaningCommon Case Study Conflict
AutonomyRespecting a decisional patient's right to informed self-determinationAn alert adult refuses dialysis or blood products despite a strong chance of survival
BeneficenceActing to promote the patient's health, comfort, and best interestUrging symptom relief or protective care when a patient declines recommended treatment
Non-maleficenceAvoiding preventable physical, psychological, or moral harmQuestioning painful, non-beneficial resuscitation at the end of life
JusticeDistributing care and scarce clinical resources fairlyAssigning the last monitored ICU bed during an emergency surge
ConfidentialityProtecting private disclosures unless consent or safety mandates applyA patient discloses suicidal plans and asks the nurse to keep them secret
Honesty and FidelityCommunicating truthfully and keeping professional commitmentsRelatives ask staff to conceal a metastatic cancer diagnosis from an alert adult

Worked Case Study of an Ethical Dilemma in Nursing

To write a strong analysis of an ethical dilemma in nursing case study, trace the conflict from bedside assessment through dialogue, structured mapping, and resolution. Hypothetical clinical case study written by our team for teaching. The patient and family are invented.

Clinical background: Mateo Rivera is a retired carpenter admitted with end-stage renal disease, fluid overload, and calciphylaxis causing severe ischemic skin pain after years of thrice-weekly hemodialysis. During morning assessment, Mr. Rivera is alert, oriented to person, place, time, and situation, and free of delirium. He tells his RN, Jordan, 'I am done with the machine. The pain after every session takes everything I have left. I want comfort care only, and I am refusing noon dialysis.' Ten minutes later, his adult daughter stops Jordan in the hallway in tears: 'My dad is just tired today. Tell him his potassium will stop his heart, take him to dialysis anyway, and do not mention hospice.'

Identifying the dilemma: Jordan faces a direct clash between autonomy and beneficence. Provision 2 of the Code of Ethics states that a nurse's primary commitment is to the recipient of nursing care, and Domain 9 sub-competency 9.1g directs nurses to advocate for self-determination even when choices conflict with family wishes. Because stopping dialysis will end Mr. Rivera's life within days to weeks, non-maleficence and beneficence also require verifying that his refusal is informed, voluntary, and not caused by metabolic encephalopathy, depression, or untreated pain.

Bedside dialogue and resolution: Alone with Mr. Rivera first, Jordan asks open-ended questions to confirm he understands the fatal outcome of stopping dialysis and explores his comfort goals. With Mr. Rivera's permission to bring his daughter in, Jordan responds empathetically without compromising patient rights: 'I can see how deeply you love your dad and how frightening this feels. Because he is alert and making informed decisions about his body, we cannot force dialysis, so I am paging his nephrologist and palliative care so we can sit down together.' Jordan holds transport, notifies the attending physician and charge nurse, arranges formal capacity verification and pain optimization, and convenes a family conference. Mr. Rivera transitions peacefully to inpatient hospice with his daughter at his side, and the unit holds a brief post-shift debrief.

4-Part Clinical Ethics Matrix Applied to the Dialysis Refusal Case
Analysis AreaKey Case FactsBedside Nursing Action
Clinical IndicationsEnd-stage renal disease with painful calciphylaxis. Dialysis prolongs survival without curing tissue ischemia.Hold transport temporarily, treat acute pain, and notify the attending nephrologist.
Patient PreferencesAlert adult understands fatal consequences of stopping dialysis and requests comfort care.Confirm understanding in the patient's own words and get consent before family discussions.
Quality of LifeIntractable post-dialysis pain outweighs prolonged survival in the patient's view.Request a palliative care consult to align symptom management with stated goals.
Contextual FactorsGrieving daughter asks the nurse to override his refusal and hide hospice options.Validate family grief warmly, refuse deception, and arrange an interdisciplinary care conference.

5 Nursing Ethical Dilemma Case Study Examples

Different clinical settings create distinct moral tensions. Below are 5 hypothetical ethical dilemma case study examples in nursing written by our team.

Case 1, Confidentiality vs. Duty to Protect in Suicidal Ideation: An oncology inpatient with severe neuropathy tells the evening nurse, 'I saved enough pain pills at home to end this after discharge tomorrow, promise you will keep this secret.' Imminent risk of self-harm overrides confidentiality because preserving safety is an immediate legal and ethical duty. The nurse refuses secrecy honestly, stays with the patient in a safe environment, and notifies the attending provider and psychiatric crisis team immediately.

Case 2, Truth-Telling vs. Family Request to Conceal a Diagnosis: Before a surgeon enters the room of an older patient with limited English proficiency, the patient's son asks the team to call an inoperable liver mass a benign cyst. Deceiving an alert adult violates honesty and autonomy. The nurse arranges a certified medical interpreter rather than using family to translate, and helps the physician ask the patient directly whether they want clinical details personally or prefer designating their son as decision spokesperson.

Case 3, Reporting an Impaired Colleague: On a night shift, a pediatric nurse sees a senior colleague slurring speech, leaving narcotic waste unrecorded twice, and miscalculating a weight-based infusion. Loyalty to a peer conflicts with patient safety. Under Provision 3 and sub-competencies 9.1e and 9.3b, the nurse stops the wrong dose immediately, alerts the charge nurse or house supervisor, and files a factual report without speculation.

Case 4, Informed Consent Breakdown Before Surgery: Moments before operating room transport for a bowel resection, a patient who signed consent asks, 'So the doctor is definitely not putting in an ostomy bag, right?' The chart lists a likely temporary colostomy. Under sub-competency 9.1f, the nurse holds preoperative sedation and transport and pages the surgeon to return and clarify risks before proceeding.

Case 5, Fair Resource Allocation During Surges: An ICU charge nurse has 1 open bed when 2 unstable patients need transfer at once: a post-operative vascular patient on vasopressors and an uninsured trauma patient from the emergency department. Justice and Domain 3 sub-competency 3.3f require allocating scarce beds by objective physiological severity and triage policy, never insurance status or familiarity.

5-Step Framework for Analyzing Any Nursing Ethics Case

Approved April 6, 2021 and updated in April 2026, the AACN Essentials organize nursing education into 10 domains, 8 concepts, and 45 competencies across 4 spheres of care and 2 levels. Under Domain 9 Professionalism, entry-level nurses (Level 1) resolve ethical dilemmas collaboratively with team members using evidence-based frameworks (9.1a), while advanced-level nurses (Level 2) appraise policies and lead ethics discussions (9.1h, 9.1k).

Use our team's 5-step sequence to evaluate any case study of an ethical dilemma in nursing systematically.

  • Step 1, Separate clinical facts from assumptions: Verify diagnosis, prognosis, pain control, decision-making capacity, and any verified advance directives or healthcare proxies.
  • Step 2, Name the exact clash: State the dilemma in 1 plain sentence pairing the competing duties, such as autonomous refusal versus beneficence.
  • Step 3, Map stakeholder rights: Check Provisions 1 through 6 to confirm where the patient's rights take priority and check your own biases.
  • Step 4, Escalate collaboratively: Involve the charge nurse, attending provider, palliative care, social work, chaplaincy, or hospital ethics committee early.
  • Step 5, Act, chart objectively, and reflect: Execute the care plan, document exact clinical facts, and evaluate outcomes under sub-competency 9.1b.

Escalation Pathways, Conscientious Objection, and Charting

Show details

When an order appears unsafe, lacks valid consent, or contradicts a verified advance directive, start by sharing structured clinical facts directly with the ordering provider. If the provider declines to reassess, follow the chain of command: unit charge nurse, nurse manager or house supervisor, department medical director, and formal institutional ethics committee consultation under sub-competency 9.1k.

Provision 5 affirms that nurses hold moral duties to self, maintaining integrity and authenticity in a safe workplace. If a non-emergent procedure conflicts with your personal moral convictions, conscientious objection never permits abandoning or lecturing a patient. Notify leadership in writing before assignments whenever foreseeable, state your refusal to a supervisor rather than the patient, and provide compassionate care until another qualified nurse assumes handoff. In a life-threatening emergency with no other clinician available, patient safety and Provision 2 come first.

Follow our team's objective charting and ethics referral checklist during clinical conflicts.

  • Record the patient's exact words in quotation marks during refusal or goals-of-care talks instead of vague labels like 'non-compliant'.
  • Chart objective markers of orientation, certified interpreter use, and specific risks explained by the provider.
  • Log exact times, full names, and roles of every supervisor, physician, or ethics consultant notified along with their verbatim orders.
  • Keep interprofessional disputes out of the patient chart and route safety reports through internal risk management channels.
  • Request an ethics consult when surrogates disagree for an incapacitated patient, families demand deception, or aggressive care causes suffering without benefit.

Moral Distress, Moral Community, and Bedside Resilience

Show details

Studying nursing ethics also introduces 4 workplace concepts from the AACN Ethics Concept framework: moral distress, moral hazard, moral community, and moral or critical resilience. Moral distress happens when you know the ethically right action for a patient, yet staffing constraints, hierarchy, or family demands block you from acting, contributing to burnout and turnover. Moral hazard occurs when institutional policies shift ethical risk onto frontline staff without adequate authority.

Provision 6 calls on nurses individually and collectively to establish, maintain, and improve an ethical work environment. Building a unit moral community pairs personal self-awareness with practical system fixes.

  • Raise recurring triggers, such as delayed palliative consults or interpreter bottlenecks, in unit shared governance councils.

How Nursing Schools Test Ethical Judgment on Casper

Selective BSN, accelerated nursing, and graduate programs pair GPA review with situational judgment testing to evaluate empathy and ethical reasoning before clinical training begins. Developed by Acuity Insights, Casper is the most widely used open-response situational judgment test for higher education admissions, completed by 1M+ applicants across 600+ partner institutions worldwide and backed by more than 20 years of research and over 150 internal and external studies. Multiple independent raters score typed and video answers on how you gather context, show empathy, and weigh competing duties in your own words.

Scenario written by our team: Volunteering on a hospital floor with Sam, a fellow pre-nursing student working overnight shifts to pay tuition, you see Sam skip hand-sanitizing and equipment wipe-downs between 2 visitor rooms. Sam says, 'Neither room is on isolation, and if I clock out late once more the coordinator will drop me.' What do you do?

Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. 'My top priority is patient and visitor safety, because skipping infection-control steps in a hospital can expose vulnerable people to preventable illness even outside isolation rooms. At the same time, I want to approach Sam privately and without judgment since overnight work and tuition stress are clearly weighing on them. Right away, I would offer to help Sam wipe down the equipment in those 2 rooms together so the immediate hazard is fixed now and Sam can still clock out on time. Once the rooms are clean, I would check in privately to acknowledge their exhaustion while stating clearly that I cannot overlook sanitation shortcuts going forward. I would encourage Sam to speak with the volunteer coordinator about adjusting shift hours before fatigue causes a bigger mistake. If Sam refuses to clean the equipment or skips protocols again, I would report the concern objectively to the coordinator.'

Use our 4-point checklist below and drill under realistic timers with our Casper practice scenarios.

  • Fix immediate safety risks first before holding longer conversations.
  • Gather missing facts privately and without shaming the other person.
  • Acknowledge human pressures on every side of the conflict.
  • Use conditional if-then steps showing collaboration first and objective escalation if harm continues.
Classroom Nursing Case Study vs. Casper Admissions Scenario
Comparison AreaClassroom Nursing Case StudyCasper Admissions Scenario
Setting and ScopeInpatient or community care governed by Nurse Practice Acts and clinical ordersEveryday workplace, academic, or volunteer conflicts needing zero clinical training
FormatUntimed paper or simulation debrief citing nursing standardsTimed open-response typed and video answers in your own words
Common MistakePromising secrecy during self-harm risk or endorsing family deceptionTaking a rigid one-sided stance or lecturing a stressed teammate

Practice question

You volunteer at a senior center. An alert resident, Mrs. Patel, tells you she skipped signing up for a new balance-exercise class because it makes her feel frail. Later, her adult son calls the front desk, insists you add her name to tomorrow's roster without telling her, and asks what she said earlier. How do you handle this?

See an example answer

Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented. I want to respect Mrs. Patel's independence and privacy while also recognizing that her son is worried about her fall risk. Because Mrs. Patel is an alert adult who made a clear decision, I cannot secretly add her name to the roster or share her private comments without her permission. On the phone, I would warmly acknowledge her son's concern for his mother's safety, then explain calmly that center policy protects resident privacy and requires residents to sign up for classes themselves. I would offer to let Mrs. Patel know he called so they can talk directly, or connect him with the center supervisor for general program details. Next time I speak with Mrs. Patel privately, I would mention her son asked about the class and gently ask if anything would make it more comfortable, such as attending with a friend, while respecting her choice.

This answer applies autonomy, confidentiality, and honesty in plain language without textbook jargon. It protects Mrs. Patel's privacy, treats her worried son warmly, involves the supervisor appropriately, and explores practical ways to reduce barriers.

Frequently asked questions

What are the 4 main ethical principles in a nursing case study?

According to the AACN Ethics Concept framework, the 4 commonly accepted bioethical principles are autonomy (self-determination), beneficence (acting for the patient's good), non-maleficence (preventing harm), and justice (fairness). Case analyses also examine confidentiality, honesty, and fidelity.

Who is a nurse's primary commitment to during a family conflict?

Under Provision 2 of the 2025 ANA Code of Ethics for Nurses, a nurse's primary commitment is to the recipient of nursing care, whether an individual, family, group, community, or population. When an alert adult's informed choice conflicts with family demands, the nurse advocates for the patient while supporting the family empathetically.

Should a nurse keep a patient's suicidal thoughts confidential if asked?

No, imminent risk of self-harm or harm to others overrides standard confidentiality because protecting life is an immediate ethical and legal duty. Stay with the patient in a safe setting, decline secrecy honestly, and notify the attending provider and psychiatric team right away.

How do nursing students resolve ethical dilemmas under the AACN Essentials?

Under Domain 9 sub-competency 9.1a, entry-level nursing students and graduates resolve ethical dilemmas collaboratively with healthcare team members using evidence-based frameworks and professional guidelines. Learners also seek early guidance from faculty, mentors, or institutional ethics committees.

Why do nursing programs require the Casper test for admissions?

According to Acuity Insights, nursing programs use Casper alongside academic metrics to evaluate social intelligence and professionalism through realistic open-response scenarios. Typed and video answers show admissions teams how applicants reason and communicate under pressure.

Sources