How Underclassmen Can Build Med School Interview Skills
Free, no sign-up to start.
Five practical habits college freshmen and sophomores can use to build reflection journals, STAR stories, and the 17 AAMC premed competencies early.
Free, no sign-up to start.
Pre-med freshmen and sophomores can build medical school interview skills years before applying by logging volunteer and campus stories as they happen, structuring experiences with the STAR method, and practicing spoken responses with advisors or campus career centers. Medical school interviews evaluate the 17 Premed Competencies for Entering Medical Students, which the AAMC updated in 2026 to rename cultural humility to self-awareness and cultural awareness to understanding others. Because the AMCAS application lets you list up to 15 significant experiences with three marked as most meaningful, per the AAMC Anatomy of an Applicant guide, keeping a reflection log early gives you specific stories that go deeper than your written application. Sources: AAMC: Preparing for Your Interview(s), AAMC: Preparing for Your Medical School Interview, AAMC: Common Interview Topics. Last checked November 11, 2026.
On this page
- Why freshman and sophomore years matter for your interview
- Habit 1: Keep a premed competency reflection journal
- Habit 2: Practice active listening and oral communication on campus
- Habit 3: Build ethical reasoning and self-awareness for situational prompts
- Habit 4: Turn everyday campus experiences into STAR stories
- Habit 5: Review your competency gaps with advisors and career services
- Semester-by-semester interview skill checklist for underclassmen
- All 17 AAMC premed competencies and where they show up
- Practice question
- Frequently asked questions
- Sources
Why freshman and sophomore years matter for your interview
According to the AAMC, medical schools usually interview significantly more applicants than they accept, making the interview a major determining factor in admissions. Your grades and MCAT score show your academic readiness, while the interview tests verbal and nonverbal skills that transcripts and written exams cannot measure.
Starting in your first or second year of college lets you capture real moments of teamwork, failure, and ethical judgment while the details are still fresh. When you eventually sit across from an interviewer, the AAMC advises that you should not simply repeat what you already wrote in your application. Instead, you need to add depth, detail, and new reflection.
Both MD and DO programs evaluate how you communicate and act long before you become a physician. The American Association of Colleges of Osteopathic Medicine (AACOM) states that responsibility, respect, good judgment, professional communication, and cooperation are expected throughout the application process. For more on how interviews fit into the whole timeline, read our medical school interview preparation guide.
When you want to practice speaking your early stories out loud, Confetto runs AI mock interviews in traditional, panel, and MMI formats and gives rubric-based feedback on your answers. Start your free week whenever you are ready to test your stories.
| Format or question type | How the AAMC describes it | What underclassmen can build now |
|---|---|---|
| 1:1 interview | An individual 20 to 30 minute meeting with a faculty member or local clinician to assess oral communication and explore your application. | A log of detailed stories from your activities that add depth beyond a short written summary. |
| Group interview | An interview cohort is given a task or problem to solve in a set time to assess teamwork and fit for small-group learning. | Experience shifting between leader and team member roles in campus labs, clubs, and group projects. |
| Multiple Mini Interview (MMI) | Typically 6 to 10 stations of 5 minutes each, focused on a scenario or question to test verbal and nonverbal communication. | Comfort thinking on your feet and weighing conflicting values in timed conversations. |
| General questions | Questions that ask you to describe yourself broadly, such as why you are interested in a specific program. | Clear notes on why specific clinical, research, or service moments confirmed your interest in medicine. |
| Behavioral questions | Questions asking you to describe past experiences to show your skills, such as handling a broken protocol on a team. | STAR-formatted examples of one specific situation where you took individual action. |
| Situational questions | Hypothetical scenarios asking what you would or should do, such as handling a crisis or a fairness dilemma. | Practice spotting ethical principles in everyday campus or work conflicts. |
Habit 1: Keep a premed competency reflection journal
When you fill out the AMCAS application later in college, you can list up to 15 significant experiences, including extracurricular activities, volunteer work, paid jobs, laboratory research, honors, and publications, and designate three of them as your most meaningful. A reflection journal started in freshman year makes sure you remember the exact conversations and turning points that make an activity meaningful.
Instead of keeping a diary of hours worked, structure your journal around the AAMC Premed Competency Experience Worksheets. The AAMC recommends completing a worksheet at the end of a short-term activity or updating it periodically during a long-term commitment. Medical schools do not expect any single activity to cover all 17 competencies, so only tag the two or three competencies that actually fit what happened.
- Activity details. Record the name of the experience, whether it was volunteer, laboratory, or paid, the start and end dates, total hours spent, and your supervisor's contact information.
- Observation. Write down what you learned about a specific competency by watching others, such as a nurse calming a worried family member or a senior lab student admitting a pipetting error.
- Development. Note how you improved in that skill over the semester, including mistakes you made early on and feedback you asked for and applied.
- Demonstration. Record one specific moment where you showed the competency yourself, with enough detail that you can tell it as a two-minute story two years from now.
- Distance traveled. Keep notes on personal obstacles or life challenges you faced and overcame along the way, which admissions officers and prehealth advisors call distance traveled.
Habit 2: Practice active listening and oral communication on campus
You do not need a hospital badge in your first semester of college to build clinical communication skills. The AAMC defines Oral Communication as conveying information effectively with spoken words, actively listening to understand the meaning and intent behind what others say, and recognizing communication barriers so you can adjust your approach or clarify information.
Look for campus roles that force you to explain hard ideas in plain words and read the room when someone is confused or frustrated. Serving as a peer tutor, a teaching assistant, an orientation leader, or a student organization officer gives you weekly practice adjusting your language for different listeners. You can also take a public speaking, debate, or improv course to get comfortable speaking without a script, which helps when you later practice with MMI practice questions and answers.
Pair oral communication with two related AAMC professional competencies during your shifts: Interpersonal Skills and Empathy and Compassion. In practice, that means noticing how social and behavioral cues affect an interaction, managing your own emotions when a classmate or customer is upset, treating everyone with courtesy and respect, and looking for practical ways to ease someone else's distress.
- Check for barriers first. When tutoring a classmate or helping a visitor at a volunteer desk, ask what they already know before launching into an explanation.
- Watch nonverbal cues. Notice when someone stops making eye contact or gives short answers, and pause to ask a clarifying question instead of talking faster.
- Practice camera presence early. Follow the AAMC's virtual interview advice during your everyday college video calls: log in early, test your microphone and connection, and look directly into the camera lens when speaking.
Habit 3: Build ethical reasoning and self-awareness for situational prompts
Situational interview questions test how you make decisions when values clash. The AAMC gives two classic examples of hypothetical interview prompts: describing how you can effectively deal with someone in a crisis, and imagining a group project where a professor compliments your work and gives you sole credit while overlooking a classmate who played a major role.
In 2026, the AAMC updated the titles and definitions of two premed competencies to clarify the behaviors medical schools look for: cultural humility is now called Self-Awareness, and cultural awareness is now called Understanding Others. Alongside Ethical Responsibility to Self and Others, these competencies form the core of how interviewers judge situational and multiple mini interview questions.
Building these habits as an underclassman also prepares you for the AAMC PREview professional readiness exam. The PREview exam presents hypothetical scenarios a student may encounter in medical school and asks you to rate the effectiveness of different behavioral responses across the professional competencies.
- Ethical Responsibility to Self and Others. When a campus group or lab faces a gray area, practice naming the conflicting principles in play, sticking to honest behavior even under peer pressure, and encouraging teammates to act ethically.
- Self-Awareness. Reflect on your own assumptions before reacting in a disagreement. Practice considering an idea from an alternative viewpoint and revising your thinking when new facts come up.
- Understanding Others. Show curiosity about how a classmate, patient, or co-worker makes sense of the world, and notice how their background and past experiences shape their reactions.
Habit 4: Turn everyday campus experiences into STAR stories
In the AAMC's interview preparation guide, Sunny Nakae, assistant dean for admissions at Loyola University Chicago Stritch School of Medicine, advises applicants to be storytellers and to prepare rather than rehearse. Memorizing scripted answers often causes applicants to pivot away from the question actually asked and recite a canned speech instead. A better habit for underclassmen is storing real experiences in the STAR format (Situation, Task, Action, and Result) so you can adapt them naturally to any behavioral prompt.
The AAMC notes that you should focus on one specific situation in each answer instead of speaking about multiple events in general. If you use a teamwork example, make sure the Action section focuses on your individual actions and contributions while showing how you collaborated toward the shared goal.
Every time you add a story to your freshman or sophomore journal, answer three reflection questions from the AAMC guide at the bottom of the entry: how you changed, what you learned, and what you would do differently next time. Here is a worked example written by our team showing how an underclassman can turn a sophomore lab problem into a structured entry.
- Situation (worked example by our team). In the fall of my sophomore year, my four-person organic chemistry lab group lost a full week of data when a water bath malfunctioned before a Friday deadline.
- Task (worked example by our team). We needed to rerun the synthesis and finish the shared lab report by Monday morning without cutting corners on safety or accuracy.
- Action (worked example by our team). Two teammates were frustrated and wanted to estimate the missing yield numbers from another group's notes. I spoke up calmly against copying data, checked with the teaching assistant to book an open hood on Friday afternoon, and volunteered to run the two-hour heating step myself while a teammate drafted the introduction.
- Result and reflection (worked example by our team). We submitted our own verified data on time and earned full credit on the methods section. I learned that resisting pressure to cut corners is easier when you offer a practical alternative right away. Next time, I would split up data backup checks earlier in the week so one equipment failure does not put the group in a last-minute crunch.
Habit 5: Review your competency gaps with advisors and career services
The AAMC recommends using advising meetings to discuss your experiences and identify which examples show your highest level of proficiency across the premed competencies.
Once a year, complete the AAMC Premed Competencies Self-Assessment. On the worksheet, you rate your current development in each competency across three levels: Planning, Progressing, or Demonstrating. Remember the AAMC's note that no applicant is expected to have mastered every competency to the same extent. Sharing this sheet with an advisor or mentor in your sophomore year gives you time to find a new volunteer role or campus project if a competency is still in the Planning stage.
You can also start practicing spoken answers long before application season. The AAMC points out that many colleges and universities offer mock interview programs through their career services offices. Book one practice session a semester with career services, a faculty mentor, or a peer using common medical school interview questions to practice talking about your experiences over video or in person.
Semester-by-semester interview skill checklist for underclassmen
This four-semester plan is our team's suggested schedule, built around the AAMC's Experience Worksheets, Self-Assessment levels, and interview preparation guidance. Use it to pace yourself from your first semester on campus through the end of sophomore year.
| Semester | Speaking and campus habit | Advising and self-assessment milestone |
|---|---|---|
| Freshman Fall | Speak up in office hours and small-group classes. Practice maintaining eye contact and active listening. | Read the 17 AAMC Premed Competencies and bring an initial Self-Assessment to your first prehealth advising visit. |
| Freshman Spring | Apply for a campus role that requires spoken explanation, such as peer tutoring, orientation leading, or a communication course. | Update your Experience Worksheets at the end of spring activities, noting what you observed, developed, and demonstrated. |
| Sophomore Spring | Complete 1 mock interview through your college career services office or over a video call with a peer or mentor. | Meet with your advisor or mentor to review your story list and confirm which examples show your highest level of proficiency. |
All 17 AAMC premed competencies and where they show up
Show details
Updated in 2026, the 17 Premed Competencies for Entering Medical Students are grouped into three categories: 11 Professional Competencies, 4 Thinking and Reasoning Competencies, and 2 Science Competencies. By our count from the AAMC Premed Competencies list, the 11 Professional Competencies make up nearly two-thirds of the 17 total competencies, and they are the ones most directly tested in behavioral and situational interviews.
When you want to test how your logged stories sound under a real timer, Confetto lets you run traditional, panel, and MMI mock interviews with AI follow-up questions that push past your first answer. Start your free week to practice out loud.
| Category | Competency | What the AAMC definition covers (paraphrased) |
|---|---|---|
| Professional (11) | Commitment to Learning and Growth | Sets learning goals, reflects on successes, challenges, and mistakes, and seeks and applies feedback. |
| Professional (11) | Empathy and Compassion | Recognizes and understands others' feelings and perspectives, and acts to alleviate distress. |
| Professional (11) | Ethical Responsibility to Self and Others | Acts with honesty and integrity, weighs conflicting principles to decide, and resists pressure to act unethically. |
| Professional (11) | Interpersonal Skills | Reads social and behavioral cues, adjusts behavior, manages emotions, and treats others with dignity and respect. |
| Professional (11) | Oral Communication | Conveys information clearly with spoken words, listens actively for intent, and adjusts for communication barriers. |
| Professional (11) | Reliability and Dependability | Takes accountability for obligations, fulfills tasks on time, and understands the impact of not following through. |
| Professional (11) | Resilience and Adaptability | Perseveres and adjusts in stressful or changing situations, seeks help when needed, and recovers from setbacks. |
| Professional (11) | Self-Awareness (renamed from cultural humility in 2026) | Reflects on personal assumptions, considers alternative viewpoints, revises thinking, and helps everyone feel respected. |
| Professional (11) | Service Orientation | Shows dedication to something larger than oneself and makes meaningful contributions that meet community needs. |
| Professional (11) | Teamwork and Collaboration | Prioritizes shared goals, shifts roles between leader and member as needed, shares information, and exchanges feedback. |
| Professional (11) | Understanding Others (renamed from cultural awareness in 2026) | Knows background shapes behavior, respects individual differences, and shows curiosity about how others see the world. |
| Thinking and Reasoning (4) | Critical Thinking | Uses logic and reasoning to weigh the strengths and weaknesses of different solutions or conclusions. |
| Thinking and Reasoning (4) | Quantitative Reasoning | Applies appropriate mathematics and quantitative reasoning to explain phenomena in the natural world. |
| Thinking and Reasoning (4) | Scientific Inquiry | Integrates scientific knowledge to solve problems, form hypotheses, and explain how science is validated. |
| Thinking and Reasoning (4) | Written Communication | Conveys information effectively to others using written words and sentences. |
| Science (2) | Human Behavior | Applies knowledge of self, others, and social systems to psychological, sociocultural, and biological health factors. |
| Science (2) | Living Systems | Applies natural science skills to solve problems across molecular and macro systems, from cells to organs. |
Practice question
Imagine you are working on a group project with a classmate. The professor compliments your work on the project. She gives you sole credit and fails to mention that your classmate played a major role. What should you do? (Sample situational question from the AAMC Common Interview Topics page.)
See an example answer
In that moment, I would thank the professor for the kind words and immediately share the credit with my classmate before the conversation moves on. If my classmate is standing right there, I would name the exact part of the project they built, such as designing our data tables or troubleshooting the statistical analysis, and invite them to explain how they solved it. Speaking up right away matters because letting a false impression sit makes it harder to correct later. If the compliment happened in a private email or during one-on-one office hours, I would reply or speak up in the room to clarify how we split the work, and I would loop my classmate in so they know their contribution was recognized. In my freshman biology lab, a teaching assistant praised me for our group's poster layout when my partner had actually drawn all the figures. Correcting the record on the spot took ten seconds, built real trust with my lab partner for the rest of the semester, and gave the TA an accurate picture of how our team worked. Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented.
It answers the AAMC prompt directly in the first sentence, distinguishes between a public and a private setting, names the specific contribution the classmate made rather than offering vague praise, and ties the reasoning back to a brief underclassman lab example showing Ethical Responsibility to Self and Others and Teamwork and Collaboration.
Frequently asked questions
What skills and competencies do medical school interviews evaluate?
Medical school interviews assess the 17 AAMC Premed Competencies, including empathy, self-awareness, understanding others, oral communication, teamwork, and ethical responsibility. According to the AAMC, interviews focus on verbal and nonverbal communication and interpersonal skills that transcripts and standardized written exams cannot measure.
What types of interview formats and questions should pre-med students expect?
According to the AAMC, schools use 20 to 30 minute 1:1 interviews with faculty or clinicians, group interviews with collaborative problem-solving tasks, and Multiple Mini Interviews (MMIs) consisting of 6 to 10 stations of 5 minutes each. Questions fall into three main categories: general questions about you, behavioral questions about past experiences, and situational questions about hypothetical dilemmas.
How should pre-med underclassmen track their volunteering and campus activities for future interviews?
The AAMC recommends completing its Premed Competency Experience Worksheets at the end of a short-term activity or updating them periodically during a long-term experience. For each relevant competency, write down what you learned by observing others, how you developed or improved, and how you demonstrated the skill yourself.
How does the STAR method help pre-med students turn everyday experiences into interview stories?
The STAR method organizes behavior-based answers into four parts: Situation, Task, Action, and Result. The AAMC advises focusing on one specific situation per response, highlighting your individual actions when using a teamwork example, and explaining what you learned from the outcome.
What changed in the AAMC premed competencies in 2026?
In 2026, the AAMC updated the titles and definitions of two of the 17 premed competencies: cultural humility was renamed self-awareness, and cultural awareness was renamed understanding others. The update clarifies the specific behaviors medical schools evaluate during holistic review and interviews.
Sources
- AAMC: Preparing for Your Interview(s)
- AAMC: Preparing for Your Medical School Interview
- AAMC: Common Interview Topics
- AAMC: The Role of the Interview
- AAMC: The Premed Competencies for Entering Medical Students
- AAMC: Anatomy of an Applicant Self-Assessment Guide (PDF)
- AAMC: FACTS Data and Reports
- AACOM: The Application Process
- AACOMAS: Online Application Portal