Why Should We Choose You? Medical School Interview Guide
Free, no sign-up to start.
How to answer "Why should we choose you?" in a medical school interview. See the AAMC competencies, a 3-part answer structure, and spoken example answers.
Free, no sign-up to start.
When an interviewer asks "Why should we choose you?", they want to hear what you will contribute to their class and how your experience fits their specific school. Getting an interview invitation means your grades, personal statement, and letters have already impressed reviewers, according to the AAMC, which evaluates entering medical students across 17 premed competencies. Answer concisely by naming two strengths backed by one concrete story, then tying that experience directly to a program or mission priority at the school. Sources: AAMC: Tips from an Admissions Officer on Interviewing for Medical School, AAMC: Ask the Experts: Preparing for Medical School Interviews, AAMC: Preparing for Your Interview(s) (Medical School Applicant Interview Preparation Guide). Last checked November 11, 2026.
On this page
- What interviewers are really asking
- The 3-part structure for a strong answer
- What to highlight: the 17 AAMC premed competencies
- Three example answers by applicant background
- How to adapt your answer for open-file, closed-file, and MMI interviews
- What to avoid: weak phrasing vs. strong phrasing
- A 4-step preparation plan and self-review checklist
- Practice question
- Frequently asked questions
- Keep reading
- Sources
What interviewers are really asking
The AAMC's list of frequently asked interview questions includes "Why should we choose you?" alongside "What do you think you can contribute to this program?" Medical schools interview significantly more applicants than they accept, making the interview a major factor in the admission decision.
An interview invitation means you have already impressed reviewers with your personal statement, letters of evaluation, and academic history. You do not need to spend your answer proving you can pass biochemistry. Interviewers use this question to test what makes you distinct from other qualified applicants and why you fit their institution.
Filomeno Maldonado, assistant dean for admissions at the Texas A&M Health Science Center College of Medicine, notes in the Ask the Experts interview guide that applicants bring their own uniqueness to the interview, and it is important to be noticed positively so interviewers remember you, while also conveying a healthy self-understanding and demonstrating humility. Sunny Nakae, assistant dean for admissions at Loyola University Chicago Stritch School of Medicine, writes in her admissions officer tips that applicants are there to testify as to why medicine is right for them and why they are right for medicine, and that she gives lower scores to bland answers like "I like people and I like science."
To practice delivering a personal, specific answer out loud, Confetto runs AI mock interviews for traditional, panel, and MMI formats with follow-up questions on your own experiences. Start your free week.
You may hear this question phrased in a few different ways:
- Why should we choose you over other qualified applicants?
- What can you contribute to our medical school class?
- What makes you unique?
- Why are you a good fit for our program?
The 3-part structure for a strong answer
Focus on contribution rather than comparison. Never talk about why you are better than other applicants. Talk about what you bring to the team and how you have already practiced those habits.
You can build a clear, conversational answer in three steps. This structure is our team's framework, combined with the Medical School Applicant Interview Preparation Guide's recommendation to use the STAR method (Situation, Task, Action, Result) when telling a story in a behavior-based interview.
- 1. Name your core contribution in one sentence. Open by naming one or two specific qualities or habits you will bring to your classmates and patients, such as bridging language gaps or organizing peer study groups.
- 2. Prove it with one specific story using STAR. Focus on one specific situation rather than speaking about multiple situations in general, and focus on your individual actions and contributions even when using a teamwork example. State the Situation and Task in one sentence, spend most of your time on your Action, and end with the Result and what you learned.
- 3. Connect your story to the school's specific mission or programs. Convey your interest in the school by stating why it is a good fit for you and what specific programs you are interested in. Name one clinic, curriculum track, or community partnership at the school where you will put that skill to work.
What to highlight: the 17 AAMC premed competencies
If you are not sure which strengths to build your answer around, use the AAMC Premed Competencies for Entering Medical Students. Originally created in 2011 and updated in 2022 and 2023 by a joint effort across MD- and DO-granting schools, the model covers 17 competencies across three domains: professional, science, and thinking and reasoning. In 2026, the titles and definitions of two professional competencies were updated, changing "cultural humility" to "self-awareness" and "cultural awareness" to "understanding others."
By our calculation from the Premed Competencies framework, 11 of the 17 competencies (about 65%) are professional competencies, while 4 are thinking and reasoning competencies and 2 are science competencies. Because your transcript and MCAT already show your science foundation, your answer should lean on the 11 professional competencies and the character traits admissions deans look for, such as social consciousness, maturity, personal integrity, tolerance, problem-solving, creativity, and service to others.
| Premed Competency | What it means | What to show in your story (our suggestion) |
|---|---|---|
| Service Orientation | Commitment to something larger than oneself. Meaningful contributions that meet community needs | A community problem you stayed with for months or years, and the specific work you did |
| Teamwork and Collaboration | Prioritizes shared goals. Adjusts role between team member and leader. Gives and accepts feedback | A time you stepped back to help a teammate succeed, or took on an unglamorous task for the group |
| Resilience and Adaptability | Perseveres in challenging or ambiguous environments. Adjusts approach to obstacles. Seeks help when needed | A plan or experiment that failed, how you adjusted your approach, and what you changed afterward |
| Self-Awareness (updated in 2026) | Reflects on personal assumptions. Considers alternative viewpoints. Willing to revise thinking | An assumption you held about a patient or classmate that turned out wrong, and how you changed |
| Understanding Others (updated in 2026) | Understands that backgrounds influence behavior. Respects differences. Curious about how others see the world | A time you learned someone's background before trying to help or persuade them |
| Commitment to Learning and Growth | Sets goals for development. Reflects on mistakes. Asks for and incorporates feedback | A piece of hard criticism from a supervisor or coach that you used to change how you work |
| Scientific Inquiry | Integrates information, formulates research questions and hypotheses, and explains how knowledge is validated | Your specific hypothesis in a lab or clinical study, what went wrong, and what question you want to test next |
Three example answers by applicant background
Every example answer below is written by our team, and the applicants and details are invented. Use them to hear the pacing and tone of a spoken answer. Do not memorize them. Memorizing answers makes you sound scripted and often causes you to pivot away from the question the interviewer actually asked. If you are a bench or clinical researcher, Norma Wagoner, PhD, who served on admissions committees at five medical schools and teaches at the University of Colorado School of Medicine, notes that applicants with extensive research backgrounds need to be able to converse intelligently on their projects.
Example 1: The community service and clinic volunteer. "I think what I'd bring most to this class is a habit of sticking with patients through the logistics that happen outside the exam room, and helping my classmates do the same. For the past two years, I volunteered as a patient navigator at a free clinic in my college town. My task was to help uninsured patients with type 2 diabetes get their insulin and come back for three-month follow-ups. Early on, I noticed several patients working night shifts at a local distribution center kept missing morning lab draws. Instead of just marking them as no-shows, I worked with our clinic nurse to move five appointment slots to Thursday evenings and created a one-page Spanish and English checklist of local pharmacies with discount programs. Over the next six months, our follow-up rate for that group went up by about a third. What I learned is that a treatment plan only works if it fits a patient's work schedule. That's a big reason I'm excited about your school's longitudinal primary care clerkship and your student-run clinic. I'd show up ready to work on the practical barriers patients face, and bring that systems perspective to our small-group case discussions." (Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented.)
Example 2: The bench or clinical researcher. "I'd bring a combination of patience with messy data and experience translating lab findings for people who aren't scientists. In my undergraduate immunology lab, I spent eighteen months testing a hypothesis on how a specific signaling protein affected T-cell exhaustion. Six months in, my control assays kept failing, and it turned out our cell line was contaminated. I had to rebuild the protocol from scratch, coordinate with a postdoc in a neighboring lab to validate our new reagents, and present the setback honestly at our department meeting. We eventually got clean data that became part of a co-authored paper, and along the way I started tutoring sophomore biology students who were nervous about joining labs. Because your curriculum requires an independent scholarly project and pairs students with faculty mentors in the first year, I'd be excited to contribute both in the lab and by helping classmates who have less bench experience feel comfortable designing their first clinical study." (Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented.)
Example 3: The non-traditional or working applicant. "Having worked full-time for three years before applying, I'd bring steady communication under pressure and a lot of comfort working on teams where I'm the most junior person in the room. Before my postbac, I worked as an operations coordinator at a busy community food bank. One winter, our main refrigeration truck broke down two days before a holiday distribution for four hundred families. My job was to find backup cold storage and reroute twelve volunteer drivers on a zero-dollar budget. I called three local grocery managers, borrowed corner space in their walk-in coolers, and rode along on the first morning route to fix scheduling mix-ups in real time. Every family got their produce on time, and it taught me how to stay calm and ask for help clearly when a plan falls apart. In medical school, especially in team-based learning and on third-year wards, I know how to listen first, keep a group organized when people are tired, and take feedback without getting defensive." (Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented.)
How to adapt your answer for open-file, closed-file, and MMI interviews
Interview styles vary across schools: you may encounter one-on-one interviews lasting 20 to 60 minutes, group interviews that test teamwork, or a Multiple Mini Interview (MMI) of 6 to 10 stations with a 2-minute prep period and 5 to 8 minutes of conversation per station, developed by McMaster University and described in the MMI fact sheet. How you answer "Why should we choose you?" depends on what the person across from you has read.
For practice across all three setups, read our guides to medical school interview questions and MMI practice questions with answers.
- The interviewer has reviewed your complete application and often has it in hand. Sunny Nakae advises not to simply repeat what you already wrote in your application, but to add depth and reflect on the experience with greater detail and insight. Pick an experience from your file and tell the story of one specific turning point that was not in your written description.
- Closed-file (blinded) interviews. As Norma Wagoner explains, some schools call upon faculty members who are not given access to the applicant's file. Give one sentence of context so the story makes sense on its own, such as where you worked and how long you were there, before describing what you did.
- MMI personal or open stations (5 to 8 minutes). Virtual and in-person MMI circuits often include a traditional one-on-one station with admissions officers or faculty alongside scenario stations. Schools such as UTMB John Sealy dedicate one station to pitching yourself and explaining your interest in the school. Keep your initial pitch concise so the interviewer has time for follow-ups.
- Medical student interviewers. Many schools pair a faculty interview with a second interview conducted by a current medical student, such as at Wayne State. Norma Wagoner cautions not to take the medical student interview less seriously, because what medical students say about applicants carries substantial weight with an admissions committee. Emphasize how you show up as a classmate in small groups, student clinics, and study teams.
What to avoid: weak phrasing vs. strong phrasing
Based on guidance from admissions deans and structured interview rubrics, here is how to replace habits that lower your score with evidence-based phrasing.
| Pitfall | What to avoid saying | What to say instead |
|---|---|---|
| Bland, unpersonalized motivation (Nakae) | "You should choose me because I'm compassionate, I love science, and I really want to help people." | "Working for two years as a hospice volunteer taught me how to sit with families during hard conversations, and I want to bring that steadiness to your palliative care interest group." |
| Repeating your written application word for word (Nakae) | "As I wrote in my AMCAS activities section, I logged 400 hours as a scribe in the emergency department and saw many cases." | "In my scribing entry I mentioned working in a rural ED, but the moment that shaped me most happened last month when a farmer came in two days late for chest pain because he couldn't leave his livestock." |
| Using "we" in a teamwork story instead of your own actions (STAR guide) | "My student organization raised $5,000 and we set up a health fair for the neighborhood." | "Our group of six planned the health fair, and my specific role was recruiting three local bilingual pharmacists to run medication checks and designing the intake flow." |
| Making excuses for an academic blemish if you bring up your record (Maldonado & Wagoner) | "My GPA is strong except for biochemistry, because I'm no good at standardized test taking and the whole course was based on that type of exam." | "During the semester I took biochemistry, I was working 25 hours a week to cover tuition and spread myself too thin. Afterward, I cut back my extracurricular commitments, met weekly with a peer tutor, and earned A's in my upper-level physiology courses." |
| Pivoting to a memorized speech that ignores the prompt (Nakae) | Reciting a long chronological life story when asked what you would contribute to small-group learning. | Answering the exact question asked concisely, then pausing so the interviewer can guide the conversation. |
A 4-step preparation plan and self-review checklist
In its guide on developing structured interviews, the AAMC explains that many programs evaluate three to five competencies per interview, referencing frameworks such as the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) competencies, using rating scales that typically range from 3 to 7 points. Interviewers use probing questions rooted in the STAR method whenever you leave out part of a story, such as asking what factors led up to the situation, what the first thing you did was, or whether there is anything you would have done differently.
Once you have drafted your talking points, record yourself answering "Why should we choose you?" once on your webcam. Check that you answered concisely, focused on contribution rather than comparing yourself to other applicants, told one STAR story using "I" instead of "we," named a real program at that school, and included one sentence of reflection.
- Step 1: Audit your application. Per Sunny Nakae's advice, everything in your application and supplemental essays is fair game. If you listed research, know the hypothesis. If you worked for a nonprofit, know its mission. If you volunteered with Affordable Care Act enrollment, know the basics of the law.
- Step 2: Map 5 stories to the premed competencies. Review your CV or resume and create a brief list of sample experiences that demonstrate your highest level of proficiency in key skills, then discuss them with an advisor or mentor. If you are a reapplicant, use stories that highlight your areas of growth, how you reflected on past failures or disappointments, and what you changed.
- Step 3: Research the school and pick two specific fit points. Read the school's website and mission statement so you can name specific programs you want to join, and prepare thoughtful questions to ask your interviewer that are not easily answered on the school's website. Whether you are preparing for Indiana University, UC Riverside, UMass Chan, (/articles/preparing-for-the-new-york-institute-of-technology-college-of-osteopathic-medicine-interview), or University of Ottawa, tie your story to what that specific school values.
- Step 4: Run a mock interview out loud in the real format. In a survey cited in the June 2024 guidance on virtual and in-person interviews, 90% of medical school applicants preferred a virtual or optional virtual format. If your interview is online, test your camera and connection in advance and look directly at the camera when speaking.
- To rehearse traditional one-on-ones, panel interviews, and timed MMI stations out loud with unscripted follow-up questions and rubric-based feedback, practice with Confetto. Start your free week.
Practice question
We are interviewing hundreds of applicants with strong GPAs and MCAT scores this season. Why should we choose you for our incoming medical school class?
See an example answer
I think what I would bring most to this class is experience building trust across language and cultural barriers, along with a habit of organizing peer support when coursework gets heavy. For the past two years, I worked part-time as a medical interpreter and intake coordinator at a community health center serving predominantly Spanish-speaking families. One afternoon, a mother brought in her eight-year-old son for recurring asthma flares, and the resident was frustrated because the family hadn't filled their controller inhaler. While interpreting, I noticed the mother kept looking at the discharge paperwork without reading it. After the resident stepped out, I asked gently if she preferred audio instructions, and learned she had limited literacy in both Spanish and English. I worked with our clinic pharmacist to create color-coded sun-and-moon labels for their inhalers and recorded a thirty-second voice memo on her phone explaining the daily dose. Three months later, her son hadn't been back to the emergency department once. That taught me never to confuse a communication barrier with non-compliance. I'm excited about your school's community health outreach track and your team-based learning curriculum, where I can bring that practical clinical perspective and help my small group think through how patients actually manage care at home. (Example answer written by our team. The applicant is invented.)
It opens with two clear contributions without comparing the speaker to other applicants. It uses the STAR method to tell one specific story (Situation: asthma visit. Task: figure out why the inhaler went unfilled. Action: noticed a literacy barrier and created color-coded labels and a voice memo. Result: no ED visits for three months), and closes by tying that exact lesson to the school's community track and team-based learning.
Frequently asked questions
What are medical school interviewers looking for when they ask "Why should we choose you?"
Admissions officers want you to show why you are right for medicine and why their specific school is a good fit for your goals. Because your grades and personal statement have already impressed reviewers enough to earn an interview, this question evaluates your uniqueness, communication skills, humility, motivation, and character traits like empathy, integrity, and service orientation.
How do I stand out without sounding arrogant in a medical school interview?
Admissions dean Filomeno Maldonado advises that while you should make sure your uniqueness gets you noticed positively and remembered, you must also convey a healthy self-understanding and demonstrate humility. Instead of claiming you are better than other applicants, tell one concrete story using the STAR method about a time you served others, worked on a team, or learned from a challenge.
Should I repeat the achievements from my AMCAS application when answering why they should choose me?
No. Admissions dean Sunny Nakae advises to know everything in your application thoroughly, but not to simply repeat what you already wrote. Add depth to your written application by reflecting on an experience with new detail and insight, then connect what you learned to the medical school's programs.
Should I memorize my script for "Why should we choose you?" before the interview?
No. Admissions guides warn against memorizing answers until they sound rehearsed and no longer genuine, noting that committee members flag applicants who sound too scripted or who pivot away from the question asked to recite a prepared speech. Prepare a short list of sample experiences and practice talking through them conversationally in mock interviews instead.
Should I bring up a low grade or MCAT score when asked why a school should choose me?
Keep your "Why should we choose you?" answer focused on your strengths, contributions, and fit with the school. According to admissions experts Filomeno Maldonado and Norma Wagoner, if an interviewer in an open-file interview asks directly about a poor grade on your record, respond forthrightly by taking responsibility, explaining the circumstances at the time without making excuses, and showing why the issue is resolved.
How should a reapplicant answer "Why should we choose you?"
Focus on tangible personal and professional growth since your previous cycle. Admissions dean Sunny Nakae recommends sharing stories about areas of growth, past failures, disappointment, goal setting, and resilience, reflecting on how you changed, what you learned, and what you did differently.
Keep reading
Sources
- AAMC: Tips from an Admissions Officer on Interviewing for Medical School
- AAMC: Ask the Experts: Preparing for Medical School Interviews
- AAMC: Preparing for Your Interview(s) (Medical School Applicant Interview Preparation Guide)
- AAMC: The Premed Competencies for Entering Medical Students
- AAMC: Preparing for Your Medical School Interview
- AAMC: What It's Like to Participate in Multiple Mini Interviews (MMIs)
- AAMC: Questions Frequently Asked of Applicants During Interviews
- AAMC: Developing Structured Residency and Fellowship Interviews
- AAMC: Guidance on Virtual and In-Person Interviews
- AFMC: Canadian Fee Assistance and Applicant Resources (referenced by AAMC)