Casper scenario · Video scene · 0:20 · Ethics, Fairness

The judge's niece

You are one of three volunteer judges for the senior division of a regional high school science fair.

The winning project earns a $2,000 scholarship. During the lunch break, in the judges' room, a fellow judge, Ms. Park, pulls you aside just as the third judge, Mr. Kowalski, walks in.

Try a free Casper ethics question

Free, no sign-up to start.

Watch the 20-second scene once, then answer on the timer

Watch it with a free trial

The two questions

  1. 1What would you say to Ms. Park and Mr. Kowalski about his scores for his niece's project?
  2. 2Suppose Mr. Kowalski agrees to recuse himself from scoring his niece's project, and when you and Ms. Park average your two independent score sheets, his niece's project is tied to the decimal with another student's project and the fair coordinator needs one winner in ten minutes. How would you and Ms. Park break the tie fairly?

A sample answer, and how to improve it

A typical first attempt at question 1, scored on the 1–9 scale raters use.

6.0

This answer scores 6.0 out of 9. 3 changes take it to about 7.5.

I’d tell Mr. Kowalski that because he has a family connection to the student, he shouldn’t score her project, and I’d ask Ms. …

The rest of the answer, each change with its reason, and the improved answer are in Casper Prep.

See the full answer and your score in Casper Prep

The first attempt is an example written by Confetto, not a real applicant's answer. The scores are from Confetto's Casper coach. Not an official score.

What raters look for

Ethics
Weighs competing duties honestly, protects people from harm, and stays accountable to rules and values.
Fairness
Notices unequal access or treatment and acts fairly, especially for people with less power.

A different rater scores each scenario. How scoring, timing and the two sections work: Casper test format.

Answer scenarios like this on the real timers

Watch the scene once, record your answers, and get each one scored on the 1–9 scale raters use. Start with a free trial.

Start your free week