Casper scenario · Written scenario · Ethics, Fairness
The balcony vote
You sit on the residents' committee of your apartment building.
Last month a balcony grill started a fire that scorched the siding of two units and sent everyone into the street at midnight. The committee is voting on a ban on smoking and open-flame grilling on all private balconies. Dragan, a neighbor of twenty years, says his balcony is the only place he can smoke without affecting his wife's breathing, and that families without yards have nowhere else to grill. Parents on the upper floors say one careless neighbor puts every home at risk. The vote is tied, and you can break it or propose something else.
Free, no sign-up to start.
The two questions
- 1How would you vote or what would you propose, and why?
- 2When is it fair for a building or community to limit what people do in their own homes?
A sample answer, and how to improve it
A typical first attempt at question 1, scored on the 1–9 scale raters use.
5.5
This answer scores 5.5 out of 9. 4 changes take it to about 7.0.
I would vote for the ban on smoking and open-flame grilling on balconies, because the recent fire showed how quickly one person's activity can put other homes at …
The rest of the answer, each change with its reason, and the improved answer are in Casper Prep.
See the full answer and your score in Casper PrepThe first attempt is an example written by Confetto, not a real applicant's answer. The scores are from Confetto's Casper coach. Not an official score.
What raters look for
- Ethics
- Weighs competing duties honestly, protects people from harm, and stays accountable to rules and values.
- Fairness
- Notices unequal access or treatment and acts fairly, especially for people with less power.
A different rater scores each scenario. How scoring, timing and the two sections work: Casper test format.
Answer scenarios like this on the real timers
Answer both questions on the clock, and get each one scored on the 1–9 scale raters use. Start with a free trial.
Start your free week